Comments 623

Re: Talking Point: Is The Switch 2 Going To Be Too Big?

swoose

I’ve been banging this drum for a while as for me, the Switch was already too big and consoles like the DS Lite and GBA were the ideal size/weight for handhelds. I revisit them regularly. But that ship has sailed as the whole market is trending towards bigger and heavier units.

I’ll take the good with the bad - bigger size, reportedly without much added weight will make it a little more comfortable to hold, and the magnet attachments will hopefully make the controls less shaky. I’ll never understand the refusal to add ergonomics to the flat joy-con however. And here’s hoping for a Lite revision that isn’t pointlessly prevented from docking again.

Re: Switch 2 'Indentations' Make It Incompatible With Original Switch Dock, Says Genki

swoose

@Skoffo There’s no agreements between Nintendo and most accessory companies. These leaks are only possible because Nintendo chose to enter mass production on a console months before they reveal it or even announce its name. This made factory leaks to interested parties basically inevitable.

Nintendo’s strategy here is that only fandom weirdos like us will follow leaks from CES, while most of their audience will only hear about Switch 2 when ads for it are plastered on their TVs and phones. Leaks might not really matter, so they chose to focus on squeezing every last sale out of Switch 1.

Re: Fans Reckon The 'Switch 2' Joy-Con May Be Usable As A Mouse

swoose

Very cool and creative if this is true, but I find it funny everyone is hype for FPS games with such a narrow, makeshift mouse. For a shooting game, the Switch already has the best control scheme possible: gyroscope. Aiming in Splatoon is faster and more natural than any FPS I've ever played, and I grew up with classics like Quake and Unreal Tournament on mouse & keyboard.

Where mice ARE superior is being anywhere on screen and holding still there without any exertion, useful for games with lots of menuing like Mario Paint or Civilization.

Re: Rumour: New 'Switch 2' Photos Show Off A Very Legit-Looking Joy-Con

swoose

Notably there’s a legible serial number on this unit which can be input to Nintendo’s support page, and it shows a valid warranty already. This is a final retail Switch 2 joycon.

And shocker: it perfectly matches the 100 other leaks and renders we’ve seen of it already, which users here were calling lies and frauds. I’ll wait patiently for the posts admitting they were mistaken, which surely are forthcoming.

Re: Nintendo's Punch-Out!! Series May Be Dead And Buried For Good

swoose

The poor sales compared to other Next Level Games projects was probably the actual nail in the coffin. It’s the kind of series that will always be a legacy title but that doesn’t necessarily justify a brand new entry. And the 80s-90s stereotypes are part of the legacy.

The NES original holds up great as a lightning-fast single player arcade/puzzle experience, on CRT with zero input lag. To make it more accessible and multiplayer, the ARMS format makes way more sense.

Re: Those Switch 2 Leaks "Might Be Legit" According To A New Report

swoose

I don't really get the almost dogmatic hatred against leaks shown by some in these comments. Burned too much in the past? Some leaks are wrong, some are spot-on. The Switch 2 has had a notably consistent stream of leaks, shipping logs and the like, all corroborating each other, so fair to think it's a poorly kept secret at this point.

Whether or not the dock ends up having its own fan, I'd say feet on the back of the dock are a good idea. Some people have shelved setups where it's easier to fit things laid flat rather than standing up.

Re: Atlus Lead Explains Why Persona Protagonists Are High School Males

swoose

There's not really a good justification for it, so I wouldn't expect one from the developers. Wada may as well say something like "creative license" or "development reasons" and leave it at that.

I've been getting into the Rune Factory series and even a smaller team like Hakama have managed dual protagonists as of RF4 on the 3DS, and even that was long in coming... I can't imagine Atlus isn't capable.

