Comments 535

Re: Poll: Is It About Time Game Freak Added Voice Acting To Pokémon?

ShadLink

@Hams96 Pokémon Snap was not a GameFreak game. GF clearly doesn't want voice acting in their games. Only reason it's not in there, and only reason it might never be. And actually looking at any other Nintendo game. Most now have voice acting in some form now.

So Nintendo would be for it. But, to me, they are not the kind of publisher that forces their studio's or their partners into a certain technology or game element just becuase they want it. And I don't really want that to change either.

Maybe if another studio did another remake (Gen 5) it would be fitting to "test" adding VA.

Re: Mini Review: Pokémon Legends: Z-A (Switch) - Mostly Stable, Much Less Shiny

ShadLink

This review is laughible even worse than the Switch 2 review.

I've played the game on Switch 1 and 2. On Switch the textures are lower res (very clearly visible), the game is 30fps, and there are a lot less particle effects. However, it still looks and runs good. Better than Legends Arceus or Scarlet / Violet. So this score is bad.

The Game on Switch ~8/10, the game on Switch 2 ~9.48/10 (scores aren't finalised until I finish the main story). Going by my own ranking.

Re: Pokémon Legends: Z‑A Ranked Battles Season 1 Now Live, Reach 'Rank K' For A Special Reward

ShadLink

@Bolt_Strike Oh no... you actually need some skill to unlock something. I really can't understand people these days. Maybe they should just have made the Mega evolution stones part of a lootbox system. So people could just buy lootboxes like in any other game. Because god forbid you actually have to play the game in order to get something, smh.

You need to get to rank K. With some decent evolved Pokémon it's not that hard.

@Dom_31 It's technically an optional part. But it's still part of the game. And sure you have to pay to play online, but that's not the game's fault. You need to pay to play any (paid) game online on Switch (2). Same goes for any Playstation or Xbox game, for that matter.

Re: Pokémon Legends: Z-A First Mystery Gift Distribution Event Now Live

ShadLink

@Emacster I agree. If you can vibe with this new battle system and are not deterred by the somewhat simple graphics, this game is absolutely somewhere between great and awesome.

Also tried some online ranked battles now. And yikes.. I have some training to do. But even online gameplay feels smooth and the battles are fast. Losing battles is also fast

Re: Pokémon Legends: Z-A First Mystery Gift Distribution Event Now Live

ShadLink

Have already played about a couple of hours an collected the Mistery gift.

Here a few opinions I have:
1. The game is extremely focused on battles. This is very different than for example Legendss Arceus.
2. The battles are extremely smooth. It's basically the same system as Legends Arceus and Scarlet / Violet but optimised until (near) perfection.
4. The story is funny and decent for a Pokémon game.
5. Locations are really detailed and you remember them from Pokémon X and Y.
6. It's a LOT of fun.
7. The area's are really detailed.
8. Overall the graphics are good.
9. The controls are really good.
10. Sure the the buildings are flat, but you stop noticing that after 2 seconds.

All in all I am loving this game. I am not going to rate it before I finish it. But right now it has a range of 9-9.5/10 contender for Game of the Year. And I've already purchased the DLC.

Also people like comparing the battles to Xenoblade Chronicles (series) but I disagree there as well. Those games are often quite slow in switching betwen world and battle or even between battle and battle. Also the battles give less control in those games (a single normal attack and a lot of "wait until available" attacks). I actually compare them with the Mana series, but still smoother.

Re: Round Up: The Reviews Are In For Pokémon Legends: Z-A

ShadLink

So basically the only complaints are that it's based inside a city and that the focus is on battles.

It's a Pokémon game, I am very happy that the focus is on battles.
And I don't mind a city world for a game. Scarlet / Violet / Arceus were more outside the cities. So a welcome change for me.

Re: Nintendo Calls On 'Stranger Things' Star To Promote Its New Pokémon Adventure For Switch 2

ShadLink

@Pillowpants

@ShadLink There's a big difference between complaining and voicing concern, if you ask me. If something you love is changing into something you don't like you should be vocal about it. Of course it matters in what way you voice it, on that I think we can agree.

Sure I agree here. But when talking about Pokémon it is not a few people voicing their concern. But it's a smal extremely vocal group complaining at every opportunity they get. That is NOT the same thing as voicing concern.

In the case op Pokémon Legends: Z-A, there's been a LOT of footage and in-depth videos to get a very good idea of how the actual gameplay will be.

Yet we have only seen a few area's of the game. Just like with previous titles. This says absolutely nothing.

But from what I've seen now PL:ZA is not a game I think I will enjoy, specifically because I don't think the mechanics are particularly well designed

And this is something you absolutely can't say without playing it. This game is going to have a completely new battle mechanic never seen in earlier Pokémon games. So how can you ever assess if it's well designed or not?!!

What you're basically saying is that "if you don't like something, keep your mouth shut."

WHERE DID I WRITE THAT?! No, my point is now and has always been: if you don't like it, don't buy it. And if you want to voice your concern, tell Nintendo. Every single Nintendo website has a contact@ address. Which is a lot better than complain in an echo chamber. (it is not going to change anything, and takes away enjoyment of people who are wanting to play this game (like me))

Re: Nintendo Calls On 'Stranger Things' Star To Promote Its New Pokémon Adventure For Switch 2

ShadLink

@Pillowpants But my point stands. People are complaining about a new game, of which they don't know how it's going to be played. Just because the game doesn't fit exactly with what they want that game to be. Or don't like the play style. Or the graphical style. Or the story.. or anything really.

