Comments 1,111

Re: Best Mario RPGs Of All Time

Waluigi451

@NintendoWife fair enough. I have not listened to comparisons on the music, but I could see how some would prefer one over the other. Personally, music won’t make one version better or worse for me, but I know others value music in games more.

Re: Best Mario RPGs Of All Time

Waluigi451

@HugoGED never said I didn’t like the original, but what part of the original is better than the remake? The “feel” of it? That just seems like nostalgia for the old graphics.

The Switch version is a faithful remake so I just don’t see what was lost that would make the original rate higher if we’re being objective on the overall game quality. If we’re talking about which game is better for the time it was released, then sure, the SNES version is groundbreaking and an important game. But by 2023 standards, if you were going to recommend a game to someone, it would be the Switch version.

Re: Best Mario RPGs Of All Time

Waluigi451

@HugoGED are we rating these off historical significance or actual game quality? Because sure, the original SNES rpg is an important game, but the remake improves upon the original in every way.

Re: Best Mario RPGs Of All Time

Waluigi451

@mariomaster96 yeah, these ratings are just a popularity contest. I mean objectively how is the original SNES version of Mario RPG higher than the remake? Absurd lol

Re: Soapbox: No, Mario Wonder's Most-Annoying Character Isn't The Talking Flower

Waluigi451

@Nool I’m with you. I hate how it seems like a segment of the community will always pick out some small thing to complain about. Doesn’t matter how good the game is, they will always find something and it ends up blowing up into articles like this or ones with some misleading headline that makes it seem as if all gamers dislike a thing. It creates a false perception that the community at large doesn’t like something when, as the poll results clearly show in this case, the author is in the clear minority here.