Comments 864

Re: Random: Of Course You Can't Fit The Nintendo Switch In Your Pocket

Rect_Pola

I think the portability will have a lot more to do with bringing it to local multiplayer setups than gaming on the go. This isn't a bad thing; it means 3DS will still have a role as the "portable" device. For now at least, the two will be distinct enough to avoid the spectre of crossbuy that annoyed us during the Wii U era.

Re: Poll: Are You Optimistic for Nintendo's 2017?

Rect_Pola

I'm excited for the Switch. There's no way Nintendo hadn't learned at least SOMEthing from the Wii U and when their intentions failed. The Switch reveal (and arguably the longass time they're letting us simmer) is proof they making a point to push this system right.

Re: Nintendo Shuts Down Another Pokémon Fan Project

Rect_Pola

It was too pure for this world. IP infringing or not, I consider fan-games that make no effort to monetize their effort or hide what they are innocent in spirit.

And while Nintendo is perfectly in the right, I can't help but wonder how much of flexing their right is more to do with percieved competition or feeling upstaged.

Re: New Code Found in Unreal Engine 4 Further Reinforces Claims of Handheld / Docked Power Gap with Nintendo Switch

Rect_Pola

I'm not concerned about the machine's capability. I'm concerned about how readily third parties are going to work around the difference. Exclusives are nice, but Nintendo's pigeon-holed themselves as "the weird other" of the industry, and exclusives don't really help that. Thank goodness the design and marketing encourages normal controls first, even if motion and touch/pointing is present.

Re: Rumour: Nintendo Switch To Start At £199.99 In United Kingdom, $329.99 In Canada

Rect_Pola

I'm stunned Nintendo might still be pushing the "superior" model SKU after the Wii U (which IIRC died rather quickly). Now a bundle with pack in stuff? That I can grok. I've missed the practice and it's a way better ask on people at launch than 'how about paying less for a model that's more poop at it's job?' That's what mid-gen upgrades are for.

And getting it for $250, that is huge. That's what 3DS kicked off with back when they thought it's purely visual trick would sell product. It's a high start for portables, but generous for a modern console. Considering it's performance will be decent for modern consoles, but generous for portables, I'd call it a nice middle ground.

Re: ​Talking Point: Ports vs. Sequels On The Nintendo Switch

Rect_Pola

I don't think the Wii U had even had it as good as Gamecube. For one thing, it's controller is beloved (especially by smash fans). Gamecube had no gimmicks beyond being a funny purple box. Wii U's chief selling feature was dual screens in the game room, and it was rarely (if ever) used well enough to warrant it over solutions on a single screen.

Re: Here Are Your New My Nintendo Rewards

Rect_Pola

Already own everything. Jeez Nintendo. I wish there were actual numbers towards how much this helps sales, because it must be amazing.

My Nintendo was clearly designed for people on the outside, specifically who got in through Miitomo. Everything about it is to keep them playing Miitomo and coax them into buying existing games. Compare that with Club Nintendo, its "freebies" (though considering what it took to get anything it was hardly free) were extra little thank yous for dedication, past purchases mostly not applicable to your enjoyment. That was a system made for the fans.

Re: Rumour: Nintendo Switch Will Support Micro SDXC Cards Up To 128GB In Capacity

Rect_Pola

Sounds fine in some respects. I use a 32 on my 3DS and it's not half full, but that's avoiding retail titles. This IS at least a sign they're learning. Nobody who understood memory limitations would have pushed "download full retail games" on the Wii U. I didn't mind the push (we're going that way anyway), but Wii U was a poor platform to give the option. Third Parties treated it as a not publication option (we're going that way anyway) and the part of the audience that didn't pony up storage were screwed out.

@AVahne maybe not, the amount of pre-installing and loading times has been going up on the big systems, but they're all disc media. They need every title to eat data because they mechanically cannot read discs fast enough. One of the strengths of cartridges is they literally become part of the machine, reducing access time. If the Switch's carts reduces or completely avoids the data-dump curse all that storage can go to digital titles.

Re: Talking Point: Imagining a Future Nintendo Switch Budget Spin-Off - A Non-Switching Microconsole

Rect_Pola

That would be nice since I'm sure unless you are actively traveling, not many (in America) are going to cart their Switch around.

However, one feature that was important to that portability was local multiplayer. if that Splatoon tournament thing implied anything, it's that they can still do it docked, but it creates an issue that makes the option more awkward.

Also, we don't know if the Switch will be set up like a console (multiple users) or handheld (one account per machine). If you live with more than one Nintendo gamer they will NOT want to simply throw out their account, even if it's meaningless. Here the Switch mechanic does work for home users because so you can have your individual account and swap them out to enjoy on the big screen.

Re: Nintendo Switch Will Be a Single-Screen Experience

Rect_Pola

I don't mind because it DID NOT WORK at the console level. First of all, not many games used the second screen in a "could not work elsewhere" situation. Real time pause screens have existed before the Wii U, and they'll go on after. And that doesn't begin to touch the unpleasantness from the Gamepad's design. Oh, it was fine holding it up for a while, but it's mass eventually took it's toll. Then the best you could do was raise and lower your head.

Re: Nintendo Share Value Drops 6.5% Following Switch Reveal

Rect_Pola

The Switch will be sizable for a handheld, but most of the reveal bits aimed at it being a "set up anywhere" console. For whatever reason, investors didn't see that as novel. One guy did at least get you can comfortably share the experience (something non-VR consoles were always good at).

Also, far as I can tell the NS is primarily traditional in controls (thank god). Perhaps they saw that a step backwards DESPITE evidence that the weird ideas were different at best, and only got in the way at worse.

The comparison against smartphones is just unfair. I don't know where smartphone gaming is in other markets, but in my neck of the woods they rarely attempt to make experiences similar to handhelds, much less something consoles crank out.

Re: Nintendo Confirms Switch Isn't Physically Backwards Compatible With 3DS And Wii U Software

Rect_Pola

Not surprised. Nintendo will get to have fun trickling out the VC library all over again.
3DS, I'm kinda hoping they keep alive for a while because it's (A) not in bad shape, and (B) offers something Switch (far as we can tell) isn't trying to emulate.
To really get Wii/Wii U as eshop options, I figure we'd need a dedicated VC machine (like I HOPED the NES mini was going to be) . Their full suite of hardware needs are too specialized. Otherwise, Switch might get a couple titles that ignored the special hardware, or have been ported to crop it out. I'd love a new play controls Star Fox Zero port.

THEORY: I wonder if they're going to release a big Home bundle with the dock, but the main kit will be a cheaper dockless version with just a charging and connection cable (docks sold separtately of course). I still suspect they're going to treat the Switch enough like a portable to push multiple units in the home. Outside the charging convenience, going without the dock would it'd be a better value for that multi-owner aim.

Going multi-owner is not a bad thing, we saw this thing can multiplayer like champ with the Spatoon teams practicing.

Re: Parent Trap: Nintendo Switch Takes on Tablets

Rect_Pola

@CB85 I doubt it because it'd be useless in the dock. Motion controls may save the Wii library (maybe), but I really do think they're letting Wii U's games go down with the system, just like the old days.

Price & Battery life. If they nail at least those two they have a winner in the most default delivery. Memory and online are next.