Re: PSA: If You're Into Switch 2 'Leaks', It's The Wild West Out There Right Now

swoose

The main things I still want confirmed:

  • Hall Effect sticks. This feels very un-Nintendo in that it's like admitting something was wrong with the Switch's sticks in the first place, which they have never done, and adopting a solution that many other controller brands marketed first. I almost expect the Switch 2 to have some proprietary Nintendo stickbox that leaves it ambiguous whether or not drift is solved, since they won't acknowledge it existed.
  • Joycon ergonomics. This one is less likely, and the CAD renders have been inconsistent about the back of the console, but they all showed the joycon still being flat on the back. Now all the peripheral leakers incorporate a grip on the back of the joycon more like a Wiimote or WiiU gamepad. That could just be part of their case designs though. They correctly identify that nobody wants to hold up a slate-thin console for hours in 2025. Ergonomics are a solved problem. I really hope Nintendo fixed it themselves and aren't just leaving the issue to 3rd parties.

Re: Talking Point: Is It Time For HD-2D To Take A Break?

swoose

There will always be a place for 2D characters on 3D backgrounds, but this "HD-2D" brand has gotten too formulaic. I prefer other looks featured in this article like Sea of Stars, or fully pixeled games like Tengo Project is making.

For me, there's too much shadow in all the games up to Dragon Quest III, the text sizes are always way too small, and the UIs are never integrated in the pixel style.

Re: Random: Did Street Fighter 6's Next DLC Just Reference Sakurai's Famous Smash Quote? Some Fans Think So

swoose

What’s annnoying about this is Sakurai’s joke was at the expense of CERO, along the lines of “CERO has decided that Smash Bros is for good boys and girls” which makes it way funnier. But the localization left that out because they think we’re stupid and don’t know what a rating board is.

And so now english social media is full of “take THAT Sakurai!!” when he never passed that judgment on Mai in the first place.

Re: Talking Point: Can Sony And Microsoft Really Compete With Nintendo In A New 'Handheld War'?

swoose

I don’t think even Nintendo can outdo the Switch’s success. I think we’re facing an economic downturn, and some market saturation for handhelds (people satisfied with their Switches). The Switch was a runaway freight train in gaming and I think the Switch 2 can be a modest success, but lightning won’t strike twice. So I don’t expect a competitor handheld to take off either.

I hope that leads to more innovation in handhelds 2 gens from now, and especially to smaller form factors. People are buying pillow attachments to hold up their “handheld” pcs and consoles this gen, so their hands don’t fall asleep since the tech is so stupidly heavy. You can barely call them portable.

Re: 'Switch 2' Accessories Are Seemingly Already On Sale Via Chinese Vendors

swoose

It may have been tricky to make an article out of the blurry joycon & console footage from yesterday, since Nintendo was getting videos of it taken down. It's very obviously real. And not surprising, given how deep into production we are.

Nintendo waiting until 2025 to reveal this may as well have been saying "We're OK with you seeing our console from leakers first."

Re: Talking Point: What Would Be The Ideal Way To Play DS Games On 'Switch 2'?

swoose

If only there was a Nintendo-made peripheral that weighed only 8 ounces, supported all DS games natively, had a nice resistive touchscreen, and was so popular that Nintendo shipped like 130 million of them, so they’re easy to find everywhere. Oh yeah, that’s the Nintendo DS.

Play your DS games on DS, people. It’s a comfier and more portable handheld than the Switch anyway. A new “Nintendo Classics” DS mini product would be preferable to all the compromises listed here, but even that I think is wasteful and too soon.

Re: Opinion: Chrono Trigger Isn't The Only Great Time-Travel RPG On DS

swoose

I remember liking the grid-based battle system in this. Can't for the life of me remember why I fell off playing it, other than it being a full-length RPG.

I think I was playing the 3DS version, which has voice acting and some extra dungeons in exchange for new anime portrait art that got mixed reviews. The DS original had a more distinctive look for sure.

Re: Zelda: Echoes Of Wisdom Devs Explain The Method Behind The Menu Madness

swoose

That Aonuma quote had nothing to do with the menu, he's just talking about using echoes in gameplay. I don't know if control schemes and menus are really his wheelhouse, seems like more of a Miyamoto thing who had no involvement with this title.

I will say the menu wasn't a huge downside for me, I only wish new echoes were automatically at the front of your "last used", instead of the end.

