Comments 1,292

Re: Review: Lunar Remastered Collection (Switch) - Two Of The Most Charming RPGs Ever Get A Fair, If Flawed, Port

MontyCircus

A while ago I googled for lists of the best Sega Genesis games. I looked for long lists each at least 50 games long, that were ranked. I assigned points based on rank and added them all up. I was left with 16 lists, 396 unique games and 1,465 total entries.

Lunar: Eternal Blue / Lunar 2 ended up the #53 best Sega Genesis game.
Lunar: The Silver Star ended up the #90 best Sega Genesis game.

And keep in mind, that on some of the lists (perhaps less than half of the lists I surveyed?) included Sega CD games at all. Which means among lists that included Sega CD games, they would both easily make the top 40 or even higher.

Re: Nintendo Download: 10th April (North America)

MontyCircus

Getting from last week:

  • Rift of the NecroDancer (rated "Overwhelmingly Positive" by over 2,600 users on Steam)
  • SaGa Frontier 2 Remastered

Getting from this week:

  • Arcade Archives ASSAULT PLUS (this enhanced version relased outside of Japan for the first time I believe)
  • Monument Valley I & II (award winning mobile games)

Re: UK Charts: Old Favourites Keep Nintendo In The Race As Xenoblade Plummets From Top 10

MontyCircus

Medic_alert wrote:

Given its continued success, I wonder whether Hogwarts Legacy will get a Switch 2 boost.

Hard to say at this point with all the upheaval at WB. I hope it does the Switch version is somewhat rough.

"Hogwarts Legacy broke a 14-year streak of Call of Duty dominating the sales charts, becoming the best-selling game of 2023."

It would be silly not to make it available in its proper form on Switch 2. I didn't get it on Switch, but easy purchase for me on S2.

Re: Nintendo Download: 27th March (North America)

MontyCircus

Will get:

  • Arcade Archives SENKYU (a falling puzzle piece game)
  • Blue Wednesday (a musical visual novel adventure game)
    Already have it on GOG, it's double-dipping time!:
  • I Have No Mouth, And I Must Scream (a great psychological horror adventure game)

Re: M2's 'Gradius Origins' Collects Some Of The Shmup Series' Finest And A Brand-New Entry

MontyCircus

NeonPizza wrote:

with the exception of the new Salamander 3, I'm pretty sure i have all of these in arcade form scattered between Arcade Archive singular releases combined with Konami Arcade Classics collection.

PKDuckman wrote:

It's very annoying that the game is almost double the price of the Castlevania GBA and DS collections. If you don't care about the extras it's cheaper to get the Arcade Classics Collection, and Gradius 3 is available separately on Arcade Archives.

There are 3 games here that aren't in the Arcade Classics Collection:

  • Gradius III (a solo Arcade Archives release)
  • Salamander 2
  • Salamander III

Yeah, there's a lot of overlap, but 2 games new to Switch.

Re: Poll: So, How Would You Rate The Nintendo Direct For March 2025?

MontyCircus

This is the worst Direct I've ever seen.
I think I've been more impressed even by all the indie directs.
Most any game interesting has already been revealed before.

I added the Patapon 1+2 Replay and Gradius Origins to my wishlist. That's it.

In the end I'll probably end up buying a bunch more, but not sold on much anything else that was newly shown.

Re: Nintendo Download: 20th March (North America)

MontyCircus

Bought Day 1:

  • Xenoblade Chronicles X: Definitive Edition
  • Assault Suit Leynos 2 Saturn Tribute

Will buy:

  • Arcade Archives Juno FIRST

Will buy if the Switch performance improves?:

  • Atelier Yumia: The Alchemist of Memories & The Envisioned Land

Anticipating because I love the genre, but I skipped the original:

  • Gal Guardians: Servants of the Dark

Re: Nintendo Expands Switch Online's SNES Library With Four More Titles

MontyCircus

One weekend my buddies and I rented Nobunaga's Ambition for NES.

It did not come with instructions.

So we fumbled along. When we figured out the rice planting and harvesting seasons, things really got cooking.

Never played the SNES version. I like that the tune is the same.

I'm sure Uncharted Waters will be the best game titled New Horizons that I've ever played.

Re: Best Super Mario Games Of All Time

MontyCircus

batmanbud2 wrote:

being the first to do something shouldn't automatically give it bonus points, especially if other games did it better.

Depends on the criteria. I think this is a "most fun to play today" type of list.

But if you're asking for "most-important, most revolutionary"? Then it's SMB1 or 64.

