Hello all. We're reaching the end of the day here in Europe, so we'll be closing the comments for the evening. Thank you to everyone who has discussed the game and this topic in good faith, with intelligence and patience. To everyone else, I'd invite you to review our Community Rules and please remember that Nintendo Life is a welcoming, friendly community for ANYONE who loves video games and wants to share that passion. You're always free to express your opinions and criticisms in the comments, but if the inclusive sentiments in articles like this anger you for some reason, it's worth reflecting on what you're looking for from an online community and, ultimately, if this one is right for you. Thanks. - Ed.
Just a reminder to everyone — comments are removed if they break our Community Rules. Please take a second to review those rules before posting if you're unsure about what's appropriate or not. Thanks.
@-wc- It's 100% NOT our job to think about sales, but to offer readers a subjective opinion on a game's quality. In an ideal world, I'd love every single NL review to be constantly updated, but the sheer number of games and updates that come out make it totally unfeasible, unfortunately! We can only ever review a game in the state it is at the time of writing. If significant updates drop which reportedly improve things, we typically add a note at the top of the review, but we don't have the resources to revisit games individually.
In the case of No Man's Sky, the Waypoint update went live four days after launch and we knew it was coming, so we decided to publish a Review In Progress over the weekend which we finalised the following Tuesday. PJ reviewed that one for us in-house, which made updating it easier.
Hmm, lots of questions. Do I need two to have both versions built at once? Maybe three to keep one MIB? Should I build an extension on the East Wing to display them? Where's the dodo egg I requested for lunch?
@Rozetta I hardly think throwing on a podcast for company while you grind the same floor for four hours is sullying the sanctity of the RPG experience.
@razza1987 We’ve added a couple more higher-scoring examples from critics that we missed when we originally scheduled the article. Seems to be a divisive one!
@DarkTron Which specific Youtubers are we advertising?
Even if it's been covered elsewhere in the past, I don't remember seeing the inside of a Switch cart before. My hunch is that it'll be interesting to many readers for whom NL is their main gateway to Nintendo-related content.
Hi all. Thanks to everyone who has shared their opinions here, many quite creatively, in accordance with our Community Rules. Due to the rate of responses and a large influx of new user accounts, we'll be closing comments for the time being.
@AccessibleDaydream Thanks for the heads-up. I've switched out the "store page" link to be the same as the one in the tweet — should be auto-applied on that one now.
@AltCode @norwichred We updated the article to remove the iPad mention and add that it's available on the App Store in other regions. Seems like we've got a few more hoops to jump through to access it here!
@CaleBoi25 Slipping a semi-ironic selection into the exclamation-filled tag is one of the few positives of assembling those things. Don’t take that away from us!
@topher6490 Ha, yes of course. Not sure how I forgot that — I'll update the text.
Edit: Tweaked, thanks for the shout. The fact I totally blanked on it probably says something about how there's room for bringing it back with the Digital Eclipse's bells and whistles. It would be great to have different versions, including the original.
@Lofoten The pros and cons aren't a scale that dictates the score, they're a quick, general overview of our impressions. There could be four pros and one con and it could still be a 6, it's not a 1:1 thing. Also, a 6/10 is an above-average, decent score!
I personally prefer minifigures from an aesthetic POV, but it's not about throwing the Super Mario functionality into the AC sets. That could have been an option, but there are loads of possibilities Nintendo/Lego could have explored given how imaginative both companies are. Nintendo's MO is to "surprise and delight", and it feels like these sets are lacking the former.
I'll be taking a look at the other ones soon, so fingers crossed they'll hold more surprises.
@StevenH As FishyS mentioned, if you click the 'Reviews' tab at the top of the page, you'll see that list. I'll add a link to the article.
In terms of listing all February releases in the article, if you bought a new game in the last four weeks that's so great that you can't even remember it... it's probably not much of a gem.
@jco83 I've been looking into this today and while it is easy enough to switch regions quickly, there are some caveats to consider in certain cases, especially if you're the admin of a Family Group.
Personally, I'd rather have a separate Nintendo Account/profile to access the Japanese eShop whenever I want, but I've assembled a guide for switching regions and embedded it in the article above.
@JohnnyMind You know, I might just do that when we add Mario vs. DK in due course. I enjoy exploring the delineation between remakes and remasters, and it created some good discussion on the previous post where we canvassed opinion, but it is nebulous and seems to be derailing things here.
@NerdyBoutKirby You're right — thanks for the heads-up.
@Sisilly_G You're also right! I've replaced the box and banner art.
@gcunit Yep, it was posing the question and requesting ratings, and this is the result.
@CaleBoi25 As we covered before, it's in the title!
As I said before, there's a fine line and several grey areas, and we haven't been consistent in our own categorisation over the last two decades. I think a game that has the word Remastered in its title is a pretty open-shut case, though.
