Maybe it's divisive, but it's objectively a good game, especially by NES standards. Whether it holds up as a good Zelda game is a matter of opinion. Personally, I prefer it over Zelda 1.
I said 5. Bananza is a "killer app" and MKW is good, but third party games leave something to be desired. Even if I ignore the fact that most of them are game key cards, they are mostly ports of old games.
Some good stuff looks to be coming by the end of the year, however.
I'll also say that I've bought a Switch 2 physical that I probably would not have just to support true physical games. Rune Factory: The Guardian of Azuma is full physical on Switch 2. This is a game I was interested in, but probably would have waited for a sale to buy it, if I did at all. Because it is one of the few true physical games available on the Switch 2, though, I went for it. It even comes with a manual, which was a pleasant surprise.
The only way I'm buying game key cards is with a steep discount. I'm sort of looking forward to the format flopping, after which I imagine I'll be able to get some at like $5 a pop.
The game looks good, but I don't know if it's worth $70 to me. Come November, there are going to be other games that I think I'd rather spend my money on.
I'll probably just buy the Switch version then, unless there are significant improvements with the Switch 2 version. In that case, I still won't get a game key card, though, I'll just buy digital.
@jake1421 Ok, but the system is launched. The cat's out of the bag, at this point. It's ridiculous that any developer who wants one can't get a dev kit.
@jarack That's exactly how I feel about the game. It's pretty much perfect aside from occasional camera jank that I don't know is even possible to get completely right, given the nature of the game. If there was a 9.5 out of 10 option, I'd pick that.
Looks nice, but what I'd really like are third party Joy-Con replacements. Particularly, I'm waiting for Hori to update its Split Pad Pro for the Switch 2. Much better for handheld play than the stock Joy-Cons.
I don't think it's a coincidence that the top-selling third party game for Switch 2 is Cyberpunk 2077, which comes with the full game on the cartridge. I buy both digital and physical games. I prefer to buy physical, but I don't ever intend to buy game key cards.
I would have bought Street Fighter 6 if it had been a real physical release. I still might get it digitally, but I have no interest in the game key cards.
I got Cyberpunk physical. I would have bought Street Fighter VI physical, but it's a game key card. I'd rather just buy a digital version than a game key card.
I'm loving the Switch 2 so far, but I still don't like using the joycons in handheld mode. They feel a little better to me than the Switch 1 joycons, but I find the sticks too small and it's too hard for me to use the shoulder buttons. Waiting for Hori or someone to come out with something better (I love the Split Pad Pro, but that doesn't attach to the Switch 2).
Switch is still my primary console, with Steam Deck being a close second. Seeing as how I couldn't pre-order a Switch 2, who knows how long it will be before I can even obtain one?
Most of these are games that don't really need any upgrades. The two exceptions are Link's Awakening and Echoes of Wisdom; if they've cleaned up the framerate drops in those games, that's great!
I have both a Switch and a Steam Deck. They're both great, but you are leaving out some of the biggest advantages of the Steam Deck. Namely, you can use a Deck like a regular PC and so you can do a lot of things that the Switch won't allow, like installing emulators or games from multiple storefronts. I can play games from Steam, Epic, GOG, and others on my Steam Deck, whereas with Nintendo you're locked into their store and ecosystem.
This points to physical media being on the way out for video games, which sucks. I have a ton of games on Steam, which has been a very good service, but even there you still get shenanigans like licensed music being patched out of games after a certain time period.
I have a question about the game-key cards. Is the key attached to the card itself, or is it attached to your account? Because if it's the former, it means that you can at least re-sell your game-key card if you want.
Ultimately, the companies will charge whatever price they think will get them the most money. If you think the prices are too high (I think the console price is fine and what I expected, but the games are too much), vote with your wallet. If people don't buy the games, publishers will have no choice but to lower the prices.
Comments 277
Re: Nintendo Adds One Of The Most Divisive Zelda Entries To 'Nintendo Music'
Maybe it's divisive, but it's objectively a good game, especially by NES standards. Whether it holds up as a good Zelda game is a matter of opinion. Personally, I prefer it over Zelda 1.
Re: Why Remake 'Dragon Quest VII' Before The Zenithian Trilogy? Yuji Horii Comments
I am very much looking forward to the game. Dragon Quest VII is my favorite in the series.
Re: Nintendo Direct September 2025: Every Announcement, Game Reveal, Trailer
I didn't get what I really wanted: Mother 3.
Re: Dragon Quest VII Gets Reimagined For Switch And Switch 2 In Early 2026
I was pumped about this. My favorite Dragon Quest game.
Re: Pokémon's Former Chief Legal Officer Believes Nintendo's Latest Patent Will Be Ignored
If the patent is honored, we live in a very stupid world.
Re: "Everyone Is A Director" At Nintendo, Says Former Dev, But Don't Make Excuses
I'd be afraid to try anything outside of spec because if I ultimately can't implement it I'd be fired.
Re: Poll: Three Months In, How Would You Rate Switch 2's Library So Far?
