The Mother series—Nintendo’s odd, modern day RPG—is one that’s had a weird relationship the West. After the first game failed to leave Japan (despite getting a full translation), the second game was eventually released here under the name Earthbound, to little fanfare. Though the game didn’t receive all that much attention around launch, a small community of fans slowly built up around the series, no doubt bolstered by series protagonists Ness and Lucas making several reappearances in Super Smash Bros. games. Eventually, Mother was released overseas as Earthbound Beginnings, but the third entry in the series—a Game Boy Advance exclusive—has never seen a release outside Japan.
IGN recently got to talk to Reggie Fils-Aime at E3 regarding releases such as this in the West, and while the exec didn’t have anything to announce, he at least wasn’t dismissive about it. When asked for a potential Mother 3 re-release, or perhaps that new Animal Crossing game that everyone was hoping would be announced, Reggie had a standard PR response prepared:
When we have something to announce, we will. Fill in the blank of your favorite franchise. Our mentality will be we’ll announce information close to its launch date versus teasing people for years on end.
Even after saying that, Reggie had something to say specifically about Mother 3:
Again, we know, I know there’s a fan base for that title. All I could say is we’re aware. It’s something that we always think about in terms of where there are opportunities to reintroduce IP to fans, to do it in a way that builds new fans, we’re certainly aware. No promises, no commitments one way or the other, but we’re aware.
It’s interesting. I show up at the Belasco [theater] and one fan is saying ‘Hi, Reggie!’ and another is saying ‘where’s Mother 3?’
Lastly, Reggie spoke to the disappointment that he witnessed when Nintendo failed to announce a new Animal Crossing this year, but he would only talk about Animal Crossing: Pocket Camp:
I did see a lot of internet memes with sad faces from the Animal Crossing group. We see tremendous opportunity in using the mobile platform to introduce IP to consumers who may not be as familiar. Animal Crossing is a great example. Tremendous interaction with Pocket Camp. Fans are really enjoying that experience. We’re introducing it to new consumers. That bodes well for whenever the next Animal Crossing might come.
What do you think? Will we see Animal Crossing at next year’s show? Will we ever get Mother 3 out of Japan? Share your thoughts in the comments below.
[source ign.com]
Comments 94
Good. As long as we get those eventually, I can wait.
Mother 3 is so damn good. Among the best RPGs ever. If they'd brought it to the Switch, I'd actually legit pay $60 for it.
Essentially, Reggie is telling everyone to shut their d*** mouths.
Well get to it then. E3 was the first poor showing from Nintendo since the launch of the Switch.
Both would be great
My wife is mad at Nintendo! She is so ready for a new Animal Crossing. And the mobile game is no good.
So is my boi basically saying be patient and we dropping heat?
Even if it won't happen, I'M SO HECKIN GLAD HE ACKNOWLEDGED IT
They're aware. They're just not going to make it happen.
Well, u can’t complain about corporate speak this go ‘round. He just laid it out there.
“No promises, no commitments one way or the other, but we’re aware.”
This is obviously a fake Reggie, where's his signature "Firstly, what I would say is this..."?
Fraud!
Didn't he say something a few years back along the lines of, "Someone just asked me about Mother 3. Maybe you're here to ask me about Metroid. Get back to me a year from now and let's see where we are." I'm paraphrasing, but that was definitely the gist of it. Of course, Metroid Prime 4 has been announced since then, but word on Mother 3 remains silent. If someone would like to link the exact quote I'm referring to, that would be appreciated.
@Audiobrainiac “No promises, no commitments one way or the other, but we’re aware.”
That's his way of saying 'We hear you and we don't care, please shut up now.'
I don't dislike Reggie like some do here or in the web in general. I can see how one can come away from his Pocket Camp response as a bit dismissive. I wasn't expecting Animal Crossing Switch to be announced at E3. But will admit a little part of me was bummed.
Basically corporate lingo for "WE KNOW! Shut up. Stop asking. No promises, but we'll see". I think I'd get annoyed with being asked all the time about Mother 3 and other franchises.
Nintendo has proved a few times in recent years that they are listening to us. I think they're listening now more than ever, but you can only do so much and things can take a long time to come together.
Animal Crossing Pocket camp is a bad joke, but if it encourages Nintendo to make a real Animal Crossing game on Switch, a game that builds on, and even improves the already excellent Animal Crossing New Leaf Welcome Amiibo - that would be very welcome.
