Comments 2,412

Re: Nintendo Left Sony "Standing At The Altar" With SNES Disk Add-On, Says Former PlayStation Exec

EarthboundBenjy

I don't see the problem with a Nintendo fan enjoying PS1 more than N64? This comment section is weird. Just because we're on a Nintendo focused site doesn't mean every user has to always side with Nintendo in every opportunity.

PS1 clearly had the larger variety of games than N64. It's not a matter of "brand loyalty" at this point, the two machines are very very different products. Like, if you were an RPG fan, you were just completely out of luck on N64, while PS1 was out there completely revolutionising the genre.

Re: Bullet-Hell Shmup Refused Classification In The West Over 'Expression Restrictions'

EarthboundBenjy

@DDFawfulGuy

I don't know if it helps or hurts the point you were making, but I just wanted to bring attention to the twitter account of the game's artist, which features many erotic artworks of big boob characters drawn in the same cutesy art style.

(WARNING EXTREMELY NSFW TWITTER)
https://twitter.com/Skapon_g

As for the big boob characters in REDNEG ALLSTARS specifically, who can say if it was intended to just be a funny character design or not, but I just wanted to point out that the artist does in fact draw erotica in the same exact art style.

By the way, my stance on the matter is that it shouldn't be such a big deal to draw a character with big boobs. I don't think big boobs are always inherently sexual, it can just be used as a character design element in order to exaggerate someone's appearance for comical effect, characterisation, or any other reason. Even just to have some big boob characters for the sake of it, or for representation, or whatever, I think it's fine.

And I also don't think that a game should be "banned" just because one of the characters is very booby. I think there must be something else going on that hasn't been made clear.

Re: The Game Awards 2024 Players' Voice Nominees Have Been Revealed - Zelda, Sonic And More

EarthboundBenjy

My personal game of the year, UFO 50, is not in this list.

Of those games in the list, the only one I've actually played is Zelda (though I did play the original Sonic Generations when it was new in 2011)

When Zelda Echoes of Wisdom came out, it was kind of awkward because I was so invested into UFO 50, I just wanted to do nothing but play it - but as a Zelda fan, I needed to also play the new Zelda, of course! So I was sort of hopping between them both, I wanted to play both of them so badly...

Then when I finished Zelda, I immediately felt relieved because it meant I could go back to UFO 50 without distractions.

And now several months post release, Zelda has mostly left my mind and yet I'm still obsessing over UFO 50 even though I've beaten both of them haha.

Makes me feel kind of bad as a huge Zelda fan though. I feel like I'm not giving Echoes of Wisdom the adoration it deserves, but to be quite honest, it was a little bit underwhelming as Zelda games go. And UFO 50 is such a huge labour of love that deserves all the respect in the world for achieving what it managed to achieve.

So yeah. Sorry to Zelda but.... as far as my personal gaming world is concerned, there was a much more significant and much more interesting game release than Zelda this year.

...Oh and tbh i'm not all that interested in The Game Awards anyway, so whatevs.

Re: Video: 10 Exciting New Games Coming To Nintendo Switch In December 2024

EarthboundBenjy

Croc was my first 3d platformer ever. I loved it as a kid, but I am well aware it is not "good". I don't know if I want the remake because I'm not sure if I'll get much value from it.

I already have the majority of the game memorised in my head. Even the weird secrets like stomping three times on the floating platform in the very first screen of the first level to enter a bonus room with 1ups, or falling off the bottomless cliff near the cogs in one of the ice levels to find a bonus room. Or having the dang pattern of the incredibly annoying sheep challenge completely memorised. Aggh. I don't know if I need to play this remake lol, it's possible I've had enough Croc to last a lifetime.

On a similar note, Rollercoaster Tycoon was also a beloved childhood game of mine. But unlike Croc, this is a game that has infinite replayability, so it may be fun to get it on Switch for the sake of it, even though I still have the original CD ROM somewhere in the house and could easily get it running on my laptop right now if I felt so inclined.... I guess having it on Switch would be a fun novelty. But it's not a priority by any means.

Re: Final Fantasy VII Switch Update Removes "Restrictions For Sharing Features"

EarthboundBenjy

square have done this in other games. Live A Live restricted the capture button during the entire final chapter iirc. They patched it out shortly after.

But this FF7 rerelease has been on Switch for years. I wonder why it took so long to patch it out for this one, especially for one of the most well-known plot twists in gaming history, at that?

btw I think this practice is absurd. Any company trying to enforce any kind of "anti spoiler" policy is completely misunderstanding their audience. It's not just Square, I've seen Atlus try to enforce stupid anti-spoiler things too.

Re: Talking Point: What Would Be The Ideal Way To Play DS Games On 'Switch 2'?

