Krull

Krull

Reading, gaming, running UK/Swe/Ire

Comments 1,600

Re: Random: Sakurai Talks About "The Most Incredible Year For The Game Industry"

Krull

@waveboy Hard disagree on the PS2 era being when gaming lost its smile. Development was still cheap enough that we’d get wild swings like Katamari. Also, the handhelds in that time, with the DS and PSP facing off, gave us some of the most innovative titles that we are yet to see the likes of again.

PS3 era, on the other hand, was when we entered the dreary grey-brown shooter world, and gaming - on home consoles at least - really did stop smiling. Didn’t help that the PS3 had such awkward architecture, I guess.

Re: Talking Point: What Are You Playing This Weekend? (13th April)

Krull

Finally more or less 100% completed Neo: The World Ends With You, so I’ve gone back to my beloved 3DS in the week the servers shut down. I’m playing Cave Story 3D, which is great. I’m slightly surprised by how much story there is, as I thought it was going to be a fairly basic Metroidvania. Instead it’s almost like a pixel Dust: An Elysian Tale.

Re: Random: BAFTA's 'Iconic Game Characters' Poll Has Us Scratching Our Heads

Krull

Lara Croft is genuinely not a bad shout. She is iconic, even if Mario is video gaming’s Mickey Mouse.

This is a poll that only 4,000 people seem to have been aware of. At least they’ve picked some interesting games, like Yakuza.

But yeah, Street Fighter II, Metal Gear, and a dozen or so mascot platformers have way more clout than half this list. Agent 47, honestly…

Re: Feature: The Pitch-Perfect Storytelling Of Final Fantasy VI’s Opera, And How The Pixel Remaster Missed A Note

Krull

@mlt I take your point, but just don’t know if I agree. Technical limitations aren’t a good explanation for turn-based combat, and certainly not by the time we get to fourth-generation consoles, because plenty of programmers had already shown you could just do an action RPG. Look at Ys, for example. OK, maybe nobody had really worked out how to do it for party combat at that point (the first Tales game was a year later), but maybe turn-based is actually just the best way to do party combat? It’s no coincidence that the more action-based FF has become as a franchise, the less party-based it has become, reaching its apotheosis in FFXVI.

Re: Feature: The Pitch-Perfect Storytelling Of Final Fantasy VI’s Opera, And How The Pixel Remaster Missed A Note

Krull

@PLATINUM7 That was super interesting, thank you. I’ll lend the original comment the benefit of a doubt then. Even if I personally dispute that turn-based combat is purely a side-effect from technical limitations - and even Ito says he was always intending to avoid a hard action element. And he was thinking in terms of setting plays in the NFL, which is about as turn-based and chess-like as professional sport gets.

You can definitely see how he ended up with the gambit system in FFXII. Cool interview.

Re: Feature: The Pitch-Perfect Storytelling Of Final Fantasy VI’s Opera, And How The Pixel Remaster Missed A Note

Krull

“Just as turn-based combat and overworlds came about to circumvent the limitations of early console generations” - what? What do technical limitations have to do with turn-based combat? Turn-based combat has been an intrinsic part of role-playing games since the very first table-top versions. Has absolutely nothing to do with technical limitations.

But yeah, the opera scene rules. Square has always been a leader in bringing a filmic vision to gaming.

Re: Metroid For NES Could Be Inducted Into The Video Game Hall Of Fame

Krull

I voted for Elite, because that game was light years ahead of its time. Open world, 3D space combat, trading, bounty hunting. And all in so few kilobytes that wouldn’t even be enough for a gif today.

It’s a public vote, so I expect Resident Evil to win the popularity contest, but all these games deserve to be in the hall of fame eventually. Apart from You Don’t Know Jack, maybe - never even heard of that game.

Re: Japanese Charts: Unicorn Overlord Dominates In Its Debut Week

Krull

For a new IP in a niche genre, those Unicorn Overlord sales are far, far better than I thought they’d be. Atlus barely gets that for SMT, let alone a dense, menu-laden Vanillaware RTS with an apparently mediocre story.

Just shows that reviews and word of mouth still count for something, and a good game can get the sales it deserves.

Re: Talking Point: What DS & 3DS Games Would You Still Like To See On Switch?

Krull

Where to start?! So many great Atlus games, including maybe the best SMT, 4 Apocalypse; the Persona Q games; the two SMT Devil Survivors; Radiant Historia; Stella Glow; the Etrian Odyssey Origins games…

Then there’s the 999 trilogy; DKC Returns; Metroid Samus Returns; Dragon Quest VII and VIII; Bravely Default and Second Layer; the best Fire Emblem (Awakenings) and two very good ones (Echoes and Fates; three Zeldas (OoT, MM and Link Between Worlds); Tales of Abyss; Rhythm Heaven…

Fortunately, I’ve got pretty much all of these still on my 3DS, and have only played about half of them. Such a great system.

The DS Castlevanias could do with an escape, though.

Re: Electronic Arts Cuts 5% Of Workforce, Closes Studio And Cancels Games

Krull

@EVIL-C You’re not wrong about the fanboys with paycheques, but it is journalism to report the facts of layoffs with company statements. It’s straight reporting. Analysis is something else, which you wouldn’t usually find within the report, which is meant to be impartial.

And TBF, games journalism is a lot better than it used to be. Plenty of sites will feature reports where they speak to fired workers, commentary on why they believe these layoffs are happening, and yes, analysis.

This is why Bloomberg has hired people from sites like Kotaku.

