Comments 1,099

Re: Lemmings-Like Space Adventure 'Moons of Darsalon' Leaps Onto Switch February 2025

FantasiaWHT

I don't agree that AI use is "theft" at all. The learning models do the exact same thing that humans have done forever, just at a much more efficient rate - which is what all technological progress has been, from calculators to steam engines. They read or look at other forms of art and then use that - not copy it - to develop their own creations. You and I do the same thing.

Re: Talking Point: Is It Time For HD-2D To Take A Break?

FantasiaWHT

It's not unique or new anymore, but so what? Why I would I want them to stop? It's usually better looking than straight 2D. Devs have to be careful to make sure the 2D and 3D styles actually mesh - I have seen some games where the characters feel too disconnected from the rest of the world.

Also I could do without the lens flares.

Re: Zelda's Voice Actor Would Love To See The Princess In "More" Playable Roles

FantasiaWHT

Echoes was pretty good, not great. Very easy - a good entry point for younger players. Definitely engaging at first, and when you found a new echo that did something significantly different than what you had previously it was fun to find new uses for it. But it didn't need nearly as many echoes as it gave you, which gummed up your list of echoes and made parts of the game a chore.

Re: New Switch Emulator Devs Are Jumping Through Hoops To Avoid A Nintendo Takedown

FantasiaWHT

@LuXifer "Emulators are in practise legal, both to make and distribute. But the moment Nintendo can prove that the distributor makes even a single cent of what they perceive as their property, either directly or indirectly, they're out of luck."

Not quite. They are in practice absolutely legal, regardless of whether you make money on them or not. The only thing whether you make money or not changes is how willing Nintendo is to go out and bully you into stopping with hollow threats.

It does not violate copyright to create a machine or other technology that is CAPABLE of violating a copyright (among other, legal, uses). Xerox isn't liable each time somebody illegally uses their machine to copy an entire book or magazine.

Re: New Switch Emulator Devs Are Jumping Through Hoops To Avoid A Nintendo Takedown

FantasiaWHT

Ugh, this is so frustrating. I know the legal battles are expensive, but there's no way Nintendo wins a copyright infringement lawsuit in America against an emulator. It's the exact same issue as the video recording machine fight in the 1980's. Yes, the technology CAN be used to do illegal things, but that doesn't make the creator liable for those illegal things, especially when there are perfectly legal things you can do with the same technology.

I wish Elon Musk or somebody would stand up and fund this sort of fight back.

Re: Palworld Developer Responds To Nintendo Lawsuit

FantasiaWHT

Very curious to see the grounds for alleged patent infringement rather than copyright. Did a few searches and couldn't find anything easily.

You can't patent game rules/mechanics. Hence the million Scrabble clones (though you can't use that name, which is copyrighted and trademarked).

Re: Bayonetta Star Jennifer Hale On The SAG-AFTRA Strikes: "AI Is Coming For Us All"

FantasiaWHT

@RupeeClock Why on earth is that alarming? It's fantastic. It allows all of us to be far more creative. It gives people tools to do more than they ever could do previously. These are great things for progress.

The whole furor is the same thing that happens with any new technology. Woe unto the buggy whip manufacturers when the auto-mobile becomes common.

On the voice issue specifically, people have been hiring sound-alikes FOREVER. It's not illegal to do an impression (it would be illegal to explicitly state that the voice is somebody it's not). Doing an impression is a talent - if you tell people they can't do that, it's harming them. Developing and using an AI to do an impression is also a talent - if you tell people they can't do that, it's harming THEM.

It's ok. Progress happens, new technologies replace old ones. New skills replace old ones. Take a deep breath and tone down the histrionics.