Comments 479

Re: The Pokémon Company Withdraws Settlement in Lawsuit Over Copyright Infringement

hypercoyote

@duffmmann Sorry, I have no idea what you're talking about. I never said anything about them not suing again. I think you may have misunderstood one comment where I said they would encourage others to do the same thing this guy did. I was saying if TPCi did as one member suggested and support this dude, then that action would encourage others to do the same. In reality, I realize they would definitely sue again.

Re: The Pokémon Company Withdraws Settlement in Lawsuit Over Copyright Infringement

hypercoyote

@Yorumi I think the main difference with the parody versus the poster is the parodies are not seeking to make a profit whereas the poster was promoting an event that was. So the examples are not really comparable. I don't disagree with your opinion that this was a bad move on TPCi's part. I think people are just saying this guy was not innocent. It's easy to overlook the immoral actions of an individual in the face of the big bad corporation, but the fact remains is he was trying to use IP that was not his to promote profit for his business, which is a shady practice in and of itself. Again, as I said in my first post, probably no one here is innocent of copyright infringement at some level, but hopefully people grow out of that stage once they realize it's wrong.

Re: The Pokémon Company Withdraws Settlement in Lawsuit Over Copyright Infringement

hypercoyote

@Yorumi You are 100% correct that legality does not make morality. However, who's moral compass would TPCi be bound to? If I was TPCi, I wouldn't sue, I would've just done the C&D, but this is a company, not a person. A company's moral compass is bound by profits. The only incentive they have not to sue is the bad publicity from doing so. However, that seems to have actually steered them to go after him harder.

Re: The Pokémon Company Withdraws Settlement in Lawsuit Over Copyright Infringement

hypercoyote

I feel bad for the guy, but he is totally in the wrong. Like others have said, he shouldn't have made it public first of all. But I'd imagine the majority of visitors to this site have also done illegal things that they could have potentially been sued for and just never got caught. So it's not like anyone here can judge him, but then again, we can't really condemn TPCi either since they're doing what they are legally allowed to do.