I just wonder if SMA4:SMB3 is going to get a discount at some point. I really want to play those e-reader levels, but no point in paying full price if I won't have time to play it now anyway.
I wouldn't buy it if it didn't include those levels. I would be thrilled if it included the missing US levels from where they stopped producing the cards.
@sketchturner My thoughts too. How can they make a blanket statement like, well, this genre didn't sell well, so we're gonna stop making all games on the 3DS. Seems like a scare tactic to drive up sales.
@VeeFlamesNL Well, but then on the other side, at stake are online rankings that will be all but forgotten in 6 months....so really, did anyone lose anything? Beyond all that, I'm more amazed at how anyone found the original levels.
@Monado_III Well, that's not entirely accurate. Technically you still don't own the 'license' for the soundtrack. When you buy a CD, you technically are buying a license to own that music in that form. It's all a bunch of technical legal mess, but the short end is, owning the game doesn't give you the rights to own the music separately.
@Ralizah I think what they mentioned above was a promo for early sign-up. But I'm kind of with you, they haven't officially announced how they will handle physical purchases.
@Darkthany Truth. Having said that, this trailer is pretty bad. I liked the first one they did, that one was actually pretty exciting. It feels like they're trying too hard to be cool.
@Kage_88 The only thing about the MN9 campaign that went wrong was the toxic attitude of the supporters. They had some unavoidable issues and some updates that could've been better, but people are painting it like it was the worst development story in history and it's simply not. Every backer is still getting what they agreed to pay for in the beginning, if not more.
Hmmm, it's easy to criticize this situation. It does seem like a bad business plan, but who knows what the full story is. Surely he didn't just go in thinking, 'meh, I'll figure out how to make the other 120k later'.
@duffmmann Sorry, I have no idea what you're talking about. I never said anything about them not suing again. I think you may have misunderstood one comment where I said they would encourage others to do the same thing this guy did. I was saying if TPCi did as one member suggested and support this dude, then that action would encourage others to do the same. In reality, I realize they would definitely sue again.
@Yorumi The people you are mentioning take content and create new content from it. They don't forklift it from the original source and reproduce it 1-to-1 somewhere else for profit. I was actually speaking to the re-dubbed animes you mentioned before. Honestly, I don't care to defend the point further though.
@Yorumi I think the main difference with the parody versus the poster is the parodies are not seeking to make a profit whereas the poster was promoting an event that was. So the examples are not really comparable. I don't disagree with your opinion that this was a bad move on TPCi's part. I think people are just saying this guy was not innocent. It's easy to overlook the immoral actions of an individual in the face of the big bad corporation, but the fact remains is he was trying to use IP that was not his to promote profit for his business, which is a shady practice in and of itself. Again, as I said in my first post, probably no one here is innocent of copyright infringement at some level, but hopefully people grow out of that stage once they realize it's wrong.
@Yorumi You are 100% correct that legality does not make morality. However, who's moral compass would TPCi be bound to? If I was TPCi, I wouldn't sue, I would've just done the C&D, but this is a company, not a person. A company's moral compass is bound by profits. The only incentive they have not to sue is the bad publicity from doing so. However, that seems to have actually steered them to go after him harder.
I feel bad for the guy, but he is totally in the wrong. Like others have said, he shouldn't have made it public first of all. But I'd imagine the majority of visitors to this site have also done illegal things that they could have potentially been sued for and just never got caught. So it's not like anyone here can judge him, but then again, we can't really condemn TPCi either since they're doing what they are legally allowed to do.
The amount of attention that Europe's Club Nintendo in contrast to North America is shameful. I hope they do a better job of equalizing prizes in whatever the next system is.
Comments 479
Re: Nintendo Further Explains Fire Emblem Fates Localisation, With Same-Sex Marriages In Each Version
@River3636 Wouldn't same-sex marriage be doomed in an evolution chain since they can't reproduce by themselves?
Re: Nintendo Download: 21st January (North America)
I just wonder if SMA4:SMB3 is going to get a discount at some point. I really want to play those e-reader levels, but no point in paying full price if I won't have time to play it now anyway.
Re: European Zelda Fans Are Getting A Shiny "Hyrule Edition" New 3DS XL Console In March
I guess they shipped the UK all the excess units for NA.
Re: Zack & Wiki and Super Mario Advance 4 Look Set for Nintendo Download Update in North America
So, does this mean it includes all the e-reader levels, including the ones that were previously JPN only?
Re: 1994 Patent Reveals Nintendo Was Looking To Create A Super Mario Maker-Style Experience Through Unique Hardware
Who finds this stuff??!?
Re: Rumour: You Can Hold More Rupees in The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess HD
@mikegamer Could be a dev screenshot I guess, but most likely it's in the game.
