I'm a big supporter of physical media (honestly just because it's nice having games ready to play) but even I've accepted these kinds of things are pretty standard
I think it was around the time I bought the bioshock collection and found it wasn't all on cart
I don't really care about 30 fps (but their approach to releasing and looking to update later is disappointing) but I also don't care at all about this remake of a game that is still available easily on switch 1 and 2 from only a few years ago
Honestly what were they thinking remaking this rather than opting for a sequel? The marketing for this has been so over the top and the development time seems just as long as a new game, who is this even marketed to? Is their selling point "we know the original wasn't great so please trust us this time we've tweaked it slightly rather than developing new content"?
@KoopaTheGamer I think because Annapurna has a reputation for the games they publish. Typically quirky but generally well regarded. It's part of the marketing essentially
Also, people complaining about the D pad. This is essentially what Nintendo has done with switch controllers - it's just supposed to be used as individual inputs rather than a proper Street fighter 2 directional combo pad
I never felt more connected with controlling a video game than using the GameCube controller on Pikmin
The C stick was perfect for flicking, the big a button was great to have centered
Now playing switch 2 I feel like there's no personality to the controller. A bit default, a bit MOR... I'd rather something that is sublime for some games and middling for others honestly. Like video games - wouldn't you rather one fantastic experience than ten average ones?
No way Nintendo would let them shadow drop on launch day. Can you imagine how much money Nintendo would be throwing at team cherry to let them announce "available at launch"?
@EVIL-C I mean you can't be prescriptive about people using a term, 2nd party is well understood despite the "legality" perhaps having different definitions
2nd party to me means any studio that either exclusively works with Nintendo or works on Nintendo IPs. E.g. Rare was a second party developer for Nintendo before they were purchased by Microsoft
I never thought I'd see the day where Nintendo offers mild improvements to existing games like this
Yes, we've had low-effort remakes and ports, but not "here's a minor upgrade aligned with new hardware". It's very much what Microsoft and PlayStation do - trying to stay at that graphical cutting edge rather than focusing on new ideas
(Yes, I'm aware updated graphics and new games aren't mutually exclusive, but Nintendo always erred on the gameplay side)
@AllBLK I mean it's basically like FIFA or COD in that you buy the latest and have the most fun in the year around launch while waiting for new content/next version
It gives me the same feel as when Sonic Frontiers was announced - kind of fun if you look at it a certain way but not at all what anyone was asking for and certainly not a great fit for the character
@Oldstalk exactly why they're taking their time with it. It it can release at the same price as the first with ridiculous amounts of content it'll be a massive seller
Yes, I like this. It's a very satisfying, physical card-esque approach to virtual games and makes me feel like I actually "own" these games rather than them being lesser as a form of digital download
Two things I'd like to say: 1. The incentive for smaller games to buy carts to fit their game is actually lower, as the user experience is less impacted by smaller downloads than larger. Why bother paying to put the full game on a cart when it's only a few GB and can be downloaded in minutes?
2. Anyone who isn't a collector or otherwise interested in gaming and tech won't bat an eyelid at this. Store person: "just so you're aware, this game needs to be downloaded. It's a game key card." Customer: "so I can't resell it?" Store person: "oh no, you can still resell it, just that you need to fully download the game first" Customer: confused look "please just give me my game"
Comments 190
Re: Mortal Kombat: Legacy Kollection Switch 1 & 2 Physical Release Does Not Include Mortal Kombat 4 On The Game Card
@SuppressorSteve I used to and still collect some media formats that aren't available on streaming
Re: Mortal Kombat: Legacy Kollection Switch 1 & 2 Physical Release Does Not Include Mortal Kombat 4 On The Game Card
I'm a big supporter of physical media (honestly just because it's nice having games ready to play) but even I've accepted these kinds of things are pretty standard
I think it was around the time I bought the bioshock collection and found it wasn't all on cart
Re: Review: Warhammer 40,000: Rogue Trader (Switch 2) - A Hard Pass For A Great Game
@Kisame83 I mean there are always slight revisions of consoles, I thought the switch 2 had had one already?
Re: Review: Simogo Legacy Collection - Nintendo Switch 2 Edition - Nothing Less Than Essential
Thanks for the great review of a game by a fantastic developer
Re: Top 100 Nintendo Games, As Chosen By Nintendo Life & IGN
@JCLKaytwo galaxy 1 is way better
No Yoshi plus spring suit? Yes please
Re: Top 100 Nintendo Games, As Chosen By Nintendo Life & IGN
This is great for engagement - what a zany list
Re: Yooka-Replaylee Runs At 30fps On Switch 2, Team Investigating Performance Mode
I don't really care about 30 fps (but their approach to releasing and looking to update later is disappointing) but I also don't care at all about this remake of a game that is still available easily on switch 1 and 2 from only a few years ago
Honestly what were they thinking remaking this rather than opting for a sequel? The marketing for this has been so over the top and the development time seems just as long as a new game, who is this even marketed to? Is their selling point "we know the original wasn't great so please trust us this time we've tweaked it slightly rather than developing new content"?
