Comments 418

Re: Talking Point: Is It Time For HD-2D To Take A Break?

RenanLK

Well, let me put it this way, Triangle Strategy is a brilliant game that I loved to play multiple times, BUT the art style was a really bad choice for a such a story-driven game. HD-2D simply couldn’t translate what was going on with the depth needed plus it got really boring to watch the long cutscenes after a while.

In other words, HD-2D is beautiful yet it IS NOT a silver bullet for old-style games, the same way the hyper-realism should not be the default for AAA games. Studios should try different art styles to figure out what works best for each game.

Re: UK Charts: Mario & Luigi: Brothership Drops Anchor Outside The Top Ten

RenanLK

It’s really impressive how Nintendo manages to create so many successful games that sell throughout the entire gen without the “live service games or nothing” mindset that every major publisher seems to be into these days.

I wish Sony attempted to mimic Nintendo on this. So annoying that the follow-up to the amazing PS4 gen has been this race for the next Fortnite.

Re: Random: Nintendo's Museum Might Be Emulating SNES Games On Windows PC

RenanLK

Well, they have to test their games on computers first, right? Very unlikely that each build is actually run in the consoles to validate changes. So it could be an open-source emulator, could be a proprietary emulator and it could be the same software they use to test builds without publishing to a console.

Whatever the case may be, it’s their product, so as others said Nintendo can do what it wants to do.

Re: Catch-Up Crew: Donkey Kong Country - "I Liked His Big Red, Er, Ribbit-Bag?"

RenanLK

My first videogame was an SNES. I remember my father showing up at lunch time in 1999 with the SNES box and 3 games - Mario World, DKC3 and Kirby Superstar. Amazing games and such a good memory. I played DKC2 next (which is still my favorite) and only got DKC later. Honestly, DKC is a little rough, beautiful and amazing for its time yes, but Rare nailed it on DKC2.

Re: Mailbox: eShop Closures, Comedy, The Physical Future - Nintendo Life Letters

RenanLK

Hey, my letter has been answered! Thanks for that! =)

Adding a bit of context, as a fan I do own all the KH games on PS5, but ever since I had my son, PS5 is collecting dust. Switch's portability makes it easier to fit in my week (mostly in bed, to be honest) and Nintendo games are more diverse and interesting to me, so if I could also play my favorite 3rd party games on Switch 2 that would be amazing.

About digital stores, we really should stop talking about shutting down the servers. It's not like each system's games are kept exclusively in dedicated servers like a physical store that is eventually closed. The infraatructure cost lies in running the store apps and the storage required for the games.

What all gaming companies could do is delete data from old games that people are no longer interested in from their store databases to save money (which makes sense from business perspective) and continuosly upgrade the same store applications for each console with a unified account system. Not saying it's super easy to do, just pointing out that it's perfectly feasible from both technical and business perspectives.

Re: Soapbox: Has Nintendo Set A Precedent That 'Switch 2' Can't Hope To Match?

RenanLK

It will be successful, no doubt there. Surpassing Switch might be difficult. It won't be a new idea, it won't have the pandemic effect (hopefully!) and lots of people love the Switch, so convincing them to migrate to Switch 2 will be another challenge.

But there is still hope. It all comes to games, if Nintendo manages to have popular hits and appropriate marketing there is a chance. It also wouldn't hurt if native versions of new 3rd party releases were released alongside the competitors (although this alone doesn't define anything).

Edit: Just thought that if they created a proper multi-device account system for Switch 2 they could definitely beat Switch sales. I only have 1 Switch because digital games are not shareable across a family account. If they were, I would definitely buy multiple consoles and I imagine other parents would do the same.

Re: Random: Welp, Now Nintendo's Going After Sheet Music

RenanLK

If someone other than Nintendo learned their music and wrote a music sheet for other fans, it should never be subject to DMCA. If it were Nintendo's music sheet that was stolen, fine, but it doesn't seem to be the case.

I'm no legal expert, they might be on their right to DMCA these sheets, but really, it's so lame to do so. What exactly are they protecting themselves against?

Re: 2004 Satoru Iwata Interview Has Been Remastered And Presented In Full

RenanLK

Interesting how current his comments are. Nintendo itself took a hit with Wii U precisely due to what he mentioned.

As others have mentioned, it remains to be seen how a Switch 2 with the same design but enhanced hardware will perform in the long term. Personally I think there's still enough interest in Switch's core ideas to expand on it and maintain a huge audience (see PS Portal's surprisingly high adoption rate).

Re: Soapbox: Square Enix's "Extraordinary Losses" And This Whole Xbox Mess Have Me Scared For The Future

RenanLK

All of us know that building games today, especially AAA games, cost a lot of money. The hard part to manage as a game publisher is that gaming for customers is a non-essential entertainment, sort of a toy for teens and adults. They can't raise the price without losing customers, but the cost is raising.

It's about time the industry goes back to its roots, understanding that games can be fun and enjoyable without all the high-cost elements of AAAs, such as hollywood-level storytelling with artists recording everything, ultrarealistic graphics and orchestra soundtrack. Btw, indies, the alternative IS NOT pixelated games with SNES look and feel. There is a whole array of possibilities between these two extremes that I hope Square Enix and other publishers explore in the future.