Re: Zelda: Link Between Worlds Figma Link Is Here, And The Desire Is Real
Wow, I've resisted all the Figmas to this point but this one does look nice. Probably not worth the price for it to sit on my desk, but.....yea.
Re: Eiji Aonuma's First Game Recieves A Fresh English Language Patch
The movement and sound effects remind of Zelda Link to the Past.
Re: Blind Gamer Completes Five-Year Quest To Finish The Legend Of Zelda: Ocarina Of Time
That is amazing.
Re: Video: Hudson's Abandoned R&D Lab Still Has Its Miniature Train Track In Place
Naw, I'll skip the depression train and catch the joy train.
Re: Weirdness: Gamer Keeps Super Famicom On For 20 Years To Preserve Umihara Kawase Save Data
Good article Damien, better late than never. We still love you.
Re: The Japanese Release of Super Mario Advance 4: Super Mario Bros. 3 Will Have the e-Reader Levels
I wouldn't buy it if it didn't include those levels. I would be thrilled if it included the missing US levels from where they stopped producing the cards.
Re: Sales for Dementium Remastered Have Been Much Lower Than Expected
@sketchturner My thoughts too. How can they make a blanket statement like, well, this genre didn't sell well, so we're gonna stop making all games on the 3DS. Seems like a scare tactic to drive up sales.
Re: Accusations of Plagiarism Directed at Popular Super Mario Maker Level Creator
@VeeFlamesNL Well, but then on the other side, at stake are online rankings that will be all but forgotten in 6 months....so really, did anyone lose anything? Beyond all that, I'm more amazed at how anyone found the original levels.
Re: Random: There Are Legend of Zelda Mods in Fallout 4, Of Course
lol, I may grab the PC version someday
Re: Xenoblade Chronicles X Special Edition Owners in North America Highlight Issues With Soundtrack USB Drive
@Monado_III Well, that's not entirely accurate. Technically you still don't own the 'license' for the soundtrack. When you buy a CD, you technically are buying a license to own that music in that form. It's all a bunch of technical legal mess, but the short end is, owning the game doesn't give you the rights to own the music separately.
Re: Xenoblade Chronicles X Special Edition Owners in North America Highlight Issues With Soundtrack USB Drive
Step 1) Obtain the full OST
Step 2) Format the Limited Edition USB drive
Step 3) Copy the music to the drive
Step 4) Enjoy!
Disclaimer: I do not condone or promote illegal downloading of copyrighted material.
Re: You Can Now Register For A New Nintendo Account In Japan
@Ralizah I think what they mentioned above was a promo for early sign-up. But I'm kind of with you, they haven't officially announced how they will handle physical purchases.
Re: You Can Now Register For A New Nintendo Account In Japan
"100 Yen for every 1000 Yen they spend on the Wii U and 3DS eShops."
I hope this isn't an indication that physical purchases will not be recognized with this service.
Re: Video: New Mighty No. 9 Trailer Aims to Bring Back the Hype
@Darkthany Truth. Having said that, this trailer is pretty bad. I liked the first one they did, that one was actually pretty exciting. It feels like they're trying too hard to be cool.
Re: Gold Mega Man amiibo Launching Alongside Mega Man Legacy Collection On 3DS
$20 for the amiibo, tho?
Re: Video: Sit Back and Relax With This Jazz Version of the Pokémon Theme
I think I have a different definition of Jazz than you guys....
Re: Video: Take a Look at This Super Mario Mod for Sonic Generations
That looks amazing.
Re: Koei Tecmo is Planning Another Major Collaboration With a Western IP
Tecmo Bowl. Calling it.
Re: Nintendo Shares Level Out After $4 Billion Drop in Company Value
Good time to buy Nintendo stock?
Re: Video: Jessica Chobot Is Samus Aran In This Lavish Fan-Made Metroid Short
Wow.....amazing production value.
Re: Super Mario Maker Gets Mid-Level Checkpoints and More in Upcoming Update
HOOOOOOORRAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY!!!!!!!
Re: Sony Wishes The NES A Happy 30th Via Twitter
@LunaticPandora I wasn't sure if I was just reading into that, but yea, it seemed like an underhanded compliment.
Re: Mega Yarn Yoshi, Exclusive To Toys "R" Us in North America, Given Release Date
I might have lined up if the release date wasn't on a Sunday morning. I'm not skipping church to line-up for a toy....
Re: Midora Developer Admits He Knew Kickstarter Funds Wouldn't Be Enough To Complete The Game
@Kage_88 The only thing about the MN9 campaign that went wrong was the toxic attitude of the supporters. They had some unavoidable issues and some updates that could've been better, but people are painting it like it was the worst development story in history and it's simply not. Every backer is still getting what they agreed to pay for in the beginning, if not more.
Re: Midora Developer Admits He Knew Kickstarter Funds Wouldn't Be Enough To Complete The Game
Hmmm, it's easy to criticize this situation. It does seem like a bad business plan, but who knows what the full story is. Surely he didn't just go in thinking, 'meh, I'll figure out how to make the other 120k later'.