As for Mother 3, if at some point Nintendo releases a GBA Classic/Mini, we might see it then.
Animal Crossing on Switch will happen people! Hopefully we can hear something next year. I have never heard of Mother.
That Reggie... he’s a funny man.
That gave me no comfort or hope. Did it ever occur to Nintendo that making old customers happy could bring new customers?
Makes me wonder how many potential customers walked away because they did research on Nintendo by going to it's communities to get a better idea on why fans love them and saw all the rants and let downs. You know?
For example, if I were new to gaming and heard about the Switch and wanted to check it out. So I look up articles and see Reggie's statement of wanting to surprise fans, so I go check out forums and I see that isn't the case...that would turn me away.
I love Nintendo. I really do.But sometimes when you really love something, you sometimes have to yell "WTF" just so they wake up before smashing into a brick wall...
@Crono1973 yeah it can be translated to whatever u want. He didn’t leave much to the imagination this time, unlike other more diplomatic responses at least. They’ll never completely shut the door on it no matter who sits in his chair, because they wanna keep the hope alive, and stay in fans’ good graces.
@StephenYap3 all depends on how long you plan to live cause i think your in for a very long life long dream.
Seems odd he is even addressing it. Normally they'd (companies in general would) just keep their mouths shut on the topic or the usual "no comment".
May not neccessarily be Mother 3 but a return to the franchise could be interesting. More so if Nintendo keep taking shine to the JRPG genre.
As for Animal Crossing. Well duh.
H*ck you Reggie quit teasing us with your riddles and lies
Yeah but are they aware of what a let down E3 2018 was?
@Nomad Pretty sure everyone is aware how much E3 as a whole was a letdown. Probably why the industry is straying more from it.
It has been over 12 years since Mother 3 came out on the GBA in Japan. I don't think it would kill Nintendo to re-release it through the Virtual Console, or the Nintendo Online service, but the fact that a game this in demand has yet to have been translated and ported to the West is ridiculous.
Well, this video is fitting
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CePk795Xum4
@Deku-Scrub The thing that gets me is that there's an official quality fan translation from a few years ago that you can get on ROM, and the creators have publicly said that they would happily hand it over to Nintendo for official sale. Still no dice.
It's been nearly 10 years since the last console Animal Crossing.
Unacceptable.
And even that was just a lazy port of the DS game that had been released 3 years before it.
I see 2 possibilities...1 good and the other GREAT!
They could release Mother 3 as part of GBA mini bundle (just like they did with SNES mini & Star Fox 2). That would be good and it'd get more GBA mini sales.
Or
They could release Mother 3 in September as one of the games you get access to with an active Nintendo Online Account.
That would be GREAT! It would help sell the Switch AND the Online subscription!
@Yoshi Yeah that was kinda my impression.
Earthbound is a great series but it’s niche, I’d never get my hopes up on Mother 3. Though it might happens, who knows.
As for Animal Crossing... it’s just been too long, 5-6 years since New Leaf, Wii U got skipped entirely so yeah, a Switch announcement would be nice. Heck, if they just leave it as a mobile title at this point it’d be such a shame... since New Leaf we’ve gotten the Nintendo Land minigame, Happy Home Designer, Amiibo Festival, and Pocket Camp. It feels like the series has been reduced to spinoffs and it’s kinda disappointing. The series still has a lot of things it could add, and New Leaf was stellar.
I've seen people bring "Localize Mother 3" signs to WWE events. Thats how far this is getting....
It understandable. For example, I whine everyday that I want Digimon localized for my Switch but it's hard but hopeful. On the otherhand, if there's alternatives it's just as good. For example, Sushi Striker is like Digimon Daemon X Machina is like Armored Core.
"Tremendous interaction with Pocket Camp. Fans are really enjoying that experience. We’re introducing it to new consumers. That bodes well for whenever the next Animal Crossing might come." Wrong, Reggie, that user base has shrunk, ever since you added loot boxes! By the time it comes out, the hype from the app will be over- just like the Go hype is dead now! Yeah, yeah, 60 million MONTHLY users is nothing, the daily users is WAY smaller than that, and this thing at the top of the hype was generating hundreds of million of users!
@Spectra
Except we don't know how good the subscription service will be (it's already cheaper than the competition) and you aren't forced to buy the Let's Go games because next year they're releasing a traditional pkmn game (gen 8).