EarthboundBenjy

the implementation of Dominus Collection is almost perfect. It's a little clumsy to make precise touchscreen inputs with the analogue stick, which is fine for this collection because it is rarely necessary in the game (and the magic seals that required precise inputs were reworked to use buttons anyway). It wouldn't work so well for Rhythm Heaven for example that requires a very specific flick action. For a game like that, it'd make more sense to remake it entirely rather than emulate. That's the tricky thing about DS touchscreen usage - it was so versatile, any modern ports are gonna have to be dealt with on a case-by-case basis.

Re: Talking Point: What Are Your Top 5 Nintendo DS Games?

EarthboundBenjy

For me it's gotta be the three Castlevanias, and then Pokémon gen 5. But... Rhythm Heaven is also one of my favourite things to ever exist too.

I spent so much time on Mario Kart and Kirby too, back in the day. The DS was so good, I still haven't gone through my backlog of games I need to play.

Most recently I played Ghost Trick for the first time (On a proper DS, too, it wasn't a modern version). It was pretty good, and it made me want to play Hotel Dusk at some point too. There's still life in the machine yet!

Re: Dragon Quest 3 Remake Producer Would "Love" To See Final Fantasy 6 HD-2D

EarthboundBenjy

How many remakes does one game need? Pixel Remaster doesn't even have the GBA content, so it's not even definitive. Did they purposefully impair the Pixel Remaster version so that they could make a HD-2D definitive version later, or what? is that why they're talking about another remake so soon after we just got one?

Hey I have an idea. they won't do it, but... What if they just made Final Fantasy 17 a HD-2D pixel art game? Just straight up do the next mainline FF game in this style. Would be more interesting than yet another extremely high budget hack n slash after FF16 and FF7R , right?

Re: Random: Rapper Doja Cat Debuts 'Bouncy' Conker-Inspired Halloween Costume

EarthboundBenjy

When you think of 18+ N64 games, Conker is the one to come to mind immediately, but for some reason the most recent N64 NSO update didn't add it. We got Shadow Man instead, which is a game I've been interested in trying. (but I decided to buy "Shadow Man Remastered" from GOG, so I still don't need to subscribe to the expansion tier just yet!)
... Maybe it's because it's too soon after Banjo Tooie was released, so they're saving Conker for later. But I have absolutely no doubt that it will come to the 18+ app sooner or later. It's the mature N64 game lol.

Re: Poll: What's The Best Ys Game? Rate Your Favourites For Our Upcoming Ranking

EarthboundBenjy

@Drake
Just for completeness's sake, did you play Ys vs Trails in the Sky: Alternative Saga for PSP? I played through story mode once just to check out its unique final boss, which is actually a dragon called Galsis from Xanadu, and isn't even from Ys or Trails. But the game itself is one of those fighters where you have to level-grind your characters individually, and there's no way in heck I'm putting that kind of time into it. I didn't even feel like unlocking all the unlockable fighters lol.

Also, during my personal quest to play every Ys game, I did decide to skip over Ys Strategy. The tutorial mission bored me to death. Maybe one day I'll find the willpower to actually figure this one out, but the prospect of playing more of it did not fill me with excitement at all.

Re: Talking Point: What Are You Playing This Weekend? (26th October)

EarthboundBenjy

For me, 2023 was the year I played every Ys game, and 2024 is the year I've been playing every Suikoden game. ...but now that Ys X Nordics has released, I've put Suikoden on hold in favour of the new Ys! So that'll be my gaming plan for the next while.

Also been playing a ton of UFO 50. I've been trying to get every cherry, and I'm getting pretty close now! Next I have to master the ridiculous controls of Onion Delivery... it's painful, but fun at the same time somehow.

Re: Poll: What's The Best Ys Game? Rate Your Favourites For Our Upcoming Ranking

EarthboundBenjy

@Tyranexx

As for Ys VI, there are multiple version of this too - the Konami versions for PS2 and PSP have some differences to the main PC release. PS2 has voice acting and uses 3D models for characters rather than sprites, and includes a brand new challenge dungeon not in any other versions. PSP version replaces the challenge dungeon with extremely tedious minigames instead, but also includes an in-game bestiary which is not in any other version. And while the original PC CD-ROM release didn't have it, the most modern Steam version of Ys VI is the only one to include fast-travel.

Ys Origin does have some minor differences between versions too - most notably consoles like Switch need to play through both Yunica and Hugo to unlock Toal's story, while Steam version only needs to play through one of them. But aside from this, there aren't many differences.

Then Lacrimosa of Dana has some differences between versions too - most notably the original PS Vita release did not include some features that were made for later versions, including the entire solo Dana dungeon, the Underground Sanctuary! This is a case where the modern versions are strictly better than the original as far as I know.

