Comments 900

Re: Best Nintendo Switch Strategy Games

dartmonkey

@PluckyRicky Mitch wasn't as taken with Reborn as many others, so it didn't meet the threshold for this list, score-wise. I agree that it's significant, though - I'll see about dropping in a mention somewhere.

Edit: I've added a section at the end of the FAQ highlighting it.

Re: Best Nintendo Switch Horror Games

dartmonkey

@OldManHermit @WoomyNNYes Crow Country was definitely supposed to be on here! It now is.

@Neckcrane I swear World of Horror was on here - either way, it's back now.

@anoyonmus Because it's neat.

Re: Review: Yakuza Kiwami (Switch) - A Decent Port Of An Ambitious, Frustrating Game

dartmonkey

@Wisps Criticism is fine and welcome! But when it veers into "Oof, I like this game and other sites gave it 8s and 9s, so this person patently doesn't know what they're talking about" and "NL does this all the time to be edgy!", that doesn't feel constructive to me.

The 6 here reflects the criticisms in line with our scoring policy, and it's not a bad score. Personally, I'm interested in trying this as I've wanted Yakuza on Switch for ages! So I read the review, balance that against other opinions and my own personal gaming tastes, and make a decision.

Criticism is welcome, but insinuations that we're giving a game a certain score for what, clout? To stand out or provoke outrage from series fans for 'engagement'? That's rubbish.

Re: Review: Yakuza Kiwami (Switch) - A Decent Port Of An Ambitious, Frustrating Game

dartmonkey

To everyone dissatisfied with the score here, it's worth a reminder that 6 is not a bad score — very explicitly 'Not Bad', in fact!

So far this month we've published 22 reviews of new Switch releases, with another 8 or 9 in the works. Naturally, they come from a lot of different reviewers and not all of them will jibe with your own opinions. It's fine to disagree with this one, but Oliver's points here are valid and the score reflects his overall opinion: the game isn't bad, but it has some issues.

I totally reject 'Nintendo Life reviewers try to be different', too - we assess games as they are, and the chips fall where they may. Sometimes a reviewer's opinion aligns with the majority, sometimes not - that's the nature of reviews! Of the 30~ we're publishing this month, there'll likely be a handful you don't agree with. That's fine, but please, let's not start questioning the validity of others' opinions or their suitability to write about the game just because their take doesn't match yours.

Lastly, using 'we' is historically a fairly common convention and something we've done for a long time now. However, we (ha) are considering a change at some point, which should help clear up any confusion it seems to generate.

Re: Review: The Plucky Squire (Switch) - Enormously Charming, But Not So Plucky On Switch

dartmonkey

@trcsf I (personally) found something like Link’s Awakening’s performance massively jarring, so I’ve really got my fingers crossed for patches. I would imagine the small team is stretched to breaking point given the cross-platform release and the outsized profile of this one, but I’d also imagine (hopefully!) it’ll get there or thereabouts in the end. 🤞

Re: Best Cozy Games On Switch

dartmonkey

Hey @WoomyNNYes - re. Little Kitty, it was considered but given the overwhelming amount of cosiness on Switch, it didn't quite meet the quality bar to make the list.

Re: Upcoming Nintendo Switch Games And Accessories For August And September 2024

dartmonkey

@rjejr Games can go live at different times on launch day, and listings on Nintendo's sites can be similarly erratic — some appearing weeks in advance in one region and not going live until after it's on the eShop itself in others. For example it's live on the Japanese store and site right now.

If it gets to the end of the day and this one's not available to buy in the West, we'll investigate. As for our review, sit tight.

Re: Nintendo Reconfirms Release Windows For Major Upcoming Switch Games

dartmonkey

@MarioBrickLayer We can tweak the max limit and various other settings. For seven options, two picks felt sufficient to get a decent spectrum of results.

On desktop, you can float the mouse cursor over the bars and see the exact results (Echoes of Wisdom has 33.8% with 127 votes atm, for example), but it would be nice to surface that on mobile too. I'll look into it.