@Silly_G calling it a DS port means you didn't play much of either the DS version or the Wii version, because there were elements from the first game (real holidays, the return of the fountain, the return of Wisp, the return of Chip- I can go on and on) that were also in City Folk. CF isn't a port of Wild World, it's truly what IGN called it- "a blending of the prior games".
As a long time fan of Animal Crossing, I certainly don't enjoy Animal Crossing Pocket Camp. Gotcha Reggie!
He also said they were aware fans wanted the Virtual Console on Switch.
They are aware of everything. That doesn't mean they are going to do anything about it.
end my suffering and just give me a flat out "no", Reggie
If we have to wait for ACPC to become popular before they announce AC Switch we are going to need to wait a good while longer...!
"Our mentality will be we’ll announce information close to its launch date versus teasing people for years on end."
...except when it's Metroid Prime 4. Then we'll tease for years.
Every year we get the same appeasement statement. We know you are aware Reggie. You have been aware for the last 4 years...I WANT AGGRESSIVE / PRO ACTIVE NINTENDO PLEASE!
Pocket camp is bullcrap! Please give us a decent follow up to the new leaf !!
Maybe Nintendo plan to release A PORT of Animal Crossing Amiibo Festival from the Wii U ?
It's kind of trendy at the moment... Muhahahahahaaaa
@Davidiam007 I totally agree with that, but I think nintendo also should realize the amount of fans they had flying to other platforms after the Nintendo’s successive screw ups
Animal Crossing on Switch will happen in 2019. 2020 at the latest.
“It’s interesting. I show up at the Belasco [theater] and one fan is saying ‘Hi, Reggie!’ and another is saying ‘where’s Mother 3?'”
I swear, some crazy fan will spray-paint "Where's Mother 3???" on Reggie's grave
@ShadJV The only good thing about amiibo festival is that now majority of the animals and assets are made in HD. Would of thought that was the point of the game (just something to use the assets for) while a main game was in development.
Perhaps the tale would be different if the Wii U was a success, but it would be a lot of wasted time and money if they never do anything with them.
I would be very surprised if Mother 3 isn't used as a 'hype game' for either a Gameboy Mini type thing or the Switch Online Service.
Let’s just face it; Mother 3 won’t come. A game doesn’t take this long to localize, and Nintendo have also said that they’ve dropped the traditional Virtual Console, which means that they’re only releasing retro games with online play support from now on. All the odds are against it happening.
Just download the excellent fan translation of Mother 3 (alongside the game) because Nintendo isn't interested in releasing one of their best RPG's.
As for AC... I never understood the appeal after the first game. The first experience is great but after that... it's just another life simulator. With improvements but still just another life simulator to me... without the social pressures of real life so that's why I guess. AC will get released eventually because Nintendo will be swimming in money after that.
"We see tremendous opportunity in using the mobile platform to introduce IP to consumers who may not be as familiar. Animal Crossing is a great example. Tremendous interaction with Pocket Camp. Fans are really enjoying that experience. We’re introducing it to new consumers."
Fans of Animal Crossing are really enjoying Pocket Camp or fans of Pocket Camp are really enjoying Pocket Camp?
If you're talking about fans of Animal Crossing, then they aren't truly new consumers and they're asking for something else anyway.
If you're talking about fans of Pocket Camp really enjoying Pocket Camp, then how sure are you that they will translate into console buyers? PC offers a different way of playing with its constant events and updates instead of the much more laid back traditional AC. Can you get the free-to-play-ers to actually lay down some cash? Wasn't revenue from PC disappointing? Enjoying a free game is vastly different to investing £300 to play a console game.
Yes, and we want F-Zero as well. Don't forget about that one.
@Luffymcduck
"With improvements but still just another life simulator to me... without the social pressures of real life so that's why I guess. "
Animal Crossing is NOT The Sims that you have do care with your Sims (Feed them if they are Hungry, Ask them to take a bath when they are filthy, Socialize with other Sims , etc).
Life Simulator will be always Casual games. It will never ended, that's why games like that has Open Ending.
Not everyone can enjoy Peaceful casual games like Animal Crossing.
Only people who is really love with Kawaii stuffs and dedicated in gaming can keep playing Animal Crossing.
