@Peppy_Hare @startropics3 that essay is genuinely one of the most insulting things I have ever read in my life. It reeks of heavy nostalgia, and is built on a false premise that Zelda 1 was in any way different from what came after in terms of design philosophy (it's not. Not by a long shot). The guy who wrote it is a complete hack and flaming, prejudiced liberal, and the kind of game he wanted completely lacks any semblance of purpose or structure. Even Zelda 1 still had structure. If want that kind of game, then just stick to Dark Souls.
Zelda 1 is ok at best, Zelda 2 is one of the worst games I've ever played in my life, and BOTW and TOTK, which "supposedly" were a response to something like that essay, are proof that such a game is incredibly shallow and not worth playing more than once. Good day.
Ah, I see how it is. You wouldn't include motion aiming in Radiant Dawn almost 20 years ago, did touch screen controls twice with DS Archanea remakes and then never again outside of FEH, and NOW you're telling me the latest game is finally taking advantage of the funny console gimmick?
Intelligent Systems at their finest, ladies and gentlemen.
I could tell it was an IntSys game from the start. The style fells reminiscent of their later stuff, like Paper Mario 64 and the GBA Fire Emblems. It's charming and fun, but nothing that'll blow your socks off. It might blow your eyes out, though, with visual effects like those.
@-wc- I think part of the problem is how often Metroid shifts dev teams. Gunpei Yokoi died after Super Metroid, Nintendo R&D1 was disbanded after Zero Mission, and outside of Retro Studios, we've seen Metroid games done by Team Ninja, Next Level Games, (almost) Bandai Namco, and, most recently, MercurySteam. I wish they would stick to a single dev team from here on out, even if it is Mercury (Samus Returns and Dread are good, and I will die on that hill).
With that said, Zero Mission is my favorite, so I will now proceed to bolt my door before I start getting death threats. Bye 😁.
I like how the theme actually shows other games besides Fortune's Weave, like the Archanea games and Three Houses. Imagine if a theme stuck to the same two games instead of showing legacy content (COUGH ZELDA COUGH).
I heard about that, actually. It's why the Oracle games have a lot of direct references to Zelda 1, which actually seems to be a rarity in this franchise.
@BAN I think you missed the entire point of Raiders. It's not meant to be like the others in terms of style and visuals. The music and locations are the way they are because it's supposed to involve a sense of eeriness and mystery in regards to the Salmonids. In addition, this game is obviously a spinoff. Don't expect Splatoon 4 to be like this, especially after Team Past win the Grand Festival.
The most notable frame dips I've experienced thus far were at the one farm with the Armu everyone fattens up for New Game Plus. I guess the Armu's glory was too much for the framerate to handle.
@SoIDecidedTo what are you talking about? Walleye Warehouse and Triple Splashdown are garbage. Walleye is generally considered one of the worst stages in both S1 and S2, and Triple Splashdown can be easily shot down if you know what you're doing.
@OorWullie Urchin Underpass and Flounder Heights did come back in 3. S3 Flounder was heavily criticized for making some walls uninkable and making the map harder to traverse overall, but Urchin Underpass is the exact same as its S1 counterpart.
We're likely never getting another stage like Saltspray, though.
@Dalamar Eshmel seems to be playing a similar role as Sothis in this game. I haven't seen them in any gameplay footage, and all the focus has been on the four main characters. Based on that, I'm assuming Eshmel will be similar to Mark from Blazing Blade, which is probably the best possible outcome.
Wow, there are a lot of things I don't agree with here.
I don't think the ports should count at all, and remasters also being here is a bit dubious.
Super Mario All-Stars can burn in the depths of Tartarus for all I care. Arguably, one of the ugliest SNES games, and it somehow manages to control worse than the originals it's based on despite releasing just two years after Super Mario World.
Zero Mission should be at the top without exception. The only other remake that did as much for the original game as Zero Mission did was Shadows of Valentia.
Finally, if you're going to put Mother 3 on the "Best GBA Games" list, than you might as well put New Mystery of the Emblem on this list as well (I'd put it somewhere around the middle, but probably closer to the bottom half).
