I'll believe it when I see it. Save Gatling Pea's return in PVZ2, I've been disappointed by the handling of this franchise since BFN's release. The series peaked with 1 (console version), 2, and GW2.
First off, Bananza in first is insane, and I'm genuinely intrigued by it now.
Second, DK'94 and DKC2 should be lower and DKC3 and DKJB should be higher. I found the former two heavily overrated by nostalgia (though both still have their merits) while I found the latter two actually quite fun.
@Anachronism if I'm being honest, 1's ending didn't exactly set a high bar to begin with. Oh, it was good, but it also (to me) felt like they planned on expanding the world from the beginning. Melia looks in the direction of the Bionis ruins, foreshadowing Future Connected, and Shulk mentions how he can't wait to meet the new world's people, foreshadowing 3 and Future Redeemed. Tbh, I've seen more conclusive endings in Mario and Kirby games (esp. Galaxy and Star Allies). Therefore, imo, Xenoblade expanding its lore is a good thing.
Gonna go ahead and say that I might actually prefer base 2 over Torna, for a couple reasons. For one, base 2's cast was more likeable and in depth for me, and I actually really liked the humor. For another, Torna's community system is the worst thing I have ever seen in an RPG (like, Temple of the Ocean King bad). No game should ever have you put up with that, especially since you've already had time to spend with the people of Torna, making it worthless. It got so bad that I stopped after making Lora a Tornan Knight and just watched the rest of Torna's cutscenes on YouTube (something I have never done with any other game). Yes, Torna's mechanics cannot be understated, but looking back, base 2 was just overall better, even without Nia.
Finally, after all these years, the FBI actually does something worthwhile. I guess that's what happens when you're not trying to protect your name on. . .THAT list.
@Fiergala you make a lot of fair points, though I've seen footage of Engage's gameplay (I also don't have it yet), and it looks fun. And yeah, the story is stupid, but it kinda has that Shark Tale/Bee Movie appeal where it's so laughably stupid that it's almost worth it.
@WiiHawk that depends on who you're asking. For instance, I actually liked the gameplay of FE11 and FE15 (the two DS remakes) when everyone else didn't.
@Erigen New Island wasn't that bad. For the most part, it was calm bassa nova with the occasional kazoo. I even have Bandit Valley on my Top 1000 playlist.
Actually, I think WW GCN is better than WWHD. I don't like the bloom, the Tingle Tuner being replaced with a dumb Miiverse feature that no longer works is, well, dumb, and I didn't mind the slow sailing or Triforce quest.
I say all of this as someone who usually prefers the rerelease of a given game (i.e. Skyward Sword HD).
@LeJuiceCup this sounds like the sad monologue of someone who got Mariokarted right at the end of Mount Wario.
And Double Dash having better music? GameCube games in general had mediocre soundfonts imo (save Metroid Prime and Kirby Air Ride), and even the remixes are just kinda ok.
@DaGoldenBoo a version of 2 with the updates 3 got would still be worse than 3 is now. 2 has the worst meta and slowest gameplay of the three, largely in part because of its shooter bias and dog water special design. It also has the worst net code and the weakest base single player. Outside of Octo Expansion, I've avoided 2 like the plague ever since I got 3.
Comments 1,256
Re: Top 100 Best Nintendo Games Of All Time
Holy cow, how this list has changed in two years. It needs a republish.
Re: Nintendo Direct Partner Showcase Announced For Tomorrow, 31st July 2025
sees Silksong fans putting on their clown makeup
Oh, this'll be good.
Re: Mario Kart World Has Been Updated To Version 1.2.0, Here Are The Full Patch Notes
Funny how this update came in the middle of me trying out the game for the first time (I love it, BTW).
Re: Talking Point: What Are You Playing This Weekend? (26th July)
Xenoblade 3: Future Redeemed
Rex is the ultimate gigachad.
Re: Rumoured Plants vs. Zombies Remaster Potentially Releasing On Switch This Year
I'll believe it when I see it. Save Gatling Pea's return in PVZ2, I've been disappointed by the handling of this franchise since BFN's release. The series peaked with 1 (console version), 2, and GW2.
Re: Random: Don't Worry Folks, Nintendo Says Mario And Peach Are Just "Good Friends"
Yeah, after just finishing Xenoblade 3 (with, you know, THAT photo), this statement ain't gonna cut it.
Re: Best Donkey Kong Games Of All Time
First off, Bananza in first is insane, and I'm genuinely intrigued by it now.
Second, DK'94 and DKC2 should be lower and DKC3 and DKJB should be higher. I found the former two heavily overrated by nostalgia (though both still have their merits) while I found the latter two actually quite fun.
