Comments 4,169

Re: Nintendo Patents Filed After Palworld's Release Suggest Lawsuit Prep Started Months Ago

anoyonmus

@GamingFan4Lyf You and I do not make the laws of the US or Japanese legal system.

It is legal to patent game mechanics whether you think it is scummy or not. WB did this with their Nemesis System. And this is also legal with the parent patent and such.

You cannot blame Nintendo or WB or any game company for patenting game mechanics, but rather the governments who allow such laws that allow game companies to patent game mechanics.

If these developers have the same mechanics BUT CODED differently, they would be by passing this patent most likely. If they were using the exact same code for copying these mechanics, then they are on radar.

It also doesn't help with the fact that the PocketPair CEO did state they don't really like being creative and like to chase trends and essentially don't mind copying from other games. One of their games pretty much rips off Hollow Knight.

And also to note, Nintendo would have ignored this if people hadn't started tagging them about this and also if people and I think PocketPair didn't market the game as "Pokemon with guns".

Re: Nintendo Patents Filed After Palworld's Release Suggest Lawsuit Prep Started Months Ago

anoyonmus

@GamingFan4Lyf NintendoLife conveniently and for some reason left out one key detail. And it is from that article that they posted.

While it is true these 4 divisional patents were filed after Palworld launched, however these are divisional patents. The "parent" patent for these 4 divisional patents was filed in December 2021. So I think this means these 4 2024 patents what are now under the 2021 patent are legally 2021 patents. Thats what I think it is. Or maybe I am wrong.

But it is legally effective against Palworld.

Re: Nintendo Patents Filed After Palworld's Release Suggest Lawsuit Prep Started Months Ago

anoyonmus

@easykiel https://automaton-media.com/en/news/whats-the-killer-patent-nintendo-is-suing-palworld-for-japanese-patent-attorney-offers-in-depth-analysis/

The parent patent for this 4 divisional patents was filed in December 2021. One month before Legends Arceus released, way before Palworld was even released. So if this was the patent in question, this is legally effective against Palworld.

Re: Nintendo Patents Filed After Palworld's Release Suggest Lawsuit Prep Started Months Ago

anoyonmus

@Serpenterror actually, @easykiel might have a point here. In the article NintendoLife posted another article from automaton media. The parent patent of the 4 divisional patents were registered in December of 2021. Palworld came out in January 2024. Meaning this is technically legally effective.

@easykiel thank you for pointing this out, I feel most people here missed this (Including me!!!)