There are so many other things I want to say about this list (mostly negative), but that would take up too much of my time. All I'll say is that, as someone who has played most of these, this list is absolutely not an accurate reflection of how these games are as remakes.
@iLikeUrAttitude THAT'S WHAT I'M SAYING. I've seen people say they won't touch RPGs with QTEs because they want to battle on strength and preparation alone, while others lambast turn-based combat for being slow and tedious. I personally like both enough, but it's impossible to please everyone.
@VinzClortho1981 last I checked, you actually can do that in Mario Luigi. It allows you to attack before they can land their hit if you time it right.
At any rate, though, I don't want E33 to become the standard for RPGs in general. Some RPG franchises don't work with QTEs, because that's not in their nature. Others, like Xenoblade, rely on constant movement and real-time action. If every future RPG were the same, that would be incredibly boring. Inserts Syndrome quote here
@Ralek85 actually, I think you summed up why I was a stick-only player for the longest time. Unfortunately, I don't think Nintendo has incentive to change this. The Splatoon pros have gotten so used to the controls for years that it's just muscle memory at this point, and there aren't enough newbies complaining about it. However, I think this is part of the reason Splatoon in general gets dismissed by the hardcore audience.
As for Star Fox, I personally adhere to stick-only, since I feel that it's the best way to go about these games, but I will definitely say that gyro is better than mouse for Star Fox.
@Ralek85 Star Fox 64 3D actually did have gyro aiming as an option, and it's about as good as you would want to be.
In regards to Splatoon, it's kinda funny that you should say that, considering Splatoon 1 was the big game that made hardcore gamers realize how good gyro can be back in 2015. I personally don't hate the gyro in Splatoon games, but I can still see why it would be disliked (I was a stick player for the longest time and only recently switched).
Sadly, GameStop isn't doing much better here in the States. I honestly feel like Blockbuster would've still died out even if Netflix didn't exist, given the direction the industry has taken. It seems that the era of dedicated retail videogame stores has come to a close.
Pretty good if we're solely basing this off the controllers you can purchase, since those are the parts of this service that you're guaranteed to own. All of them are pretty fun to use and well-made from my experience, and they'll definitely have a lasting impact.
As for the rest, I don't mind the DLC and upgrade packs on offer, but the retro service is the real meat and potatoes here. As is, the library is already arguably better than any previous Virtual Console, but the drip feed is a bit annoying. Sometimes I forget NSO still gets updates until a new trailer drops. Obviously, I also wish there was a way to outright buy the games, or even just the apps themselves, since they're downloaded directly to your device and work offline.
All in all, it could still be better with a few changes, but it's still way better than GamePass and PS Plus by far, especially since those services actively hinder the sales of the games that release on those platforms.
GX probably has licensing issues, and no one seems to care about the GBA games, so this choice makes sense. I actually really like the White Land + Death Wind remix. It turned the two worst songs in the game into one of the best.
@Dimjimmer I mean, I, too, would be afraid of expanding on Star Fox if the last original game completely assassinated basically every character and had awful controls.
@SuperEndriu no, but it's blatantly obvious that they're gearing up for the end, especially since FEH isn't making as much money as it used to. The current book is the first stage of Ragnarok, which, according to Norse myth, takes place in three stages.
A bit sad, but it was inevitable. I liked playing this game well enough and only spent money on the Gold Pass. Really hoping Piranha Plant Pipeline returns in a future Mariokart.
In other news, this means Super Mario Run, Fire Emblem Heroes, and Fire Emblem Shadows are left. Super Mario Run was always a "pay once for everything" game since its release, FEH will have a definitive ending to its story by Book 12, and FES. . .I guarantee Nintendo isn't making any money on that game.
Nintendo is clearly try to ditch the mobile game market entirely by 2030.
@mlt I only played the demo, but it was prompted at the beginning, and it was on the main menu. It basically tests your input on every fourth beat, and if it's successful, it'll calculate inputs in the rest of the game based on that test.
Honestly, this release is far too late for Nintendo consoles. This game seems to have lost its luster and popularity in the two decades since its release that a Nintendo version isn't exciting in the slightest.
Also, this game was infamously responsible for the DLC plague we are dealing with to this very day, so there's that, too.
