Comments 251

Re: The Nintendo Switch Has Exceeded 114 Million Units Sold

Tober

Market saturation is setting in. Not a surprise. There will be only so many that will want to upgrade their OG switch to the OLED. Who knows perhaps there will be an addition to the Switch family or we just have to wait for a real next gen.

Still though the projected 19 million this financial year is still up there. PS5 is projected to sell 18 million this financial year, so it's hardly terrible.

Re: Nintendo To Merge Its European Subsidiaries Into One Big Organisation

Tober

Local entities where established in a different time when sales went primarily through local retailers and there where greater differences in accounting standards between the countries. So these entities where the ones that where the legal contract partners.

With the EU becoming more and more legally cohesive, standardization of accounting practices and cross national wholesale becoming more important, let alone digital sales, the added value of these local entities is getting smaller.

It's not only Nintendo, but it's a trend with all companies (gaming industry or otherwise) to centralize the legal structure in Europe. Local offices will be closed, jobs will be made redundant and contracts with local partners need to be renewed.

Re: Japanese Charts: Bayonetta 3 Debuts In Second As PlayStation 5 Outsells Switch

Tober

PS5 & PS5 Digital outsell the combined Switch family this week in Japan. It's all in preparation of the OLED Pokomon edition coming in. So buyers / retailers are holding back on the Switch models last week.

If the Pokomon edition isn't going to boost sales as expected, then we can see market saturation for the Switch taking form on it's home market.

Re: Hideki Kamiya Thanks Nintendo For Helping Make Bayonetta 3 A Reality

Tober

@yuwarite , As far as I am aware, it started after Bayo2 was announced to be wii U only back in 2014. He got a lot questions and hate for it. He tried to respond to it on Twitter in English, but because he's not fluent it was always broken English in a way. So the Twitter Mob, being the Twitter Mob started to make fun of him because of his English. That's why he's picky about it now.

Re: Round Up: The Reviews Are In For Bayonetta 3

Tober

I've read the Polygon review. There was no score at the end and this is a good thing.

In my opinion you cannot score a game based of how the story ended. Because that's subjective in if you liked the story's writing or not.

You can base a score how the story is told, but the reviewer does not elaborate on that. It's script versus direction.

Re: Bayonetta's OG Voice Actor Responds To Online Backlash In Ongoing Dispute

Tober

@VinylCreep Platinum has 303 employees and owns no IP for games itself. It's essentially a contract shop making games on other companies IP. I don't think it will be valued at $450M.

A tenth of that maybe, but that's only for a company that has an intimidate shortage of staff. But thinking of it, even that makes not a lot of sense because you can hire them for a project anyway.

Re: Bayonetta's OG Voice Actor Responds To Online Backlash In Ongoing Dispute

Tober

@nocdaes A VA is not part of the management team. So no she would not have access to any revenue projections or anything to do with perceived value of the franchise. There is no value for a VA to have access to this information.

Besides why would in preparation of the third game they would talk about perceived value of the franchise especially in a marketing prep for the 3th game? That does not make sense.

At the very best it would be part of the salespitch to Nintendo to fund the game. Which is something complete different. But even so if Platinum would use a number like $450m as a salespitch to get the game funded, Nintendo would not take them seriously. I mean Sega the ip-holder is not interested to fund games for it, would that be the case if they were sitting on a near 1/2 billion franchise?

As for background information the VA gets. she would have access to story boards, the script and planned promotional work. But only after she signed up for the job. Which she hadn't. So no.

Re: Bayonetta's OG Voice Actor Responds To Online Backlash In Ongoing Dispute

Tober

@nocdaes Why would a voice actor be made privy to revenue projections? That does not make sense. And if that would be the case, which is highly doubtful, why she not mention it?

Also $450M revenue projected on Bayo3? This is not Splatoon3 we are talking about. If the games sells 2 million copies, it would be the best selling in the franchise and Platinum will be happy.

Re: Bayonetta's OG Voice Actor Responds To Online Backlash In Ongoing Dispute

Tober

@Kaldrith Perhaps that is what she did, essentially tripled the number of copies. Still though using the US $60 standard price doe not make sense.

Example, in Europe a EUR60 price includes VAT, so you have to take that out (19-21% depending on country) to get to revenue.