All this before they play the (final version of the) game. Just remember that games change during development. Also developers/publishers rarely show every aspect of a game before release. And no game caters to everyone, and that is okay too.

For example, I don't like Warriors-style games. So I won't be buying Hyrule Warriors. I have played the previous entries but could never really get into those games. But do I complain about it? No. I will just skip it and buy a different game later on (Kirby AirRiders).

Re: Nintendo Calls On 'Stranger Things' Star To Promote Its New Pokémon Adventure For Switch 2

ShadLink

I've seen a lot of times that people complain about Pokémon games being stale and boring because they keep repeating the same formula. Now GameFreak changes the formula and even before the games release, people complain about the formula being changed. (about it being in a city, about the new battle mechanics, etc..)

People really don't know what they want.
Anyway, I do think this game looks awesome and I can't wait for the 16th. And the ad looks exactly like most of the "celebraty game ads" Nintendo has made before. Boring, but the whole reason is "look this celeb is playing our game, buy our game now!" Which is boring, but well.. it's an ad.

Re: Poll: Do You Think Nintendo's New Animated Short 'Close To You' Is Pikmin Related?

ShadLink

I just think it's a cute short video, like the Pixar shorts, that doesn't have any direct relation to any game or media by Nintendo. It does have Pikmin music, but that doesn't say anything since Nintendo Pictures also worked on Pikmin content before.

[s]Also like others have pointed out. There are no humans in the Pikmin universe. This couldn't be related to any Pikmin game.[/s]

Edit: Ah yes, it was indeed linked to Pikmin

Re: Rumour: Silent Hill 2 May Be Coming To Switch 2 As Its Exclusivity Window Ends

ShadLink

@EVIL-C Actually it's not a real issue.

@Medic_alert If we didn't have gamekeycards these games either

A. wouldn't be released on Switch 2
or B. would be codes in a box.
or C. games would be a lot more restrictive in capabilities.
and D. games would've been (even) more expensive.

A would be far worse for Nintendo and B would be the same as just buying the game in the eShop.
C would just hurt games in the long term because of the slow eMMC storage on the cartridges.

The complaining about GKC just means that next Nintendo console will be a download only console.

Re: Mario Kart World And Donkey Kong Bananza Shortlisted For 'Console Game Of The Year'

ShadLink

@Anti-Matter Honestly I feel the opposite. I always liked the large A button, since it's the one you use the most. And I don't have any issues with the analog triggers. Only downside the GC pad has, for me, is that it doesn't have a select button and that the sticks don't 'click'. Which means they are not really usuable in modern games.

The PlayStation controllers are decent as well, but I hate the stick placement on those. And I much rather have the XBOX / Nintendo GameCube/Switch/Switch 2 placement of the sticks.

Re: Yooka-Replaylee Runs At 30fps On Switch 2, Team Investigating Performance Mode

ShadLink

@purple_shyguy So basically like on any console, first year titles aren't that much better than best games on last gen console. Same was the case for PS5 and XBOX Series and in the past as well. It really is, when we see games that are designed for Switch 2 that we will see performance improvements. But that is going to take time.

@lumothesinner If you want stable 60fps in all games you shouldn't be buying a console at all.

Re: Preview: Pokémon Legends: Z-A's Combat Shines Brightly, But Its Visuals Are Still Dull

ShadLink

@FancyJehuty It also had a very broken "good AI" that meant that the opponent always picked the most effective move. Even if that move was only a stat change. And Psychic was literally overpowered. Get yourself a Kadabra, Alakazam (or Mewtwo) and you basically destroy everything.
And that is before you look at even crazier stuff like Missing No and the Badge Boost Glitch.

And backsprites were unique, but they were also very, very awful for some Pokémon. (which was fixed in Yellow) And Pikachu saying "Pikachu" in Yellow was indeed neat. And Yellow did fix some of the issues, but Yellow was also one of the final games on the original GameBoy published by Nintendo. But "graphical showcases of the platform"? Nope, that has it never been.

Gold / Silver was indeed because of Iwata's compression algorithm. But before that it was going to be a very different game (shorter) so basically Nintendo there saved the Pokémon franchise.

And I honestly think that after the Scarlet and Violet backlash, Gamefreak basically toned their game down drastically. I also think that when we see a specific Switch 2 Pokémon game (2027 at the earliest) that we will get something different.
(next year will be Pokémon Pokopia and Champions as a stop gap)

Re: Preview: Pokémon Legends: Z-A's Combat Shines Brightly, But Its Visuals Are Still Dull

ShadLink

It looks like it's a very fluid battle mechanic. Leaving less memory (etc) for other graphics. It's what you prioritise. Also I think it looks decent in trailers, sure a bit simple but I can live with that.

" It really is baffling and overwhelmingly disappointing that Pokémon games continue to fall short in the looks department, especially when you consider that historically (on handheld devices) they were graphical showcases many moons prior."
Honestly this was never the case. Even on original GameBoy / GameBoyColor the games weren't that great in comparison to other games. The best "graphical" Pokémon games were Black/White for their generation, but those were honestly the worst in battle mechanics. And many older Pokémon couldn't be caught. X&Y (3DS) was also quite bland and had graphical issues (but was a great game). Sun/Moon, well we won't talk about it.