Re: The Pokémon Company Withdraws Settlement in Lawsuit Over Copyright Infringement
@duffmmann Sorry, I have no idea what you're talking about. I never said anything about them not suing again. I think you may have misunderstood one comment where I said they would encourage others to do the same thing this guy did. I was saying if TPCi did as one member suggested and support this dude, then that action would encourage others to do the same. In reality, I realize they would definitely sue again.
Re: The Pokémon Company Withdraws Settlement in Lawsuit Over Copyright Infringement
@daff3ww See my above comment.
Re: The Pokémon Company Withdraws Settlement in Lawsuit Over Copyright Infringement
@Yorumi The people you are mentioning take content and create new content from it. They don't forklift it from the original source and reproduce it 1-to-1 somewhere else for profit. I was actually speaking to the re-dubbed animes you mentioned before. Honestly, I don't care to defend the point further though.
Re: The Pokémon Company Withdraws Settlement in Lawsuit Over Copyright Infringement
@Yorumi Naw, I get that. But on the parody, the ones I've always seen were free to download/watch. I guess you mean YouTube ads?
Re: The Pokémon Company Withdraws Settlement in Lawsuit Over Copyright Infringement
@duffmmann That would only invite more people to infringe on their IP....
Re: The Pokémon Company Withdraws Settlement in Lawsuit Over Copyright Infringement
@Yorumi I think the main difference with the parody versus the poster is the parodies are not seeking to make a profit whereas the poster was promoting an event that was. So the examples are not really comparable. I don't disagree with your opinion that this was a bad move on TPCi's part. I think people are just saying this guy was not innocent. It's easy to overlook the immoral actions of an individual in the face of the big bad corporation, but the fact remains is he was trying to use IP that was not his to promote profit for his business, which is a shady practice in and of itself. Again, as I said in my first post, probably no one here is innocent of copyright infringement at some level, but hopefully people grow out of that stage once they realize it's wrong.
Re: The Pokémon Company Withdraws Settlement in Lawsuit Over Copyright Infringement
@PlywoodStick Oh.....then he (or she) is making a jerk move.....but one totally within his (or her) rights.
Re: The Pokémon Company Withdraws Settlement in Lawsuit Over Copyright Infringement
@Yorumi You are 100% correct that legality does not make morality. However, who's moral compass would TPCi be bound to? If I was TPCi, I wouldn't sue, I would've just done the C&D, but this is a company, not a person. A company's moral compass is bound by profits. The only incentive they have not to sue is the bad publicity from doing so. However, that seems to have actually steered them to go after him harder.
Re: The Pokémon Company Withdraws Settlement in Lawsuit Over Copyright Infringement
I feel bad for the guy, but he is totally in the wrong. Like others have said, he shouldn't have made it public first of all. But I'd imagine the majority of visitors to this site have also done illegal things that they could have potentially been sued for and just never got caught. So it's not like anyone here can judge him, but then again, we can't really condemn TPCi either since they're doing what they are legally allowed to do.
Re: This Is The Last Real Console Cycle, Proclaims Industry Analyst Michael Pachter
@6ch6ris6 LOL what you said. I think he hates the game industry as many times as he predicted it's downfall.
Re: Talking Point: Star Fox Zero's Delay Could Be The Final Nail In The Wii U's Coffin
Lacks a AAA release? Xenoblade Chronicles X doesn't count?
Re: Nintendo UK Store Offering Limited Edition Super Mario Box Packed With Goodies
Oh, you guys can actually order online from your Nintendo Store? What a novel idea!
Re: Pokémon Go is an AR Game Headed to iOS and Android, With Accompanying 'Plus' Device for the Wrist
I have to wonder if, in real life, the people it's showing play this game would actually play this game.
Re: Man Goes On Quest To Buy Every Single amiibo In Australia In 24 Hours
@Farpun or Amiibo Depot.
Re: Man Goes On Quest To Buy Every Single amiibo In Australia In 24 Hours
Can't Australians just walk into a gas station and pick up all of them? j/k
Re: Club Nintendo Goodbye Coin Now Available in Europe and Australia
The amount of attention that Europe's Club Nintendo in contrast to North America is shameful. I hope they do a better job of equalizing prizes in whatever the next system is.
Re: Gorgeous Xenoblade Chronicles X Special Edition Confirmed for North America
@Xaldin Naw, to just download it would be illegal since it's not obtained through legitimate means.
Re: Gorgeous Xenoblade Chronicles X Special Edition Confirmed for North America
Why are there only 10 tracks on the thumb drive? Why not the whole OST?
Re: European Club Nintendo Has a Lovely Last Hurrah With the Nintendo Sound Selection Double CD
I wonder why Nintendo hates North America.