Btw, i have 4 copies of Animal Crossing New Leaf 3DS, I managed my 4 Different towns and i still play them until today since December 2013 (It was one copy on that year).
@Yoshi and rightfully so. A company can get this kind of memo from the first couple thousand demands or so; many folks don't seem to account for the possibility that the company listens but simply doesn't comply, especially in the spheres where they owe people nothing (like making another game in a series). Vox populi isn't quite vox dei, and even in the legitimate practice of wallet votes, the demand doesn't always generate immediate offer. Depending on the interests, abilities and strategies at the moment, it's all up to them to decide - we can but accept the fact that sometimes they really "don't want our money" - or, to be precise, they can do without our money.
Here's a hint: Just go for the rom with the english patch! Super quick and doesn't cost you a thing!
@westman98 let's just hope no crazy fans will ever drive their unfortunate human hosts to be responsible for said grave. :/
I'd put money on AC being 2019. And that's from someone who isn't really a fan.
@electrolite77 Animal Crossing in 2019 is a no-brainer. It MUST happen.
@Yoshi agree yeah they know but do they give a toss nope
Nintendo rarely release anything while people are crying out for it, they'd rather wait until the requests die down in order to make it more of a surprise. My theory here is; if you really want Mother 3 then shut the hell up about Mother 3.
Can't wait for their convoluted half listened response
Looking forward to a new Animal Crossing on Switch. Happy to wait if it means real changes / improvements.
I have earthbound on my snes classic edition, but haven't played it yet, but ive been wanting to, so I can learn more about ness and Lucas, and honestly, I don't see another ac game coming out for a while. Maybe at least two years out at least. I don't understand why people were disappointed about there being no ac announced, it's not like Nintendo said they would announce it or something, there wasn't even a single rumor, just hopes and wishes
I have to admit I bought and English language cart off eBay as I was desperate to ay mother 3 as originally planned on my GBA. I do own the original Japanese release! I don't personally pirate games but felt justified in doing so. They did a cracking job capturing the tone with the translation!
Errr......fire Reggie?
Really, how much effort would it take to put Mother 3 on Switch, especially when it already exists? Unless Nintendo is working on some kind of Earthbound Collection, I’m baffled why they haven’t localized yet because of the such high demand.
"Animal Crossing is a great example. Tremendous interaction with Pocket Camp. Fans are really enjoying that experience."
Not everyone is Reggie.
@Luffymcduck If you ever had the chance to play Happy Home Designer, it shows just how much potential there is for the franchise. For as deep as it already is, there is so much more that can be done with it. And I think its charm and sense of humor makes it more than just a simple life simulator
I gave up hope on that a while ago. Nintendo killing off the Virtual Console didn't help any, either.
Reggie: "You'll play Pocket Camp and you'll like it, you ingrates."
Got to love the large diverse Nintendo fan base where you can please one section with games and features from Ips the fans asked for, yet displease the next with what they don’t have and say they never listen to their fan.
The Switch has been out for a year, wait one more and then start making Molotov cocktails for Animal Crossing. Best case scenario, they’re doing a reverse Metroid Prime 4 announcement (working on it but keeping it on the dl).
As for Mother 3, well…. Hey I just realized it’s the 1st day of summer
Pocket Camp is an abomination
that's all I wanted to say
Switch seems like the perfect time to make Mother 3 happen. Also I wouldn't mind having a few other GBA games on that giant portable screen.
There's no way they're not making a new Animal Crossing. The series prints money and they already have HD assets they can reuse from Amiibo Festival to speed up development a little bit.
Considering they explicitly said mobile titles were designed to generate interest in core games on consoles, there's obviously going to be an Animal Crossing game on Switch to capitalize on Pocket Camp's popularity.
Mother 3 is still dead as ever
I’m sure an AC game will hit the Switch eventually. Mother 3 on the other hand.... 😑
@XenoShaun part of me thinks it’s a given that Nintendo is working on a Switch AC already... and part of me doesn’t trust Nintendo even knows what they’re doing with the series.they had that big update for New Leaf a couple years ago and I don’t know if they figured instead of making new ACs they’d just update that and move on... I thought the mobile title was going to connect to a console title in some way yet two E3s into the console and they haven’t even announced a title... and this is just too many spinoffs at this point to a series that shouldn’t have spinoffs. Spinoffs work for Mario because it’s a huge IP. Animal Crossing has had 4 mainline Western releases... and 3 spinoff games, not counting Nintendo Land’s inclusion. And that wouldn’t be too bad if it wasn’t for ALL the spinoffs releasing after the most recent mainline entry.