Re: Nintendo Download: 6th March (North America)

MontyCircus

Getting:

  • Suikoden I & II HD Remaster: Gate Rune and Dunan Unification Wars (PS1 Classics!)
  • Ever 17 - The Out of Infinity (very well-regarded visual novel from a long time ago)
  • Sorry We're Closed (Rated "Overwhelmingly Positive" by Steam users, the highest possible rating; and a "9" from NL)

Already have:

  • Arcade Archives DEAD CONNECTION (in the Taito Milestones 3 collection)

Looks cool, but want some reviews:

  • Beyond the Ice Palace 2

Re: Nintendo Places Outside Top 20 In Metacritic's 15th Annual Game Publisher Rankings

MontyCircus

@Mana_Knight

I'm not even defending Nintendo, I don't think the "average of all your games" is very useful.

In 1995, Square released Chrono Trigger, Secret of Evermore, and Trials of Mana / Seiken Densetsu 3.

Does anyone care if they made a dozen or two dozen flops that year? No! It's irrelevant. It's a fantastic Square year!

Or to put it another way, you might hear someone say "the '80s were a great time for action movies!"

Would someone then start listing all the bad '80s action movies? Who cares? They were ignored then and forgotten now.

When evaluating gaming companies, we remember the "hits".

Re: Nintendo Places Outside Top 20 In Metacritic's 15th Annual Game Publisher Rankings

MontyCircus

In 2017 Nintendo released Breath of the Wild and Super Mario Odyssey.

Would anyone care to be pointed out if they also released a dozen other forgettable games that year? That doesn't make those 2 game any less awesome.

We remember developers and publishers for their "hits", and ignore their misses. I would rather MetaCritic say...tally up their "85+" score games released, maybe bonus points for "90+" and "95+". That would better reflect what they have contributed to our industry.

Re: Nintendo Confirms Removal Of Switch Online SNES Game

MontyCircus

NL users (that's you and me!) rank Super Soccer the #58 best SNES game on the NSO (out of 70).

I found a Ranker.com list where nearly 700 people ranked the SNES soccer games.
Out of 36 games, Super Soccer ranked #3, behind only International Superstar Soccer and its Deluxe sequel.

Re: Nintendo Switch Online Announces Removal Of Super Famicom Title

MontyCircus

@zockermiller

I check DekuDeals, and at least here in Canada, nearly all games are only available digitally. Here are the last bunch I've been interested in:

  • Sorry, We're Closed
  • Star of Providence
  • Stories from Sol: The Gun-Dog
  • Momodora: Moonlit Farewell
  • Citizen Sleeper 2: Starward Vector
  • Laika: Aged Through Blood
  • Robobeat
  • Turbo Overkill

That's a whole month of games. None available at retail in Canada. Maybe somewhere, in some far-flung country they're available, but they're all the same to me as all-digital.

Re: Nintendo Download: 20th February (North America)

MontyCircus

Getting:

  • Cosmic Fantasy Collection2 (2 former Japan-exclusive PC-Engine CD games)
  • Ninja Five-O (A good old Game Boy Advance game)
  • Star of Providence (Rated "Overwhelmingly Positive* by nearly 1,900 users on Steam)
  • Stories from Sol: The Gun-Dog (3 strong Switch reviews so far)

Re: Review: Sid Meier's Civilization VII (Switch) - An Incredible Game That's Not Quite Ready

MontyCircus

Critics reviews rank it the worst mainline Civ yet.

I found an article, ranking them all by MetaCritic score, and it ended up 10th-best in the entire series including spinoffs.

I've also read the top Steam users reviews, and oof, their complaints make a lot of sense to me.

Most games with numbered sequels tend to iterate and grow on their previous instalments. Change things just enough so that it rides that line between familiarity and shininess.

Firaxis apparently missed this particular industry-wide memo, and thus the Civilization series will happily buck its own trends and well-established ideas in order to deliver something fresh every single time

I believe the usual rationale for making a new Civilization games was:

  • ⅓ the same
  • ⅓ improved
  • ⅓ new

Historically accurate where it needs to be, historically inaccurate when it's more fun that way

One of Sid Meier's lessons he learned from a failed game was:
"when forced to be given a choice between giving the gamer 'realism' or 'fun', give them 'fun'."

Re: Switch 2 Units Are Reportedly Selling For $40,000 On The Chinese Black Market

MontyCircus

tweaknmod wrote:

@Lizuka The value of money is subjective.
You wouldn’t pay $40,000 for an early Switch 2, but would you pay $.40?

There are many people on this earth so insanely wealthy that $40,000 is virtually the same as $.40 might be to the average person.

China has 814 billionaires. The most in the world.

Someone with $1 billion, invested in stocks at 8% return makes a quarter million $ a day.

They'll be able to afford another $40,000 Switch 2 every 4½ hours.