@OpheliaDynamight This is how I feel about it, too. Yes, it hurts some people pretty hard in the short term, but in the long term it's just part of technological progress and overall will be a positive thing.
I don't care if something is made by AI or not just like I don't care if animation is hand-drawn or computer generated or not. I care if it's good.
#1 - Parody is the quintessential example of fair use
#2 - Human beings also learn to create art by studying vast quantities of other copyrighted art
#3 - Might as well sue the pen manufacturer somebody used to draw Pikachu on their notebook.
Just found this from the other article about DD2. The comment above about FE games becoming bloated is dead on point. I've really disliked the latest entries. Might look into this one and its sequel.
Over at CTRL-ALT-DEL comics, they whined and moaned about how unfair the Silksong publishers were being by giving so little warning, which "made" other games change their release dates. Good grief. One business has no obligation to make things easier for their competitors.
Still, thanks for taking a minute to highlight these! I'll be looking into Dark Deity 2 (maybe there's Japanese VAs? The English ones are pretty corny. They Japanese ones might be too, but I couldn't tell). Also Fling to the Finish! Been looking for something light to play with my daughter.
The best solution is not to demand features you haven't paid for, but to not buy games that don't guarantee you an offline experience - if that's what you care about. You spent your money on a game that didn't have a feature you want, don't go crying to the government demanding you get something you didn't pay for.
I'm way in the minority here, but to my eye the NA version is way too busy & chaotic and makes less sense the more I look at it. Japan is cleaner and I really like the wire frames. I'll admit the sharp cutoff between the scene and the diagrams is too severe though.
I love to play games with a mouse! I don't like to play games with something 1/4 the size of a normal mouse, not shaped like a mouse, with buttons not placed like a mouse. Just I like I don't playing with a controller... that's 1/8 the size of a normal controller, not shaped like a controller, with buttons not placed like a controller.
So, can I just connect a normal mouse to the Switch 2?
@Polvasti Commercial use is relevant, but not determinative, of the question of fair use. Many fair uses can be monetized. This site uses images of Nintendo products and Nintendo games. I don't know if it profits or not, but if they're monetizing ads or other revenue streams, it's still a commercial use and it's still OK. Like I said I don't know exactly how far this service's use goes but it should be within the realm of possibility to make a dating site for people who enjoy Smash Bros. that still uses a (limited amount) of the names, images, logos, etc.
Hm, I'd have to have more details, but this really seems likely to be fair use, both of copyright and/or trademark. As long as they're not trying to make it seem like it's being run by, sponsored by, or approved by Nintendo itself, you're allowed to talk about an IP, gather together fellow fans of the IP, etc.
Lol that's not how trademark works. You can't violate a trademark by talking about something, showing pictures of it, reporting on it, etc. You violate a trademark by trying to make your own version and passing it off as your own to sell it. It's closer to a trade secrets violation.
@cvrator I worked at an EB Games when PS2 came out (college job). We definitely sold people on "that's not much more than you'd pay for a standalone DVD player".
It's fine. There's so much demand for the product that they likely can find enough buyers willing to pay for a bundle. There's people willing to pay way over market price just to get the console itself (from resellers), so why should retailers be hamstrung? For that same price the reseller is charging, you can get the console plus games/accessories from the retailer.
Manufacturers force them to sell at a particular price (ahem, vertical antitrust problem, anyone?), selling a bundle is one way they can compete and actually make money (since the consoles sell for little, if any, markup).
No, but I noticed that you shut off comments on the article about how Trump's tariffs are negatively affecting something the vast majority of us readers are really interested in.
@Jayenkai Both of those are good comparisons. And one of my first thoughts was "What if you put the left joycon in your right hand and vice versa, could you hold it like an ergonomic mouse to access the buttons better?" Or you could flip it around maybe.
Seems like a less-than-ideal gimmick, just like the detachable joy cons in the first place. Those things are incredibly uncomfortable to play with for more than 5 minutes, and after the initial "oh neat, look kid, we can set the Switch propped up on a table and both play", I never used it that way again.
The pearl clutching and outrage just makes me laugh. Video games are a luxury, people. If you don't like the price, don't buy it, and move on. Stop pretending that it's some kind of personal offense that things are getting more expensive.