Re: Random: Here's A Few Of Our Favourite Donkey Kong Bananza Easter Eggs
@9_10DOH64 not counting DK'94, DK has ELEVEN 2D platformers in comparison to two 3D platformers. I think this is a fair trade-off.
Re: Poll: What Review Score Would You Give Donkey Kong Bananza?
9.1 currently. Wow. Just. . .wow.
Re: Random: Here's A Few Of Our Favourite Donkey Kong Bananza Easter Eggs
I heard someone else returned. Someone VERY special.
I'll say no more.
Re: Mailbox: Ninty Getting Its Freak On, Area Codes, The 'Discourse' - Nintendo Life Letters
Nintendo DID get their freak on. It's called Xenoblade 2 and 3.
"HANDLING A MAN'S TUR--"
Re: Crash Bandicoot Co-Creator Believes The Remakes "Botched" The Jump Mechanics
You think you could've told us that earlier?
Re: Sonic Racing: Crossworlds On Switch 2 Will Feature The Full Base Game On Cartridge
. . .that didn't take long.
Re: Best Xenoblade Chronicles Games Of All Time
@Anachronism to each their own, I guess.
Re: Best Xenoblade Chronicles Games Of All Time
@Anachronism if I'm being honest, 1's ending didn't exactly set a high bar to begin with. Oh, it was good, but it also (to me) felt like they planned on expanding the world from the beginning. Melia looks in the direction of the Bionis ruins, foreshadowing Future Connected, and Shulk mentions how he can't wait to meet the new world's people, foreshadowing 3 and Future Redeemed. Tbh, I've seen more conclusive endings in Mario and Kirby games (esp. Galaxy and Star Allies). Therefore, imo, Xenoblade expanding its lore is a good thing.
Re: Best Xenoblade Chronicles Games Of All Time
Gonna go ahead and say that I might actually prefer base 2 over Torna, for a couple reasons. For one, base 2's cast was more likeable and in depth for me, and I actually really liked the humor. For another, Torna's community system is the worst thing I have ever seen in an RPG (like, Temple of the Ocean King bad). No game should ever have you put up with that, especially since you've already had time to spend with the people of Torna, making it worthless. It got so bad that I stopped after making Lora a Tornan Knight and just watched the rest of Torna's cutscenes on YouTube (something I have never done with any other game). Yes, Torna's mechanics cannot be understated, but looking back, base 2 was just overall better, even without Nia.
Re: Talking Point: What Are You Playing This Weekend? (12th July)
Finished Xenoblade 2 (amazing, BTW), so back to Pikmin until Xenoblade 3 gets here.
Re: The FBI Has Seized A Switch ROM Site As Part Of A 'Law Enforcement Operation'
Finally, after all these years, the FBI actually does something worthwhile. I guess that's what happens when you're not trying to protect your name on. . .THAT list.
Re: Switch Port Experts Share Thoughts About Switch 2's "Raw" Performance
Speaking of ports, cough cough, Smash 64 leak.
Re: Talking Point: What Are You Playing This Weekend? (5th July)
Xenoblade 2.
BTW, for anyone who's played, was it a good idea to start with Torna?
Re: Every Nintendo Switch Online GameCube Game On Switch 2, Ranked
@AnonyQ lol, that was just Sunshine and the Zelda games (Luigi's Mansion was remade, not remastered).
Re: Every Nintendo Switch Online GameCube Game On Switch 2, Ranked
@splinters they have.
Re: Every Nintendo Switch Online GameCube Game On Switch 2, Ranked
@Fiergala you make a lot of fair points, though I've seen footage of Engage's gameplay (I also don't have it yet), and it looks fun. And yeah, the story is stupid, but it kinda has that Shark Tale/Bee Movie appeal where it's so laughably stupid that it's almost worth it.
Re: Every Nintendo Switch Online GameCube Game On Switch 2, Ranked
@Advantage you should play Echoes, then.
Re: Every Nintendo Switch Online GameCube Game On Switch 2, Ranked
@WiiHawk that depends on who you're asking. For instance, I actually liked the gameplay of FE11 and FE15 (the two DS remakes) when everyone else didn't.
Re: Every Nintendo Switch Online GameCube Game On Switch 2, Ranked
I genuinely believe Wind Waker and FE9 are the best games on the system, with GX a close third. Sunshine can go take a hike, though.
Re: Minecraft Is Updating Copper To "Make It More Useful"
That's great, but what about guns (mods excluded)?
Re: Nintendo Music Update Adds Another Mario Album, Here's Every Song Included
B A H
In all seriousness, I would rather have the first NSMB game. U's soundtrack is one of the worst in the mainline Mario series.
