Comments 187

Re: Round Up: The Reviews Are In For Super Mario Galaxy + Super Mario Galaxy 2 On Switch

FlyingDunsparce

Price should never be a factor in a review. You don't know how much someone paid for the product, they could've gotten it for free as a gift in which case it's completely irrelevant.

That being said it's difficult reviewing two 10/10 games if you try to factor in people who've played them before and expect new content, with the price possibly factoring into that setting expectations. But ultimately it's up to each person to decide for themselves whether they deem the product worth the price, with the review outlining the product.

Re: Review: Bubsy In: The Purrfect Collection (Switch) - Limited Run Cleans Out The Kitty Litter

FlyingDunsparce

@AussieMcBucket @Daniel36 I get what you're saying and obviously the games are what it's all about. But when it comes to a collection like this the games will all already have individual reviews you can look up. At that point just apply the score of the highest reviewed game to the collection as that's the best it will get with everything else being a bonus. Obviously barring any emulation/performance issues. In that case the score makes sense.

The reason I said the score was unfair is because I don't think it gives justice to the competency of the collection itself. A 4 is a failing grade which means the collection should've been better than it was. So let's ask three questions:

  • Does it include all the original Bubsy games?
  • Do all the games run properly?
  • Does it include any QOL features and bonus content?

I'm pretty sure all of these question can be answered with YES. So then I wonder what else this collection should've done to earn a passing grade?

It's difficult in this case because you obviously don't want to give people the impression that these are good games. The 4 is a good way to make sure people know that. But it doesn't give the developers any feedback on what they could've done better other than that they shouldn't have made this collection to begin with.

Re: Review: Bubsy In: The Purrfect Collection (Switch) - Limited Run Cleans Out The Kitty Litter

FlyingDunsparce

I feel like the score is kind of unfair. It sounds like the collection itself is great, just the games in it aren't. Which then begs the question of what is actually being reviewed.

I have no stake in this since I've never actually played any of these games and I've heard they're very bad so I guess the score is justified in that sense. But that would also mean there's no way the score could ever be any higher than this no matter what they do.

Either way I appreciate games being preserved even if they're bad.

Re: Opinion: Honestly, I'm So Glad We Had To Wait For Donkey Kong Bananza

FlyingDunsparce

As much as I'm very excited for DK Bananza, I won't be getting it at launch. I'm most likely still going to pick it up sometime this summer but I don't feel like I'm ready yet to jump into a brand new game. I'm also waiting for some kind of Direct to tell us how the rest of the year is going to look.

The three games I'm almost guaranteed to pick up this year though are:

  • DK Bananza
  • Pokemon Legends Z-A
  • Metroid Prime 4

Re: Talking Point: With Bigger GameCube File Sizes, Should Nintendo Let Us Download Individual NSO Games?

FlyingDunsparce

The real problem is that they have both the European and NA versions in the app. Meaning that every game they add actually gets added twice. For the other consoles this wasn't really an issue since the file sizes were small anyway, but for GameCube this adds up fast.

They should simply add only PAL versions to Europe and only NTSC versions to NA. With the exception of region exclusives like Doshin the Giant where NA should get the PAL version and vice versa.

People who want to play versions from the other regions can just change their account to those regions and download those versions of the NSO apps.

Re: Best Yoshi Games Of All Time

FlyingDunsparce

The only games here I've played so far are Yoshi and the original Yoshi's Island. I've gotta say, I really didn't like Yoshi's Island. Probably one of the worst Nintendo games I've played. Conceptually it should be a good game but for some reason I just didn't have fun.

Re: What Review Score Would You Give Mario Kart World?

FlyingDunsparce

Don't know yet but probably 9 or 10. The biggest issue is the nonsensically bad character select screen. The second biggest issue is that 3 lap tracks aren't the standard for online races.

I don't know what the reward is for doing all the missions (my guess is nothing) but I think a great reward would be a vehicle with perfect stats that's exclusive to free roam.

Re: Mario + Rabbids Dev Is Hiring For A New 'AAA' Rayman Game

FlyingDunsparce

@Dom_31 Don't get me wrong I love the first Mario+Rabbids game (haven't played the second one) but they're the reason we never got Rayman 4. I would want a new Rayman game to be about the Rayman world and the Rabbids would dilute that. Rayman has it's own style of humor that's very different from the Rabbids and all around it would be a huge shame to finally get a new Rayman game after all these years and have it feature the Rabbids.

Re: Nintendo Direct: Mario Kart World: Every Announcement - How Would You Rate It?

FlyingDunsparce

Worst and most useless Direct I've ever watched. Told us basically nothing we didn't already know. If only they at least hinted at more characters and things being in the game, perhaps unlockable by doing the missions in free roam, it would've made me more excited for the game. Now I'm left thinking we know everything there is to know about the game, which is very disappointing.

Still gonna get it day 1 though.