"Companies aren't your friend." Streamers aren't your friend either, neither are content creators, but they still can be good people with flaws. Companies are masses of people, who may or may not deserve congratulations for their hard work. People with hopes and dreams, flaws and crimes, all together trying to make something special.
People tell you the company isn't your friend is the same way a parent might tell you nobody on the internet is your friend, and neither are the majority of people you meet on the street, that doesn't stop them from being important or good people. There are friends on the internet, but I can agree that saying something equivalent of a house for people is your friend is insane. We live in a world of 8 billion.... let's just get along.
Happy anniversary to all the people inside Nintendo!
@Thomystic Smart Waddle Dee knows things, I must capture it so that I may never look dumb in the comments section again! MWAHAHAHAAH-
In all seriousness I thought they were native because of how Austrailia literally waged war on them twice. (also I apologise for saying it instead of them, villain persona and all that for the joke)
Patents mean methods, not the end result like copyright is meant to protect. Patents I think also use include trade secrets or encryption, my opinion is that though palworld is questionable, they exploited the law just enough to avoid copyright, but if somebody on the team copied trade secrets or encryption keys... first why tf would you copy that if you can code, second they deserve it 100 % if so instead of 80%... If it's code or mechanics... Good luck getting that to stick, code is copyright, and mechanics don't fall under copyright , trademarks, or patents as far as I know
From Wikipedia:
A patent is a type of intellectual property that gives its owner the legal right to exclude others from making, using, or selling an invention for a limited period of time in exchange for publishing an enabling disclosure of the invention.[1] In most countries, patent rights fall under private law and the patent holder must sue someone infringing the patent in order to enforce their rights
Here we stand, in an endless, past, present, future span. Our wishes are the flames that light up history. We've come far, you and I, on our journey. Sights and sounds, highs and lows, all that we've seen. Nothing at the start, at the void of night. But then out there, in the dark, a path came to light. Did you think back then we'd be here? Guiding others in our shoes? Tiny, tiny seeds, left on the trail, someday to bloom. Star at night, glowing bright, bringing us your light- A message to us from far in the past, saying, "Shine on!" Words you write, line by line, showing us your sights- Passed down to us so we sing them today, we feel you still. Team past. History.
I like how the creatures are designed, the wolf in the thumbnail and the llama in particular... I think the human cast is colorful.... but I haven't seen enough world interaction to determine whether this is will be good.
If the humans can't interact with the world like ingame... I'm out.
Also the creatures would look way better if their models were allowed to clip. I know that's considered bad, but the continous softbody skin brings the excellent texture work down a peg, plus that's how it works ingame.
@FantasiaWHT The orange text usually tells you which option to pick, or gives you a lead, turn highlighting on if it's off. It's a better system than the first 2 games but not perfect.
Tiana is my favorite, design wise, I really love yellow, even froggy yellow. The contrast between her skin and the dress, draws my eyes to her face, even though the dress is brighter. I see what they were going for with the purple dress on the white chick, yellow and purple contrast, but they don't look nearly as smashing as Tiana.
@sanderev Since the Dev is rebranding I view this as a good push forward that the dev needed to move on. But it's still sad that it won't be available for a few months.
Good words work better with proper dandori. I think from software has three options, make smaller indie like games so that they have the budget to fail, with the potential to profit... This is the warchest approach where less spending is good. The second is to make a big AAA game and hope it sells well. This is what most AAA publishers are doing... and I don't think it works very well.
What nintendo does is make games that they think will succeed alongside games they want to make, so that they can be pleasantly surprised and well as sustained. I think I'd reccoment this approach, as sustainability comes before making what you want, even if making what you want is the end goal. Funny how surprise and delight works in their business model.
the mod creator waikuteru has a patreon. I think that's why. Never charge for fan content.
It's within the copyright holders rights to accept or banish fan content. I've heard that it's literally law in japan that fan content has protections as long as the copyright holder turns a blind eye.
@HeadPirate The way you disrespect people isn't my vibe, I picked up very big "this man is gullible laugh" vibes from your last comment. I am not gullible, and you should put more care into respecting others, even if they disagree with you, but not letting them run your life.