Re: Embracer Group To Split Into Three Separate Companies

RenanLK

Well, I think the "& Friends" is far worse than Middle-Earth Enterprises.

Smart of them to have a line of business focused on smaller games. They cost less and if done right can bring in a good amount of profit - the industry should give it a try. But let's be honest, Embracer did this to make it easier to sell parts of their business.

Re: Poll: Do You Want To See 'Super Mario Bros. Wonder 2'?

RenanLK

I'd like something new after Wonder.

Wonder looked great, but its level designs were not even near Super Mario World. Just try to play a level without touching the wonder flower, they feel less fun/creative than the New series. Wonder flowers should be the entire levels, IMO. Plus, Nintendo already makes Kirby games to target children that are starting to play games, there is no need to make 2D Mario games super easy! Please give us a challenge, Nintendo.

Re: Random: New Pokémon Ad Positions 3DS As 'Retro', And The Internet Disagrees

RenanLK

For me personally retro is not about how old the console is, but how long has it been "dead" (which effectively makes memories of games go into mostalgia territory). Sure, 3DS is old, but it had Nintendo 1st party games released as late as 2019. Not sure about you, but 2019 memories aren't far enough to reach nostalgic feelings for me (it doesn't help that pandemic hit right after that, but that's not the point). I would put DS in retro category, but not 3DS yet.

Re: Poll: So, Have You Finished Pokémon Legends: Arceus Yet?

RenanLK

I enjoyed it a lot, but for some reason I stopped playing halfway through. Will definitely play it this year, it is the most exciting Pokémon game on Switch (better than Violet/Scarlet IMO). If they added more competition to it (gyms, Elite 4, stuff like that) it would be THE Pokémon game to play.

By the way, is anyone discussing the awful Z-A name?

Re: Poll: What Do You Think Of The Prince Of Persia: The Lost Crown Demo?

RenanLK

Gameplay is a lot of fun, controls are fluid and it seems to be a rich world to explore.

Only not sold on the graphics so far. I know they went for a cartoonish look, but character designs in particular still look odd, they wouldn't be out of place in the memories I have of PS2. I played the demo on PS5, though, no ideia if the visuals are more consistently good on Switch.

Re: GTA 6 On 'Switch 2' Would Be "Very Tricky To Pull Off", Says Digital Foundry

RenanLK

To be honest, GTA only resonates with Nintendo gamers if said gamers enjoy realistic shooters. More often than not, this is the public that owns more than one console (or a gaming PC), so it's no big deal.

I love my Switch, but I only buy 3rd party games that have a Nintendo feeling to them. There's no point in getting downgraded ports of games that play better elsewhere.

Re: Soapbox: This Year, The Game Awards Failed The Industry

RenanLK

Can they fix it, though? How many people actually watch The Game Awards for the awards, like the Oscars vs how many people watch just for reveals? Is there enough $$$ to keep The Game Awards for the awards?
I honestly believe that there is only so much you can do with the money and interests of investors...

Re: Best Nintendo Switch Metroidvania Games

RenanLK

I love this list. I would easily buy most of these games if I had the time to play them.

I don't like blurred SNES-like graphics, but I really enjoy when they modernize it or try new art directions (such as Hollow Knight hand-drawn art). Such a fun subgenre to play!

Re: Reaction: What's Your Gut Feeling On The Zelda Movie News?

RenanLK

Live action is an odd choice, but it could work if done right. I'm not very fond of the idea, though.

I'm mostly concerned about the fact that most Zelda games tell a similar story with the same protagonists and antagonist. There's no single "right" story, but they're all legends around the same characters. As a side-effect, many people (particularly children) will expect the movie to tell the "real" story and then be frustrated with the games.

On the plus side, Mario movie made Nintendo translate Wonder to many languages they didn't usually translate to. Hopefully the same happens to Zelda.

Edit: Link will need to have a voice, which is also gonna be odd.

Re: Tears Of The Kingdom Continues To Prove That 'Open World Zelda' Is A Best-Selling Formula

RenanLK

Zelda just consolidated itself as the most important IP after Mario to Nintendo this gen.

Nintendo really deserves the praise when you stop to think about how long these IPs exist and we're still enjoying each and every new game.

TOTK is a great game, but I still believe BOTW is better. BOTW is more balanced, I'm playing it for the 2nd time and now that I'm no longer expecting it to play like a linear Zelda anymore it's just brilliant at every turn. TOTK is like a restaurant that costs a lot because it serves everything, but you can only eat so much before you feel like enough - I had to step down a bit due to fatigue.

I'm curious to see how Nintendo is going to handle Zelda going forward. Clearly there is demand for both styles of Zelda.

Re: Soapbox: No, Mario Wonder's Most-Annoying Character Isn't The Talking Flower

RenanLK

Since we're in minor complaints mood:
Dialogues in 2D Mario should be banned, honestly, apart from key events where comedy twists are fun (think Super Mario World after beating castles). Also I don't see the point in walking around to find the next level, what was wrong with the fixed paths in World and Bros 3? If it isn't broken, don't fix it. =)