the mod creator waikuteru has a patreon. I think that's why. Never charge for fan content.
It's within the copyright holders rights to accept or banish fan content. I've heard that it's literally law in japan that fan content has protections as long as the copyright holder turns a blind eye.
@HeadPirate The way you disrespect people isn't my vibe, I picked up very big "this man is gullible laugh" vibes from your last comment. I am not gullible, and you should put more care into respecting others, even if they disagree with you, but not letting them run your life.
@abdias Toby's parts of the soundtrack are good. The hill you are on isn't worth the suffering required to live on it. Though I will admit, he can't make this shine.
What happened was that there were abuse scandals and Nintendo hates mods because they interfere with the original creative vision (They don't hate fans lol).
You also said that Nintendo can't take down every tournament or copyright violation... but they can at least take down any that exist online, Music detection systems are very powerful, that's why they were able to put out these guidelines, they do turn a blind eye.
It's not a fantasy to fight for rights to use things we own, I do not live In LaLaland, If I was I would be suggesting that Nintendo allow piracy. I believe that copyright needs limits to how far it can control users. Things like taking videos and posting what they play, hosting events, even right to repair, which many companies use copyright and voiding warranties to fight. We do not enter contracts when we buy food, a wrench, or a puzzle (closest comparison to creative works I can think of). We can film these things, host events that involve them. I know that the public performance laws for copyright outright prohibit these things for games and other forms of media. Posting Elsa's Let it go should not happen, but having a video be taken down because it was playing in the background of something different, I could see fair use being extended. People even abuse copyright to cover up evidence of abuse (See Police using it prevent filming Brutality)
Many people claim fair use when backed into a corner with copyright, that's the only thing they do really.
I don't believe I have a strong enough arguement for modding. So I won't bother with that.
(replacing old message to add context to convo, otherwise I'm peacing out)@sanderev preventing piracy is protecting sales, controlling a tournament is not protecting sales at least for people who actually know a thing or two about how brands work, for people who can't tell their brands from their behinds, it is protecting sales.
My issue is that controlling how a user uses your expression is not a form of protection offered for most forms of expression (Look at people quoting eachother out of context on twitter, unregulated.). So that is a reason I disagree that games should have the same protection. that is a form of me disagreeing with it, I'm sure I can find others if I'm pressed.
@HeadPirate IP holders shouldn't have rights to control users. Only to protect sales. And this is control of how the game itself is used. If one doesn't follow guidelines, Nintendo enforces copyright instead of turning a blind eye. I don't think they should have rights to turn a blind eye sometimes, and enforce other times. It's too messy.
An aside regarding modification and fanwork, I only have beliefs here, that only modifications that replace existing works should be struck down. I do not think this part is strong enough to debate, as it is not wholly definitive. Please respond to the first part instead.
@Aeralto I knew there was a 32nd reason why daylight savings is bad 1. messes with your schedule 2. you need to recalibrate your clocks 3. you need to wake up earlier 4. alternatively you need to sleep later 5. daylight savings doesn't even sync with sunrise 6. daylight savings doesn't sync with sunset 7. farmers for which daylight savings is intended, work from can't see to can't see 8. It messes up your circadian rhythm a little bit 9. you have to go to work early or late 10. your coworkers get their schedules mixed up 11. it doesn't transfer from state to state properly 12. if you have a plane flight during daylight savings delays can feel worse or better 13. Daylight savings is useless when we have street lights and light bulbs 14. Most people stay up all night on their phones 15. You have to re-time all the clocks in the building of your office or home 16. Your pet tries to wake you up early or late because they can't read time 17. Stores change their schedules drastically 18. For religious people, their church hours get shifted. 19. your significant other's sleep schedule is also disrupted. 20. homeless people transcend time, so why should we need daylight savings. 21. If you were born on daylights savings changing, get prepared for a messed up birth certificate 22. The automatic air conditioner system goes out of alignment and you have to fix it 23. Your doctor's appointments become earlier or later, and you realize it ain't in your schedule anymore. 24. Your routine gets messed up so you end up using the bathroom at weirder and weirder times. 25. You look like an idiot when you misstate the time. 26. the clock on your nintendo switch becomes desynced from the clock on your oven. 27. the clock on your oven and microwave need to be recalibrated 28. birds transcend daylight savings. 29. You get confused by the time for a moment or two. 30. It messes up your surprise parties, when the tennant comes home early 31. you die of heart attacks more easily due to sleep disruption 32. you get obese due to sleep disruption
The world explainin why it's complaining at the rendevous deliciously positioned to empower, the esports scene at this dark hour.
