Comments 308

Re: Switch Stock Shortages Cost Nintendo First Place In May's NPD Hardware Charts

Phin68

@JunkRabbit It is definitely true you can observe the intentions of a film production by judging its qualities, but I'm saying the same could be done with anything in regards to criticism. Observing Nintendo's history of low asset production at launch leads me to believe a similar or identical situation is happening with the Switch. As with a movie too, you'll never be able to completely rationalize for why something is the way it is. They're all just educated guesses.

Re: Switch Stock Shortages Cost Nintendo First Place In May's NPD Hardware Charts

Phin68

@JunkRabbit The "you couldn't have done better" argument is a cop out. That's like saying a critic can't critique a movie because they never made a movie. You can criticize something without having knowledge of the field.

But back to the topic. When I say that Nintendo is falsifying demand, I'm not making a baseless accusation. I can look at companies like Microsoft and Sony and see they don't encounter the same stocking problems Nintendo goes through. Is that because they're less successful than Nintendo? Not necessarily. Compare the launches of the PS4 to the Wii U, and see which system had the early shortages (it was the Wii U). Thus, I can assume that the way these companies approach these products must be different.

I'm not saying that Nintendo's in the wrong for approaching this strategy though. It just seems like a foolish action for Switch's long term success.

Re: Switch Stock Shortages Cost Nintendo First Place In May's NPD Hardware Charts

Phin68

@JunkRabbit Nintendo aren't unfamiliar with product shortages. They've done it with amiibo, the NES Classic, etc. Heck, even the Wii U had product shortages for a time. And we know that wasn't a result of popularity.

Nintendo has done this stocking strategy for years now, so I can't help but assume that the same thing's happening with the Switch. I agree that it's a clever tactic to make consumers want something they can't have, but that strategy can only hold itself for so long.

Re: Round Up: Yooka-Laylee's Scores Are In, And Critics Appear Divided

Phin68

@SleeplessKnight As a spiritual successor, it's perfectly fine for Yooka Laylee to invoke nostalgia of Banjo Kazooie. But nostagia shouldn't excuse Playtonic from ignoring the basic technical problems of modern gaming. Wonky camera and constant frame rate drops were not fun in the N64 age, and they aren't fun now.

@MarioPhD Much of Mighty No 9's hate stemmed from broken promises and overconfidence on the part of the developers. Delays only added to their disdain. Thankfully, Yooka-Laylee has managed to avoid significant controversy (save for the JonTron incident).