Comments 2,054

Re: Pokémon FireRed And LeafGreen Are Already "Best Sellers" On The Switch eShop Charts

Dr_Lugae

@RoboCube If you get it on your phone or your PC then you're pirating the game lol.

Honestly if you do that and don't actually own the original cartridge you ought to be obliged to buy this version. You'd have a lot of cheek complaining "how easy" it is for them to sell this version game, if you've never actually paid them for their original work in the first place.

Who are you to enjoy their game, their work for free, and then tell them what price they should sell it at?

Re: Pokémon FireRed And LeafGreen Are Already "Best Sellers" On The Switch eShop Charts

Dr_Lugae

@swoose I'd agree, re: point 2 Pokemon and Mario just have the cultural cachet that would make re-releases of their classic games more highly desirable and with a greater perceived value.

e.g. similar to this modern port of Final Fantasy 7 is $16. its barely changed from the original release other than some in-built cheats and for some reason despite being unchanged the characters models are high-resolution, which makes it look worse than the original because all the backgrounds at at the PS1 resolution which make the characters clash. And it crashes fairly regularly.

That fairly sloppy FF7 port has added 5.5million to the overall sales figure of FF7 despite changing almost nothing about the underlying game and being at a similar price to FR/LG. Because FF7 just has the cultural cachet that people will play a premium to play the original.

Re: Pokémon FireRed And LeafGreen Are Already "Best Sellers" On The Switch eShop Charts

Dr_Lugae

@Yosher I think the idea that a fan of a series spends £17, £50 or £60 on a game or two every couple of years isn't particularly outrageous.

If I said I'm a big fan of Pokemon. In the last year I spent £75 on Pokemon, £58 on Legends ZA and soon £17 on Pokemon Leaf Green. I'm not exactly emptying out my bank account for the brand.

There's people who think nothing of spent more on some cosmetic crap in some F2P gacha game each week than I've spent on Pokemon in the average year.

But you can't even buy a £17 re-release of a Pokemon game you like without someone online finger wagging like you took out a loan to buy a golden statue of Pikachu lol.

Re: SEGA Records $200 Million Impairment Loss As Angry Bird Dev's Performance Is "Sluggish"

Dr_Lugae

Other wonders of the report is Sonic sold 1.76m between October and the end of December. About half of what it did in 2024s holiday season.

And I don't mean Sonic Crossworlds. I mean the entire Sonic game franchise(Crossworlds,Generations, Superstars,Frontiers,Mania, etc.) sold as many copies as Kirby Air Riders by itself sold in the last quarter.

Whatever SEGA is doing isn't sustainable, there's no reason a mascot as popular as Sonic's entire gameography should be selling the same as a single kirby spin-off game.

Considering Forgotten Land, Star Allies and Return to Dreamland DX will still be selling, Kirby is currently a bigger game franchise than Sonic.

Re: Surprise! Braid: Anniversary Edition Nintendo Switch 2 Edition Just Dropped

Dr_Lugae

@B3RTAY Because the original Braid and The Witness did monstrously well its possible Blow just has an overinflated sense of how well his games should be selling.

It kind of reminds me of how Yahct Club Games reported they "need" Mina the Hollower to sell 200-500k when its just some 8-bit Gameboy Zelda clone

Feels like some of the popular indie developers business model is to "win the lottery" every time they release a game.

Re: Nintendo's Share Price Drops 11% Following Its Financial Release

Dr_Lugae

A lot of videogame companies had this happen following Googles Genie AI crap.

I think the good thing is this means those AI crazies won't be shareholders and asking Nintendo to pivot their business to AI generated games.

I'd rather Nintendo's shareholders be people who want them to actually make games and not prompt them lol.

Re: Metroid Prime 4: Beyond Sales Have Got Off To A Slow Start

Dr_Lugae

Considering Metroid Prime 2 and 3 sold like 1.2million and 1.4million respectively.

Its just one of those situations where the reputation is bigger than the actual demand. Even if MP4 sold inline with typical series expectations, split between S1 and S2 it's pretty likely neither version will sell 1million even if MP4 became the 2nd best selling Metroid Prime.

