"Persona without the heart" is reductive. SMT is about the gameplay, environmental storytelling, and broader worldviews. It's different from but not less than Persona.
@Bolt_Strike if the rest of the market is making luxury purchases without looking into it, clearly the money isn't a big deal for them. If the money is a big deal, they are likely to seek more information.
This is the best practice for a market. Set a price, give people information on the product, and let them decide. Nobody is being misled.
If you want to complain about monetization, there are plenty of games full of ads and loops meant to be addictive and predatory. This isn't such a case.
Selling someone else's IP without a license generally not a good thing. Probably doesn't deserve jail time, but a mild case being allowed opens the door for more severe ones. Best nip it in the bud.
The Pokemon Company will be fine, and I do suspect Pocket Pair will owe them some money and require some changes to similar monsters.
The issue is that this is a recurring thing for them. They've been more than just "inspired" by a couple other franchises for their games, and their next release copies from an indie dev, Team Cherry, who doesn't have the financial might of the Pokemon Company.
It is in the best interests of creators everywhere for Pocket Pair to be hammered hard for this.
@SpaceboyScreams it sounds an awful lot like you have exactly zero technical programming knowledge or any understanding of the use of assets and resources.
Breath/Tears have a tiny fraction of the high fidelity character models that Pokemon has. Pokemon devs may have made a mistake on prioritizing the mons themselves over the environment and frame rate, but if you want to have a pokemon game look like Breath of the wild, the number and quality of pokemon models is going to go down. Way down.
I doubt there's any real legal ground for the Pokemon Company to sue or anything, but it is a blatant rip-off and the artists should be embarrassed to have had anything to do with it. It's certainly not work to be proud of.
I empathize and wish Nintendo would do better. But it's definitely not simple, even if it seems many game developers are doing better.
1. It's expensive. It's a business. I'm doubtful most of these companies actually make money creating these features. (good on them for doing it anyway).
2. They add a lot to settings menus. This might not seem like a big deal, but for every setting is both a line of reading and a choice a player needs to make, giving them the opportunity to make the wrong choice or to miss something that is important to them. Diablo 4, lauded for its accessibility, is also a disaster in its settings with numerous things located in several areas and it can be difficult to find what you're looking for.
@DonkeyBrainKing anyone who ever says "most people" agree with X thing tend to be full of it. But I am willing to bet the creators of most fiction and art in general would prefer their creations aren't outright copied by others.
If you want to keep the event from running too long, maybe you can get rid of the absurd "best e-sports team" and "most anticipated game" awards. Absolute nonsense.
Comments 479
Re: The Results Of Our 2024 Switch Summer Survey Are In
I periodically lick switch cartridges when I start to doubt my memory of their insanely bad taste.
Re: Prince Of Persia: The Lost Crown Dev Team Reportedly Disbanded By Ubisoft
The team responsible for making the game isn't the issue here, Ubisoft.
Re: Poll: Are You Bothered By The Frame Rate In Zelda: Echoes Of Wisdom?
Noticed yes, bothered no
Re: Palworld Developer Responds To Nintendo Lawsuit
It's easy to hate on Nintendo or TPC for this, but Palworld's developers have made a habit of copying other works a little too closely.
Maybe you dislike TPC... but what if their next game rips off Team Cherry, an ACTUAL small indie dev team? Oh, right, they are doing EXACTLY that.
IP protection needs to be strong in the creative space.
Re: Poll: What Is Your Favourite Game In The Marvel vs. Capcom Fighting Collection?
I wanna take you for a riiide.
Re: Review: Shogun Showdown (Switch) - A Turn-Based Roguelike Masterclass
This game is exceptional. Controls are snappy and logical. Simple, yet deep. Stylish.
Re: Soapbox: The Next Pokémon Game Should Rework Old Critters, Not Just Add Dozens More
The best game since the originals was Black and White which only had new pokemon until the post-game.
That said, there are a lot of weak pokemon that could use buffs, strong moves or evolutions.
Re: Stardew Valley Creator Pledges To Never Charge Money For DLC Or Updates
If someone has earned the right to charge for updates, it's probably ConcernedApe.
Re: Digital Foundry Hails Luigi's Mansion 3 As The Best-Looking Exclusive Switch Game
Astral Chain IMO
Re: Best Shin Megami Tensei Games On Switch And Nintendo Systems
"Persona without the heart" is reductive.