@abdias Toby's parts of the soundtrack are good. The hill you are on isn't worth the suffering required to live on it. Though I will admit, he can't make this shine.
What happened was that there were abuse scandals and Nintendo hates mods because they interfere with the original creative vision (They don't hate fans lol).
You also said that Nintendo can't take down every tournament or copyright violation... but they can at least take down any that exist online, Music detection systems are very powerful, that's why they were able to put out these guidelines, they do turn a blind eye.
It's not a fantasy to fight for rights to use things we own, I do not live In LaLaland, If I was I would be suggesting that Nintendo allow piracy. I believe that copyright needs limits to how far it can control users. Things like taking videos and posting what they play, hosting events, even right to repair, which many companies use copyright and voiding warranties to fight. We do not enter contracts when we buy food, a wrench, or a puzzle (closest comparison to creative works I can think of). We can film these things, host events that involve them. I know that the public performance laws for copyright outright prohibit these things for games and other forms of media. Posting Elsa's Let it go should not happen, but having a video be taken down because it was playing in the background of something different, I could see fair use being extended. People even abuse copyright to cover up evidence of abuse (See Police using it prevent filming Brutality)
Many people claim fair use when backed into a corner with copyright, that's the only thing they do really.
I don't believe I have a strong enough arguement for modding. So I won't bother with that.
(replacing old message to add context to convo, otherwise I'm peacing out)@sanderev preventing piracy is protecting sales, controlling a tournament is not protecting sales at least for people who actually know a thing or two about how brands work, for people who can't tell their brands from their behinds, it is protecting sales.
My issue is that controlling how a user uses your expression is not a form of protection offered for most forms of expression (Look at people quoting eachother out of context on twitter, unregulated.). So that is a reason I disagree that games should have the same protection. that is a form of me disagreeing with it, I'm sure I can find others if I'm pressed.
@HeadPirate IP holders shouldn't have rights to control users. Only to protect sales. And this is control of how the game itself is used. If one doesn't follow guidelines, Nintendo enforces copyright instead of turning a blind eye. I don't think they should have rights to turn a blind eye sometimes, and enforce other times. It's too messy.
An aside regarding modification and fanwork, I only have beliefs here, that only modifications that replace existing works should be struck down. I do not think this part is strong enough to debate, as it is not wholly definitive. Please respond to the first part instead.
Comments 285
Re: Anniversary: Nintendo Is 135 Years Old Today
"Companies aren't your friend." Streamers aren't your friend either, neither are content creators, but they still can be good people with flaws. Companies are masses of people, who may or may not deserve congratulations for their hard work. People with hopes and dreams, flaws and crimes, all together trying to make something special.
People tell you the company isn't your friend is the same way a parent might tell you nobody on the internet is your friend, and neither are the majority of people you meet on the street, that doesn't stop them from being important or good people. There are friends on the internet, but I can agree that saying something equivalent of a house for people is your friend is insane. We live in a world of 8 billion.... let's just get along.
Happy anniversary to all the people inside Nintendo!
Re: Random: Hilarious 'Untitled Goose Programme' Proof-Of-Concept Has Us Desperate For More
@Thomystic Smart Waddle Dee knows things, I must capture it so that I may never look dumb in the comments section again! MWAHAHAHAAH-
In all seriousness I thought they were native because of how Austrailia literally waged war on them twice. (also I apologise for saying it instead of them, villain persona and all that for the joke)
Re: Random: Hilarious 'Untitled Goose Programme' Proof-Of-Concept Has Us Desperate For More
I want an Emu Game. An emu game with a hot topic, and skateboards. Set in austrailia
Re: Nintendo And Pokémon File Lawsuit Against Palworld Developer Pocketpair
Patents mean methods, not the end result like copyright is meant to protect. Patents I think also use include trade secrets or encryption, my opinion is that though palworld is questionable, they exploited the law just enough to avoid copyright, but if somebody on the team copied trade secrets or encryption keys... first why tf would you copy that if you can code, second they deserve it 100 % if so instead of 80%... If it's code or mechanics... Good luck getting that to stick, code is copyright, and mechanics don't fall under copyright , trademarks, or patents as far as I know
From Wikipedia:
A patent is a type of intellectual property that gives its owner the legal right to exclude others from making, using, or selling an invention for a limited period of time in exchange for publishing an enabling disclosure of the invention.[1] In most countries, patent rights fall under private law and the patent holder must sue someone infringing the patent in order to enforce their rights
Re: Nintendo And Pokémon File Lawsuit Against Palworld Developer Pocketpair
I can agree with headpirate here.