This game was the beginning of the end for Bethesda.
@xzacutor the dialogue in the remake is actually closer to the original Japanese text than how it was previously. Most of the lines in Star Fox 64 proper were improvised, from what I've seen. I'm not saying I disagree, but it's definitely a localization quirk more than anything.
@rvcolem1 apparently, Blue Storm sucked, according to Wave Race die-hards. I agree on the Excite games on Wii, though. Those games genuinely shocked me with how solid they were.
Comments 1,536
Re: Review: Super Mario Sunshine (GameCube) - Not What We Expected, But It Still Shines
I don't know who the guy with the Joshua Fire Emblem pic is, but his opinions are pretty based.
Also, I've said it before, but I don't really care for this game all too much.
Re: Aonuma: Wii U Zelda Is All About "Rethinking Series Conventions"
@Peppy_Hare @startropics3 that essay is genuinely one of the most insulting things I have ever read in my life. It reeks of heavy nostalgia, and is built on a false premise that Zelda 1 was in any way different from what came after in terms of design philosophy (it's not. Not by a long shot). The guy who wrote it is a complete hack and flaming, prejudiced liberal, and the kind of game he wanted completely lacks any semblance of purpose or structure. Even Zelda 1 still had structure. If want that kind of game, then just stick to Dark Souls.
Zelda 1 is ok at best, Zelda 2 is one of the worst games I've ever played in my life, and BOTW and TOTK, which "supposedly" were a response to something like that essay, are proof that such a game is incredibly shallow and not worth playing more than once. Good day.
Re: Fire Emblem: Fortune's Weave Will Allow You To Strategise With Mouse Controls
Ah, I see how it is. You wouldn't include motion aiming in Radiant Dawn almost 20 years ago, did touch screen controls twice with DS Archanea remakes and then never again outside of FEH, and NOW you're telling me the latest game is finally taking advantage of the funny console gimmick?
Intelligent Systems at their finest, ladies and gentlemen.
Re: Mini Review: Dragon Hopper (Virtual Boy) - A Zelda-Like With Height, Heart, And A Spring In Its Step
I could tell it was an IntSys game from the start. The style fells reminiscent of their later stuff, like Paper Mario 64 and the GBA Fire Emblems. It's charming and fun, but nothing that'll blow your socks off. It might blow your eyes out, though, with visual effects like those.
Re: Sam Neill Will Reportedly Appear Posthumously In The Legend Of Zelda
He's definitely the old man who gives Link his first sword.
It would probably be a perfect final casting, since he would effectively be passing the torch.
Re: Feature: Six Things I'd Like To See in 'Metroid 6'
@-wc- I think part of the problem is how often Metroid shifts dev teams. Gunpei Yokoi died after Super Metroid, Nintendo R&D1 was disbanded after Zero Mission, and outside of Retro Studios, we've seen Metroid games done by Team Ninja, Next Level Games, (almost) Bandai Namco, and, most recently, MercurySteam. I wish they would stick to a single dev team from here on out, even if it is Mercury (Samus Returns and Dread are good, and I will die on that hill).
With that said, Zero Mission is my favorite, so I will now proceed to bolt my door before I start getting death threats. Bye 😁.
Re: Every Splatoon Game, Ranked
@BAN I was almost 10 when Splatoon 1 came out, but I only had a Wii and 3DS at the time. Looking back, I don't regret not owning a Wii U.
Re: Nintendo Music Adds Fire Emblem: Fortune's Weave As A Special Release
I like how the theme actually shows other games besides Fortune's Weave, like the Archanea games and Three Houses. Imagine if a theme stuck to the same two games instead of showing legacy content (COUGH ZELDA COUGH).
Re: "I Threatened Him" - Capcom Producer's Radical Approach To Negotiating With Miyamoto
I heard about that, actually. It's why the Oracle games have a lot of direct references to Zelda 1, which actually seems to be a rarity in this franchise.
Re: Every Splatoon Game, Ranked
@BAN I think you missed the entire point of Raiders. It's not meant to be like the others in terms of style and visuals. The music and locations are the way they are because it's supposed to involve a sense of eeriness and mystery in regards to the Salmonids. In addition, this game is obviously a spinoff. Don't expect Splatoon 4 to be like this, especially after Team Past win the Grand Festival.