We've discussed it some more and decided to remove Donkey Kong GB from the running. It's a great game, but essentially a port of arcade DK with an entirely new game bolted on the end — not really a 'remake'.
It's more like 3D World + Bowser's Fury, if Bowser's Fury was 80% of the game.
We've also eliminated Mario World and Yoshi's Island on GBA, which feel more like straight ports than remakes.
I've adjusted the headline slightly to "Heading Into 2024" — it's unclear at the moment, and Switch outselling any new hardware in this calendar year seems very likely to me, but going into the year seems more accurate. @FishyS @pbisawsem
@MarioBrickLayer There are always cases that blur the lines between remake and remasters, but LA is a total rebuild. I can’t imagine there’s anything of the original Game Boy code running under the hood, whereas Metroid Prime Remastered is an augmented HD version of the GameCube original.
@Poodlestargenerica Ha, I can’t think of any examples of Excitebot-style controls specifically, but loads of games must measure z movement — 1-2-Switch, Switch Sports, Warioware Move It, off the top of my head.
Comments 885
Re: Review: Star Wars: Hunters (Switch) - A F2P Hero Shooter That's Fast, Fun, And Force-ful
@NinjaLuigi Don’t make me start dropping links to show that’s simply not true!
@JayJ Why?
Re: Review: Star Wars: Hunters (Switch) - A F2P Hero Shooter That's Fast, Fun, And Force-ful
@Axecon IGN doesn't own us.
And wut?
Re: Soapbox: Nintendo Needs More Characters Like Paper Mario's Vivian
Hello all. We're reaching the end of the day here in Europe, so we'll be closing the comments for the evening. Thank you to everyone who has discussed the game and this topic in good faith, with intelligence and patience.
To everyone else, I'd invite you to review our Community Rules and please remember that Nintendo Life is a welcoming, friendly community for ANYONE who loves video games and wants to share that passion.
You're always free to express your opinions and criticisms in the comments, but if the inclusive sentiments in articles like this anger you for some reason, it's worth reflecting on what you're looking for from an online community and, ultimately, if this one is right for you. Thanks. - Ed.
Re: Soapbox: Nintendo Needs More Characters Like Paper Mario's Vivian
Just a reminder to everyone — comments are removed if they break our Community Rules. Please take a second to review those rules before posting if you're unsure about what's appropriate or not. Thanks.
Re: Eiyuden Chronicle: Hundred Heroes Switch Update Adding Performance Mode
@-wc- It’s not defensiveness, I’m just clarifying our position! You asked a question I’m best placed to answer. 🙂
Re: Eiyuden Chronicle: Hundred Heroes Switch Update Adding Performance Mode
@-wc- It's 100% NOT our job to think about sales, but to offer readers a subjective opinion on a game's quality. In an ideal world, I'd love every single NL review to be constantly updated, but the sheer number of games and updates that come out make it totally unfeasible, unfortunately! We can only ever review a game in the state it is at the time of writing. If significant updates drop which reportedly improve things, we typically add a note at the top of the review, but we don't have the resources to revisit games individually.
In the case of No Man's Sky, the Waypoint update went live four days after launch and we knew it was coming, so we decided to publish a Review In Progress over the weekend which we finalised the following Tuesday. PJ reviewed that one for us in-house, which made updating it easier.
Re: LEGO Unveils 'Great Deku Tree 2-In-1' Zelda Set, Pre-Orders Now Available
Hmm, lots of questions. Do I need two to have both versions built at once? Maybe three to keep one MIB? Should I build an extension on the East Wing to display them? Where's the dodo egg I requested for lunch?
Re: Review: Wizardry: Proving Grounds Of The Mad Overlord (Switch) - A Grand Remake Of An Iconic Game
@Rozetta I hardly think throwing on a podcast for company while you grind the same floor for four hours is sullying the sanctity of the RPG experience.
Re: Nintendo Download: 23rd May (North America)
@Bunkerneath 🙏
Re: Nintendo World Championships: NES Edition Launches On Switch In July
NES Remix...er, Remix?!
Re: Rumoured 'Hi-Fi Rush' Switch Port In Doubt As Microsoft Culls Tango Gameworks And Other Studios
Just smh.
Don't worry, folks! There'll be another Forza along in a couple of minutes...
Re: 50 Best Nintendo Switch Games To Play Right Now (2024)
@riccyjay Thanks for flagging, I’ll look into it.
Re: Round Up: The Reviews Are In For Endless Ocean: Luminous
@razza1987 We’ve added a couple more higher-scoring examples from critics that we missed when we originally scheduled the article. Seems to be a divisive one!