Wow, I hated this so much. Annoying characters, terrible writing, every cliche in the world packed into the first 5 minutes. The game HAS NO MENU. At least not early in the prologue, once you start the gameplay, you have no way to quit the game without doing so from Windows, there's no way to change settings, etc. Ridiculous. Dialogue can be skipped completely but it can't be sped up/advanced.
I intentionally picked the cliched "No, I don't want to save the world" option at the first opportunity to get the game over screen so I could quit. NOPE. Dropped me right back in to the same decision point, still with no menu.
It's just a fancy way of raising prices slightly. Just like when they were implemented, it was a fancy way of lowering prices slightly. Take a deep breath everybody, it will be OK.
Comments 1,099
Re: "Consumers Generally Do Not Care" About AI In Games, Says Former Square Enix Exec
On the one hand, one example is not data.
On the other hand, there's a lot of people commenting on this thread who think their social media bubble is representative of reality.
Re: Feature: How Mega Starmie Became The Internet's New Queer Icon
Removed
Re: Feature: How Mega Starmie Became The Internet's New Queer Icon
Removed
Re: Feature: How Mega Starmie Became The Internet's New Queer Icon
Removed
Re: Feature: How Mega Starmie Became The Internet's New Queer Icon
Removed
Re: EA Is Diving Headfirst Into Generative AI With New Partnership
@OpheliaDynamight This is how I feel about it, too. Yes, it hurts some people pretty hard in the short term, but in the long term it's just part of technological progress and overall will be a positive thing.
I don't care if something is made by AI or not just like I don't care if animation is hand-drawn or computer generated or not. I care if it's good.
Re: Poll: Box Art Brawl - Duel: Hey You, Pikachu!
Yeah both are weak. Japan's is boring, NA looks like a magazine advert instead of a game cover.
Re: Talking Point: How Do You Play NES Games These Days?
"Something else entirely" * emulation * cough * cough *
Oh, are you not allowed to use that word?
Re: Poll: Do You Think Nintendo's New Animated Short 'Close To You' Is Pikmin Related?
I mean of course it is, look at the picture at the top of the article, there's a pikmin right there
Re: "OpenAI Is Trying To Get Sued" - Nintendo IP Floods Sora 2 Video Generation App
#1 - Parody is the quintessential example of fair use
#2 - Human beings also learn to create art by studying vast quantities of other copyrighted art
#3 - Might as well sue the pen manufacturer somebody used to draw Pikachu on their notebook.
Re: Genre-Bending 'Baroque YA' Collection Headed To Switch In Japan
@Debo626 I had the same question. Young Adult? "Yeah"? YAbba-dabba-do?
Re: Puzzle Quest: Immortal Edition Brings Match-3 RPG Fun To Switch This Month
I played the crap out of this on 3DS. Might be interested, but would really rather see a new game.
Re: "I Can't Afford To Give It Away For Free" - Silksong's Low Price Is Causing Devs To Re-Evaluate Their Own Games
<company whines that competitor delivers better goods at lower prices>
Boo hoo?
Re: Review: Dark Deity (Switch) - A Shameless But Satisfying Fire Emblem 'Homage'
Just found this from the other article about DD2. The comment above about FE games becoming bloated is dead on point. I've really disliked the latest entries. Might look into this one and its sequel.
Re: Round Up: Pour One Out For These 6 Brave Games Launching On 'Silksong Day'
Over at CTRL-ALT-DEL comics, they whined and moaned about how unfair the Silksong publishers were being by giving so little warning, which "made" other games change their release dates. Good grief. One business has no obligation to make things easier for their competitors.
Still, thanks for taking a minute to highlight these! I'll be looking into Dark Deity 2 (maybe there's Japanese VAs? The English ones are pretty corny. They Japanese ones might be too, but I couldn't tell). Also Fling to the Finish! Been looking for something light to play with my daughter.
Re: Word Game Showcased In Japan's 'Indie World' Is Coming To The West
@JohnnyMind I was wondering about parallels to Baba Is You. Thanks for confirmation!
Re: Bubsy's Physical Switch Collection Pre-Orders Open Later This Week
But these games were soooo bad haha.
Re: Under Night In-Birth II Sys:Celes Adds A New DLC Fighter Later This Month
And people were complaining about that Elliott game's title from the Direct?
Re: Reaction: Switch 2 Needed A Partner Showcase With Pep; This Wasn't It
Elliot = Secret of Mana, anybody else? Pacing feels similar, coop play
Also: "How can we make this game stand out?" "I know, let's come up with YET ANOTHER WAY to spell... let's make it "Faie" this time!"
