Comments 513

Re: Talking Point: Would A Third Wave Of Smash Bros. Ultimate DLC Have Been Too Much?

Rooty

Even though I voted that Sora was the perfect capper on the DLC and I still for the most part think a third wave would have tipped things way too far over onto the side of needless bloat I'll admit this thread has softened my stance towards a potential Smash sequel thanks to everyone's awesome suggestions. I think Shantae is probably a lock should that happen given WayForward's cosying up to Nintendo in recent years, as is Rayman (though he absolutely remains the world's dullest mascot in my estimation). Surprised to see all the Oatchi love, but I think he'd make a fine second representation for Pikmin as well.

Re: Nintendo Download: 27th July (North America)

Rooty

Yggdra Union is a game I played a bit of back on the...I want to say Gameboy Advance? Like a cross between Advance Wars and Fire Emblem but cripplingly difficult. Is this a port/remake or just a separate entry in the franchise? Because it was good and I'd definitely be down for giving it a second chance if it's the formwe.

Re: Final Fantasy Developers Reminisce On IV, V, And VI In Anniversary Chat

Rooty

@ModdedInkling At this point in time, I'd say probably not. I was about twenty years late to the FFVII party and when I finally did get around to playing it it all just seemed so....eh. Times move on, and what was once groundbreaking is quickly superseded by people building on and bettering it. I say this is someone who absolutely rates Final Fantasy VI as one of the greatest video games of all time, but a lot of that has to be contextualised in the era in which I first played it. If you've a deep abiding love for turn-based RPG combat then you might be able to put aside the clunkier aspects of the game, but if you've little to no experience/interest in them I can't see FFVI being the game to change your mind. Great as the story is, it's still delivered in the trappings of early-nineties game design which has evolved significantly since in the genre.

Re: Poll: What Review Score Would You Give Pikmin 4?

Rooty

Haven't played it so I don't feel remotely qualified to pass judgment on it score-wise, but I loved Pikmin 1 and 2 back in the day and it's amazing to see the hype there is for this series after twenty years of it just quietly existing as its own Pik-thing.

Re: Random: Mortal Kombat Co-Creator Knows Who He'd Add To Smash Bros., If Nintendo Was To Ask

Rooty

I could honestly easily see this happening, but for the fact it would mean advertising Mortal Kombat's existence to legions of eight year olds. Never would have thought Bayonetta would have made it in for instance, and before her Solid Snake. Both characters from quote-unquote mature franchises that would seem at odds with Nintendo's usual family friendly veneer. Mortal Kombat is on another level to those, though, and probably one Nintendo won't ever want this brand associated with.

Re: Top 100 Best Nintendo Games Of All Time

Rooty

Seeing them all laid out like this, it's hard to imagine any other game company ever coming close to matching the mighty N in terms of sheer volume of quality releases. This as an extraordinary catalogue of classics that reminds us all why we fell in love with Ninty in the first place.

Re: Talking Point: What Are You Playing This Weekend? (July 8th)

Rooty

Played a lot of Smash Ultimate, both online and off and more than a little disheartened to finally discover a Smash Bros character I can say I unequivocally despise. Incineroar. God that thing is hideous to behold. I could almost forgive it if it weren't for the fact Pyroar is right there, guys. Stupid furry Broly. Better believe you're getting picked less than Pichu, pal D:<

Re: Talking Point: What Makes A Good Sidequest, Anyway?

Rooty

Much as people are down on collectathon-style quests these days, I've always loved them provided what you're collecting is unique enough. I adore taking pictures of all the stuff in Breath of the Wild for instance, but the one that immediately sprang to mind for me was finding all the family members to honour an old man's desire for them to be present at his deathbed in Baiten Kaitos. It was such a great way to encourage you to talk to everyone you found in the game and by extension immerse yourself in the game's world.

Re: Talking Point: What Are You Playing This Weekend? (July 1st)

Rooty

Sunk a fair amount of time into Smash Ultimate today, only to learn that apparently my one true nemesis is the dread witch Isabelle (seriously that fishing rod can naff right off.). Unlocked a handful of new fighters, ventured into online for the first time and spent some gold points on snazzy Mii fighter costumes after only just learning this week those things come with an expiration date. Ah, Nintendo. You truly are the parent that loveth to take almost as much as you give.

Re: Review: Ghost Trick: Phantom Detective - A DS All-Timer Returns In Stunning Form

Rooty

Whether it is a 10/10, a 9/10 or a rhombus/figs what matters most is the actual written content of the review, which should be more than enough for most folks to make a reasonably educated guess at whether they'd like to try it for themselves. Numerical scores can be useful to give a broad sense of a game's quality if looked at in aggregate but that's about all they can reasonably offer and probably shouldn't be used to dictate your spending habits. Besides, I'm pretty sure the antiquated scale used at NintendoLife isn't even capable of accurately reading the game's true score of Pomeranian out of Pomeranian.

Re: The Next Scarlet & Violet TCG Expansion Is A Throwback To The Original 151 Pokémon

Rooty

@burgerkingsauce People like gen 1 specifically because their designs are so uncomplicated compared to the LSD crayola scribble the series is perceived to have descended into by some quarters of the fandom. Everyone has their personal preference for these things, and if it seems like gen 1 gets a disproportionate amount of coverage that's probably because it generated a disproportionate amount of fans in the series. Pokemon literally went from zero to millions off the back of those designs alone, and that's why they'll likely always be held up as exemplars in the franchise.

Re: Yes, Your Grace: Snowfall Is A Pixel Art Kingdom Management Sim Steeped In Slavic Myth

Rooty

Played about 60-70% (?) of the first one before setting it aside in favour of other games. I think I'd have really loved it as a kid because the choice-based gameplay made it feel at times like a Choose Your Own Adventure story but it just lacked the polish to make it essential entertainment these days for me. Here's hoping the sequel spruces things up a bit as it certainly had potential.

Re: Best Harvest Moon / Story Of Seasons Games Of All Time

Rooty

It's fascinating to see the differences in opinion between users and critics in these lists. The highest rated game critically is one that most probably don't even consider a proper HM game, and likewise there's an entry in the people's top ten that got whacked with 5/10 on review.

Re: Star Wars: KOTOR II 'Sith Lords' DLC Cancelled For Nintendo Switch

Rooty

Only yesterday morning I was watching the trailer for the rerelease of this series and wondering idly if they ever actually got around to producing the DLC. What an absurd situation to have so many people working for so long just to give the damn game a reasonable ending. Almost makes me sympathise with Bioware's decision to just shut the door on Mass Effect 3 and move on. Almost.

Re: Dolphin Emulator Steam Release "Indefinitely Postponed"

Rooty

@RadioHedgeFund One thing I have to take issue with is the idea that Nintendo don't lose money on people downloading ROMs of their games. Part of the reason Nintendo is so prohibitive with its back catalogue is so they can potentially re-monetize them in the future via remake/remaster or simply dumping them on an iteration of their own Virtual Consoles. On top of that it prevents earlier entries from long-running franchises like Pokémon from cannibalising the sales of future games. Perhaps that wouldn't ultimately amount to much in the way of lost revenue but it's really not as straightforward as 'X game is unavailable on current gen systems so there's no financial loss for the company by freely distributing it.'

Re: The Lord Of The Rings: Gollum Dev Apologises For "Underwhelming" Launch State

Rooty

Sad as this is and honourable as the apology might be, Daedalic are not a bunch of amateurs cooking some pie in the sky fan project up from their basement. They've been in this industry long enough to know the score, and their product was always going to be unacceptable to launch in the state it's in. I wish them every success in fixing the game, but this is wholly a mess of their own making.