Re: Random: Here's What's Inside A Switch Cart
@Stormcloudlive True. Although I actually flagged this one in our Slack channel and Ollie kindly wrote up the article. 😄
Re: Random: Here's What's Inside A Switch Cart
@DarkTron Which specific Youtubers are we advertising?
Even if it's been covered elsewhere in the past, I don't remember seeing the inside of a Switch cart before. My hunch is that it'll be interesting to many readers for whom NL is their main gateway to Nintendo-related content.
Re: Review: Library Of Ruina (Switch) - Potential Aplenty, But Just Doesn't Stack Up
Hi all. Thanks to everyone who has shared their opinions here, many quite creatively, in accordance with our Community Rules. Due to the rate of responses and a large influx of new user accounts, we'll be closing comments for the time being.
Re: Unofficial Metroid Pixel Art eBook Is Currently Free, But Be Quick
@AccessibleDaydream Thanks for the heads-up. I've switched out the "store page" link to be the same as the one in the tweet — should be auto-applied on that one now.
Re: Best First-Party Game Boy Games
@Lofoten I’m choosing to take it that the competition is SO fierce and the quality SO high that you’re still getting all-timers in the teens.
Re: The First Third-Party iOS App Store Hosts A Free Nintendo Emulator (Europe)
@AltCode @norwichred We updated the article to remove the iPad mention and add that it's available on the App Store in other regions. Seems like we've got a few more hoops to jump through to access it here!
Re: Poll: So, Will You Be Getting Xbox's Grounded For Switch?
@CaleBoi25 It's in the diary.
Re: Soapbox: The Games Industry Needs To Give Up On Exclamation Marks!
@CaleBoi25 Slipping a semi-ironic selection into the exclamation-filled tag is one of the few positives of assembling those things. Don’t take that away from us!
Re: Site News: So, Where's Our MLB The Show 24 Review?
@Savage_Joe @HeeHo I am thoroughly ashamed I didn't think of either of those! Top work.
Re: Random: This Animal Crossing: New Horizons 'Myst' Island Has Us Jonesing For A(nother) Switch Port
@Thomystic Those are both great shouts. Both @Olliemar28 and I are big fans of the series, so I'm sure we could work something up. Watch this space 👀
Re: Random: This Animal Crossing: New Horizons 'Myst' Island Has Us Jonesing For A Switch Port
@topher6490 Ha, yes of course. Not sure how I forgot that — I'll update the text.
Edit: Tweaked, thanks for the shout. The fact I totally blanked on it probably says something about how there's room for bringing it back with the Digital Eclipse's bells and whistles. It would be great to have different versions, including the original.
Re: Poll: What's The Best Pokémon Spin-Off Game? Rate Your Favourites For Our Upcoming Ranking
@JohnnyMind Should be displaying now. 👍
Re: Review: Princess Peach: Showtime! (Switch) - Peach Breaks A Leg In A High-Class Production
@Uncle_Franklin ? I think it's pretty clear you can get 10+ hours out of it if you're collectible-hunting.
Re: Review: Princess Peach: Showtime! (Switch) - Peach Breaks A Leg In A High-Class Production
I was on the fence, but this sounds like just the ticket for the weekend!
@NintendoNewsPL @Uncle_Franklin @JasonLee99 "You can easily rack up double figures of playtime hours grabbing all of this stuff."
Re: Review: LEGO Animal Crossing - Bunnie's Outdoor Activities - Is It Any Good?
@Thomystic Yes! Zapped, thanks for spotting the folt.
Re: Review: LEGO Animal Crossing - Bunnie's Outdoor Activities - Is It Any Good?
@Lofoten The pros and cons aren't a scale that dictates the score, they're a quick, general overview of our impressions. There could be four pros and one con and it could still be a 6, it's not a 1:1 thing. Also, a 6/10 is an above-average, decent score!
I personally prefer minifigures from an aesthetic POV, but it's not about throwing the Super Mario functionality into the AC sets. That could have been an option, but there are loads of possibilities Nintendo/Lego could have explored given how imaginative both companies are. Nintendo's MO is to "surprise and delight", and it feels like these sets are lacking the former.
I'll be taking a look at the other ones soon, so fingers crossed they'll hold more surprises.
Re: Zelda: Tears Of The Kingdom: Breath Of The Wild Story Recap
@Mince Lies?
Re: Balatro Removed From European Nintendo eShops Due To Ratings Switch
@fR0z3nS0u1 @Pikachupwnage Apologies, all adjusted now.
Re: Community: What's The Best Switch eShop Game We Missed? (February 2024)
@StevenH As FishyS mentioned, if you click the 'Reviews' tab at the top of the page, you'll see that list. I'll add a link to the article.
In terms of listing all February releases in the article, if you bought a new game in the last four weeks that's so great that you can't even remember it... it's probably not much of a gem.