Know what series also did something like that? Star Fox, as they abandoned mainline Star Fox mechanics for a bunch of more experimental styles and only finally released a “new” one with Zero which was basically a soft reboot. Now I’m not much of a SF fan so I haven’t really cared there but it’s a worrying realization that AC is sorta just following that pattern. Nintendo does that when they don’t know what to do with a series to keep it fresh (the same reason they haven’t given a new f-zero since the GameCube). Heck, if they simply told us they were working in a Switch title, no game footage necessary, I’d be a bit less worried...
I'm not at all worried that a new Animal Crossing game is coming to the Switch, I'm just tired of waiting for it.
I understood why one never came to the Wii U. An Animal Crossing on the Wii U would have been very unambitious and might have turned out to be just as bad as City Folk. However, this fall it will have been a full six years since the release of New Leaf in JP. It is well past time for a new Animal Crossing to at least have been announced. They better be making something really special at this rate.
Remember the rumors of GameCube VC and Mother 3 coming to Switch VC before the Switch launched? Why would anyone create these rumors? What point would it be to generate hype that doesn’t come to anything? I can’t think of any reason besides click bait to get people to read these rumors on their websites to generate more traffic and views.
Well, y'know... Nintendo gotta surprise us at the right time that... not even they know, sometimes lol
Guy in crowd - "Come on Reggie! Give us Mother 3!"
Reggie - "How about this instead?" (eats fire flower and launches fireball at guy)
E3 2014
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CePk795Xum4
@Nomad yo do realize they were aiming for smash bros fans and even said that smash would be a majority of the event. So u just set yourself up for disappointment. While low majority of people were actually happy.
@XenoShaun You do realize that they warned you about the E3 and said that smash would take up a majority of the direct, so you set yourself up for disappointment. Plus a majority of people were satisfied in some way. Not worse than the Nintendo E3 back in wii days.Imo it was good if not including smash bros ultimate.
@Lazygamer17 Of course and about a million people have already pointed that out. It doesn't change the fact that even with a focus on Smash Bros, the presentation was poorly paced and Nintendo missed a big opportunity to build momentum for the Switch's critical second year.
As for the majority of people being happy with Nintendos E3 presentation, I think you might be a bit wrong there. Go and read the comments from some of the E3 articles and you will see the general consensus was one of overall disappointment. Even check out the poll Nintendolife did and you will see it was the minority of people that were actually happy.
Honestly who really cares what Reggie says when asked questions like this. You know it's going to PR speech because he doesn't control what Nintendo of Japan does. His job is to be able to respond in a clam manner, and he does a good job at it, but his comments aren't really important.
@Lazygamer17 I liked Nintendo's E3. One of the only conferences this year I did like.
Just release the entire trilogy on Switch, the first two are already English translated and only the third one need the localization. If anything remastered all of them in HD for Switch then create a fourth one to finish off the trilogy as fans doesn't count the first Mother game as that one was already known as EarthBound Zero.
They are putting Animal Crossing with Mother 3..............oh God save us all.
Translate it, put all three on a Switch cart, charge $60, get rich.
Someday, we're going to get a LONG and detailed interview from someone high up in Nintendo about Mother 3 and it's localization situation. Hopefully it'll come with the Nintendo Online Subscription service, if they get to adding Gameboy Advance titles. It would be cool, especially if they had Earthbound and Beginning there too.
As for Animal Crossing, it's going to happen, and I've had to reason to think otherwise. The phone game always felt like a means of helping to push the main series ala Pokemon Go for Sun and Moon. It's not bad in itself, but as a free-to-play phone game, it's not up there with the main series, so I never assumed it could hold as a replacement.
That aside, AC's gotten pretty big over the years and did great on 3DS. Having a life-sim title on a console you can play on the TV and on the go sound perfect for getting through your daily in-game responsibilities.
@UmbreonsPapa
I've played Happy Home Designer. Not really my thing, but they could add gameplay found in that title to the main games.
@XenoShaun People expect to much surprise games and stuff, they need to be appreciative of what we got and stop complaining. They even said they have some games they didn't want to show at E3 and have it's own Nintendo direct.
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...