SMT is about the gameplay, environmental storytelling, and broader worldviews. It's different from but not less than Persona.
Re: Donkey Kong Country Returns HD Costs $60 On Switch
@Bolt_Strike if the rest of the market is making luxury purchases without looking into it, clearly the money isn't a big deal for them. If the money is a big deal, they are likely to seek more information.
This is the best practice for a market. Set a price, give people information on the product, and let them decide. Nobody is being misled.
If you want to complain about monetization, there are plenty of games full of ads and loops meant to be addictive and predatory. This isn't such a case.
Re: Donkey Kong Country Returns HD Costs $60 On Switch
Nobody is making you buy it.
You should be well informed on the item. Determining if it's worth the price for you should be simple.
Re: Talking Point: Is Summer Game Fest Really Missing Nintendo's Presence?
Nontendo 4DS
Re: Talking Point: Would You Want Quality And Performance Options For Nintendo's 'Switch 2' Games?
The only "quality" IS performance. The other one is a game developer's psychosis, believing some graphics things matter more than performance.
Re: Soapbox: Fire Emblem’s Future May Not Be In Turn-Based Combat
Nothing about sipping tea was fun. I find it unlikely this had anything to do with Three Houses popularity.
Re: Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door Codebase Apparently Contains References To 4K Output
Frame rate is the god-king of visuals as far as enjoyment goes. Most modern TVs upscale well enough, and handheld will never need more than 1080p.
Re: Nintendo Discontinuing 'X' Integration On Switch Next Month
The social media platform is still literally twitter.com
Re: Nintendo Apparently Wanted Samus Aran's Fortnite Skin To Be A Switch Exclusive
Protecting your valuable IP is smart.
Re: Japanese Man Arrested For Selling Hacked Scarlet And Violet Pokémon
Selling someone else's IP without a license generally not a good thing. Probably doesn't deserve jail time, but a mild case being allowed opens the door for more severe ones. Best nip it in the bud.
Re: Random: BAFTA's 'Iconic Game Characters' Poll Has Us Scratching Our Heads
The top 3 are Mario, Pikachu, Sonic. Choose whoever you want after that.
Re: New Unicorn Overlord Survey Gauges Interest In Sequel
Would buy. Amazing game. Need more politics in the story though!
Re: Japanese Charts: Unicorn Overlord Dominates In Its Debut Week
This game is really good.
Re: Best Monster Hunter Games, Ranked - Switch And Nintendo Systems
Flip Rise and GU IMO
Re: 50 Best Nintendo Switch Games To Play Right Now (2024)
Did I miss Astral Chain or is it not on there?
It's a top 5 Switch game. Not top 50, top 5.
Breath of the Wild
Tears of the Kingdom
Super Mario Odyssey
Hollow Knight
Astral Chain
If this isn't your top 5, you're wrongggg. Subjective? Don't care. Still wrong.
Re: The Pokémon Company Releases Official Statement About Palworld
The Pokemon Company will be fine, and I do suspect Pocket Pair will owe them some money and require some changes to similar monsters.
The issue is that this is a recurring thing for them. They've been more than just "inspired" by a couple other franchises for their games, and their next release copies from an indie dev, Team Cherry, who doesn't have the financial might of the Pokemon Company.
It is in the best interests of creators everywhere for Pocket Pair to be hammered hard for this.
Re: Round Table: Let's Talk About Palworld - Comparisons, Controversy, 'Copying'
@SpaceboyScreams it sounds an awful lot like you have exactly zero technical programming knowledge or any understanding of the use of assets and resources.
Breath/Tears have a tiny fraction of the high fidelity character models that Pokemon has. Pokemon devs may have made a mistake on prioritizing the mons themselves over the environment and frame rate, but if you want to have a pokemon game look like Breath of the wild, the number and quality of pokemon models is going to go down. Way down.
Re: Round Table: Let's Talk About Palworld - Comparisons, Controversy, 'Copying'
"if something like Palworld can release and run as well as it does, then there’s really no excuse anymore."
Palworld has 137 creatures.
Pokemon SV has 600 or more, and it's running on a toaster.
Are you SURE there is "no excuse"?
Come on, man, be honest.
The real questions might be how do the models compare and how many animations each one has, but at least act like you know something here.
Re: Peach's Voice Actor Confirms She Is Still The Princess In New Switch Game
"X" is still known as Twitter. Might as well call it Twitter.