I said 5. Bananza is a "killer app" and MKW is good, but third party games leave something to be desired. Even if I ignore the fact that most of them are game key cards, they are mostly ports of old games.
Some good stuff looks to be coming by the end of the year, however.
Re: Ubisoft Employee Explains Why Star Wars Outlaws Is A Game-Key Card
Can't they just copy data from the cartridge initially and put it on the internal storage? Install the game, if you will.
Re: Final Fantasy Tactics' Devs Had To Lean On Fans To Recover Original Source Code
They really give absolutely no thought to preserving these games, do they?
Re: Review: Kirby And The Forgotten Land - Nintendo Switch 2 Edition + Star-Crossed World - Kirby's Best Shines Even Brighter
I never bought the base game because a 30 fps Kirby platformer seemed like a letdown after Mario Odyssey, but I might check it out now!
Re: Japan's National Library Says Game-Key Cards Are Not Eligible For Preservation
I'll also say that I've bought a Switch 2 physical that I probably would not have just to support true physical games. Rune Factory: The Guardian of Azuma is full physical on Switch 2. This is a game I was interested in, but probably would have waited for a sale to buy it, if I did at all. Because it is one of the few true physical games available on the Switch 2, though, I went for it. It even comes with a manual, which was a pleasant surprise.
Re: Japan's National Library Says Game-Key Cards Are Not Eligible For Preservation
The only way I'm buying game key cards is with a steep discount. I'm sort of looking forward to the format flopping, after which I imagine I'll be able to get some at like $5 a pop.
Re: Official Box Art For Kirby Air Riders Revealed, Price And File Size Confirmed
The game looks good, but I don't know if it's worth $70 to me. Come November, there are going to be other games that I think I'd rather spend my money on.
Re: Rune Factory: Guardians Of Azuma Ships Over 500,000 Copies
They deserve high sales for doing a real Switch 2 physical edition.
Re: First Impressions: Pokémon Legends: Z-A Is An Attempt To Catch The Hardcore Again
I didn't realize this game was going to have real-time battles. I'm not excited about that.
Re: Octopath 0 Is A Game-Key Card On Switch 2, And Square Enix Has "No Plans" For A Switch 1 Upgrade Option
I'll probably just buy the Switch version then, unless there are significant improvements with the Switch 2 version. In that case, I still won't get a game key card, though, I'll just buy digital.
Re: Octopath Traveler 0 Will Bring More Adventures To Switch 1 & 2 This Year
They always hook me with HD2D games. I wish I could just inject that art style into my veins, lol.
Re: 'Mouse Work' Gets Second Trailer, But Can't Release Until Creators Get Switch 2 Dev Kit
@jake1421 Ok, but the system is launched. The cat's out of the bag, at this point. It's ridiculous that any developer who wants one can't get a dev kit.
Re: Poll: What Review Score Would You Give Donkey Kong Bananza?
@jarack That's exactly how I feel about the game. It's pretty much perfect aside from occasional camera jank that I don't know is even possible to get completely right, given the nature of the game. If there was a 9.5 out of 10 option, I'd pick that.
Re: 8BitDo's 'Pro 3' Controller Boasts Magnetic ABXY Buttons And A Charging Dock
Looks nice, but what I'd really like are third party Joy-Con replacements. Particularly, I'm waiting for Hori to update its Split Pad Pro for the Switch 2. Much better for handheld play than the stock Joy-Cons.
Re: Furukawa's Defence Of Game-Key Cards Ain't All That Convincing
I don't think it's a coincidence that the top-selling third party game for Switch 2 is Cyberpunk 2077, which comes with the full game on the cartridge. I buy both digital and physical games. I prefer to buy physical, but I don't ever intend to buy game key cards.
Re: Marvel Rivals Dev NetEase "Already In Contact With Nintendo" About Switch 2
Nintendo seems to have dropped the ball with dev kits. The Switch 2 is out now; there is no reason any developer shouldn't be able to get a dev kit.
Re: 'Full Metal Schoolgirl' Announced For Switch 2, And It Looks Utterly Bonkers
Looks cool. Reminds of something you might play in the arcade in the late 90's, albeit with better graphics.
Re: Front Mission 3: Remake Appears To Replace 2D Art Assets With Generative AI
This is horrible and, dare I say, grotesque. An insult to artists and gamers.
Re: Feature: Every Switch 2 Launch Game, Ranked
@geiseldiesel It's based on Nintendo Life user ratings.
Re: Third-Party Launch Games On Switch 2 Reportedly Sold "Very Low Numbers"
@PerfectFrost I was shocked that Metaphor was not a Switch 2 launch game. I would have definitely picked that up (I was fully expecting to, in fact;).
Re: Third-Party Launch Games On Switch 2 Reportedly Sold "Very Low Numbers"
I would have bought Street Fighter 6 if it had been a real physical release. I still might get it digitally, but I have no interest in the game key cards.
Re: Best Nintendo Switch 2 Controllers
I need third party joycons for playing in handheld mode ASAP. Hori needs to hurry up with a Split Pad Pro 2.
Re: Talking Point: How Are You Finding Mario Kart's Open World?
