Comments 240

Re: Talking Point: Do You Miss Instruction Manuals?

StarryCiel

Growing up during the Wii era, I always really loved the instruction manuals. It was cool to learn about combos/techniques I wasn't smart enough to figure out myself!

I thought the interactive Wii U manuals were a good followup, especially the cool Mario Maker one, but Nintendo doesn't even do that anymore.

Re: Soapbox: Zelda: Skyward Sword Is Good, Actually

StarryCiel

It's not my favorite 3D Zelda game, but I absolutely adore Skyward Sword. At its best, it has some of the best dungeons, characters, items, and musics in the whole series. I really hope that the button controls allow for more people to get past that initial motion control barrier because they're missing out on a real gem!

Re: Poll: Which Is Your Favourite GameCube Console Variant?

StarryCiel

Looking at pretty much all of the other consoles, both Nintendo and otherwise, there's something so unique about that pleasing shade of indigo purple used for the GameCube and Game Boy Advance. I wish more consoles had that willingness to just be colorful outside of collector's editions.

Re: Feature: Best Kirby Games Of All Time

StarryCiel

I'm not super surprised Robobot is at first, everyone seems to like that one. But I was kinda hoping for SuperStar Ultra or Return To Dreamland to make first, they've always felt like the definitive Kirby games to me. Pretty solid list, though.

Re: Custom-Made Etika Joy-Con Which Raised $10k For Charity Fell Foul Of Copyright Claim, Creator Reveals

StarryCiel

Okay, so this whole situation has become this massive mess over the past few days that has become far more than just another instance of Nintendo C&D'ing. To recap, the original C&D happened back in September, which only happened because of the words "Joy-Con". They were perfectly fine with the Etikons being produced as long as the trademark wasn't there.

Putting aside the fact that a crowdfunded product being shut down wasn't revealed until a few months later at the exact moment when Nintendo was getting a lot of flack, CptnAlex did a solid job of clearing up the misinformation at the time and started another indiegogo to revise the Etikons which became a success fairly quickly.

However, soon after Etika's brother opened up and revealed that CptnAlex never asked his family to use Etika's name, made even worse when a confusing statement on the indiegogo implied that the charity wouldn't even be getting all of the profits. Since then CptnAlex did talk to Etika's brother and showed receipts as proof that he didn't pocket any of the money, but his reactions to the allegations weren't great either, as he threatened to sue a Reddit user who made a post about it. Still, the fact that he based a controller on Etika and didn't bother to contact his family until this whole controversy is a bit shaky. Etika's brother seems to be planning an Instagram Live to discuss the whole situation, and we'll see how it ends up turning out.

In general, I think this has become this incredibly nuanced and messy situation that's way more complicated than just "Nintendo was right or wrong". There are a lot of arguments to make about Nintendo's copyright policies, but I don't think this is the best case to base them on. If anything, it might be best to distance yourselves from the whole situation and let the people involved resolve it amongst themselves. If you want to donate money to charity in support of mental health, I highly recommend that you actually find a charity and donate directly rather than do it through a middle man.

Re: Custom-Made Etika Joy-Con Which Raised $10k For Charity Fell Foul Of Copyright Claim, Creator Reveals

StarryCiel

For those who weren't sure about whether or not this happened last year, it didn't: https://twitter.com/Cptn_Alex/status/1116438659102801926

CptnAlex did have a copyright infringement issue last year, but it wasn't about the Etikons.

It's also worth noting that CptnAlex is considering to launch a campaign to revise the Etikons if #FreeCptnAlex gets on trending:
https://twitter.com/Cptn_Alex/status/1335993691060703232

It's a shame this happened, but I think CptnAlex is taking this fairly well, and I'm glad that there's still a chance for the Etikons to continue being sold, albeit in a slightly different form.

Re: Custom-Made Etika Joy-Con Which Raised $10k For Charity Fell Foul Of Copyright Claim, Creator Reveals

StarryCiel

I'm split on this. I totally get why Nintendo wouldn't want anyone to produce merch using the word "JoyCon", but this was not a good time to do so given that they were simultaneously honoring a dead person and donating the proceedings to charity. Not a good look for Nintendo at all.

Although, it seems like no one is mentioning the fact that CptnAlex is still allowed to produce these decals as long as it doesn't say "Joycon" on it, so I don't think it's a complete loss such as fan games and the Slippi incident.

Re: Zelda, Sonic And Untitled Goose Game Sets Are Being Officially Reviewed By LEGO

StarryCiel

The Untitled Goose Game is silly, but I don't think it would be super fun to build.
That Eggman Robot in the Sonic set looks like a lot of fun, though, along with the loop and the Half-Boiled Heavies.
Hyrule Castle is impressive, but with that many pieces, I'm sure it would be way too expensive.
Still, this is a solid lineup and it would be cool to see Lego branch out with more videogame-themed sets, they've definitely been doing it a lot more lately (Overwatch & Mario).