Re: Poll: What's The Best Ys Game? Rate Your Favourites For Our Upcoming Ranking

EarthboundBenjy

@Tyranexx

III and IV are the "only" ones with multiple versions??
There are way more Ys games with multiple versions than that.

Most notably., Ys I & II have like a billion versions. Most notably are the "modern" remakes, the Eternal / Complete / Chronicles versions which revamped the games, notably adding the port town Barbado to Ys 1, redesigning the overworld, and adding the gift items to Ys II among many other additions and changes.
But aside from this, all the various console ports of Ys I and II have major differences between them. the Famicon Ys 1 had many differences in the overworld, including a new quest to get into the Mines, the X68000 Ys 1 had an expanded Minea town and a very truncated overworld, and the DS Legacy of Ys version added an entirely new location to traverse, the "Vageux-Vardette".
The TG-16 Ys Book I & II also changed some story elements, including Adol safely arriving on the boat instead of arriving shipwrecked, as well as the fate of Sara the fortune-teller.
Not to mention the MS-DOS Ys II Special which claims to be Ys II but is in fact a completely original game.

It's definitely not like a Legend of Zelda situation where there is only one version of Zelda I and only one version of Zelda II, despite having so many GBA ports, GameCube ports etc - they are all the "same" game inside. But Ys I & II very often have different content with each release.

Wanderers from Ys and Oath in Felghana as you say are the two "Ys III" versions, that is as you say.

As for Ys IV, of course there's Dawn, Mask and Celceta as you mentioned, but there's actually another version called Ys IV: Mask of the Sun - A New Theory for PlayStation 2.

I played through A New Theory, and it was completely different from the SNES Mask of the Sun. The overworld layout was redesigned (and better than SNES, that's for sure), all the bosses, dungeons, story progression was different, the combat and magic system was different.
It was a better-balanced game than the SNES one, but it had its own brand new problems that make it a very mediocre game in its own way. The magic system is convoluted and largely useless, the backtracking is extreme and tedious (and the majority of mandatory backtracking is required before getting fast-travel), and most annoyingly of all, you can't save in dungeons, which means you have to do the whole dungeon, including the boss, and the turning-around-and-leaving-the-way-you-came without dying a single time. It's very very annoying.

As for Ys V, there was also a PlayStation 2 version of this game too. It has similar overworld as the SNES Ys V, except they removed some areas such as the jungle and marsh entirely. And the city of Kefin itself was redesigned. The dungeon interiors are all new, and now are all extremely extremely bad. It's some of the worst RPG dungeon design I have ever seen, and makes the latter half of the game a huge chore.

Re: Poll: What's The Best Ys Game? Rate Your Favourites For Our Upcoming Ranking

EarthboundBenjy

Lacrimosa of Dana is the best one overall I think. Most people probably agree with this. Though I've just started Nordics today, so we'll see if it can hold a candle.

The EGG CONSOLE releases' main problem is the lack of English. Aside from that, they're not bad releases, but they also don't look as nice as the TurboGrafx-16 version.

Unfortunate the TurboGrafx-16 Ys Book I & II is not in this poll - it was released on Wii Virtual Console after all, so that should count as a Nintendo release, right?

The SNES version of Wanderers from Ys is kinda awful. Actually most versions of Wanderers from Ys aren't that great, but I found the SNES version particularly bad. If you're looking to play Ys III, I'd say just play Oath in Felghana instead. Unless you're really interested in watching the series evolve over time (like I was). Oath in Felghana has the same plot and setting as Wanderers, but in the form of a good game, rather than an incredibly mediocre one.

Speaking of the TurboGrafx-16 - if you enjoy Ys Book I & II, absolutely be sure to check out the fan translation of Ys IV: The Dawn of Ys! It's the best of the old-school bump-combat games for sure! And don't get it confused with Ys IV: Mask of the Sun, which is an entirely different game (and isn't all that great, especially in comparison to Dawn).

Just be aware that Dawn of Ys is incredibly non-canon. And ever since the release of Memories of Celceta, Mask of the Sun isn't canon any more either. This series has a complicated history, go figure.

I'd say the most underrated Ys game of all is the MS-DOS exclsuive "Ys II Special" which is so obscure it wasn't even released in Japan. It's Korea-exclusive, and unfortunately no fan translation exists yet. But it is such a huge expansive Ys game - it's not like the regular Ys II, it's so much bigger. And it manages to combine the traditional bump-combat with having an actual sword button at the same time, and it works great!
...Just be aware that Ys II Special is incredibly buggy, and a game-breaking, progress-blocking bug exists that can only be circumnavigated if you have found a very hidden item that lets you save and reload outside of towns (since saving and reloading at a specific point can prevent the crash, but if you don't have this item, you're out of luck).... eehhh, maybe I don't feel so great recommending Ys II Special since you have to jump through so many hoops to enjoy it, but I certainly had a great time with it personally, even if I couldn't read any of the text.

