Comments 233

Re: Talking Point: Do You Play Zelda Games For The Story?

Zeldinion

@Dr_Corndog Well there's an outdated take if I've ever seen one. Video games have been used in the last decade to tell some of the most creatively led stories around, using their gameplay and interactivity as a bonus to the story rather than a hinderance. Alan Wake II, Clair Obscur, Immortality, and Disco Elysium for example.

Re: Rumour: The Legend Of Zelda Movie May Have Found Its Composer

Zeldinion

@Anchel Came here to say this. It seems likely that a lot of the crew will be Wes Ball's usual collaborators such as Dan Zimmerman listed as editor, with Nintendo higher up acting as consultants where necessary. All sounds good to me so far, the only thing still slightly worrying me is the track record of the film's two credited writers.

Re: Professor Layton And The New World Of Steam Has Been Delayed Until 2026

Zeldinion

@VoidofLight As far as we know, Layton does not have any AI generated materials in it or it's trailers thus far. While they have used it in marketing for other IP, the way Hino spoke about it recently makes me believe that they currently only plan to use it as placeholder material or for marketing to speed up development and lower costs, while still replacing any in game assets with real art. This isn't confirmed, and its still not great, but it isn't all evil.

Re: Opinion: Silksong's Big 'Anticlimactic' Premiere Was Absolutely Perfect

Zeldinion

Only thing I would have also liked is a little video update from the devs similar to the announcement vid. and also where the heck are the release details? Two weeks away and we have no ideas on stuff like pricing or physical releases, or how the game runs on consoles like Switch 1. Definitely would like to hear about those soon!

Re: Editorial: Gamers, Support The People And Sites You Love, Before It's Too Late

Zeldinion

@Alaninho I did miss it actually, although I'd have to agree with most of their points. And no, its not a misnomer. There is no percentage of political games. Politics is not just something you see on the news and the election ballot, it is not something you can avoid. It is intrinsic to modern life, the rules of society influencing every person and thus every creation. Architecture is political. Cartography is political. Food is political. And again, art is most DEFINITELY political at its most fundamental basis.

Re: Editorial: Gamers, Support The People And Sites You Love, Before It's Too Late

Zeldinion

@dskatter There's often so little space for nuance in these conversations, to say 'theres no hope' is very unfair. As I said, it's less inflammatory than it is learnt experience. You won't be surprised to find the language of Daxmans original comments in several hateful spaces on the internet, where they do mean to purposefully exclude or insult people of colour or members of the LGBTQ+ community. It's definitely far less rude than the comment I highlighted that called many of the responses on this chain 'nasty'.

Re: Editorial: Gamers, Support The People And Sites You Love, Before It's Too Late

Zeldinion

@dskatter Maybe so, but its not unfair to say that the term 'pushing agendas' is consistently used as a dog whistle on the internet for exactly what they describe

@dr-ghost You are wrong in your assumption, my statement stands that ALL art is political. There is no 'my politics'. Whether it be right wing, left wing or anything inbetween, every piece of creation is an extension of its creator and therefore the political values of their time.

Re: Editorial: Gamers, Support The People And Sites You Love, Before It's Too Late

Zeldinion

@Alaninho If you frame these as attacks then that itself is the issue. Debate is encouraged, and structuring your own points and opinions as a disagreement is perfectly justifiable. I, nor any other comment here, has said anything I would deem inflammatory in response to Dazman. If you perceive the many comments that say "these journalists were fired because they put politics in video games" as 'opinions' and the people disagreeing with them as 'nasty' and 'hive-minded' then that lends itself to showing your own bias about who can speak freely and who cannot.

Re: Editorial: Gamers, Support The People And Sites You Love, Before It's Too Late

Zeldinion

@Dazman You can choose to ignore it if you wish, but all stories are by-products of the times in which they were created. They are a direct result of the world we live in - whether it be the childlike wonder of catching bugs in nature that spawned Pokémon, the rapid modernization of America in the late 1800s that later inspired Red Dead Redemption or more bluntly the treatment of minorities by police officers as one of the central themes of Life Is Strange 2. As the co-director of the latter Michel Koch said, "When you're creating something it is political in every way because we hold up some of our own beliefs.And sometimes deciding to speak about something or also deciding not to talk about a subject is a political decision in and of itself.". Call of Duty games are often set in real warzones, Assassin's Creed plays off historic settings, and every dystopian game setting is about a the fundamentally political idea of dystopia (Fallout is a prime example there). Even media which bears no apparent link to the state of the world such as the tv show 'Spy X Family' and the 2023 Bayonetta spinoff 'Cereza and the Lost Demon' were created with Japan's declining birth rate in mind (both projects feature children as central characters, meant to inspire potential parents to have kids of their own).

At this point I will make the assumption based on the terms you used in your rhetoric and your brief defence of the app-once-known-as-twitter that your idea of 'pushing agendas' stems from the increase in games being made with a greater sense of diversity, a wider variety of historical context, and a deeper sense of identity. This, as all things, is not simply an 'agenda' or a 'narrative'. It's art made by people who have always existed, who will always exist, who have only now had their voices heard. That is what videogames are, and what games journalism highlights.

Re: Editorial: Gamers, Support The People And Sites You Love, Before It's Too Late

Zeldinion

Polygon's video team (responsible for some of the most well known, iconic and just generally fun video games journalism on youtube) has been reduced to just one person, the wonderful video presenter Simone De Rochefort. The entire rest of the team was laid off. A huge loss for the gaming space online in my opinion, whether you watched them or not.

And as for @Dazman, games are an art form. Art has always been political. The two are inherently intertwined and journalism is exactly the space in which those links are explored.

Re: Zelda Timeline Featuring Breath Of The Wild And Tears Of The Kingdom Spotted

Zeldinion

Awh man they've changed it AGAIN, previously to this they claimed breath of the wild was so far into the future it happened in ALL THREE timelines which I thought was incredibly interesting lore wise - like no matter what they were destined to happen. Dont get ne started on the lack of Age of Calamity either, it would have been so easy to slot that in before breath of the wild with a divergent timeline that splits off into the future. A second case of Win/Lose timelines that result in breath of the wild happening in only one. I know realistically it doesnt matter and its never affected my enjoyment of the games but it is a lot of fun to try and figure out why nintendo puts certain games where and having two of them separated entirely is a little boring.