(I still like the goofy games articles, though. Give me more rankings of the best crabs in Nintendo games…)

Re: New Metroidvania From CERN Physicist Focuses On The Wonder Of Science

Krull

Will playing Exographer summon demons? Never heard of the CERN conspiracy theory before - that’s hilarious. Clearly I don’t spend enough time reading “facts” on the internet.

This game looks cool. I don’t understand what they’re doing with the puzzles from the video, but trust it will make sense in context. I’ll wait for a review, but I’m interested.

Re: Pokémon Presents 'Pokémon Day' Broadcast Runtime Revealed

Krull

Oh, I wonder what Pokemon Company, which pushes out at least one game every year (sometimes two), could possibly have to announce.

2017 - Ultra Sun and Moon
2018 - Let’s Go and western release of Detective Pikachu
2019 - Sword and Shield
2020 - Sword and Shield DLC + Mystery Dungeon
2021 - Diamond and Pearl remake
2022 - Arceus and Scarlet and Violet
2023 - ScarVi DLC and Detective Pikachu Returns

There’ll be something. I haven’t even included any of the mobile spinoffs that were also released on Nintendo hardware. I’d love to see another spinoff. Pokemon Conquest is due a return.

Re: Poll: Box Art Brawl - Duel: Jack Bros. (Virtual Boy)

Krull

Plenty of characters in Shin Megami Tensei are nightmare fuel, but this is supposed to be about Jack Frost and his bros. Did nobody in the NA office read the brief or play the game?

Japan should be walking this one home (says the guy with a Jack Frost keyring)

Re: Square Enix To Slim Down Its Gaming Lineup To Ensure Higher Quality

Krull

Kind of feel like this is Square getting ahead of the Switch 2 release, when the higher specs will make development of even AA games more expensive. Which is a shame, because Squenix has been on a great run. I think Octopath is established enough to get a third instalment, DQ is going to keep getting remakes and Monsters spin-offs, and I think even Triangle Strategy will come back. It’s the offbeat mid-budget failures like Neo: The World Ends with You (which is actually really good, just hasn’t really sold), Diofield and DQ Treasures and maybe even deep-cut remakes like Star Ocean 2R and Trials of Mana that I fear for, not to mention the weird stuff like Voice of Cards and Dungeon Encounters. We need the weird stuff, Squenix!

Re: Talking Point: What Are You Playing This Weekend? (January 13th)

Krull

@imadeanaccount I love the original The World Ends With You, but you don’t need to have played it first. They share a premise, and Neo acknowledges the first story happened, but it’s a new set of characters who have to be introduced just like a player coming to the series for the first time.

If you do want to play the first game, though, I highly recommend the iOS version. You can totally play it left-handed (and one handed) on a phone or tablet and it is far less … weird than the DS version. The Switch version of TWEWY kind of takes the iOS version and adds physical controls as an alternative to the touchscreen controls - but I’d say touchscreen, unusually, is better. After all, the original was based on partly using the DS stylus

Re: Yes, The Nintendo Switch Showcase Really Was Seven Years Ago

Krull

@sketchturner I have seriously never heard of 1001 Spikes, but I will point out - just to be that guy - that Metroid Prime 4 wasn’t revealed in the January showcase. It was announced in the E3 showcase in the summer.

If it’s any consolation, the games that sold me on getting the Switch at launch, beyond BotW, were Shin Megami Tensei V and Dragon Quest XI. It was a long wait even for DQXI.

Re: Nintendo Reportedly Seeking More Studios To Work On Its IP

Krull

Clearly it’s now time for Fromsoft to make Pokemon Souls. Remedy can take on Luigi’s Mansion 4. Paradox can move the Advance Wars series forward.

Team Cherry remakes Zelda II (might take a while, that one). Larian picks up Golden Sun. Supergiant Games reboot Kid Icarus.

As long as it’s not Kemco, Game Mill and LJN…

Re: Best Nintendo Switch Games Of 2023

Krull

How on earth is Persona 3 Portable trending below an 8? It’s a 10 for me - I think the characters and tone are among the best in the series - but I think there’s a knee-jerk response to its “visual novel” sections. They’re EXACTLY the same as the real world sections in P4G but more honest: you skip from point to point rather than walking and pretending you could stumble on something secret (which you can’t). I actually prefer the P3P approach to P4G’s, as it doesn’t lead you on or waste your time.

P4G is still dope, though. 137hrs, my clock reads.

Really hope Persona 6 comes to the Switch 2.

Re: Metacritic Reveals "The Worst Video Games Of 2023"

Krull

Missed that Loop8 was so poorly reviewed everywhere. Didn’t get the best write-up on this site, but sounded like it still had enough about it to recommend it. Flashback 2 is also a shame - though the original always had more style than substance.

Re: Feature: "Doing Things A Bit Differently" - Blending Final Fantasy & Devil May Cry Combat In 'Worldless'

Krull

@HeadPirate I agree that there’s a bit of a lazy shorthand in comparing something new to more well-known properties, but it’s not limited to gaming. The Citizen Kane of westerns; Beyoncé crossed with Korn; Charles Dickens meets Shirley Jackson… Does feel a bit tired, but it’s a very effective way of communicating what a property is trying to do.

But really I’m replying because I really want to play Hades meets Animal Crossing and the Dark Souls of Mario Kart. Those both sound amazing!

Re: Nintendo Switch "Lifetime US Unit Sales" Surpass Xbox 360

Krull

@SBandy1 Fair shout on the indie games. Stuff like Dust: AET was great. The exclusives, though… Great if you like racing games (nope!) and shooters (meh - mixed feelings), I suppose. I find that library pretty dreary - but I guess that’s AAA gaming in the Noughties. PS3 was far better in the teens. Not my favourite generation, I must admit.