Re: Switch 2 Storms Towards Its Forecast Target With 17.37 Million Units Sold

Dr_Lugae

@OmnitronVariant Its not weird, like do you even understand maths?

At 17million that means roughly 1 in 10 people who had a Switch (155m) have a Switch 2. Even with these huge sales figures it'd take years to sell a Switch 2 to every Switch 1 owner and you couldn't expect to see many people upgrade yet.

It took 9 years to sell 155m Switch 1s. Your mickey mouse method of determining Switch 2 sales would result in more people owning a Gamecube... because S2 hasn't outsold it yet.

Re: Sonic Racing: CrossWorlds Fails To Meets Sega's Expectations

Dr_Lugae

@Buizel Yeah I played the Sonic Crossworlds demo on Xbox Series. What got to me was the Grand Prix was just 3 tracks followed by a 4th race that was just separate laps of the 1st three.

For a $70 game it felt like such an obvious attempt to short change players when they don't have enough tracks to have the GP actually be 4 unique tracks. Yet they had a bunch of tracks ready for the season pass.

Re: Sonic Racing: CrossWorlds Fails To Meets Sega's Expectations

Dr_Lugae

@waluigilives Yeah I think its a bit silly.

Like Crash Team Racing Nitro fuelled sold over 10million copies and it was "up against" Mario Kart 8DX. It didn't have to beat Mario Kart and it didn't need to, Crash sold better than any Sonic Racing game.

If Sonic Racing was going to take off, how well the latest Mario Kart sold or what people thought of Mario Kart is irrelevant. People buy games that can sell themselves, not based on whether they think it "beat game X".

If Crossworlds underperformed then obviously they failed to make it appealing. The fact SEGA themselves made an advert to trying to imply its better than MKW suggests their priorities were out of whack.

If Kirby Air Riders has outsold Sonic Crossworlds, then its pretty clear SEGA need to re-evaluate these racing games.

Re: Switch 2 Remains The Fastest-Selling Console In The US At 4.4 Million Units

Dr_Lugae

@GamingGod 429 what?Whatever currency you paid for the Steam Deck OLED the Switch 2 will have been cheaper unless you bought the OLED on sale/discount.

You see less Switch 2's out there because there are 155million Switch 1's out there from almost 9 years of sales. The Switch 2 is 7 months old and currently its selling faster than the Switch 1 but that doesn't change that there could be at least 10 Switch 1s out there for every Switch 2 sold. Thus you are 10x more likely to see someone with a Switch 1.

In 2017-2019 I saw more people using 3DS' out and about than Switchs but that's because the Switch had yet to outsell the 3DS. But obviously that wasn't a sign the Switch was selling poorly considering it ended up selling double the 3DS.

You'd have to get back to me in 2035 and tell me if you see more kids walking around with more Switch 2s or Switch 1s for that to mean anything lmao. Like if you bought your kids Switchs for 250 (so after the price cut in 2021) your family aren't year 1 customers for Nintendo systems. You probably won't admit it but I'd suspect in 4-5 years time there's a fair chance your household will have one.

Re: Switch 2 Remains The Fastest-Selling Console In The US At 4.4 Million Units

Dr_Lugae

@GamingGod the only Steamdeck cheaper than the Switch 2 has an LCD screen and has been discontinued lol.

The cheapest OLED Steam Deck is more expensive than the Switch 2, its less powerful than the Switch 2, has a lower resolution screen and can't support 120fps.

You should probably actually learn about the stuff you're talking about. You clearly don't own either of these systems if you don't know what features or prices they have.

Re: Industry Veteran Hideki Konno Has Apparently Left Nintendo After Four Decades

Dr_Lugae

@Fighting_Game_Loser I think with Miyamoto he'll probably never officially retire. Since he's a member of their board of directors It's probably better for Nintendo for him to be there than not even if he's no longer actually spearheading any projects or initiatives.

I think after his involvement in the movies and theme parks are sorted. I predict we'll still probably see him credited supervisory roles on internal Mario/Zelda/Pikmin games, and Nintendo Direct appearances, be part board/shareholder meetings, etc.

But I think Super Mario Run will always be the last Miyamoto-led game.