This is meant to be read to section 3 of The World Revolving, the one with Gaster's Theme in it. The part where it goes in circles whimsically as the speed falls down a toilet and becomes a catch me if you can.
Woah Pigtails are a bold move for a protagonist. Can this Anime Girl live up to the great pigtailed anime girls? We've got Legendary characters such as Madoka Magica, and Nokia from Cybersleuth on our side.
man, baby, babyman, undo this curse wrought by the manbaby's hand!
Stir the prodigious and protest digital.
Sing supreme and wrest upon all physical the right to remain.
Comments 309
Re: Nintendo Issues Multiple DMCAs On The Modding Site 'GameBanana'
the mod creator waikuteru has a patreon. I think that's why. Never charge for fan content.
It's within the copyright holders rights to accept or banish fan content. I've heard that it's literally law in japan that fan content has protections as long as the copyright holder turns a blind eye.
Re: Switch Emulator Yuzu To Pay $2.4 Million To Nintendo & Cease Development
@HeadPirate The way you disrespect people isn't my vibe, I picked up very big "this man is gullible laugh" vibes from your last comment. I am not gullible, and you should put more care into respecting others, even if they disagree with you, but not letting them run your life.
Re: Switch Emulator Yuzu To Pay $2.4 Million To Nintendo & Cease Development
@HeadPirate I thought you sounded rational until that guy turned out to be a lawyer. so I'm just not reading your essays anymore.
Re: Round Up: The Previews Are In For Penny's Big Breakaway
@HotGoomba goombers have ears?
Re: Fan-Made 'Link's Awakening DX HD' Port Taken Down By Nintendo
Make actual fangames instead of remakes, Nintendo comes after Remakes harder.
Re: Undertale Creator Toby Fox Remixed Ed Sheeran's Pokémon Song In The New Scarlet & Violet DLC
@abdias Toby's parts of the soundtrack are good. The hill you are on isn't worth the suffering required to live on it. Though I will admit, he can't make this shine.
Re: Netflix's Pokémon Concierge Starts December 28, Here's The Official Trailer
@Kermit1 which frame?
Re: Nintendo Is Most-Nominated Publisher At The Game Awards 2023
15 noms? Om nom nom nom.
Re: Super Mario RPG Switch Leaked Online Ahead Of Next Week's Release
@Eel oh you tease!
Re: It Looks Like A Smash Bros. Ultimate Switch OLED Bundle Might Be Coming Soon
Joy-con themed Smash controllers
Re: Poll: WarioWare: Move It! Is Out Today, Will You Be Getting It?
I like to move it, move it
I like to move it, move it
I like to move it, move it
We like to move it!
I like to move it, move it
She like to move it, move it
We like to move it, move it
We like to move it!
Re: Hands On: Bluey: The Videogame, In Real Life
both of the comments above me, sheesh.
Re: Sonic's New 3D Action-Platformer Is Exclusive To Apple Arcade
I hope it has touch to walk controls instead of a bad joystick, and that homing attack targets can just be tapped on to go there.
Re: Toby Fox Shares Deltarune Development Update: "No More Waiting For Chapter 5"
I worry for Toby's mental health.
Re: Nintendo's Updated Guidelines For Tournaments & Content Creation Sparks Community Backlash
@chaser206 attack on character, dislike report, whatever this man.
Re: Nintendo's Updated Guidelines For Tournaments & Content Creation Sparks Community Backlash
@HeadPirate
What happened was that there were abuse scandals and Nintendo hates mods because they interfere with the original creative vision (They don't hate fans lol).
You also said that Nintendo can't take down every tournament or copyright violation... but they can at least take down any that exist online, Music detection systems are very powerful, that's why they were able to put out these guidelines, they do turn a blind eye.
It's not a fantasy to fight for rights to use things we own, I do not live In LaLaland, If I was I would be suggesting that Nintendo allow piracy. I believe that copyright needs limits to how far it can control users. Things like taking videos and posting what they play, hosting events, even right to repair, which many companies use copyright and voiding warranties to fight. We do not enter contracts when we buy food, a wrench, or a puzzle (closest comparison to creative works I can think of). We can film these things, host events that involve them. I know that the public performance laws for copyright outright prohibit these things for games and other forms of media. Posting Elsa's Let it go should not happen, but having a video be taken down because it was playing in the background of something different, I could see fair use being extended. People even abuse copyright to cover up evidence of abuse (See Police using it prevent filming Brutality)
Many people claim fair use when backed into a corner with copyright, that's the only thing they do really.