Re: Nintendo Direct September 2025: Every Announcement, Game Reveal, Trailer
So if you have the original non-anniversary edition of human fall flat, what is the upgrade path to the Nintendo switch 2 edition?
Is there an additional cost for the anniversary content plus the switch 2 edition?
Re: Annapurna's Delightfully Weird Creature Collecting Roguelite Scores Switch Release Date
@KoopaTheGamer I think because Annapurna has a reputation for the games they publish. Typically quirky but generally well regarded. It's part of the marketing essentially
Re: Annapurna Is Bringing This Cute Co-op LEGO Game To Switch In September
What's the latest with Annapurna after all those layoffs?
Re: Nintendo's LEGO Game Boy Officially Revealed, Releasing 1st October 2025
@infernogott to make it playable you'd need lots of wiring and large individual pieces.. would suck all of the fun of it being a Lego set out of it
Re: Blurred Art In Nintendo's N64 Switch Online Trailer Suggests Exciting Upcoming Additions
It's such a higher barrier to entry to enjoying N64 games vs nes or snes... They really should be picking the best ones
Re: Dredge Developer 'Black Salt Games' Isn't Working On A Sequel
Maybe if they made dredge 2 they could actually integrate the content and story with the gameplay?
I felt like I was doing fetch quests for the whole game with little incentive to explore
Re: Every Nintendo Switch Online GameCube Game On Switch 2, Ranked
@batmanbud2 what's the difference between a remake and remaster or Luigi's mansion?
Re: Every Nintendo Switch Online GameCube Game On Switch 2, Ranked
"here's the original versions of games we've remastered" - Nintendo
Re: PSA: Do Your Switch 2 Joy-Con Disconnect In Docked Mode? It Might Be The HDMI Cable You're Using
@RootsGenoa i just have one HDMI cable that I switch between for my Bluray player and switch
Easier to swap it across than have a loose extra cable there that needs me to find the remote to switch between inputs for
Re: Assassin's Creed 4: Black Flag Actor Drops The Biggest Remake Hint Yet
I just don't understand all these remakes of games from a generation (or two) ago that are still available to play on current consoles
Re: Poll: Box Art Brawl: Duel - Resident Evil: The Darkside Chronicles
Is that Wesker in the Japanese one?
Re: Review: Tron: Catalyst (Switch) - A Repetitive & Forgettable Time On The Grid
How is the game length a positive?
Re: Review: Nintendo Switch Online GameCube Controller - The Return Of The King
Also, people complaining about the D pad. This is essentially what Nintendo has done with switch controllers - it's just supposed to be used as individual inputs rather than a proper Street fighter 2 directional combo pad
Re: Review: Nintendo Switch Online GameCube Controller - The Return Of The King
I never felt more connected with controlling a video game than using the GameCube controller on Pikmin
The C stick was perfect for flicking, the big a button was great to have centered
Now playing switch 2 I feel like there's no personality to the controller. A bit default, a bit MOR... I'd rather something that is sublime for some games and middling for others honestly. Like video games - wouldn't you rather one fantastic experience than ten average ones?
Re: Random: You Can Mix & Match Switch 1 + 2 Joy-Con As Pairs
Thanks for the note on the switch 2 joycons on the switch 1, I was half considering buying a pair
Re: Hardware Review (In Progress): Nintendo Switch 2 - A Faster, Slicker, Sexier Switch
I'm not planning on buying one for a while, I think it came down to two things for me:
Re: 007 First Light Official Game Reveal, Launching On Switch 2 In 2026
Uh no thanks
Give me an older bond struggling to keep up with the world for a change
Re: Mortal Kombat: Legacy Kollection Comes To Switch And Switch 2 In 2025
No mortal Kombat trilogy? Not interested
Re: Hollow Knight Fans Reignite Silksong Shadow Drop Speculation Following Steam Page Update
No way Nintendo would let them shadow drop on launch day. Can you imagine how much money Nintendo would be throwing at team cherry to let them announce "available at launch"?
Re: Nintendo Updates 'Switch Online' Trailer With New Switch 2 Footage
@tourjeff good luck waiting for star fox after the horrible string of games leading to zero
Re: Feature: "Game-Key Cards Don't Sit Right With Us" - Lost In Cult Dives Into Its New Physical Games Line
Is there any kind of physical preservation movement for PC games given the use of steam, gog etc currently?
