Comments 266

Re: PSA: Final Fantasy VII Rebirth Is Surprisingly Cheap On The UK eShop Right Now

charliecarrot

On one hand I trust Square Enix to put proper care into this release, but on the other hand, I want to caution people against preordering this game. Rebirth on the base PS5 was notoriously blurry and was really only able to shine on the PS5 Pro.

They did amazing things with VII Remake on Switch 2, but that was originally a PS4 game. I worry about how well Rebirth will make the jump to Switch 2 when it was built ground up for the PS5, and even that console could hardly handle it.

Re: Feature: "Reimagining The Scenario Was Necessary" - Making Old & New Fans Happy With Dragon Quest VII: Reimagined

charliecarrot

@Kingy As one of those people who hasn't played it, I'll avoid saying too much, but I'll point out that differing opinions on this game are obviously subjective. What's paced well for one person might not be for another.

I think of the recent TV show Pluribus, where I watched it thinking it was a masterpiece of television, keeping me glued to the screen the entire time - and then I go on the internet and see loads of voices calling it boring and slow.

I made that general comment about cuts made thinking of the recent Final Fantasy Tactics remaster, where every comment section on the internet was filled with people saying it's a ripoff because it didn't include two bonus classes and two cameo characters from the PSP version.

Since I haven't played DQVII, I don't have a strong opinion about it, but I think in general, the idea that more content is always better is a misplaced idea. That's where I was coming from - responding to a general sentiment I often see in internet comment sections. Maybe I'm off base on this one, but it's not really for me to say.

Re: Talking Point: Where's Your Nintendo Labo Now?

charliecarrot

I never bought any of these things! It seems like a cute idea but didn't go anywhere beyond a novel toy you use once or twice. Maybe if there was a whole ecosystem developed around it with 3rd party support or creative ways to make your own gadgets out of regular cardboard, it could've had some staying power.

As it is? I'm content never touching or seeing anything to do with LABO.

Re: Review: Dragon Quest VII: Reimagined (Switch 2) - A Fantastic Makeover & The Best-Looking DQ Ever

charliecarrot

Interesting to have so much "it doesn't quite live up to X game series" - being unfavorably compared against other games at least three times, and then see a 9/10 score at the end.

Obviously a score is just a number and people who take it seriously are missing the point of reviews, but I was not at all expecting a close to perfect score based on the text of this review.

Re: Talking Point: What Are You Playing This Weekend? (31st January)

charliecarrot

As for me, I've just been playing Forza Horizon 5

I love driving across the beautiful map, through desert and jungle and canyons, finding new cars and customizing them. It might just be the best car / racing game I've ever played.

Most recently I started the Rally Adventure DLC and it might be the best part for me - I love me some rally (I'll take an off-road rally any day over the super fast super cars)

Re: Google's 'Project Genie' Is Basically A Huge Plagiarism Tool, So When Will Nintendo's Legal Ninjas Strike?

charliecarrot

Yeah, so you can also use AI tools to slap together a fancy website that looks really polished.

But when you try to maintain that AI-generated website over many years and add new features without breaking any existing functionality, suddenly it's really difficult because no one understands the codebase and the AI is getting things wrong (as all AI tools do constantly, every day, to this day, and there's nothing about the technology that guarantees generative AI will stop getting things wrong).

And websites are extremely simple compared to video games. It may not matter if buttons are styled slightly differently and show different behavior when hovered on every page of a web app, but players expect consistency in game mechanics.

Sure, we see in these videos that you can produce some weak facsimile of one part of an existing video game, or some generic Frankenstein of the most-streamed video games on YouTube, but can you use this technology to actually produce anything useful for game devs, components that can be tweaked and inserted as a functional part of an overall project? I'm not convinced.

Re: Talking Point: Metroid Prime 4 And The Burden Of Being 'Good Enough'

charliecarrot

We've been trained to focus on negatives by algorithms that prioritize engagement over everything else. Content creators make money on YouTube with long videos only pointing out flaws in games they claim to otherwise love.

One of the first comments on this article only has negative things to say about the game, and then says "it's a 7/10" which is a decidedly above average score (meaning, assumedly, more positives than negatives). It's so odd to me - if you like something enough to consider it above average, why would you share only criticism? Maybe sharing more about the parts you liked could help elevate the discourse.

Re: "I Don't See AI Taking Over" - Split Fiction Director Josef Fares On The Rise Of AI

charliecarrot

It's so funny how many people buy into the venture capitalist / shareholder propaganda. Of course they say "it's going to constantly improve" and other capitalist nonsense that assumes endless resources because that's what gets them short term $$$.

In reality, the capabilities have plateaued for years now, every AI company is bleeding money, and there's not actually good evidence to show that it IS going to improve any more - they just hope if they throw enough money at it and build more data centers, something magical will happen eventually.

I often use AI tools at work as a software developer, and while they're immensely useful to generate boilerplate and reduce the number of rote tasks I have to do, when you work with these tools regularly, you become intimately aware of their limitations.

I'm genuinely scared for the future with the number of people who rely on LLM chatbots to make decisions and trust them as valid sources of information. The disclaimers are right there - LLMs don't know anything, they don't think, and they regularly hallucinate information. They're fancy autocomplete, probabilistically generating text strings based on previous input. But people ignore that because it feels magical to use chatGPT, and critical thinking goes out the window.

Re: GameStop Kicks Off 2026 By Reportedly Shutting "Hundreds" Of Stores

charliecarrot

No one deserves $35 billion. No one even deserves $1 billion.

I don't think people comprehend how much that is: The difference between a million dollars and a billion dollars is about a billion dollars.

That means someone with a million or two is closer to a minimum wage worker than they are to someone with a billion dollars.

No one should have a billion dollars.