Comments 251

Re: Dolphin Emulator Steam Release "Indefinitely Postponed"

Tober

@shaneoh In your examples e.g. US States it's clear that those are laws within those states. In other words within that society. That there are differences between societies what is morally the right thing to do is nothing new. It does not matter if this is on the level of a state or a country.
The other example is one of oppression. I hope you are not taking the example of oppression as a means to condone unlawful behavior ethical in the context of piracy of video games.

Re: Dolphin Emulator Steam Release "Indefinitely Postponed"

Tober

@johnvboy I do not know how you've interpreted my comments, but the only kind of emulation I support is the hobbyist that can run Tomraider on a Gameboy.

Any other form I'm against. Especially the kind that believes that game preservation is the same thing as being entitled to playing every game ever made.

Re: Dolphin Emulator Steam Release "Indefinitely Postponed"

Tober

@mikegamer If January 2023 you decide you cannot purchase Metroid Prime and decide to be morally right to pirate it, what do you do in February 2023 when the remaster is announced?

Delete the pirated version and buy the remaster or decide since you already have the game to spend the money on something else?

Re: Zelda: Tears Of The Kingdom Has Surpassed 10 Million Sales In Three Days

Tober

"Nevertheless, 10 million in three days is simply incredible for a Zelda game. For context, Breath of the Wild now officially stands at a total of 29.81 million sales "

Why do these articles always forget the 1.7 Million sold on the Wii U. The correct number for BotW is therefore 31.51 Million.

Also Pokomon was launched close to holiday season, having BotW this many sales in May is incredible.

Re: Japanese Charts: Minecraft Legends Comes Out On Top After A Quiet Week

Tober

@Cashews I get that, but it does not seem Xbox is putting any marketing muscle behind their Japanese market efforts. We never see Xbox mentioned in the list of most sold games. Not even in the top50 that Famitsu publishes a day after the top 10. That includes Minecraft that is a huge success in Japan..on the Switch.

Re: FTC Reportedly Wants Info From Nintendo On Call Of Duty Deal (North America)

Tober

@Not_Soos But the FTC as in a government body are not judges. It's like when the US Senate subpoena a person. If it's a government employee they need to show up, but a non government employee does not.

If a judge subpoena's then yes, but the text says it's the FTC. That's two different things. Also there is jurisdiction. If it would have been a Japanese citizen then obviously it would not make sense anyway.

Re: Metroid Prime Engineer "Let Down" By Exclusion Of Original Credits In Remaster

Tober

@larryisaman Read my comments again please. The 2023 release is not an emulation. if Nintendo would have emulated the 2002 or 2011 release it would be the same game, for which the team knew they where credited beforehand including their credentials verified. Essentially just a re-release. My point (again) is not to use names without consent of those individuals for a new project which is the 2023 release. This means you have to get this pixel perfect. Your comment to add everybody and then remove people afterwards that have a problem with it is even worse then not asking consent beforehand. The damage is then already done.

Re: Metroid Prime Engineer "Let Down" By Exclusion Of Original Credits In Remaster

Tober

@larryisaman You are making several assumptions. Like it would not be a big deal to people if their name would not be correct. Or people would not mind their names be used without their consent (because that's my point) in what is a new 2023 project release they might not be aware of existed. The point is the people working on the original where aware their names are being used on that version, no matter when somebody would decide to play it.

I would personally not like my name being used on new projects without my consent. There where hundreds of people involved in the first 2 games. Assuming they are all ok with using their names without consent has no base.

Re: Metroid Prime Engineer "Let Down" By Exclusion Of Original Credits In Remaster

Tober

@larryisaman Classic Switch online games are dated at the time they where released. e.g. Mario64 is still dated 1996. People that are credited on those games where fully aware of that. Metroid Remastered though is a 2023 game. Most people that worked on the older games might not even know this project existed. Can you then just use their names without consent?

As an example imagine that you worked on the original back in 2002 and see your credits on the 2023 and notice its still the ex-husbands family name from which you brutally divorced 15 years earlier. I'm pretty sure there would be a twitter rage following "Why did Nintendo not contact me before they use my name. I did not know this project even existed!"

My argument was, that it's so hard to get spot on without insulting anybody, that the option Nintendo took with the general message is probable the lesser of two evils.

Re: Metroid Prime Engineer "Let Down" By Exclusion Of Original Credits In Remaster

Tober

@Wexter I understand that in the entertainment industry credits are a thing and I have nothing against them in the slightest. But in this specific case of Prime Remastered it's impractical and impossible to get right. Let me explain.

I think just copying the credit lists from Prime 2002 and Trilogy 2011 and pasting them in Prime Remaster is a no go. You cannot just do that without consulting the individuals themselves if they want to be credited for this project of whom many probably did not know it existed.

  • Names might have changed, through marriage or otherwise
  • People might choose not to be credited on a project they did not work on
  • People might have passed away, in this case a family member needs to approve and a special note should be made in remembrance.

This means to track down all individuals of the 2002 & 2011 release to ask for consent and check if credentials are up to date. Not just retro studio's, but all the localization offices, musicians, QA testers, etc etc etc.

It will be hundreds of people, going back as far as 20 years. It's a task impossible to get right. You'll end up insulting someone. And how long do you spend doing so? Would a game be released without having a complete list? And what you'd do with the people you could not find? Leave them in / Leave them out. There is no good answer.

I think the solution Nintendo opted is probably the best one. People that are interested can see the credentials of the original games that are just a google search away.