Re: Reaction: Switch 2 Needed A Partner Showcase With Pep; This Wasn't It
Hela good!
(Stupid comment length requirements)
Re: Poll: Box Art Brawl - Duel: Weaponlord (SNES)
NA isn't anything special but wow is that Europe cover trash.
Re: "It Will Have A Chilling Effect On Game Design" - EU Group Responds To 'Stop Killing Games'
The best solution is not to demand features you haven't paid for, but to not buy games that don't guarantee you an offline experience - if that's what you care about. You spent your money on a game that didn't have a feature you want, don't go crying to the government demanding you get something you didn't pay for.
Re: Metal Gear Solid Fans Should Keep One Eye On The Retro-Flavoured 'Spy Drops'
Pixel art retro is one thing, but I have zero desire to relive the early 3D days of PS1 and N64.
Re: Poll: Box Art Brawl: Duel - Star Wars: Rogue Squadron
I'm way in the minority here, but to my eye the NA version is way too busy & chaotic and makes less sense the more I look at it. Japan is cleaner and I really like the wire frames. I'll admit the sharp cutoff between the scene and the diagrams is too severe though.
Re: Video: Digital Foundry Tests Out Switch 2's Free Switch Game Upgrades
Even with a graph showing me exactly when it's happening, I still can't tell the difference between 30 fps and 60 fps
Re: Mailbox: Switch 2 Innovations, Localisation Dreams, "That Big Playtest Thing" - Nintendo Life Letters
I love to play games with a mouse! I don't like to play games with something 1/4 the size of a normal mouse, not shaped like a mouse, with buttons not placed like a mouse. Just I like I don't playing with a controller... that's 1/8 the size of a normal controller, not shaped like a controller, with buttons not placed like a controller.
So, can I just connect a normal mouse to the Switch 2?
Re: Random: Unofficial Smash Bros. Dating App 'SmashTogether' Shut Down By Nintendo
@Polvasti Reporting is only one example of fair use. There are many others, including some commercial uses.
Re: Random: Unofficial Smash Bros. Dating App 'SmashTogether' Shut Down By Nintendo
@Polvasti Commercial use is relevant, but not determinative, of the question of fair use. Many fair uses can be monetized. This site uses images of Nintendo products and Nintendo games. I don't know if it profits or not, but if they're monetizing ads or other revenue streams, it's still a commercial use and it's still OK. Like I said I don't know exactly how far this service's use goes but it should be within the realm of possibility to make a dating site for people who enjoy Smash Bros. that still uses a (limited amount) of the names, images, logos, etc.
Re: Random: Unofficial Smash Bros. Dating App 'SmashTogether' Shut Down By Nintendo
@FantasiaWHT To use an obvious example, this site survives by almost exclusively talking about and promoting itself to fans of Nintendo.
Re: Random: Unofficial Smash Bros. Dating App 'SmashTogether' Shut Down By Nintendo
Hm, I'd have to have more details, but this really seems likely to be fair use, both of copyright and/or trademark. As long as they're not trying to make it seem like it's being run by, sponsored by, or approved by Nintendo itself, you're allowed to talk about an IP, gather together fellow fans of the IP, etc.
Re: Square Enix Details Plan To 'Reboot And Awaken' Its Business
"The biggest takeaway" is that they're good at jargon that doesn't actually mean anything.
Re: The Company That "Leaked" Switch 2 Is Being Sued By Nintendo
Lol that's not how trademark works. You can't violate a trademark by talking about something, showing pictures of it, reporting on it, etc. You violate a trademark by trying to make your own version and passing it off as your own to sell it. It's closer to a trade secrets violation.
Re: GameStop Apparently Investigating New York Store Over Sus Switch 2 Bundle Sales
@StewdaMegaManNerd It might, yeah. It's always a balancing act - will this alienate too many people such that the increased sales aren't worth it.
Re: GameStop Apparently Investigating New York Store Over Sus Switch 2 Bundle Sales
@cvrator I worked at an EB Games when PS2 came out (college job). We definitely sold people on "that's not much more than you'd pay for a standalone DVD player".
Re: GameStop Apparently Investigating New York Store Over Sus Switch 2 Bundle Sales
It's fine. There's so much demand for the product that they likely can find enough buyers willing to pay for a bundle. There's people willing to pay way over market price just to get the console itself (from resellers), so why should retailers be hamstrung? For that same price the reseller is charging, you can get the console plus games/accessories from the retailer.