Re: Industry Veteran Hideki Konno Has Apparently Left Nintendo After Four Decades

Dr_Lugae

@AstroTheGamosian Yeah, it seems so far Yabuki who took over the Mario Kart series, directed 7, 8 and promoted to producer for 8Deluxe onwards took the reigns of Mario Kart and knows what he's doing.

I think the interesting one will be 2D Mario and Yoshi, because that's still being produced by Tezuka who was around since the NES and Super Mario Bros. He's still producer for 2D Mario as of Super Mario Bros Wonder, but is in his mid 60s now. So presumably in the next ~5 years there may be someone new in charge of 2D Mario.

Re: Japanese Charts: Animal Crossing: New Horizons Digs Up A Win On Switch 2

Dr_Lugae

The PS5 has collapsed back below 10k and 66% of them are those cheap digital editions that Sony have to be making a loss on.

I think at this point the PlayStation's presence in Japan is more like an obligation to keep Japanese developers making games for it. Probably the same reason Microsoft haven't entirely given up on Japan with the Xbox.

Re: Donkey Kong Bananza Has Been Nominated For Even More Awards

Dr_Lugae

@Ramouz Yeah was going to say. CO's level design is also pretty much FFXIII if it had a world map between each of its locations, and all you do is move around, jump at ledges and either aim to auto zipline across gaps or fire your gun at the same 3 balls in every dungeon to open a chest.

There are barely any puzzles, and even in battle I think some of the enemies parry/dodge timings are actually out of sync with the animations/sound.

Re: Japanese Charts: Nintendo's Dominance Continues As Switch 2 Flies Past 4 Million Units Sold

Dr_Lugae

@JaxonH Switch 1 did have Super Mario Odyssey for its first Christmas. Whereas Kirby Air Rider's is the S2's only equivalent that wasn't also on S1. Like Pokemon ZA is the bigger game but its on both systems.

It does make me wonder if Nintendo have withheld a finished S2 exclusive game which they didn't think they needed to meet or beat their projections. So was better off saved for later.

It will be tough for 2026 to match or beat 2025. But if 2026 has two big holiday exclusives instead of a Kirby Spin-Off and cross-gen Pokemon it'd have an edge.

Re: Review: Fire Emblem: Path Of Radiance (GameCube) - Aged & Easier Than You're Used To, But Still A Winner

Dr_Lugae

@Froakiebloke Yeah I don't think its til SD/New Mystery that the difficulty got nailed down.

I think PoR is an awkward period of FE where Normal/Hard are too easy for skilled players. The concept of permadeath is too unforgiving to attract/retain new players, and Maniac just bogged things down rather than challenged the player.

I think by Shadow Dragon they got the idea right where the hardest modes have very powerful enemies that need to be handled strategically. When you make the right moves/weapons you can still do stuff like one-shot Pegasus Knights with Bows or take out Armours in one round with Hammers or powerful enough spells.

Which made the challenge more satisfying as if you do the right moves you're finishing chapters in a similar number of turns as other modes and there's a better pace/flow to the game.

Then New Mystery/Awakening introducing Casual mode helped Fire Emblem keep new players who like the gameplay but permadeath was a barrier to them enjoying the games.

Re: UK Charts: Metroid Prime 4 Falls From The Top Ten

Dr_Lugae

@John_Deacon Last time Nintendo updated their sales figures over 90% of Switch 2 owners had Mario Kart World.

So most Switch 2 owners who didn't get the bundle must have bought Mario Kart World physically because almost everyone with the system has the game.

Re: The Game Awards GOTY For 2025 Is Clair Obscur: Expedition 33

Dr_Lugae

@Max_the_German Yeah I think when you've got celebrity Voice Acting in your game, and support studios working on the game, and had a movie in the works... before the game even came out, you're probably not an indie lol.

I don't think E33 is quite AAA level you can sort of tell with the lack of towns or NPCs in the games areas. But its made with the kind of resources you'd associate with a AAA production that would be far out of reach of even the successful indie Studios.

Re: UK Charts: Metroid Prime 4 Debuts Behind Mario Kart World And EA Sports FC 26

Dr_Lugae

@KingMinosOfKnossos Its probably a combo of Metroid Prime not being popular in the UK and the gamecube mega bombing in the UK.