Re: Soapbox: Game Freak Could Actually Learn A Thing Or Two From Palworld
I'd prefer to not have encumbrance rather than Machamp increase it.
Re: Pokémon Fans Set Their Sights On Palworld's Monster Designs
I doubt there's any real legal ground for the Pokemon Company to sue or anything, but it is a blatant rip-off and the artists should be embarrassed to have had anything to do with it. It's certainly not work to be proud of.
Re: Talking Point: What Will The 'Switch 2' Actually Be Called?
Nontendo 4DS
Re: 'Switch 2' Will Be An Iterative Evolution And Will Cost $400, Predicts Analyst
Are predictions from some random dude to be considered news from now on?
Re: Soapbox: How Zelda's Bad Economy Made Weapon Degradation Great Again
Weapon degradation makes you care about your stuff more.
Re: Soapbox: Zelda: Tears Of The Kingdom Straight Up Fails In Just One Respect: Accessibility
I empathize and wish Nintendo would do better. But it's definitely not simple, even if it seems many game developers are doing better.
1. It's expensive. It's a business. I'm doubtful most of these companies actually make money creating these features. (good on them for doing it anyway).
2. They add a lot to settings menus. This might not seem like a big deal, but for every setting is both a line of reading and a choice a player needs to make, giving them the opportunity to make the wrong choice or to miss something that is important to them. Diablo 4, lauded for its accessibility, is also a disaster in its settings with numerous things located in several areas and it can be difficult to find what you're looking for.
Re: Activision Blizzard's Bobby Kotick Will Step Down Later This Month
Kotick is a comically evil villain who's behind nearly every excessively capitalist monetization practice out there. Good riddance.
Re: Fan-Made 'Link's Awakening DX HD' Port Taken Down By Nintendo
@DonkeyBrainKing anyone who ever says "most people" agree with X thing tend to be full of it. But I am willing to bet the creators of most fiction and art in general would prefer their creations aren't outright copied by others.
Re: Fan-Made 'Link's Awakening DX HD' Port Taken Down By Nintendo
@ninfriendo_1973 NintendoLoaf, with writer Alina Hogues.
Re: Feature: Nintendo Switch Year In Review 2023 - Our Most Played Games
I put 340 hours into Fire Emblem Engage, clearing hard and then maddening difficulties.
Re: Review: Pokémon Scarlet & Violet - The Indigo Disk (Switch) - Enjoyable But Safe DLC Is Far From A Treasure
Again, repeatedly, there is no mention of whether you're playing online or not.
The game's performance (and that in Sword and Shield) were far better playing OFFLINE.
Did you review in offline or online?
Re: Soapbox: If You're Not Playing LEGO Fortnite, You're Missing One Of The Best Survival Games
I played it. Basically all other survival games are better.
Re: Fortnite's Dev Really Wants A Crossover With Nintendo But Hasn't Had Any Luck
Fortnite should consider at least one original idea at least once.
Re: Random: The Game Awards Urged Eiji Aonuma To 'Wrap Up' Zelda Acceptance Speech
If you want to keep the event from running too long, maybe you can get rid of the absurd "best e-sports team" and "most anticipated game" awards. Absolute nonsense.
Re: Poll: What Is Your Favourite Character Reveal Trailer For Super Smash Bros. Ultimate?
Inkling, Joker. Both were amazing in their own ways.
King K. Rool and Banjo were pretty good though.
Re: Talking Point: Would You Like To See More Streaming Media Apps On 'Switch 2'?
There really is no need.
Re: Video: Where Does Mario Kart Go From Here?
Mario Kart 8 Deluxe Deluxe.
My vote would be to keep building on MK8.
Re: Talking Point: Does Zelda: Ocarina Of Time Need A Full Remake?
There are two options for remaking a Zelda game:
Remake the 2D ones in the style of Link's Awakening HD
or
A full reimagining of the original.
Re: Talking Point: Which Zelda Game Should Be Adapted For The Movie?
ALTTP or OOT
I think you need something relatively gimmick free.
Re: Warner Bros. Says It's Focused On Transforming Its "Biggest Franchises" Into Live Services
Sounds awful. Good thing I don't care about them.
Re: Sega's Executive Director Wants Sonic Games And Movies To "Surpass Mario"
Keep releasing half-baked Sonic games and it will never happen.
Re: Unity's CEO And President Retires After Policy Debacle
Removed