Comments 110

Re: Poll: One Year After The DLC, Are You Still Playing Animal Crossing: New Horizons?

MelodiCat

While New Horizon's customization is great, the villagers are even more robotic than ever before. The villagers are the charm of the series that keep people playing. The setting also doesn't help; the tropical island vacation doesn't feel as "real" or human as a small town in the woods where you talk to animal friends. I'm hoping the next animal crossing game keeps a fair amount of the customization from new leaf but puts the focus back on the villagers.

Re: Xenoblade Chronicles 2 Sells Out In Japan Following Pyra and Mythra's Smash Announcement

MelodiCat

Everyone's discussing XC2 here, so I'll give my thoughts as well. XC2 had a smaller dev staff because many at Monolith were working hard on BOTW, and it shows a bit. The Merc Group system is very tedious and contstantly interrupts gameplay; if it could have been automated, that would have been great. Tiger Tiger is super unnecessary; why not salvaging via Rex be the way to get parts for an artificial, robotic blade? That makes so much more sense and would cut down on the amount of systems.

But my main critique of XC2 is the character designs. They're so embarrassing, to the point that if I tell someone about how much I love Xenoblade, I try to avoid any screenshots with female blades in them.

SPOILERS BEGIN HERE
XC2's narrative is good, but XC1's is better, imo. The character motives are clear and poignant in XC1. I haven't finished Torna (I need to get back to it), but Jin's motive makes no sense. His love of his life died, so he decides he wants to kill everyone else in the whole world? I mean, I guess that makes sense, but it's not that interesting nor believable. It's been done before; lol, I'm reminded of Super Paper Mario right now with Count Bleck.

Malos is also pretty weak. He's evil just because Amalthos is evil, and a driver and a blade are connected that way? It works, but it's not very relatable to us as viewers, as this evil-driver-affects-blade's-personality isn't something that happens in our own lives. Well, I guess people do have bad influences, so that is relatable there. But Malos wasn't influenced to be evil; he straight up just awoke evil because Amalthos is such such a bad person. In the real world, I think people have a bit more chance to do good. When Malos dies, I found his words very touching, as he realized he may have had a chance to do good, too.

Amalthos is a good villan, and I hate him so so so so so much, which is what a good villan can do. That said, he does once again suffer from the Count Bleck problem. "Something bad happens to me, therefore I must ruin the whole world!"... people are more nuanced than that. Many people hate the world because life's given them *****, but few would actually destroy the world for this reason. It would have been much more believeable if Amalthos just hated the speicifc country that destroyed his family, rather than just hating everyone. But I could be wrong.

On another note, I don't see the reason why Pyra exists. It doesn't really add anything to Mythra's character. I guess you could see it as a metaphor of wanting to hide behind another persona after so much trauma, but Pyra's a complete person, so that analogy doesn't exactly hold. A minor nitpick, though, as I love that both Pyra and Mythra exist, and Chapter 3's ending is sooooo epic!
SPOILERS END HERE

And that's the thing: these are all nitpicks in the sense that they are stuff I notice looking back. When playing XC2, it was an amazing ride with great gameplay and tons of twists. And even post-playing, I still love characters like Nia soooo much, as well as Morag and even Rex. But as a complete package, XC1 more effectively conveys a moving, well-designed story, and it's also the more polished game to boot, especially with definitive version.

But both games, while playing, are insanely fun, as is XCX. I recommend all three!

Re: Pokémon Detective Pikachu Shocks The Competition In Its Opening Weekend

MelodiCat

Not much of a Pokemon fan besides loving Pikachu, and I really enjoyed this movie! The writing could be a bit better—Lucy's integration feels a bit off and some of Detective Pikachu's funniest lines from the trailers are quietly rushed—but the CG and story is just a good time. If you don't like Pokemon at all though I could see you not liking this movie, though you would at least find it better than anything Illumination has produced... Poor Mario movie.

Re: Future Business Shift Could See Nintendo Move Away From Home Console Development

MelodiCat

The article's title is a bit too click-baiting/radical compared to the modest thoughts of what Furukawa actually said. He said that if the company needed to leave the console business, they would, because Nintendo is flexible. That isn't to say they will cleave the home console business, as the article title suggests is imminent, just that Nintendo could if they wanted to.

Re: Undertale - A Postmodern RPG Classic That Every Fan Of The Genre Should Play

MelodiCat

This is going to get meta, but what annoys me is not the game itself, nor the supposedly terrible fandom, nor supposed people who complain about the fandom either. What bothers me is that every internet section about Undertale has to have the preface of "the game is good, just not the fandom". Conversations about Undertale can never be about just the game anymore, and that makes me sad.

Re: Video: Fight For Your Right To Eat Sushi With This New Sushi Striker Story Trailer

MelodiCat

@MH4 I'm not sure what to compare it to as I don't play too many puzzle games, but I will say it is highly addictive. Your goal is to chain as many adjacent Sushi of the same color as possible to then send at your opponent, but the longer the current chain is, the faster the conveyor belts shuffle the sushi around. The game features a full story mode with anime-styled cut-scenes, an RPG-styled leveling and party system, as well as online! I still think it should have been in the $40-$30 range, but depending on when it releases I will pick it up!
Edit: It comes out June 8th!

Re: Nintendo Labo Drops To Fourth (And 17th) In The Japanese Charts

MelodiCat

Labo just seems too overpriced for what you get, and I think its sales will reflect that. It also doesn't have too much longevity in my opinion. Like, take the piano. You build it, and I guess you learn about how infrared cameras work? If you want to learn about music, there are much better keyboards out there. If you want to learn about robots, I think lego robot kits are better. The cool part is that the kid can say "I built that mini piano!", but it still doesn't seem too appealing. I hope the Switch stays strong regardless.

Re: Talking Point: What Games Are You Playing This Weekend

MelodiCat

@Tyranexx Yeah; right after I stopped playing XCX at 300 hours about six months after its launch I played through the original (though I kept switching to other games like BOTW, making my playthrough take a while), and then it was not much longer until XC2 came out, which I am now playing through! RPG's do take a while, but I will say that XC2 is tempting me the most to do a 2nd playthrough due to how many quality of life features they have been adding via updates and the New Game Plus only content. I ended up enjoying XC1 more than XCX as I preferred its combat and story, but XCX is still fantastic in my book for its side quests, character development, music, great world/atmosphere, and amazing exploration!

Re: Talking Point: What Games Are You Playing This Weekend

MelodiCat

@Tyranexx Yeah, the ending implies a future sequel, which is weird since they were not going for a story-based game yet we are left with a cliffhanger. I think the side quests in X are great if you enjoy side quests usually, and I think you should at least do Elma's last affinity mission (which to me is the game's real ending, as it is post-game only). After I beat the game I got 100% in all the side quests, and then went on to play the original. Now I am playing XC2 and am having a blast!