The worst Ys game of all time is the PlayStation 2 version of Ys V Lost Kefin Kingdom of Sand. The original SNES version of Ys V wasn't all that great to begin with, but the PS2 version takes the cake for its absolutely atrociously boring level design in the dungeons. It's endless copy+pasted room after room. ...
They really need to take the Ys V/Xandria/Kefin story and turn it into a proper new game one of these days, just like Oath did for Wanderers and Celceta did for Mask. ... Maybe it'll be the next Ys release?

Re: Upcoming Vampire Survivors DLC Is An Epic Ode To Castlevania

EarthboundBenjy

Wow, the game was already a huge Castlevania homage, it's kind of weird to see the "knock-off" Belmont stand-ins appearing next to the actual Belmont characters in the same scene lol.
It's cool though, the game is good fun, and it's nice to see Konami collaborate with indie devs who are obviously huge fans of Castlevania

Re: Zelda Speedrunners Are Already Beating Echoes Of Wisdom In Under An Hour

EarthboundBenjy

Ahh, I love Zelda speedruns. I have been taking my time with the game (only done the first three dungeons so far) so I won't be watching them until I'm done, but I'm glad to see this game has the same Zelda speedrunning shenanigans we all know and love.

I remember the previous Zelda game of this style, Link's Awakening, had some cool tech where you could manipulate the orange foxes in Mabe Village to knock you on top of the trees. But now in Echoes of Wisdom, walking on top of the trees is a natural part of the game! So the crazy stuff can only escalate from there.

Re: Talking Point: What Are You Playing This Weekend? (28th September)

EarthboundBenjy

I've been playing Zelda of course. It's great. But I've also been playing UFO 50. It's also really great. The release dates of these two games are awkwardly conflicting, because I would love nothing more than to devote my undivided attention to Zelda, or to UFO 50, but now I'm kind of awkwardly swapping back and forth between them because I want to play both so badly lol.

Re: Lunar Remastered Collection Revives Beloved '90s JRPG Series On Switch In Spring 2025

EarthboundBenjy

Nice. I've wanted to play these for a while, but I haven't had access to them, the PS1 discs are kinda pricey secondhand. And annoyingly the Mega-CD versions contained in the Japanese Mega Drive Mini 2 are unfortunately Japanese only, despite other games in the MD Minis having all regional variants. They wanted to make extra sure I wasn't able to play it I guess.

I did play a tiny amount of Lunar Legend for GBA, but that version had buggy saving... the game doesn't save your inventory properly and I ended up losing a good armour. So I stopped playing cause I didn't want to deal with that lol. Glad that I'll be able to get a nice new version.

Re: Best Nintendo Switch Collections And Compilation Games

EarthboundBenjy

@Cipher36
Input delay might not be noticeable if you're not familiar with the games or don't have a comparison point. The input delay in the collection was so bad it made Sonic unplayable for me, but a few of the other games were more bearable since I don't have the same familiarity, even if the delay is the same. And for RPGs the delay was not a problem - so in the end, I primarily used this collection as a Phantasy Star IV launcher haha (seriously that game is so good, it's worth getting the collection just for it alone)

If you're interested, try booting up Sonic Origins or Sega Ages Sonic 2 and jumping around a bit, and then go back to the Mega Drive Classics collection version of Sonic and compare how it feels. Even if it's a fraction of a second difference, that difference is noticeable to Sonic fans and makes the fast-paced platforming significantly more annoying to play.

Re: Talking Point: What Are You Playing This Weekend? (21st September)

EarthboundBenjy

I'm still in my phase of playing through my huge RPG backlog (Suikoden V is next on my to-do list), however I don't want to start a new one just before Zelda comes out, 'cause any time a new Zelda comes out, that'll always be top priority.

For now, I decided to buy UFO 50 which was recently released on Steam. It's basically a modern take on the "Action 52" concept - a compilation of 50 completely original NES-style games, except it differs from Action 52 in that the games are actually good. It's a really cool package, especially for retro enthusiasts.
Kind of just browsing through them at the moment, though one of them titled "Mooncat" really fascinated me with its completely unique control scheme and otherworldly aesthetic

Re: The Legend Of Zelda '80s Cartoon Series Gets DVD Re-Release

EarthboundBenjy

...I already have a DVD of this. I don't really keep track of different DVD releases, so I'm not sure what this new announcement really means.

I even watched it a year or so ago. I felt like I owed it to myself as a Zelda fan to actually see this cartoon.

...It was bad.

I did kind of like Spryte the fairy though.