Comments 1,350

Re: Poll: What Review Score Would You Give Donkey Kong Country Returns HD?

IceEarthGuard

@Rykdrew Not sure what you are trying to get here. I'm talking about a game that did release 10-15 years ago and being rereleased. Why are you bringing up if it's a game that didn't release? I'm not talking about unreleased games either. Unreleased means pretty much no one ever played the game at all except for the devs/play testers.

Whole point of my comment is that I do not factor in price with the rating/score that I give to games.

Re: Astral Chain Director Seemingly Forms New Studio After Leaving PlatinumGames

IceEarthGuard

@RiasGremory I meant by the overwhelmingly positive feedback/reviews for the game. For example the game got a 87 metascore and the user score on that site is 9/10. Similar on this site as well.

If the rumors are true that the development for the second game is very messy, and with what is happening to Platinum games, that just makes me think the next game might be all over the place in what direction the game is going for. Which may result in the game being not as good as the first game.

But I am going to wait and see what happens next.

Re: Poll: What Review Score Would You Give Donkey Kong Country Returns HD?

IceEarthGuard

@Mando44646 I'm talking about the rating for just the game itself. I understand time length and cost together being a factor for someone's score/rating, but just only cost alone, makes no sense to me.

When someone rates a game 9/10, and then lets say 10-15 years later they release it again with a few extra stuff or just make it look better graphically without tweaking any of the original gameplay, for an increased price. Your rating for the game should technically be still 9/10 (if everything work as it did back them with no problems.)

If I do change my rating for a game, it won't be because of the price.

Re: 'Hyperdimension Neptunia' & 'Death End' Switch Releases Scrapped For "Not Complying With Nintendo Guidelines"

IceEarthGuard

@Samalik Well that was what I was getting at in my comment. I agree with you. I guess I should have been more clear. What I meant about it "being good," I was thinking about the more realistic stuff. But then again I doubt something like that will get submitted to the Nintendo platform, so it's pretty much useless that guideline, if they have it implemented that is.

Re: 'Hyperdimension Neptunia' & 'Death End' Switch Releases Scrapped For "Not Complying With Nintendo Guidelines"

IceEarthGuard

@TheTony316 Yeah I saw other gameplay videos, it's not because of the performance.

I don't know if it's confirmed, but I read a comment somewhere else about a new guideline saying "they revised their guidelines to not allow sexualization of what can appear as underaged characters."

Which is a good thing, but there is a catch, a guideline like that can be abusive/not used properly when it comes to Anime style art games and cause problems when they shouldn't, and Hyperdimension Neptunia and Death end re;Quest does not violate this guideline.

Re: 'Hyperdimension Neptunia' & 'Death End' Switch Releases Scrapped For "Not Complying With Nintendo Guidelines"

IceEarthGuard

What the heck? This makes no sense. I was looking forward for these games to be on the Switch.

I don't believe these games violated the guidelines, someone has to be screwing them over. This is not good. Just look at all the AI hentai games on the Eshop that they approved.

Plus other games from these series are available in the Eshop in the west. Makes me even more suspicious.