Re: Review: Pocket Card Jockey: Ride On! (Switch) - Game Freak's 3DS Gem Is Still A Prize Pony
Who needs Switch 2? Check in on me in 2026...
Re: Best Nintendo Switch DLC & Expansions
@nukatha Ha, indeed! Zapped, thanks.
Re: Mother 3 Is Coming To Nintendo Switch Online, But There's A Catch
@jco83 I've been looking into this today and while it is easy enough to switch regions quickly, there are some caveats to consider in certain cases, especially if you're the admin of a Family Group.
Personally, I'd rather have a separate Nintendo Account/profile to access the Japanese eShop whenever I want, but I've assembled a guide for switching regions and embedded it in the article above.
Re: Nintendo Direct: Partner Showcase February 2024 - Time, Where To Watch, What To Expect
Finally!
@step_over I've removed the Mini references, apologies for any confusion!
Re: Ys X: Nordics Will Launch On Switch In The West In Fall 2024
@vec42 NIS America reached out to clarify some of the wording in the original press release, we've updated that section.
Long story short, their website is correct: Japanese audio options on consoles, too. Japanese text options on PC only.
Re: Best Nintendo Remakes Of All Time, Ranked
@JohnnyMind You know, I might just do that when we add Mario vs. DK in due course. I enjoy exploring the delineation between remakes and remasters, and it created some good discussion on the previous post where we canvassed opinion, but it is nebulous and seems to be derailing things here.
@NerdyBoutKirby You're right — thanks for the heads-up.
@Sisilly_G You're also right! I've replaced the box and banner art.
Re: Best Nintendo Remakes Of All Time, Ranked
@gcunit Yep, it was posing the question and requesting ratings, and this is the result.
@CaleBoi25 As we covered before, it's in the title!
As I said before, there's a fine line and several grey areas, and we haven't been consistent in our own categorisation over the last two decades. I think a game that has the word Remastered in its title is a pretty open-shut case, though.
Re: First Impressions: Turn-Based Scrawler 'Inkulinati' Flows Well After A Wordy Intro (Exclusive)
@Peteykins It ran perfectly from what I've played.
Re: Talking Point: What's The Best Nintendo Remake Ever?
We've discussed it some more and decided to remove Donkey Kong GB from the running. It's a great game, but essentially a port of arcade DK with an entirely new game bolted on the end — not really a 'remake'.
It's more like 3D World + Bowser's Fury, if Bowser's Fury was 80% of the game.
We've also eliminated Mario World and Yoshi's Island on GBA, which feel more like straight ports than remakes.
Re: Switch Sales Pass 139 Million, Will Be "Main Business" Heading Into 2024, Says Nintendo President
@Scoopz I’ve adjusted the wording to highlight that November was when the figures were reported.
Re: Switch Sales Pass 139 Million, Will Be "Main Business" Heading Into 2024, Says Nintendo President
I've adjusted the headline slightly to "Heading Into 2024" — it's unclear at the moment, and Switch outselling any new hardware in this calendar year seems very likely to me, but going into the year seems more accurate. @FishyS @pbisawsem
Re: Talking Point: What's The Best Nintendo Remake Ever?
@MarioBrickLayer I believe they reworked some models and did a lot of texture work — I’m pretty sure they didn’t remodel every asset, though.
Re: Talking Point: What's The Best Nintendo Remake Ever?
@MarioBrickLayer There are always cases that blur the lines between remake and remasters, but LA is a total rebuild. I can’t imagine there’s anything of the original Game Boy code running under the hood, whereas Metroid Prime Remastered is an augmented HD version of the GameCube original.
Re: Talking Point: What's The Best Nintendo Remake Ever?
@Yoshif3 I mean, it is called Metroid Prime Remastered.
And Another Code is on there now @T-3.
Re: Review: GRIME Definitive Edition (Switch) - A Poor Port Of A Superb Soulslike Metroidvania
@NateAndDestroy Ha, now that would be a VERY different game. The art monkeys who stole the L have been found and apprehended.
Re: Talking Point: As A Nintendo Fan, Do You Really Need To Play The Virtual Boy?
@Rozetta Thanks for the heads-up — zapped.
Re: Feature: Nintendo Life eShop Selects & Reader's Choice (January 2024)
@Vyacheslav333 It got a physical release, so wasn't eligible.
Re: Feature: "We’ve Tried To Do Something Very Different" - Rivalry & Drama In Arcade Racer 'New Star GP'
@Poodlestargenerica Ha, I can’t think of any examples of Excitebot-style controls specifically, but loads of games must measure z movement — 1-2-Switch, Switch Sports, Warioware Move It, off the top of my head.
Someone tore down and reverse engineered them — it definitely measures all three axes with both accelerometer and gyro:
https://github.com/dekuNukem/Nintendo_Switch_Reverse_Engineering