Re: Pokémon Sleep Development To Shift To Internal Subsidiary

swoose

A bit concerning as Select Button only makes bangers... but they've also ONLY made Magikarp Jump and Pokemon Sleep in the past 10 years. I'm guessing they're a smaller studio that mostly does support work, art and UIs and such.

I'll keep an eye out for any negative changes but if this keeps Sleep supported for longer, it's a good thing. The structure of the game is there.

Re: Round Up: The Reviews Are In For Mario & Luigi: Brothership

swoose

A couple misconceptions. The IGN review was written by a superfan of the Mario & Luigi RPGs, who was clearly let down by this entry vs. his expectations. It was not a case of being unfamiliar with the series or biased against Nintendo, Logan Plant is often on their Nintendo Voice Chat podcast. Sometimes the biggest fans are the biggest critics; if NintendoLife asked for my review of Pokemon Scarlet & Violet, I might have given that a 5.

Which raises the point: look at the writer, not the website. I keep seeing “but IGN gave [bad game] a 9!” So what? The same reviewer doesn’t give every score, and sites can’t enforce a monolith opinion across their staff. You wouldn’t judge PJ O’Reilly’s review skills by this site’s review of Sonic x Shadow Generations. He didn’t write that one!

Re: Plans To Announce The 'Switch 2' Have Not Changed, Says Nintendo's President

swoose

I think this whole thing was a fumble and uncharacteristic of Nintendo. Why acknowledge a successor this year at all? The damage to their sales momentum has likely already been done by that.

It wasn't just hopium thinking the announcement would have to be this year, with a spring or early summer release. It's now looking like a fall 2025 release at the earliest. That's on a chipset that is already known to be a couple years old, into a market with another year of competition from other entertainment devices. Not to be nintendoomed about it, but the prototype was shown to devs ages ago and this ramp-up seems very slow.

Re: Random: Kit & Krysta Discuss The "Drama" Behind The Switch Reveal Trailer

swoose

Half of every comment section on aggregated Kit & Krysta bits is yelling at the clouds about them being relevant. I don’t follow them but clearly they saw a spot in the media market for views from former Nintendo employees, and people listen to them.

If you object to this so much just stop clicking on their headlines on NintendoLife.

Re: Nintendo Museum Overseas Visitors Reportedly Breaking 'No Photos' Rule

swoose

I was always taught to ask "why?" and consider logic.

There is absolutely zero logic to banning photography. It takes 1 second, is unobtrusive, and deals no damage to the value of the museum. And further it's unenforceable, unless you want to confiscate all smart phones or watch every patron like a hawk. Such an obvious losing battle.

Re: Random: Nintendo's Museum Might Be Emulating SNES Games On Windows PC

swoose

Weirdly defensive stances towards Nintendo here in my opinion. I love their games and products, that doesn't mean we have to love their legal activities and the hypocrisy here is obvious.

They've repeatedly gone after both open-source emulators AND non-profit rom archives, that's the main sore point with people even before they started charging for an emulation experience in their museum.

Re: Talking Point: How Would You Fix Zelda: Echoes Of Wisdom's Most Frustrating Feature?

swoose

@Sarkos I know, but that's what I mean by extra inputs that shouldn't be there. They should just be sorted in sequence with my most recently used.

I've taken to stopping what I'm doing, and summoning every single echo as soon as I acquire it to move it to the front. Otherwise I get 10 new echoes and have to remember which ones I've summoned yet or not, and which ones will be in front or back of the line.

Re: Talking Point: How Would You Fix Zelda: Echoes Of Wisdom's Most Frustrating Feature?

swoose

I have to think Nintendo has done some design study that shows people visually process items faster if they’re in a single row. The Switch menu has also stuck to this for 7 years. Because otherwise, 2 rows is such an obvious option I can’t believe they didn’t go with it. 1 for objects, 1 for monsters?

I’m getting by fine with the default “recently used” sorting, except whenever getting new echoes (which is constantly). They put those new echoes LAST in the list unless you switch to “recently learned”. The best function would obviously be recently used & learned combined, but that doesn’t exist so I’m doing extra inputs every time to shuffle my new echoes to the front.