I don't believe I have a strong enough arguement for modding. So I won't bother with that.
Re: Nintendo's Updated Guidelines For Tournaments & Content Creation Sparks Community Backlash
(replacing old message to add context to convo, otherwise I'm peacing out)@sanderev preventing piracy is protecting sales, controlling a tournament is not protecting sales at least for people who actually know a thing or two about how brands work, for people who can't tell their brands from their behinds, it is protecting sales.
My issue is that controlling how a user uses your expression is not a form of protection offered for most forms of expression (Look at people quoting eachother out of context on twitter, unregulated.). So that is a reason I disagree that games should have the same protection. that is a form of me disagreeing with it, I'm sure I can find others if I'm pressed.
Re: Nintendo's Updated Guidelines For Tournaments & Content Creation Sparks Community Backlash
@dew12333 It's a frustration that the idea is everywhere yet you can do nothing with it.
Re: Nintendo's Updated Guidelines For Tournaments & Content Creation Sparks Community Backlash
@HeadPirate IP holders shouldn't have rights to control users. Only to protect sales. And this is control of how the game itself is used. If one doesn't follow guidelines, Nintendo enforces copyright instead of turning a blind eye. I don't think they should have rights to turn a blind eye sometimes, and enforce other times. It's too messy.
An aside regarding modification and fanwork, I only have beliefs here, that only modifications that replace existing works should be struck down. I do not think this part is strong enough to debate, as it is not wholly definitive. Please respond to the first part instead.
Re: Lego Teases Three New Sonic The Hedgehog Minifigures
@Samalik Rouge the flat
Re: Super Mario Bros. Wonder English Voice Actors Officially Announce Their Characters
Daisy's voice actor could use some rasp, but I don't want them to ruin their voice...
Re: The Original Switch Reveal Trailer Has Been Removed From Nintendo's YouTube Channel
@GrailUK HaHa HaHa, Yeah they are.
Re: 3DS And Wii U Online Play Ends In "Early April" 2024
@Angelic_Lapras_King It wasn't hackers doing the taking down, nintendo wanted to prevent bad actors from using an exploit
Re: Sonic Superstars' New Multiplayer Battle Mode Detailed By SEGA
Isn't the star thing just mario vs luigi in sonic?
Re: Poll: Pikmin 1+2 Scores A Physical Switch Release This Week, Will You Be Getting It?
@Juanblue85 solato robopfp? Neato burrito.
Re: Toby Fox Shares Another Development Update On Deltarune Chapter 3
@HotGoomba you sir are the most sane person in this room.
Re: The Legend Of Zelda: Oracle Of Seasons & Oracle Of Ages - Which Should I Play First?
I was never able to finish ages so seasons.
Re: New Splatoon 3 Splatfest Kicks Off Next Month
This is Money vs Love all over again. Money vs Love is a traditional splatfest at this point.
Re: Hands On: Pokémon Sleep (Open Beta) - An Absolute Snoozefest
@Aeralto I knew there was a 32nd reason why daylight savings is bad
1. messes with your schedule
2. you need to recalibrate your clocks
3. you need to wake up earlier
4. alternatively you need to sleep later
5. daylight savings doesn't even sync with sunrise
6. daylight savings doesn't sync with sunset
7. farmers for which daylight savings is intended, work from can't see to can't see
8. It messes up your circadian rhythm a little bit
9. you have to go to work early or late
10. your coworkers get their schedules mixed up
11. it doesn't transfer from state to state properly
12. if you have a plane flight during daylight savings delays can feel worse or better
13. Daylight savings is useless when we have street lights and light bulbs
14. Most people stay up all night on their phones
15. You have to re-time all the clocks in the building of your office or home
16. Your pet tries to wake you up early or late because they can't read time
17. Stores change their schedules drastically
18. For religious people, their church hours get shifted.
19. your significant other's sleep schedule is also disrupted.
20. homeless people transcend time, so why should we need daylight savings.
21. If you were born on daylights savings changing, get prepared for a messed up birth certificate
22. The automatic air conditioner system goes out of alignment and you have to fix it
23. Your doctor's appointments become earlier or later, and you realize it ain't in your schedule anymore.
24. Your routine gets messed up so you end up using the bathroom at weirder and weirder times.
25. You look like an idiot when you misstate the time.
26. the clock on your nintendo switch becomes desynced from the clock on your oven.