Re: Random: Mario Kart World's Devs Had To Double Check Mario Actually Eats Power-Up Mushrooms
A nice beef Wellington with mushr-
Re: Nintendo Music's Latest Update Celebrates Another NES Classic, Here's Every Song Included
I was honestly extremely impressed when I played this game about ten years ago
Has a rogue like feel and the difficulty is juuust hard enough to make you want to master it
Re: Here's A Look At The Size And Inside Of Switch 2 Game Cases
Pretty standard iteration then
Much nicer than the swapping of console banner from the left to the right with DS to 3DS. They really should have used some kind of blue
Re: Nintendo Has "No Plans" To Use Game-Key Cards For First-Party-Developed Titles
@EVIL-C I mean you can't be prescriptive about people using a term, 2nd party is well understood despite the "legality" perhaps having different definitions
2nd party to me means any studio that either exclusively works with Nintendo or works on Nintendo IPs. E.g. Rare was a second party developer for Nintendo before they were purchased by Microsoft
Re: Nintendo Has "No Plans" To Use Game-Key Cards For First-Party-Developed Titles
I mean the future is 100% digital, absolutely
I'm glad to have been around for physical media, and enjoy my physical collection, but it's high time we all acknowledged where this is ending up
Re: 12 Switch Games Are Getting Free Switch 2 Upgrades, Here's What You Can Expect
I never thought I'd see the day where Nintendo offers mild improvements to existing games like this
Yes, we've had low-effort remakes and ports, but not "here's a minor upgrade aligned with new hardware". It's very much what Microsoft and PlayStation do - trying to stay at that graphical cutting edge rather than focusing on new ideas
(Yes, I'm aware updated graphics and new games aren't mutually exclusive, but Nintendo always erred on the gameplay side)
Re: Talking Point: Are You Ghosting Switch 1 To Save Yourself For Switch 2?
@LastFootnote have only just started it but I'm impressed so far. Loving the aesthetic and the lack of handholding
Sort of brings to mind a cross between Minit and Tunic
Re: Talking Point: Are You Ghosting Switch 1 To Save Yourself For Switch 2?
I've just started on Master Key... Why do I need a new console?
Re: Mortal Kombat 1 Looks To Be Winding Down Support With The 'Definitive Edition'
@AllBLK I mean it's basically like FIFA or COD in that you buy the latest and have the most fun in the year around launch while waiting for new content/next version
Re: Random: 'New' Super Mario 64 Sound Effect Can Only Be Heard By Leaving The Game On...For 14 Months
Imagine there's a bus
Re: Random: YouTuber Cracks Donkey Kong Bananza's Secret Language Before L(a)unch
Gosh I'm just not excited for this
It gives me the same feel as when Sonic Frontiers was announced - kind of fun if you look at it a certain way but not at all what anyone was asking for and certainly not a great fit for the character
Re: Star Wars: Grand Collection For Switch Now Available, Nine "Iconic" Games In One
@SillyG hey, they had lower financial returns entirely due to their milking of franchises, it's not their fault!
Re: Hollow Knight: Silksong Will Be Playable At An Australian Museum In September
@Oldstalk exactly why they're taking their time with it. It it can release at the same price as the first with ridiculous amounts of content it'll be a massive seller
Re: ICYMI: 12 Switch Games Will Receive Free Switch 2 Upgrades
Oh boy I can't wait to play captain toad on a fourth console
Re: PSA: Redownloading Switch eShop Games Has Now Changed With Latest Update
Yes, I like this. It's a very satisfying, physical card-esque approach to virtual games and makes me feel like I actually "own" these games rather than them being lesser as a form of digital download
Re: Mulitple Profie Icons Revamped In Latest Switch Firmware Update
I don't mind the DK redesign but what's going on with the triangular Yoshi egg? OUCH
Re: Nintendo Today Video Showcases The New Switch 2 Pro Controller
What's wrong with carting around the Wii U GameCube controller adaptor and plugging in my orange spice controller whenever I want to use a controller?
Re: Random: Speedrunner Beats Zelda: Breath of the Wild At Switch 2 Experience
Okay I think Nintendo are actually being a bit clever with the expansion pass
Not enough value in a single thing to make you get it, but combined with drips and drabs across games, it's quite tempting
Re: 'EA Sports Madden NFL 26' Switch 2 File Size Seemingly Revealed
@Anti-Matter why should it? If you were a publisher and knew you could price games at $80, why would you increase the cost to manufacture the games?
My point is, the cost of the carts would be passed on to the consumer. Would you be willing to pay more for the full game on cart?
Re: 'EA Sports Madden NFL 26' Switch 2 File Size Seemingly Revealed
@Anti-Matter would you pay an extra $10-$20 to have the full game on cart? Because that's what publishers would do
Re: Poll: Box Art Brawl - Duel: Fire Emblem: The Sacred Stones
The Japanese one tells me "this is an RPG and takes place across a large map"
Re: Switch 2 Game-Key Cards Won't Make It Easy For Physical Collectors In Japan
Two things I'd like to say:
1. The incentive for smaller games to buy carts to fit their game is actually lower, as the user experience is less impacted by smaller downloads than larger. Why bother paying to put the full game on a cart when it's only a few GB and can be downloaded in minutes?
2. Anyone who isn't a collector or otherwise interested in gaming and tech won't bat an eyelid at this.
Store person: "just so you're aware, this game needs to be downloaded. It's a game key card."
Customer: "so I can't resell it?"
Store person: "oh no, you can still resell it, just that you need to fully download the game first"
Customer: confused look "please just give me my game"