Comments 4,818

Re: Nintendo Direct: Mario Kart World: Every Announcement - How Would You Rate It?

Uncle_Franklin

24 racers on a track...
For me less is more.

Open world games can be great, I really don't think Mario Kart needed it.

I feel with a lot of franchises that Nintendo are, excuse the pun, running out of road.

As for price, Sonic Racing CrossWorlds is a lot cheaper; is Sega that much richer than Nintendo?
Presumably it's about Nintendo feeling they can get away with asking for $80 a game.
And maybe they're right, but the backlash to the price and the lukewarm reception to this direct suggest that may not be the case.

"But Nintendo have always been greedy, they've done research and this must be the right price!"
Like how they had to drop the 3DS price?
Like how they had to be persuaded to include Wii Sports with the console that became a runaway success?

Yes, Nintendo has always been about maximising profits like most companies, but let's not pretend that they always get that equation right.

Re: Nintendo: Hyrule Warriors: Age Of Imprisonment Is A "Canonical Tale"

Uncle_Franklin

Really enjoyed Calamity, but by the end I felt they were scraping the bottom of the barrel and was already left cold by the prospect of DLC,
this game holds even less interest for me.

Add that Kingdom essentially repeats Wild's storyline with different mcguffins (to the point where it's surreal that residents don't talk about the previous game's events) and this version of Hyrule is getting really tired.

@GoldenSunRM

The time travel didn't make the story invalid,
just made it a bit naff.

Re: Nintendo Of America President Says Tariffs "Not Factored" Into Switch 2 Price

Uncle_Franklin

@johnvboy

But if negotiations were his aim,
then why did he not accept them?

And why is he ruling out a zero for zero deal?

And if we're using the reductionist thinking of, y happened after x, therefore x caused y, then you could just as easily argue that the EU tariffs caused the 90 day delay (I don't think that was the cause, but that reasoning is just as logical).

Will be interesting how it turns out.

Re: Opinion: A Few Too Many Questions & Unwelcome Surprises Are Taking The Shine Off The Switch 2 Reveal

Uncle_Franklin

The thing that strikes me,
is that if they had waited a day or two to announce, in terms of optics, the prices would have looked a lot more justifiable.

But the crux of the issue isn't around emotional nonsense about whether Nintendo is greedy or not, or being obnoxious about certain people supposedly being poor.
A cretinous assertion in itself, as some wealthy people can be quite thrifty.

Rather, it's a question of whether this is strategically wise, and whether individual customers want to pay that much.

And certain failures in the past for Nintendo suggest they are more than capable of getting it wrong. N64, GameCube, Wii U, and 3DS all show this, but that last one is perhaps is most illustrative here;
Nintendo got the 3DS price completely wrong,
and despite being a for profit company, and a company that had done research, they had to decrease the price, at a loss or at least comparative loss.

A lot of people seem to be suffering from amnesia.

As for my memory, yes Nintendo has always been for profit of course, but it seemed in the past to be a more long term vision,
with discount games series which enhance their reputation, artistic directions that aren't guranteed to sell versus the more risk averse releases now. This recent Disneyfication has been much remarked upon. Mario has been bigger than Mickey Mouse since the late 80s, yet they didn't rush to do the theme parks.
A company intent on short term profits would have built a store in Japan long ago.
They were reticent towards the microtransactions on mobile, not because it wouldn't yield money short term, but because it might hurt their reputation long term.
Whilst obviously wanting to make money, they seem to in the past have wanted to appear to have artistic integrity, and to not appear rapacious.
I think now we are seeing more direct short term calculations, more akin to the Anglosaxon approach.
(That is not an ethical judgement, just an observation on their strategies.)
So to blithely state that Nintendo is a for profit company is be so banal as to be of little utility.

Re: Poll: Box Art Brawl - Nintendo Switch 2 Special

Uncle_Franklin

Box Art Brawls - Nintendo Switch 2 Special:

1st) Donkey Kong Bonanza

2nd) Mario Kart World

3rd) Metroid Prime 4

4th) The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild (US)

5th) Kirby and the Forgotten Land + Star Crossed World

6th) The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom

7th) The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild (EU)

8th) Super Mario Party Jamboree + Jamboree TV