27. the clock on your oven and microwave need to be recalibrated
28. birds transcend daylight savings.
29. You get confused by the time for a moment or two.
30. It messes up your surprise parties, when the tennant comes home early
31. you die of heart attacks more easily due to sleep disruption
32. you get obese due to sleep disruption
Re: Arzette Is A "Spiritual Successor" To The Infamous Zelda CD-i Games And It's Coming To Switch In 2023
Seedy Eye, CDi? PUN BAM YOU PUNINJAS.
Re: Mario Kart 8 Deluxe Booster Course Pass Wave 5 Arrives Next Week
@Dijita Teh Cheat
Re: Pokémon Launches Official Community Forums And It's Already A Disaster
I'm pretty sure these freaky things are only normal on the internet
Re: Nintendo Of America Announced As A Sponsor Of Dream Con 2023 (US)
@Aeralto I am vaguely insulted. Congratulations Captain Obvious!
Re: Round Up: Here's What Switch Fans Are Saying About The Pikmin 4 Demo
Pikmin 4 protagonist is named Riley imo, you cannot change my nonfactual opinion on this antimatter.
Re: Nintendo Of America Is A Sponsor Of Dream Con 2023 (US)
The world explainin why it's complaining at the rendevous deliciously positioned to empower, the esports scene at this dark hour.
This is meant to be read to section 3 of The World Revolving, the one with Gaster's Theme in it. The part where it goes in circles whimsically as the speed falls down a toilet and becomes a catch me if you can.
TLDR: EVENT GOOD.
Re: Action RPG CryMachina Looks Stunning, And It's Launching This October
Woah Pigtails are a bold move for a protagonist. Can this Anime Girl live up to the great pigtailed anime girls? We've got Legendary characters such as Madoka Magica, and Nokia from Cybersleuth on our side.
Re: WayForward's Game Boy Color Classic 'Xtreme Sports' Comes To Switch This August
The difference in clothing is stark.
Re: Review: Ghost Trick: Phantom Detective - A DS All-Timer Returns In Stunning Form
@Iconoclysm but the issue is that you can't tell, then go to a site where you can. I'm not gonna continue to stir the pot.
Re: Review: Ghost Trick: Phantom Detective - A DS All-Timer Returns In Stunning Form
@Iconoclysm Just check out metacritic after the reviews get aggregated.
Re: Review: Ghost Trick: Phantom Detective - A DS All-Timer Returns In Stunning Form
GHOST TRICK: PHANTOM DETECTIVE deserves this 10/10, even just watching a lets play of the original DS game I was blown away.
Re: Round Up: Here Are The First "Hands On" Impressions Of Pikmin 4
PIKMIN 4 and GHOST TRICK are my games of JUNE. Yes all proper NOUNS need to be fully capitalized.
Re: E3 2024 And 2025 Have Supposedly Been Cancelled
@Uska N is drowning in a vat of acid, please assist him.
Re: Nintendo Updates Pikmin 3 Deluxe Switch Icon In Latest Patch (Version 1.1.1)
@PikaPhantom The gradient and the slight glow on the lettering makes it look leaflike... I think the new logo is less than generic but not stand out.
Re: Mario + Rabbids Sparks Of Hope - The Last Spark Hunter Story Details Surface
I am rabid for more rabbid.... said nobody ever, except mario fans.
Re: Sonic Mania Dev Confirms Superstars Translates 'Retro Engine' Physics Into 3D
@PikaPhantom It's ported physics code
Re: Naruto X Boruto: Ultimate Ninja Storm Connections Reveals More Playable Characters
Demi-Human from shin megami tensei III? What a devilish deal!
Re: Feature: Nintendo Fans Needn't Lose Sleep Over Foamstars, Square Enix's 'Splatoon Rip-Off'
any negativity is certified stranger.
Re: Mario Movie Star Chris Pratt Says Sequel News Is Coming "Soon"
I shall use undictionaryable words if I scallywimple dang fancy it.
Re: Mario Movie Star Chris Pratt Says Sequel News Is Coming "Soon"
What a biggiferous fanciful announcement, a secondary mario movie!
Re: Sonic Origins Plus Physical Listing Says New Content Is "Downloadable Via Included Code"
man, baby, babyman, undo this curse wrought by the manbaby's hand!
Stir the prodigious and protest digital.
Sing supreme and wrest upon all physical the right to remain.