Comments 302

Re: Feature: Six Things That Need To Change In The Zelda: Ocarina Of Time Remake

MatthewTaranto

First five are okay suggestions.

Totally disagree with that last one. Turning a spoiled, stubborn princess into an "crate" you have to move around the dungeon is hilarious. Changing it into a dime-a-dozen escort mission would be stripping that sequence of all its personality. You're supposed to be kind of annoyed by her. And Ruto has plenty of "agency." She has so much that she demands the hero carry her around and by gum she gets her wish!

Re: Nintendo Direct June 2026: Every Announcement, Game Reveal & Trailer

MatthewTaranto

I just can't get excited for remakes these days. I have no problem playing the original OoT and there's an appeal to me on what a game like that was able to achieve on the hardware at the time. Not Nintendo's fault but it also didn't help that leakers decided to spoil that one.

Tons of Switch 2 versions of stuff and I'm kind of over that. I love Wii Sports Resort but the new one is yet another pseudo-remake instead of a real sequel. I'm not interested in XB or KH but getting the next installment of each were good reveals.

Rhythm Heaven Groove is shaping up really well at least. It wasn't a surprise game but I am looking forward to it.

Re: The Best Nintendo Switch 2 Games

MatthewTaranto

DK Bananza is currently my favorite, one of the best Nintendo games in years I'd say. MK World is fantastic. Rarely have I felt so disconnected from the Nintendo fandom as I have with the MKW vs MK8 discourse. Oh well. Requiem would probably be my third pick. Looking forward to Elliot!

Re: 'Rayman Legends Retold' Brings The Beloved Platformer Back To Switch 2 This Year

MatthewTaranto

I agree with the comments saying it feels a little too soon for this to be remade. It's already in HD, already on current systems, and already looks GORGEOUS. So it's kind of a head-scratcher.

That said, at only $40 AND it includes Rayman Origins HD, that's really not a bad price at all. And Rayman Legends is one of the best modern platformers ever. I just wish we could see a brand new Rayman game that looks like this.

Re: Nintendo Skips Over Some Heavy-Hitters In Its Super Mario 40th Anniversary Ad

MatthewTaranto

Very cute commercial and I love the focus on 1980s Japan in particular.

To nitpick, ending with a port of Galaxy is some serious weak sauce though. I would've highlighted Mario 1, 3, World, 64, Galaxy, Maker 1, and Odyssey, and then had a sneak peek at the next game for 2026. But I guess this probably means no new Mario for this year. In a pinch they could've used MK World but that kind of goes against the spirit of the commercial.

Re: Super Metroid's Soundtrack Has Been Added To Nintendo Music Today

MatthewTaranto

@HammerGalladeBro
I'm a little confused too; from what I understand, "Theme of Samus Aran" has always been the intro of the game (the song you hear after "The last Metroid is in captivity...") with the ending theme elaborating on it further.

But according to this playlist, "Theme of Samus Aran" is now the song that plays in Crateria after you make some progress in the game. So I dunno what's what.

What I do know is that this is one of the best OSTs ever and I'd love for Metroid games to go back to this style of music again.

Re: Talking Point: Are You Tired Of The Talking Flower Yet?

MatthewTaranto

He made me chuckle a few times in Mario Wonder. But he also felt kind of superfluous. I'm still not sure how I feel about running commentary and quips in a Mario game. I'm all for Nintendo weirdness and whimsy but something about this dude almost feels a little cynical.

Maybe if he had a better voice and a better name. "Talking Flower" was honestly the best they could come up with?

Re: Nintendo Comments On Metroid Prime 4's Placement In The Metroid Timeline

MatthewTaranto

@Henners
It's not really about Samus's powers, that's something that people can overlook. It's more that the timeline for Metroid is actually pretty compelling and makes a lot of sense between the first game through Dread (even with the developers bending over backwards to make certain things make sense plotwise, such as the climax of Metroid: Samus Returns).

Super Metroid and Other M say in no uncertain terms that Metroids are all but wiped out. So--immediately after those two games--it feels kind of lame to have this random warrior guy just running around with them, with no explanation. Metroids are supposed to be a really big deal.

Re: Review: Octopath Traveler 0 (Switch 2) - A Bit Of A Retread, But Unmissable (And Enormous)

MatthewTaranto

I love Octopath and this one scored higher than I was expecting. Looking forward to trying it out eventually, although the Game-Key Card thing is a pretty big deterrent in my eyes.

@Exerion76
Why not just play it until you're tired of it? Either way you'd play for 30 hours. As any Tetris player can attest to, you don't have to "beat" a game for it to be worth your time.

Re: Poll: What Review Score Would You Give Dragon Quest I & II HD-2D Remake?

MatthewTaranto

Dragon Quest has been consistently great for nearly 40 years and this remake is no exception. Looks and sounds great, the new additions are (mostly) very welcome, and I really love the fact that they bundled both games together--a bit of generosity you don't see that often nowadays.

I do think the difficulty balance is weirdly wonky at points in DQ1, where survival can come down to luck due to RNG in the boss fights. And I'd argue a few of the new scenes take away from the serene, simple quest of the original.