Re: Opinion: When It Comes To Metroid's Future, Familiar Is Better
Kirby has entered the chat
Sometimes, the best thing a franchise can do is to not change.
Re: Video: Digital Foundry Delivers Its Tech Review For Xenoblade Chronicles 2 On Switch 2
The most notable frame dips I've experienced thus far were at the one farm with the Armu everyone fattens up for New Game Plus. I guess the Armu's glory was too much for the framerate to handle.
Re: Every Splatoon Game, Ranked
@SoIDecidedTo what are you talking about? Walleye Warehouse and Triple Splashdown are garbage. Walleye is generally considered one of the worst stages in both S1 and S2, and Triple Splashdown can be easily shot down if you know what you're doing.
Re: Every Splatoon Game, Ranked
@OorWullie Urchin Underpass and Flounder Heights did come back in 3. S3 Flounder was heavily criticized for making some walls uninkable and making the map harder to traverse overall, but Urchin Underpass is the exact same as its S1 counterpart.
We're likely never getting another stage like Saltspray, though.
Re: Every Splatoon Game, Ranked
Oh no.
This franchise is old enough to have a ranking of every game.
Insert GIF of Matt Damon getting old
Re: Fire Emblem: Fortune's Weave Characters - Every Hero Revealed So Far
@Marchop we found our Potential Man (or Woman, I guess).
Re: Fire Emblem: Fortune's Weave Characters - Every Hero Revealed So Far
@Dalamar Eshmel seems to be playing a similar role as Sothis in this game. I haven't seen them in any gameplay footage, and all the focus has been on the four main characters. Based on that, I'm assuming Eshmel will be similar to Mark from Blazing Blade, which is probably the best possible outcome.
Re: Nintendo Expands Switch 2's GameCube Library With Another Game In August
Two problems with that:
1. I already own Mario 3D All-Stars.
2. Sunshine is my least favorite 3D Mario.
Still good for those who were looking forward to this. I just it was there from launch.
Re: Best Nintendo Remakes & Remasters Of All Time, Ranked
Wow, there are a lot of things I don't agree with here.
I don't think the ports should count at all, and remasters also being here is a bit dubious.
Super Mario All-Stars can burn in the depths of Tartarus for all I care. Arguably, one of the ugliest SNES games, and it somehow manages to control worse than the originals it's based on despite releasing just two years after Super Mario World.
Zero Mission should be at the top without exception. The only other remake that did as much for the original game as Zero Mission did was Shadows of Valentia.
Finally, if you're going to put Mother 3 on the "Best GBA Games" list, than you might as well put New Mystery of the Emblem on this list as well (I'd put it somewhere around the middle, but probably closer to the bottom half).
There are so many other things I want to say about this list (mostly negative), but that would take up too much of my time. All I'll say is that, as someone who has played most of these, this list is absolutely not an accurate reflection of how these games are as remakes.
Re: Xenoblade Chronicles 2 - Nintendo Switch 2 Edition Estimated File Size Revealed
@iLikeUrAttitude THAT'S WHAT I'M SAYING. I've seen people say they won't touch RPGs with QTEs because they want to battle on strength and preparation alone, while others lambast turn-based combat for being slow and tedious. I personally like both enough, but it's impossible to please everyone.
Re: Xenoblade Chronicles 2 - Nintendo Switch 2 Edition Estimated File Size Revealed
@VinzClortho1981 last I checked, you actually can do that in Mario Luigi. It allows you to attack before they can land their hit if you time it right.
At any rate, though, I don't want E33 to become the standard for RPGs in general. Some RPG franchises don't work with QTEs, because that's not in their nature. Others, like Xenoblade, rely on constant movement and real-time action. If every future RPG were the same, that would be incredibly boring. Inserts Syndrome quote here
Re: Xenoblade Chronicles 2 - Nintendo Switch 2 Edition Estimated File Size Revealed
@VinzClortho1981 you know E33 basically borrows its combat from the Mario and Luigi games, right?
