Comments 443

Re: Opinion: Silksong's Big 'Anticlimactic' Premiere Was Absolutely Perfect

Oldstalk

@Maxz A lot of writers have a blog where they keep their community updated on their progress, or just share random stuff (fan arts, thoughts, next event they are participating to...)

That's extremely common place. Even GRR Martin does it.

I'm gonna add this to my previous comment : Silksong was initially a DLC funded through kickstarter. Sure, it's extremely nice it turned out to be a full game, but it justifies even less Team Cherry's communication practice : you had people that paid to see this content see the light of day, so frequent updates, even just to say the team is still ALIVE, should have been provided. That's standard practice for a kickstarter campaign, and in a way Silksong was a by-product of the original KS campaign

Also, reminder that until recently, you could see people on NL say that Silksong is just vaporware and will never come out. That's how radio silence they were.

Re: Opinion: Silksong's Big 'Anticlimactic' Premiere Was Absolutely Perfect

Oldstalk

Welp, I'm glad it's finally here, but I will never change my mind on this : it was a bad idea to not say anything in 6 years, and it would not have been that time consuming to give some news once or twice a year. No one is gonna convince me that writing one article every few months on their website, sharing details on a few enemies, maybe some lore, whatever man, it does not have to be a freaking novel, but something, could take more than 2 hours.

So the whole "we did not want to use development time to communicate, therefore we litteraly did not communicate at all with our fanbase" seems pretty BS to me. If you don't want to communicate with your fanbase, just say it, but don't use poor excuses like this one.

Re: First Impressions: Pokémon Legends: Z-A Is An Attempt To Catch The Hardcore Again

Oldstalk

It's crazy to think both Cyberpunk 2077 and Pokémon Z-A run on the same hardware.

And more importantly : they are both priced the same.

On one hand, you have one of the most breathtaking video game setting ever created, one so well crafted and full of details you litteraly never want to fast travel, just to take it all in.

On the other hand, you have Pokémon Z-A. What did they do to make the setting interesting or captivating ? Nothing. It's generic city 101, there are Pokémons, that's it. No sense of ambiance or mood.

Re: We Might Be Getting An Update About Sakurai's New Kirby Game Soon

Oldstalk

Welp, there's something new to add to my collection of "great things the internet kinda ruined and I'm glad I was not on it when I experienced them"
This list includes Wind Waker, the Star Wars prequels, and now, MK Double Dash.

Double Dash is 100% pure fun. Plain and simple. This is what this series should aim to be imo, and MK World kinda approached it, but not fully, same for MK Wii. MK DS and MK 7 were snore fest. MK 8 was a mix bag for me, it's content rich, but something holds it from being a really fun game.

Re: Talking Point: What Are You Playing This Weekend? (9th August)

Oldstalk

I just bought Cyberpunk 2077 and so far I'm liking it : it runs great but more than that, it seems like an incredible RPG, especially its setting and the way the game fully immerse you in it

I also bought "Is this seat taken", it's really cute, I recommand it

I tried Mina and... yeah, I'm really not digging the way it controls and this digging ability. I know it's part of the challenge, but having a small delay between your jump and the moment you dig is kind of frustrating. Hard pass for this game when it comes out

Re: Opinion: We Really Don't Need A Donkey Kong Timeline

Oldstalk

People think timelines are important for Donkey Kong and Zelda when those franchises were invented by Miyamato, the infamously anti-story guy at Nintendo that completely made up story stuff on the spot when asked about it

Not everything needs to be a shared cinematic universe, and in this case, a shared gaming universe

Re: Nintendo Won't Let Charity Speedrunning Event Use Its Games Without Permission, Because Of Course

Oldstalk

It's really a nothing burger. They will just ask for proper permission next time and that's it.

Nintendo do not want to get their IPs involved with anything bad looking. You know, stuffs like Darth Vador saying racial slurs and stuff... And I fully understand them. Their IPs are the most important aspect of their business. Getting a few articles pointing how strict they are with it is completely inconsequential to them.

Re: Nintendo Direct Partner Showcase Announced For Tomorrow, 31st July 2025

Oldstalk

YES !!

Well considering everything Nintendo dropped those past two days, I was half-expecting a partner showcase. And I'm really excited for it as we need more infos on third party games for Switch 2.

I want to see Persona 3 and Metaphor Refantazio on Switch 2, that would be really sweet. And if Sony is really bringing some games, Gravity rush 1 and 2 would be a great start !

Re: Sony Job Listing Suggests More PS5 Games Could Get A Nintendo Release

Oldstalk

The only things I would be interested in :
Bloodborne, Gravity rush 1 and 2, Ico, SOTC, TLG, Astrobot, Ape escape games, the old ratchet and clank games in some remastered form (not the new ones that are meh)

So 99% chance we wont getting these, as Sony does not even care about it on its own plateform, and these geniuses axed the studio behind most of these masterpiece !

Re: Best Donkey Kong Games Of All Time

Oldstalk

Bananza is indeed the best game in the series. I don't know how it can be up to debate at this point. And no, it's a little bit more than "punching the ground". The game litteraly give you every clue in its level design so you never have to dig randomly.