Manufacturers force them to sell at a particular price (ahem, vertical antitrust problem, anyone?), selling a bundle is one way they can compete and actually make money (since the consoles sell for little, if any, markup).
Re: Poll: After One Month, How Often Are You Actually Using 'Nintendo Today'?
Where's the option for "What's Nintendo Today?" Never heard of it.
Re: Review: Lunar Remastered Collection (Switch) - Two Of The Most Charming RPGs Ever Get A Fair, If Flawed, Port
" By and large, the scripts are the same, with those less-timely jokes removed,"
Ok, more honest people, just how hard did the PC crowd hit this one? Is Kyle still permitted to be a misogynist or is he watered down?
Re: Sony Vet Shuhei Yoshida Says Nintendo Is "Losing Their Identity" With Switch 2
Agreed, this is Switch 1.5. It's not inherently bad, but it's very unlike Nintendo to do something this derivative rather than innovative.
Re: Every Nintendo Switch Online Sega Genesis / Mega Drive Game Ranked
every time this article pops up
Ooh Imma play Shining Force I & II again.
Re: Random: Did You Notice This Snazzy Switch 2 Reference In The Devs' Direct Outfits?
No, but I noticed that you shut off comments on the article about how Trump's tariffs are negatively affecting something the vast majority of us readers are really interested in.
Re: Random: Did You Notice This Snazzy Switch 2 Reference In The Devs' Direct Outfits?
NL shut off comments on the Trump tariff article. What are we coming to?
Re: Opinion: Oh No, I'm Not A Fan Of Switch 2's Mouse Mode At All
@Jayenkai Both of those are good comparisons. And one of my first thoughts was "What if you put the left joycon in your right hand and vice versa, could you hold it like an ergonomic mouse to access the buttons better?" Or you could flip it around maybe.
Re: Opinion: Oh No, I'm Not A Fan Of Switch 2's Mouse Mode At All
Seems like a less-than-ideal gimmick, just like the detachable joy cons in the first place. Those things are incredibly uncomfortable to play with for more than 5 minutes, and after the initial "oh neat, look kid, we can set the Switch propped up on a table and both play", I never used it that way again.
Re: "Don't Let Nintendo Ruin The Entire Industry" - Is $80 For Mario Kart World A Bridge Too Far?
The pearl clutching and outrage just makes me laugh. Video games are a luxury, people. If you don't like the price, don't buy it, and move on. Stop pretending that it's some kind of personal offense that things are getting more expensive.
Re: Nintendo Expands Switch Online's SNES Library With Four More Titles
New Horizons is so good! Such a fun open world pirate game. Played a ton of it, but never got around to doing much in the story, hah.
Re: Nintendo Highlights Four Brand New Games "Coming Soon" To Switch
@Tyranexx Yeah I watched a few episodes, it was pretty bad.
Re: "They Stole The Whole Game" - Horror Indie Dev Fights The eShop Scam Blatantly Ripping Their Work
"this is not the first time we've heard about Nintendo's slow reaction times to complaints like these."
Um, you are presenting zero information about how long this process is taking. Did the dev make this complaint a day ago? A week ago? A month ago?
Re: New Tactical RPG From Danganronpa & Zero Escape Creators Scores A Demo
Wow, I hated this so much. Annoying characters, terrible writing, every cliche in the world packed into the first 5 minutes. The game HAS NO MENU. At least not early in the prologue, once you start the gameplay, you have no way to quit the game without doing so from Windows, there's no way to change settings, etc. Ridiculous. Dialogue can be skipped completely but it can't be sped up/advanced.
I intentionally picked the cliched "No, I don't want to save the world" option at the first opportunity to get the game over screen so I could quit. NOPE. Dropped me right back in to the same decision point, still with no menu.
No thanks.
Re: Opinion: Scrapping Gold Points Makes Sense For Nintendo, But It's A Bitter Pill For Loyal Fans
It's just a fancy way of raising prices slightly. Just like when they were implemented, it was a fancy way of lowering prices slightly. Take a deep breath everybody, it will be OK.
Re: We're Getting Some Strong 'Inside' Vibes From Konami's Upcoming Octopus Platformer
@Coolmusic I was trying to remember the name of Little Nightmares, because it reminded me of that game too