Comments 487

Re: Review: Red Dead Redemption - A Fine But No-Frills Switch Port, For A Fistful Of Dollars

Rooty

It's slightly worrying that I only played this a few years back, loved the heck out of it and yet still can't for the life of me remember what it was that supposedly took place at the start of the game in that 'shocking' train sequence. Or even that there was a train. I may only have room for one video game train intro in my brain, and I think it's been given to Uncharted 2 instead :/

Re: Talking Point: Zelda: TOTK Isn't A Shoo-In For GOTY 2023, And That's A Good Thing

Rooty

I think Baldur's Gate 3 will probably take it, given the momentum the hype train is building around it at present. Not sure how I feel about a game that's been playable in some form or another for what feels like years at this point taking the award for this particular year, but I'm enough of a fan of the series to overlook that at the end of the day.

I think TotK would have been an absolute lock if it weren't for the fact they recycled so much of the original game in it. It doesn't matter that it's still bonkers creative, I think it's just too easy to dismiss it as copypasta Zelda and use that as an excuse not to give it the top prize.

Re: Memory Pak: Making Contact With The "Ungoogleable" Game I Couldn't Quite Remember

Rooty

I owned Contact and completed it years ago, and although I can at least say I've retained a basic knowledge of its name in the intervening time since I found myself watching a playthrough of it on Youtube some months ago and realised with some bemusement I didn't remember a lick of the game's actual content outside of the weird, fourth-wall breaking final scenes. I guess some games are just destined to live outside the range of human memory.

Re: Poll: Box Art Brawl - Duel: Pokémon Stadium

Rooty

@NinjaNicky The article sort of explains this but I appreciate it doesn't make it wholly clear that they the Japanese Pokemon Stadium 2 is what we received as just plain old Pokemon Stadium. The very first Pokemon Stadium game had far less Pokemon in it and was pretty much considered redundant by the time America and Europe had jumped on the Pokemon bandwagon, so they released Pokemon Stadium 2 in lieu of the actual first game there.

Re: Review: Quake II - Another Truly Outstanding Remaster Of An FPS Icon

Rooty

I have next to no deep nostalgia for Quake or any particular fondness for the FPS genre in particular. I think I did have the game on the N64 back in the day but I was absolute cack at it and I've never been back to the series since. At this price however I'm legitimately considering buying it and attempting to rediscover this universal classic, and I hope this release rakes in a tidy profit for Nightdive and all involved. This right here is how you do video game preservation right, here's to many more revisited properties to come

Re: Talking Point: What Are You Playing This Weekend? (August 12th)

Rooty

Stumbled back into Rogue Legacy 2 after an extended hiatus away from the game and, gasp, actually managed to beat some bosses! The influx of new goodies and areas this unveiled saw me pretty swiftly back out of the endeavour in sheer dread and return to Yakuza 0. And also that one rhythm game on the Switch with the birds in it and you are also a bird. You know the one. Super Bird Buddies or what have you. It's adorable and you get to jam out with a woodpecker, so sue me.

Re: Take-Two CEO Defends Red Dead Redemption's $50 Price Tag, Says It's "Commercially Accurate"

Rooty

I've defended this price already once on this site, but good grief companies don't help themselves when they release patronising statements like this that are defiantly tone deaf to the mood in the fandom. I appreciate the executives need their post-holiday bonuses but come on, Take Two, would it have killed you to just do the decent thing for once and drop the price by ten or twenty bucks? When you're already on thin ice with the state of your ports you probably don't have the luxury of sitting there telling customers what they should be paying you.

Re: Review: Pokémon Stadium 2 - A Sequel Of Gold (& Silver) Standard

Rooty

Not even sure why they bothered putting the original Stadium on NSO when this eclipses it in just about ever way save for its lack of Lickitung-based sushi bar antics. Even without the gameboy conectivity it holds up, thanks in no small part to the hilarious random cup that makes the rubbish rental Pokemon into something of a positive since everyone's lumbered with them all the time.

Re: Anniversary: Dead Cells Is The Gift That Keeps On Giving Five Years On

Rooty

Beat the base game once, only to find out it didn't really 'count' as I'd used skills that invalidated the run. Genuinely fun experience, but like a lot of games in the genre it can occasionally be a bit on the obtuse side regarding mechanics which necessitates either way too much time experimenting or poring over online guides to clue you in. Obviously to some that will be an abject positive but for me it eventually became a bit of a frustrating time sink.

Re: Memory Pak: Secret Of Mana's Dazzling World Of Colour Opened My Eyes

Rooty

I know, I know, that on paper the sequel is just better than Secret of Mana in nearly every aspect. But one thing Seiken Densestu 3 can't beat this game on in is simple, earnest heart. Spending time with Secret of Mana's protagonists is utterly charming from start to tear-jerking end. The fact it looks and sounds gorgeous on top of that is just icing on the cake.

Re: Talking Point: What Are You Playing This Weekend? (August 5th)

Rooty

Down to the last ten shrines in Breath of the Wild, and fully intended to have it wrapped up by the end of the week. That was until I fell down a hole named Yakuza 0 and redirected the bulk of my game time to that instead. Technically the only game I've actually played on the weekend so far this week is Smash Ultimate though-I just can't get enough of the adorable bespoke paths for the characters in Classic Mode so I've been forging ahead with those.