Also you need to subtract the merchant cut from the amount to come to Platinum revenue and obviously the same for the IP holder, which is SEGA.

All assuming that platinum's revenue was correlated to copies sold and is not just a flat fee contracting job for first SEGA, then Nintendo.

In any way the $450M is a gross overestimation of what Platinum's revenue on the franchise was, let alone how much in the end was left as profit, if any profit was left at all.

Re: Bayonetta's OG Voice Actor Responds To Online Backlash In Ongoing Dispute

Tober

3000 Pound sterling for the first game, that was 2009. Taking into account exchange rates at that time, it was around $4800 for an unknown amount of sessions in 2009.

Taking into account inflation 3000 Pound Sterling in 2009, is the equivalent of more then 4000 Pound Sterling today. Which in current exchange rates is about $4500.

Re: Bayonetta 3 Dev Responds To Voice Actor Dispute In Official Statement

Tober

Yes the Video Game Industry has turned into a Billion dollar powerhouse, but that has a name: Microtransactions.

If you like development of games to become ever more expensive, because pay everybody more more more, then that's the only kind of games you are going to get.

There is something like a reasonable wage for the work you'd do. Sure everybody likes to have a bigger paycheck, but if one cries out 'it's to little', it's not always a reasonable ask.

Re: Bayonetta 3's New Voice Actor Asks Everyone To "Just Be Good To Each Other"

Tober

Hideki Kamiya and Jennifer Hale have been the subject of untold harassment by the twitter mob over this. How many of the twitter mob are going to apologize now to them. Will it be less or more then 1%?

I wished for Hellena Taylor to apologize herself and set the record straight, that would have been the most elegant resolution to all of this. There is still the opportunity to do so.

Re: Talking Point: Given The Voice Artist Controversy, Will You Be Boycotting Bayonetta 3?

Tober

@Mince Good points. I could be more sympathetic with her if the franchise was a knock-out financial success, but alas it's not.

Nintendo funded the last game and this one, because they want to diversify their line-up not because It's a money maker. No wonder it took 8 years since the last one. Not a priority, because not a money maker. Just like Metroid alas. We should just be happy these franchises get new entries.

Re: Talking Point: Given The Voice Artist Controversy, Will You Be Boycotting Bayonetta 3?

Tober

@Mince The first thing she claimed in her monolgue is that Bayonetta made $450 million profit. That is absurd. Not only because she has no way of knowing, but also since the entire franchise sold a little more then 3 million copies over 12 years. A money maker Bayonetta has never been.

She opened with that to set the stage, as a stage actress she would know. To paint a picture of her against rich company so to harness sympathy. She spread disinformation as a manipulating tactic to get peoples sympathy.

That should cause a red flag, let alone she want to see the work of hundreds of people destroyed that she walked away from.

Re: Talking Point: Given The Voice Artist Controversy, Will You Be Boycotting Bayonetta 3?

Tober

@Coffeemonster ". Let’s say Bayo 3 makes another $450 million. "

The franchise never made that money not in revenue let alone profit. That she claimed it had, should have been a red flag. It sold 3.09 copies according to VGCharz and no their not selling for $150 a copy. Let alone profit.

It was a manipulation tactic for her to start her monologue like that. "Me against rich company, please support me". Truth is Bayonetta never made much money at all.

Re: Talking Point: Given The Voice Artist Controversy, Will You Be Boycotting Bayonetta 3?

Tober

The article is written with a tone that is one sided. You have not heard Platinum's official side of the story yet.
It is written in using preconceptions she was underpaid, without knowing how many hours of work is associated with that pay.
You make assumptions that a large sump would be appropriate because the prestige of the Bayonetta franchise, without mentioning it has been doing break-even at best for the last 12 years. A money maker it is not.
You have not mentioned in your question to boycott the franchise, that we are talking about a wish off an individual to destroy the work of 300 individuals over a period of 5 years, even though she was not involved in any of that work.
You have not mentioned that not only did she deliberately tried to manipulate her audience by claiming Bayonetta made
450Million profit, whish is nonsense to any critical thinker, but even copying that claim that Bayonetta is some sort of financial success.
Every one can have their own opinion, but with an article like this some more due diligence can be expected.