Pho

Pho

Nintendo fan/Healer extraordinaire!

Comments 826

Re: Poll: What Review Score Would You Give Dragon Quest VII: Reimagined?

Pho

  • 7
  • Pho

Will get it eventually. Wasn't a huge fan of the 3ds remake, but I'm hoping Reimagined will change my view of VII. Didn't help that the 3ds version had input lag in battles.
If they make a Reimagined VIII I will be on it day one, Dragon Quest VIII remains my 2nd favorite game of all time.

Re: Ubisoft Cancels 6 Games In Major Organisation Restructure

Pho

@Dr_Awkward Ignoring your jabs, but why would you even want your world building NPC dialogue to not just be written by a human being? As it currently stands it does not save time, or come up with quality dialogue or story. You could just have a human being hand craft it, rather than have someone prompting and then editing said output. Even taking away any plagiarism claims it's not worth it, as there are still plenty of other issues with generative AI. Its not any more efficient than good writers fleshing out their own game, and it won't surpass the quality of a normal writing process.

Re: Ubisoft Cancels 6 Games In Major Organisation Restructure

Pho

@Dr_Awkward Your knowledge of Gen AI is half baked, and plagiarism is literally only one aspect of why it shouldn't be used. And you'll have no way of knowing if that "in world lore" was trained on their own content. Even then, human written content will always be superior. This isn't some "new technology bad" Satanic Panic, theres myriad examples of how inept it is at simple tasks.

Re: Ubisoft Cancels 6 Games In Major Organisation Restructure

Pho

@Nep-Nep-Freak It doesn't matter if a person makes something similar or not totally original, as long as its not plagiarism. Its made by a human, not an AI. GenAI is always plagiarising from someone, and theres no actual human element to it. If you want to play GenAI created games be my guest, but I have no desire to touch them.

Re: Ubisoft Cancels 6 Games In Major Organisation Restructure

Pho

@MarioLinkSamus The problem is how it's "creating" what it comes up with. All that data, art, etc. has to come from somewhere, and it's taking that from non consenting parties to generate what it comes up with. Even were it using data entirely from within the company, that's only the tip of the iceberg. Ultimately its not creating things of quality or care. Look to the latest debacle with Larian, their own higher ups who are forced to use Gen AI such as the lead writer has stated what its putting out is of poor quality. Its not augmenting them, its only something to get in the way of actual human creativity.

Re: Ubisoft Cancels 6 Games In Major Organisation Restructure

Pho

@MarioLinkSamus Thats not what generative AI means. Procedurally generated or NPC AI is entirely different. Generative AI takes from other existing sources to spit something out, and doesn't result in what you've suggested except potentially speaking to NPC's via microphone, which would have to use GenAI to pull responses from.
GenAI should never be part of the creative process for many reasons, because its scraping that data its using from someone else's work and mashing it together.

Re: Poll: What Review Score Would You Give Metroid Prime 4: Beyond?

Pho

Just beat it last night. Solid game, great music, graphics and boss fights. Didn't mind the side characters beyond Myles early on. Desert area and crystal collecting bring it down a bit, if that was tightened up or removed it'd be an easy 9/10 for me. Story was also just a bit. nothing. Also really short.