Re: Talking Point: Would A Third Wave Of Smash Bros. Ultimate DLC Have Been Too Much?

Rooty

Even though I voted that Sora was the perfect capper on the DLC and I still for the most part think a third wave would have tipped things way too far over onto the side of needless bloat I'll admit this thread has softened my stance towards a potential Smash sequel thanks to everyone's awesome suggestions. I think Shantae is probably a lock should that happen given WayForward's cosying up to Nintendo in recent years, as is Rayman (though he absolutely remains the world's dullest mascot in my estimation). Surprised to see all the Oatchi love, but I think he'd make a fine second representation for Pikmin as well.

Re: Nintendo Download: 27th July (North America)

Rooty

Yggdra Union is a game I played a bit of back on the...I want to say Gameboy Advance? Like a cross between Advance Wars and Fire Emblem but cripplingly difficult. Is this a port/remake or just a separate entry in the franchise? Because it was good and I'd definitely be down for giving it a second chance if it's the formwe.

Re: Final Fantasy Developers Reminisce On IV, V, And VI In Anniversary Chat

Rooty

@ModdedInkling At this point in time, I'd say probably not. I was about twenty years late to the FFVII party and when I finally did get around to playing it it all just seemed so....eh. Times move on, and what was once groundbreaking is quickly superseded by people building on and bettering it. I say this is someone who absolutely rates Final Fantasy VI as one of the greatest video games of all time, but a lot of that has to be contextualised in the era in which I first played it. If you've a deep abiding love for turn-based RPG combat then you might be able to put aside the clunkier aspects of the game, but if you've little to no experience/interest in them I can't see FFVI being the game to change your mind. Great as the story is, it's still delivered in the trappings of early-nineties game design which has evolved significantly since in the genre.

Re: Poll: What Review Score Would You Give Pikmin 4?

Rooty

Haven't played it so I don't feel remotely qualified to pass judgment on it score-wise, but I loved Pikmin 1 and 2 back in the day and it's amazing to see the hype there is for this series after twenty years of it just quietly existing as its own Pik-thing.

Re: Random: Mortal Kombat Co-Creator Knows Who He'd Add To Smash Bros., If Nintendo Was To Ask

Rooty

I could honestly easily see this happening, but for the fact it would mean advertising Mortal Kombat's existence to legions of eight year olds. Never would have thought Bayonetta would have made it in for instance, and before her Solid Snake. Both characters from quote-unquote mature franchises that would seem at odds with Nintendo's usual family friendly veneer. Mortal Kombat is on another level to those, though, and probably one Nintendo won't ever want this brand associated with.

Re: Top 100 Best Nintendo Games Of All Time

Rooty

Seeing them all laid out like this, it's hard to imagine any other game company ever coming close to matching the mighty N in terms of sheer volume of quality releases. This as an extraordinary catalogue of classics that reminds us all why we fell in love with Ninty in the first place.

Re: Talking Point: What Are You Playing This Weekend? (July 8th)

Rooty

Played a lot of Smash Ultimate, both online and off and more than a little disheartened to finally discover a Smash Bros character I can say I unequivocally despise. Incineroar. God that thing is hideous to behold. I could almost forgive it if it weren't for the fact Pyroar is right there, guys. Stupid furry Broly. Better believe you're getting picked less than Pichu, pal D:<

Re: Talking Point: What Makes A Good Sidequest, Anyway?

Rooty

Much as people are down on collectathon-style quests these days, I've always loved them provided what you're collecting is unique enough. I adore taking pictures of all the stuff in Breath of the Wild for instance, but the one that immediately sprang to mind for me was finding all the family members to honour an old man's desire for them to be present at his deathbed in Baiten Kaitos. It was such a great way to encourage you to talk to everyone you found in the game and by extension immerse yourself in the game's world.

Re: Talking Point: What Are You Playing This Weekend? (July 1st)

Rooty

Sunk a fair amount of time into Smash Ultimate today, only to learn that apparently my one true nemesis is the dread witch Isabelle (seriously that fishing rod can naff right off.). Unlocked a handful of new fighters, ventured into online for the first time and spent some gold points on snazzy Mii fighter costumes after only just learning this week those things come with an expiration date. Ah, Nintendo. You truly are the parent that loveth to take almost as much as you give.

Re: Review: Ghost Trick: Phantom Detective - A DS All-Timer Returns In Stunning Form

Rooty

Whether it is a 10/10, a 9/10 or a rhombus/figs what matters most is the actual written content of the review, which should be more than enough for most folks to make a reasonably educated guess at whether they'd like to try it for themselves. Numerical scores can be useful to give a broad sense of a game's quality if looked at in aggregate but that's about all they can reasonably offer and probably shouldn't be used to dictate your spending habits. Besides, I'm pretty sure the antiquated scale used at NintendoLife isn't even capable of accurately reading the game's true score of Pomeranian out of Pomeranian.