Yeah, I thought it would be for me, but it isn't. That's OK. The actual racing is on-point, and I find it to be much more compelling.
Re: Japanese Charts: Switch 2 Crushes PS2 To Become Fastest-Selling Console Ever
@TheExile285
I got Cyberpunk physical. I would have bought Street Fighter VI physical, but it's a game key card. I'd rather just buy a digital version than a game key card.
Re: Round Up: The Reviews Are In For The Nintendo Switch 2
I'm loving the Switch 2 so far, but I still don't like using the joycons in handheld mode. They feel a little better to me than the Switch 1 joycons, but I find the sticks too small and it's too hard for me to use the shoulder buttons. Waiting for Hori or someone to come out with something better (I love the Split Pad Pro, but that doesn't attach to the Switch 2).
Re: No Man's Sky Multiplayer Is Currently Broken On Switch 2, Cross-Saves Also Causing Issues
Maybe they really did have deaf kids instead of dev kits all this time!
Re: Hardware Review (In Progress): Nintendo Switch 2 - A Faster, Slicker, Sexier Switch
I still hate using the joycons in handheld mode. I hope Hori hurries up with a new Split Pad Pro for Switch 2.
Re: Talking Point: Are You Ghosting Switch 1 To Save Yourself For Switch 2?
Switch is still my primary console, with Steam Deck being a close second. Seeing as how I couldn't pre-order a Switch 2, who knows how long it will be before I can even obtain one?
Re: Game Devs Weigh In On Switch 2, And A "Much Better" eShop Is A Must
I don't care whether or not there is hentai, I just want the eShop to run much better.
Re: ICYMI: 12 Switch Games Will Receive Free Switch 2 Upgrades
Most of these are games that don't really need any upgrades. The two exceptions are Link's Awakening and Echoes of Wisdom; if they've cleaned up the framerate drops in those games, that's great!
Re: Limited Run's Atlus Switch 2 Collector's Edition Is A 'Game-Key Card' Release
If you're not planning to sell or give away your games, the game key cards have all the negatives of having a digital game but none of the positives.
$250 for no actual physical game is outrageous, but I would never give LRG my money to begin with.
Re: Donkey Kong Bananza Might Be Teasing The Return Of An Old Friend
I'm really excited about this game, but who knows when I'll be able to get a Switch 2!
Re: Opinion: Steam Deck Fans Are Seriously Underestimating The Switch 2
I have both a Switch and a Steam Deck. They're both great, but you are leaving out some of the biggest advantages of the Steam Deck. Namely, you can use a Deck like a regular PC and so you can do a lot of things that the Switch won't allow, like installing emulators or games from multiple storefronts. I can play games from Steam, Epic, GOG, and others on my Steam Deck, whereas with Nintendo you're locked into their store and ecosystem.
Re: Video: 20+ Things We Still Don't Know About Switch 2
NSO price increase? Please don't give them any ideas!
Re: "We MUST Resist Buying These Game-Key Releases", Says GamesMaster Host
I probably won't bother with these. My preference is:
1. Full physical games
2. Digital games from the eShop
3. Game key cards
4. Code in a box
Re: Switch 2 GameChat Choppy Frame Rate Explained By Nintendo
I will probably never use this feature, so this is a non-issue for me.
Re: The Switch 2 Won't Have Achievements Or eShop Music
I don't care about achievements, but I loved the Wii's UI music. It's disappointing that Nintendo has abandoned that.
Re: Switch 2 Game Cart Max Capacity Is 64GB, Says CD Projekt Red
This points to physical media being on the way out for video games, which sucks. I have a ton of games on Steam, which has been a very good service, but even there you still get shenanigans like licensed music being patched out of games after a certain time period.
Re: Bravely Default Is Finally Freed From Its 3DS Prison, Coming To Switch 2 At Launch
I have a question about the game-key cards. Is the key attached to the card itself, or is it attached to your account? Because if it's the former, it means that you can at least re-sell your game-key card if you want.
Re: Please Make Sure You're Wearing Trousers When Using Switch 2's Mouse Controls
I intend to get one of those trays that you can attach to the arm of your couch and use that as the mouse surface.
Re: Hands On: Mario Kart World Brings The Utter Chaos In Knockout Mode
At least Nintendo is still putting out great games. Say what you will about their greed and anti-consumer practices--they still make great games.
Re: The Switch 2 Will Emulate Switch Games, Because It Shares No Internal Hardware With Its Predecessor
This explains the compatibility issues with some games.
Re: Donkey Kong Country Artist Shares His Thoughts On Kong's New Design
I'm not crazy about the new design, myself, but I'll get used to it, I guess. The new DK game looks great, though, I am excited to play it.
Re: "Don't Let Nintendo Ruin The Entire Industry" - Is $80 For Mario Kart World A Bridge Too Far?
Ultimately, the companies will charge whatever price they think will get them the most money. If you think the prices are too high (I think the console price is fine and what I expected, but the games are too much), vote with your wallet. If people don't buy the games, publishers will have no choice but to lower the prices.