Comments 1,099

Re: Unavailability Of Classic Titles Is "Holding Game Culture Back", Says Platinum's Hideki Kamiya

FantasiaWHT

"And the responsibility for keeping those games available" Come on, that's silly. Nobody has a "responsibility" to keep games available. Nobody has some ephemeral duty to spend their own money bringing these games on to modern platforms or in remakes or on new hardware that plays classic games.

There is money out there to be made for old games.... IF there is the demand for them. Not every game has enough demand to justify the expense of doing so. The vast majority of them don't. Nobody should be expected to lose money just to bring these games up for the few people who are interested.

And just because a game has a high resale price on the second-hand market doesn't NECESSARILY mean there would be the demand to actually buy it to PLAY. Much of the price is for pure speculation, and the person who would pay $300 for Game X because they suspect it'll be worth $400 in a year is not likely to pay $50 for Game X Remastered.

Re: Best GameCube Games

FantasiaWHT

Great list. Glad to see Sunshine is very low on it (although it shouldn't on the list at all) - that game was awful. Never build an entire game around a gimmick like that. It's as if Nintendo had built a sequel to Mario 3 where you wear the kuribo shoe (a fun diversion) the entire game.

There are many things I think should have been higher when I first look at them, but then I realize that the top list of games is so jam-packed with incredible quality that it doesn't really make much difference.

Re: Take-Two Files Lawsuit Against Creators Of The GTA Reverse Engineering Project

FantasiaWHT

This may not even be a fair use question, this may not violate copyright at all. What are they ACTUALLY doing? Nothing is clear about this. If they are writing code or creating a device that allows a legally-purchased copy to be played on something else, that's not a copyright violation. It MIGHT (and I say might because it's not clear these licensing provisions are even enforceable) violate the game's license if somebody uses the re3 project to play GTA 3 on Switch, but that's on the user, not on re3.

Re: Hand-Drawn Game Guide Kickstarter Taken Down Following "Legal Trouble"

FantasiaWHT

Yeah, this doesn't look like a good argument for fair use

#1 - Commercial use instead of reporting, educational, or parody. Very different than fan guides on gamefaqs
#2 - The character designs are Nintendo's IP. Looking at the covers they're extremely close. Also different than fan guides on gamefaqs (text only).
#3 - I don't know this, but if they're using in game-art, including maps, that's protected IP too. Again, you don't see that on fan guides.

Re: EB Games Canada To Rebrand To GameStop By The End Of This Year

FantasiaWHT

When I was a kid (in the US) I remember traveling to the "Big city" (Green Bay) mall and being so excited to shop in Electronics Boutique. Computer games! When I was in college, I worked at an "EB Games". After college, I spent a year as store manager of an EB Games right when Gamestop bought the company.

We were all really unhappy with that. I know we were biased, but we all thought EB was the better store - better prices on used games, especially. I left before the stores started changing names, that was a slow process.

Re: Collection Of Mint Condition NES Games Fetches $30,000 For Goodwill

FantasiaWHT

Wow, how dare people earn a living while running charities! It's not like running a business takes skill, experience or knowledge... oh wait. It's not like a charity wants to attract talent... oh wait.

On the paying people less than minimum wage question... have you even considered that some people are completely unemployable because they don't have the skills to create enough value for an employer to even make them worth that much? This law doesn't PREVENT any employee from making more money - if these disabled workers could find better-paying work, they would. This law helps them find work at all where otherwise they couldn't earn anything.

Re: Neo: The World Ends With You Could Take 100+ Hours To Beat Depending On Your Playstyle

FantasiaWHT

I can see that. TWEWY is my favorite game of all time, I've beaten it a few times and tried to 100% it twice but both times when I got into the 99%+ range I didn't quite make it (the second time my son unintentionally deleted my game...) I had a blast playing the demo this weekend. Seems to translate well so far, although my old brain is slowing down I can't process everything that's happening in fights.