Re: Poll: What's Your Switch (2) Game Of The Year So Far?
None, because I haven't played anything past Echoes of Wisdom, but I'll let you know when I get a Switch 2 (or XCX DE, whichever comes first).
Re: Talking Point: What Are You Playing This Weekend? (28th June)
Finally, FINALLY got to Xenoblade.
No spoilers, but Chapters 11-13 were just. . .wow.
Also, thanks, Smash Ultimate, for spoiling some key characters for me.
Re: Weirdness: There Are Super Smash Bros. for Nintendo 3DS Demo Codes Being Sold on eBay
@acNewUpdates I scrolled this far. It almost broke my phone.
Re: Best Yoshi Games Of All Time
Only Wooly World grabbed me. The rest were just ok, including the original Yoshi's Island (enemy spam central).
Re: Another Yoshi Soundtrack Joins Nintendo Music, Here's Every Song Included
"what up y'all, Yoshi Munchakoopas is my name
And imma tell ya how I beat the IRS at their own game."
Re: Another Yoshi Soundtrack Joins Nintendo Music, Here's Every Song Included
@Erigen New Island wasn't that bad. For the most part, it was calm bassa nova with the occasional kazoo. I even have Bandit Valley on my Top 1000 playlist.
Re: Random: Mario Kart World Player 'Breaks' The Game, Takes Flight Over Mario Circuit
Unrelated, but why is the article photo from Mariokart Tour?
Re: Mailbox: Switch 2 Price Point, Wind Waker Vs. HD, Drip-Feed Updates - Nintendo Life Letters
Actually, I think WW GCN is better than WWHD. I don't like the bloom, the Tingle Tuner being replaced with a dumb Miiverse feature that no longer works is, well, dumb, and I didn't mind the slow sailing or Triforce quest.
I say all of this as someone who usually prefers the rerelease of a given game (i.e. Skyward Sword HD).
Re: Talking Point: What Are You Playing This Weekend? (21st June)
Finally hopping on that Pikmin train with the first game. Also Samus Returns. That too.
Re: Donkey Kong Bananza Direct: Every Announcement - How Would You Rate It?
@X68000 As a new Fire Emblem fan. . .I've heard worse. . .
SHUT UP, MAE, YOURE SO ANNOYING!!
Re: Reaction: Donkey Kong Bananza Has Instantly Become My Most Anticipated Game Of 2025
I'd play this over TLOU any day of the week.
Re: Donkey Kong Bananza Direct: Every Announcement - How Would You Rate It?
Only downside is that Funky isn't there to strap you up with magnums. #protectthe2nd.
Other than that, peak.
Re: Check Out Donkey Kong Bananza's All-New Kong Cast Members & Animal Transformations
@tanaka2687 yeah, I know. I'm just saying that because. . .Star Allies gave me chills with that name.
Re: Check Out Donkey Kong Bananza's All-New Kong Cast Members & Animal Transformations
Void Company. . .
OH NO
KIRBY STAR ALLIES FLASHBACKS INTENSIFY
Re: Rumour: The Search For The Zelda Movie's Link & Zelda Has Begun, Apparently Seeking Actors 16-23
I'm ok with that, as long as the young actors prove their worth, especially since this movie could decide the fate of their careers.
Re: Review: Gex Trilogy (Switch) - A Happy Throwback That Couldn't Be Any More '90s
Jeb Jab's dream collection.
On a side note, Scott somehow secured an advertisement for this collection on Scott's Stash.
Re: Best Mario Kart Games Of All Time
@DennyCrane Are you kidding? That's been an option since at least DS.
Re: Best Mario Kart Games Of All Time
@LeJuiceCup this sounds like the sad monologue of someone who got Mariokarted right at the end of Mount Wario.
And Double Dash having better music? GameCube games in general had mediocre soundfonts imo (save Metroid Prime and Kirby Air Ride), and even the remixes are just kinda ok.
Re: Best Mario Kart Games Of All Time
@astros75 these are user votes.
Re: Best Mario Kart Games Of All Time
Tour and 7 higher, 64 and Wii lower. Ain't no way Wii is better than World in any way.
Re: Nintendo Reminds Us DK Is On The Way To Switch 2 Next Month
@Crockin you didn't get Tropical Freeze?
Re: PSA: Splatoon 3 On Switch Has Made Some Cuts To Keep Pace With Switch 2
@DaGoldenBoo a version of 2 with the updates 3 got would still be worse than 3 is now. 2 has the worst meta and slowest gameplay of the three, largely in part because of its shooter bias and dog water special design. It also has the worst net code and the weakest base single player. Outside of Octo Expansion, I've avoided 2 like the plague ever since I got 3.