Same with Kirby Air Riders, any game/series mostly leaning on or following up a previous release on Gamecube just isn't going to be as popular in the UK as it is in the US or Japan. It was the same with Metroid Prime 3

It'd be like gauging a Sonic game based on Japanese sales where the character doesn't have much popularity and the Megadrive/Genesis sold poorly. Even a successful game in the west for Sonic probably isn't going to do particularly well in Japan.

Re: Review: Metroid Prime 4: Beyond - Nintendo Switch 2 Edition (Switch 2) - Samus Returns In Prime Form

Dr_Lugae

@MrStark Its a ~80% because that's an average some reviews will like it more than average, others will like it less there's always going to be a range of opinions. Reviewers aren't robots who'll uniformly hand out the same score to the same game.

If you think someone scoring it 1 point higher than average is wrong do you think the people scoring it 7/10 are wrong too for "underrating it".

Some people are ridiculous lol

Re: UK Charts: Kirby Is Nowhere To Be Seen In A Quiet Week

Dr_Lugae

@Suketoudara Yeah but 2022 is peak Switch lifecycle and a really high budget mainline entry. Kirby Star Allies released in 2018 a year into the Switch's lifespan didn't top of the UK chart either:

https://www.nintendolife.com/news/2018/03/kirby_star_allies_denied_uk_number_one_chart_debut_by_burnout_paradise

So the idea a Kirby spin-off releasing 6 months into the Switch 2's lifespan would be topping charts in the UK is a pipe dream. A mainline 2D one couldn't 1 year into Switch. The next 3D Kirby game when the Switch 2 is more established might top the charts in the UK but it has a lot more qualifiers than say Mario Kart, Donkey Kong or Pokemon topping the charts during the Switch 2's launch year.

Re: UK Charts: Kirby Is Nowhere To Be Seen In A Quiet Week

Dr_Lugae

Kirby just isn't really geared towards success in the UK. He's a bit too cutesy.

When the original came out during peak GTA3 - San Andreas fever, I didn't play it. But if I did it'd be the kind of game you'd keep secret from people at school lol!

The US and Japan are likely going to carry this game since Kirby is actually popular there.

Re: UK Charts: Kirby Air Riders Narrowly Misses Out On A Top Ten Spot

Dr_Lugae

Tbh it was never going to compare with Mario Kart but I think the point of games like Kirby Air Riders, MP4 and next years Fire Emblem Fortunes Weave isn't to sell like Mario Kart or Pokemon.

Its to attract across specific audiences to the Switch 2. Air Riders is probably a way of getting Sakurai and Kirby fans across without a big new 3D/2D Kirby game or Smash Bros.

Re: Pokémon Legends: Z-A Was The Best-Selling Nintendo Game In October (US)

Dr_Lugae

@ShadLink I think given the games averaged ~80% overall and there's always going to be a range of opinions 9/10 or 7/10 isn't unexpected as there's always going to be a range of preferences.

But it is odd that a site dedicated to Nintendo has reviewers who'd score it as low as 6/10 (Switch version) considering if a reviewer for a Nintendo site is far more likely to be a Nintendo fan. So you'd expect a stronger affinity to these kinds of games than the average site.

Re: Pokémon To Receive Prestigious Award At The 15th Annual New York Game Awards

Dr_Lugae

@topsekret I mean the whole aim of creating a successful product is to make the most amount of money possible from the investment lol.

I think very few people who gain from a products success would be saying "Why don't we turn our 10x return on investment into 5x", they probably only invest what they think is needed to maintain the same level of success.

The only exception is if they feel they'll end up getting more back by putting more in, hence why something like Pokemon and even say Minecraft have incredibly modest production values for how successful they are. Similarly until Super Mario Bros Wonder, 2D Mario tended to have lesser production values to the 3D Mario games even though they sold more.

I think Pokemon's production values will continue to rise as they have been over the course of the Switch gen, but its going to be very gradual given the appeal of the game isn't the production values outside of the Pokemon and Trainer designs which very obviously get a lot of focus.