Comments 268

Re: After Years Of Waiting, Metroid Prime 4's Launch Trailer Is Finally Here

Filthy

I got a bit curious after the divisive reviews, so I decided to check some videos and SkillUp’s review pretty much told me what I feared.

I can’t see many of the OG Retro developers being there. The ship of Theseus, trying to simply emulate what worked decades ago — tacking on a bad open world and horrible writing.

Easy pass for me. Hope the people who buy it get what they want, though.

Re: Best Zelda Games Of All Time

Filthy

Skyward Sword was just as bad with regular controls and is a genuinely boring and bad entry to the series. Great soundtrack, the rest falls flat.

Re: Poll: What Do You Make Of The Mario Galaxy Movie's Leaked Yoshi Design?

Filthy

@coolioam No, I said it because that's what I think it looks like. It's not the fault of the artist, it's on whoever approved this design.

EDIT: To elaborate, it's the glassy eyes, textured scales along with the (obviously) cartoony proportions which puts it in an uncanny valley for me — and it reminds me a lot of what generative AI pours out.

Re: Best Dragon Quest Games Of All Time - Switch And Nintendo Systems

Filthy

DQXIS on top so far, for sure — but I've got plenty of games to go. DQI 2DHD was fantastic, DQII is great so far and I had a great time with Builders 2 and got to pick Monsters: The Dark Prince up again. I liked what I played.

Also picked up a Japanese 2DS XL with DQXI, and fired it up quickly. Looks lovely!

@h3s Why not both?

Re: Review: Dragon Quest I & II HD-2D Remake (Switch 2) - Rounds Out The Erdrick Trilogy In Style

Filthy

Having blasted through DQI now, I don't get where the minus is coming from. It's clear they've added quite a bit of complexity when having one party member fighting multiple opponents (unlike the OG release), the characters and cutscenes added make for a nice modernization — and it somehow feels surprisingly fresh.

If DQI were a long game I'm sure it'd get stale, but at 12-ish hours — it almost feels like bonus content for DQII.

Re: Talking Point: When Did 'Good Enough' Become Good Enough For Pokémon?

Filthy

This is some top tier engagement bait. Well done!

They’ve got a brilliant business going, so for Pokemon Company — ”Good Enough” is fantastic.

Personally, I don’t think it’s good enough. With the production values on display they should be about 30 EUR titles, not asking for the same money as much higher quality experiences. And ”but it’s for kids” is a bad argument. Kids deserve nice things too — and the cost is still the same.

Now if people want to pay fine dining prices for McDonalds, let them.