Re: New TMNT: Mutants Unleashed Gameplay Trailer Is Packed With Bodacious Brawling
I also am totally tubular, Shell out for me my peeps.
Re: PSA: Zelda: Echoes Of Wisdom Has Reportedly Leaked Online In Full
@LikelySatan I don't see it often enough for that kind of beatdown either. What is wilton on about?
Re: Splatoon 3's 'Grand Festival' Splatfest Kicks Off Tomorrow, Which Team Gets Your Vote?
Here we stand, in an endless, past, present, future span.
Our wishes are the flames that light up history.
We've come far, you and I, on our journey.
Sights and sounds, highs and lows, all that we've seen.
Nothing at the start, at the void of night.
But then out there, in the dark, a path came to light.
Did you think back then we'd be here? Guiding others in our shoes?
Tiny, tiny seeds, left on the trail, someday to bloom.
Star at night, glowing bright, bringing us your light-
A message to us from far in the past, saying, "Shine on!"
Words you write, line by line, showing us your sights-
Passed down to us so we sing them today, we feel you still.
Team past. History.
Re: Sonic Fans, Don't Get Your Hopes Up For A Standalone Chao Garden Game
I think having it as an addition to regular gameplay is best. Otherwise it becomes an animal crossing clone.
Re: Toree Saturn Scores A New Trailer Ahead Of This Year's Switch Release
I desperately want to sing in the comments section for this game
Re: Nintendo Highlights Super Mario Party Jamboree's Five New Boards In Fresh Footage
@Nintoz unspeakable acts at a reasonable price
Re: First Minecraft Movie Trailer Features Creepers, Piglins And Jack Black's Steve
I like how the creatures are designed, the wolf in the thumbnail and the llama in particular... I think the human cast is colorful.... but I haven't seen enough world interaction to determine whether this is will be good.
If the humans can't interact with the world like ingame... I'm out.
Also the creatures would look way better if their models were allowed to clip. I know that's considered bad, but the continous softbody skin brings the excellent texture work down a peg, plus that's how it works ingame.
Re: UK Charts: Star Wars Outlaws Bags Number One While Emio Flounders
@FantasiaWHT The orange text usually tells you which option to pick, or gives you a lead, turn highlighting on if it's off. It's a better system than the first 2 games but not perfect.
Re: Review: Emio - The Smiling Man: Famicom Detective Club (Switch) - A Stylish Mystery With One Foot In The Past
@Olliemar28 pay attention to the highlighted orange text, it's a guide on what to do next.
Re: Persona-Inspired JRPG 'Bloomtown: A Different Story' Lands On Switch Next Month
I smell a certain kind of artist on the concept art team.
Re: Emio - The Smiling Man: Famicom Detective Club Is Out Next Week, Will You Be Getting It?
if my money allows, believe in the heart of the bills!
Re: Disney Dreamlight Valley Welcomes Tiana In New Free Update, Here Are The Full Patch Notes
Tiana is my favorite, design wise, I really love yellow, even froggy yellow. The contrast between her skin and the dress, draws my eyes to her face, even though the dress is brighter. I see what they were going for with the purple dress on the white chick, yellow and purple contrast, but they don't look nearly as smashing as Tiana.
Re: Hands On: Emio - The Smiling Man: Famicom Detective Club - Rated M For 'Murder'
I am obsessed with this villain. The name makes me smile just thinking it. E M I O The Smiling Man.