Re: Review: Splatoon Raiders (Switch 2) - The Best Single-Player Splatoon Has Fantastic Multiplayer
@Ralek85 actually, I think you summed up why I was a stick-only player for the longest time. Unfortunately, I don't think Nintendo has incentive to change this. The Splatoon pros have gotten so used to the controls for years that it's just muscle memory at this point, and there aren't enough newbies complaining about it. However, I think this is part of the reason Splatoon in general gets dismissed by the hardcore audience.
As for Star Fox, I personally adhere to stick-only, since I feel that it's the best way to go about these games, but I will definitely say that gyro is better than mouse for Star Fox.
Re: Review: Splatoon Raiders (Switch 2) - The Best Single-Player Splatoon Has Fantastic Multiplayer
@Ralek85 Star Fox 64 3D actually did have gyro aiming as an option, and it's about as good as you would want to be.
In regards to Splatoon, it's kinda funny that you should say that, considering Splatoon 1 was the big game that made hardcore gamers realize how good gyro can be back in 2015. I personally don't hate the gyro in Splatoon games, but I can still see why it would be disliked (I was a stick player for the longest time and only recently switched).
Re: Xenoblade Chronicles 2 Has Been Updated To Version 3.0.0
@Jintenzo ahem. . .the ones from the photo.
Yes, THAT photo.
Tbh, I'll be shocked if Nia doesn't also get her dress.
Re: Xenoblade Chronicles 2 Has Been Updated To Version 3.0.0
I'm nervous as to who the new Blade will be and whether or not they'll give THOSE dresses to Pyra and Mythra.
You know the ones.
Re: UK Retailer GAME Entered Administration Owing A Staggering £16 Million
Sadly, GameStop isn't doing much better here in the States. I honestly feel like Blockbuster would've still died out even if Netflix didn't exist, given the direction the industry has taken. It seems that the era of dedicated retail videogame stores has come to a close.
Re: Poll: How Would You Rate Nintendo's Switch Online Offering In 2026?
Pretty good if we're solely basing this off the controllers you can purchase, since those are the parts of this service that you're guaranteed to own. All of them are pretty fun to use and well-made from my experience, and they'll definitely have a lasting impact.
As for the rest, I don't mind the DLC and upgrade packs on offer, but the retro service is the real meat and potatoes here. As is, the library is already arguably better than any previous Virtual Console, but the drip feed is a bit annoying. Sometimes I forget NSO still gets updates until a new trailer drops. Obviously, I also wish there was a way to outright buy the games, or even just the apps themselves, since they're downloaded directly to your device and work offline.
All in all, it could still be better with a few changes, but it's still way better than GamePass and PS Plus by far, especially since those services actively hinder the sales of the games that release on those platforms.
Re: Mario Tennis Fever Free 'Super Mario Galaxy' Update Out Now, Here Are The Full Patch Notes
Virgin "release unfinished and add content updates later" Aces vs. Chad "release complete and add bonus updates later" Fever
Also, this update has more original content than the entirety of Ultra Smash.
Re: Talking Point: New Ocarina = New amiibo? Nintendo Needs To Make These Zelda Figurines
That would be nice, except for one thing: we already have an OOT amiibo with the OOT Link that released for the franchise's 25th anniversary.
Though, I suppose that didn't stop them when making the Zelda and Loftwing amiibo for Skyward HD, despite a Skyward Link amiibo also existing.
Re: Another F-Zero Album Joins The Nintendo Music Library This Week
GX probably has licensing issues, and no one seems to care about the GBA games, so this choice makes sense. I actually really like the White Land + Death Wind remix. It turned the two worst songs in the game into one of the best.
Re: Japanese Charts: Holy Moly, Look At Those Rhythm Heaven Groove Sales
@Dimjimmer I mean, I, too, would be afraid of expanding on Star Fox if the last original game completely assassinated basically every character and had awful controls.
Re: Mario Kart Tour Service Officially Ends This September
@SuperEndriu no, but it's blatantly obvious that they're gearing up for the end, especially since FEH isn't making as much money as it used to. The current book is the first stage of Ragnarok, which, according to Norse myth, takes place in three stages.