Re: Warner Bros. Is Reportedly Looking To Sell A Stake In Its Games Business
@LikelySatan I think they mean scraping the internet for feedback.
Re: Feature: The Next Splatfest May Decide Splatoon 4's Future, So We Make A Case For Every Team
pearl's outfit is more reminiscent of a gay scene outfit. pearlina?
Re: Nintendo Reconfirms Release Windows For Major Upcoming Switch Games
why is nobody excited for emio? the music in the girl who stands behind was awesome.
Re: New Fire Emblem: Three Houses Figures Announced, Pre-Orders For Dimitri Live
why does this article have the sega skin? the blue is usually reserved for sega games.
Re: Nintendo Japan Reveals New Splatoon 3 Merch For September's 'Grand Festival' Splatfest
I think the Past informs the present and the future... I love history, so the Past it is!
Re: Don't Worry, Nintendo Likely Won't Utilise Generative AI In Its Game Development
@Samalik there are 16 set personalities and a catchphrase, villagers pull from this pool of dialogue.
Re: Nintendo Files DMCA Against Fan-Made 'Rhythm Heaven' Remix Software
@sanderev Since the Dev is rebranding I view this as a good push forward that the dev needed to move on. But it's still sad that it won't be available for a few months.
Re: FromSoftware Boss Wouldn't Allow Studio Layoffs To Happen, Cites Satoru Iwata
Good words work better with proper dandori. I think from software has three options, make smaller indie like games so that they have the budget to fail, with the potential to profit... This is the warchest approach where less spending is good. The second is to make a big AAA game and hope it sells well. This is what most AAA publishers are doing... and I don't think it works very well.
What nintendo does is make games that they think will succeed alongside games they want to make, so that they can be pleasantly surprised and well as sustained. I think I'd reccoment this approach, as sustainability comes before making what you want, even if making what you want is the end goal. Funny how surprise and delight works in their business model.
Re: Nintendo Issues Multiple DMCAs On The Modding Site 'GameBanana'
the mod creator waikuteru has a patreon. I think that's why. Never charge for fan content.
It's within the copyright holders rights to accept or banish fan content. I've heard that it's literally law in japan that fan content has protections as long as the copyright holder turns a blind eye.
Re: Switch Emulator Yuzu To Pay $2.4 Million To Nintendo & Cease Development
@HeadPirate The way you disrespect people isn't my vibe, I picked up very big "this man is gullible laugh" vibes from your last comment. I am not gullible, and you should put more care into respecting others, even if they disagree with you, but not letting them run your life.
Re: Switch Emulator Yuzu To Pay $2.4 Million To Nintendo & Cease Development
@HeadPirate I thought you sounded rational until that guy turned out to be a lawyer. so I'm just not reading your essays anymore.
Re: Round Up: The Previews Are In For Penny's Big Breakaway
@HotGoomba goombers have ears?
Re: Fan-Made 'Link's Awakening DX HD' Port Taken Down By Nintendo
Make actual fangames instead of remakes, Nintendo comes after Remakes harder.
Re: Undertale Creator Toby Fox Remixed Ed Sheeran's Pokémon Song In The New Scarlet & Violet DLC
@abdias Toby's parts of the soundtrack are good. The hill you are on isn't worth the suffering required to live on it. Though I will admit, he can't make this shine.
Re: Netflix's Pokémon Concierge Starts December 28, Here's The Official Trailer
@Kermit1 which frame?
Re: Nintendo Is Most-Nominated Publisher At The Game Awards 2023
15 noms? Om nom nom nom.
Re: Super Mario RPG Switch Leaked Online Ahead Of Next Week's Release
@Eel oh you tease!
Re: It Looks Like A Smash Bros. Ultimate Switch OLED Bundle Might Be Coming Soon
Joy-con themed Smash controllers
Re: Poll: WarioWare: Move It! Is Out Today, Will You Be Getting It?
I like to move it, move it
I like to move it, move it
I like to move it, move it
We like to move it!
I like to move it, move it
She like to move it, move it
We like to move it, move it
We like to move it!