Re: Mario Kart Tour Service Officially Ends This September
A bit sad, but it was inevitable. I liked playing this game well enough and only spent money on the Gold Pass. Really hoping Piranha Plant Pipeline returns in a future Mariokart.
In other news, this means Super Mario Run, Fire Emblem Heroes, and Fire Emblem Shadows are left. Super Mario Run was always a "pay once for everything" game since its release, FEH will have a definitive ending to its story by Book 12, and FES. . .I guarantee Nintendo isn't making any money on that game.
Nintendo is clearly try to ditch the mobile game market entirely by 2030.
Re: Nintendo Expands Switch Online's Game Boy & GBA Library With Four More Titles
First off, this website lacks a dedicated page for Dr. Mario & Puzzle League. Y'all might wanna check that out.
Second, WL1 should've been there from day one on the GB app instead of WL3. It's a way better game, imo.
Re: Nintendo Will Stop Selling The Original Switch From February 2027
It's also the end of the 7th generation technology that began with the Xbox 360.
I'll miss them beautiful 720p screens. . .
Re: Poll: What Review Score Would You Give Rhythm Heaven Groove?
Why is this even a question? It's Rhythm Heaven. Everyone already knows what score they would give it.
Re: Poll: Box Art Brawl: Rhythm Heaven Fever (Wii)
@martynstuff the sad thing is that this game came out in 2011-2012, before that flag was even an issue.
Remember back when no one had a problem with rainbow flags on anything?
Re: Opinion: What's The Best Star Fox Stage, And Why Is It Sector X?
Macbeth or Area 6, probably.
Re: Round Up: The Reviews Are In For Rhythm Heaven Groove
@AussieMcBucket NOOOOOOOOOO YOU BEAT ME TO IT
Re: Round Up: The Reviews Are In For Rhythm Heaven Groove
"I'm sorry, but you've thrown off the Emperor's Groove."
Sorry, I couldn't help myself. That movie is one of my favorites from Disney, and that subtitle triggered my nostalgia.
Re: Review: Rhythm Heaven Groove (Switch) - A Low-Key Swansong And Perfect Mic-Drop For Switch 1
@mlt I only played the demo, but it was prompted at the beginning, and it was on the main menu. It basically tests your input on every fourth beat, and if it's successful, it'll calculate inputs in the rest of the game based on that test.
Re: Review: Rhythm Heaven Groove (Switch) - A Low-Key Swansong And Perfect Mic-Drop For Switch 1
They have an input test to help nullify the lag, and it worked for me, so I don't see what the issue is here.
Other than that, about what I expected. It's Rhythm Heaven. Go buy it.
Re: Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion Remastered Launches August, Physical Edition Confirmed
Honestly, this release is far too late for Nintendo consoles. This game seems to have lost its luster and popularity in the two decades since its release that a Nintendo version isn't exciting in the slightest.
Also, this game was infamously responsible for the DLC plague we are dealing with to this very day, so there's that, too.
This game was the beginning of the end for Bethesda.
Re: Poll: What Review Score Would You Give Star Fox On Switch 2?
@xzacutor the dialogue in the remake is actually closer to the original Japanese text than how it was previously. Most of the lines in Star Fox 64 proper were improvised, from what I've seen. I'm not saying I disagree, but it's definitely a localization quirk more than anything.
Re: Poll: What Review Score Would You Give Star Fox On Switch 2?
@xmkbest I think you completely missed the appeal of Star Fox 64.
Re: Poll: What Review Score Would You Give Star Fox On Switch 2?
It's an 8.5 for me. No Star Fox was ever gonna be a 9 or 10 for me, but this is as good as it gets for this franchise.
Re: Poll: What Review Score Would You Give Star Fox On Switch 2?
@rvcolem1 apparently, Blue Storm sucked, according to Wave Race die-hards. I agree on the Excite games on Wii, though. Those games genuinely shocked me with how solid they were.
Re: Poll: What's Your Switch 2 Game Of The Year So Far?
I know we're halfway through the year, but this feels like terrible timing, since most of the impactful stuff is in the latter half of the year.
As of right now, though, Star Fox.
Re: Multiple Switch Games Have Received Switch 2 Compatibility Fixes
@RupeeClock ok, thank you for that.