Re: Hands On: Bluey: The Videogame, In Real Life
both of the comments above me, sheesh.
Re: Sonic's New 3D Action-Platformer Is Exclusive To Apple Arcade
I hope it has touch to walk controls instead of a bad joystick, and that homing attack targets can just be tapped on to go there.
Re: Toby Fox Shares Deltarune Development Update: "No More Waiting For Chapter 5"
I worry for Toby's mental health.
Re: Nintendo's Updated Guidelines For Tournaments & Content Creation Sparks Community Backlash
@chaser206 attack on character, dislike report, whatever this man.
Re: Nintendo's Updated Guidelines For Tournaments & Content Creation Sparks Community Backlash
@HeadPirate
What happened was that there were abuse scandals and Nintendo hates mods because they interfere with the original creative vision (They don't hate fans lol).
You also said that Nintendo can't take down every tournament or copyright violation... but they can at least take down any that exist online, Music detection systems are very powerful, that's why they were able to put out these guidelines, they do turn a blind eye.
It's not a fantasy to fight for rights to use things we own, I do not live In LaLaland, If I was I would be suggesting that Nintendo allow piracy. I believe that copyright needs limits to how far it can control users. Things like taking videos and posting what they play, hosting events, even right to repair, which many companies use copyright and voiding warranties to fight. We do not enter contracts when we buy food, a wrench, or a puzzle (closest comparison to creative works I can think of). We can film these things, host events that involve them. I know that the public performance laws for copyright outright prohibit these things for games and other forms of media. Posting Elsa's Let it go should not happen, but having a video be taken down because it was playing in the background of something different, I could see fair use being extended. People even abuse copyright to cover up evidence of abuse (See Police using it prevent filming Brutality)
Many people claim fair use when backed into a corner with copyright, that's the only thing they do really.
I don't believe I have a strong enough arguement for modding. So I won't bother with that.
Re: Nintendo's Updated Guidelines For Tournaments & Content Creation Sparks Community Backlash
(replacing old message to add context to convo, otherwise I'm peacing out)@sanderev preventing piracy is protecting sales, controlling a tournament is not protecting sales at least for people who actually know a thing or two about how brands work, for people who can't tell their brands from their behinds, it is protecting sales.
My issue is that controlling how a user uses your expression is not a form of protection offered for most forms of expression (Look at people quoting eachother out of context on twitter, unregulated.). So that is a reason I disagree that games should have the same protection. that is a form of me disagreeing with it, I'm sure I can find others if I'm pressed.
Re: Nintendo's Updated Guidelines For Tournaments & Content Creation Sparks Community Backlash
@dew12333 It's a frustration that the idea is everywhere yet you can do nothing with it.
Re: Nintendo's Updated Guidelines For Tournaments & Content Creation Sparks Community Backlash
@HeadPirate IP holders shouldn't have rights to control users. Only to protect sales. And this is control of how the game itself is used. If one doesn't follow guidelines, Nintendo enforces copyright instead of turning a blind eye. I don't think they should have rights to turn a blind eye sometimes, and enforce other times. It's too messy.
An aside regarding modification and fanwork, I only have beliefs here, that only modifications that replace existing works should be struck down. I do not think this part is strong enough to debate, as it is not wholly definitive. Please respond to the first part instead.
Re: Lego Teases Three New Sonic The Hedgehog Minifigures
@Samalik Rouge the flat
Re: Super Mario Bros. Wonder English Voice Actors Officially Announce Their Characters
Daisy's voice actor could use some rasp, but I don't want them to ruin their voice...
Re: The Original Switch Reveal Trailer Has Been Removed From Nintendo's YouTube Channel
@GrailUK HaHa HaHa, Yeah they are.
Re: 3DS And Wii U Online Play Ends In "Early April" 2024
@Angelic_Lapras_King It wasn't hackers doing the taking down, nintendo wanted to prevent bad actors from using an exploit
Re: Sonic Superstars' New Multiplayer Battle Mode Detailed By SEGA
Isn't the star thing just mario vs luigi in sonic?