Comments 959

Re: Nintendo Set To License All IP to Mobile Publisher DeNA

CaviarMeths

The best news here is that the online membership is coming. I suspect a true unified account system independent from hardware. This is also likely the replacement to Club Nintendo.

Also notable is that DeNA is now 10% owned by Nintendo... and 13% owned by Sony.

And yeah, Nintendo isn't going mobile. They're just doing what Iwata said they were going to do all along - use mobile to leverage their own IPs.

Re: The Nintendo 3DS Was North America's Best-Selling Hardware Platform In February

CaviarMeths

Lesser news, but the Wii U is also up YoY. It's still selling poorly, but it's still chugging along and picking up a little steam on the way. It's not much momentum, but it's momentum. I think 2015 will be its peak year. It would be following the same trend as the Wii, which also had its peak year the year following MK and Smash.

Fantastic results for Majora's Mask and Monster Hunter, and I'm sure NoA is pleased at the launch for N3DS as well.

Re: Flashcard Company Announces Initial Support for New Nintendo 3DS

CaviarMeths

@Takerkaneanite6 People aren't going to start stealing things just because they can. They haven't for the last few thousand years and they're not going to start now. People are generally pretty good at following the rules of society.

Piracy and theft is a relatively small market, and yes, it's bad. There are better ways to deal with it though. Updating firmware is fine and a good way to curb it. Competing with it works too, just ask Netflix and Steam. Sending a team of lawyers armed with cease and desist letters though is just wasteful, and that seems to be Nintendo's MO.

Re: Etrian Mystery Dungeon Just Misses Top Spot in Japanese Charts as New 3DS LL Climbs to Second

CaviarMeths

For what it's worth, I think Famitsu had EMD at 1st with about 70k, so the battle for first was very close. Either way, that's an improvement over both the last Etrian Odyssey game and the last Mystery Dungeon game.

Nice to see Majora's Mask still chugging along. Mario Kart 8 looks like it will crawl past a million some time this year too.

Massive drop for Dragon Quest Heroes, but pretty standard for Musou games. I'm impressed at the solid hold for PS4 hardware despite the big drop in software.

Re: Koei Tecmo Says Hyrule Warriors Has Breathed New Life into the Series

CaviarMeths

I'd just take another season of DLC for Hyrule Warriors over a sequel, really. I'm still used to being an MMO gamer, where games get expansions, not sequels. For a new game for Nintendo, I agree with everyone else that Fire Emblem Warriors seems like the most logical (and awesome).

And Dragon Quest Heroes is doing more to convince me to buy a PS4 than any other game right now.

Re: Full Details Emerge on Shin Megami Tensei: Devil Survivor 2 Record Breaker Launch Edition

CaviarMeths

@Quinn_Blackwood $60 in Canada.

Edit: Oh, saw your other comment. Nintendo of Canada publishes these games domestically, so there should be no currency conversion. 3DS games are normally $40-45. Etrian Mystery Dungeon and Persona Q are $50, so I had marked that up as the "Atlus tax." This game is $60, the price of a Wii U game. It is overpriced, even for Canadian 3DS games, even for Atlus games.

And the games are published domestically in the UK too, so British consumers aren't paying for a currency conversion either. £32 and $40 are almost exactly the same in terms of average wage vs price of game.

Re: Former Sega of America CEO Talks Out on the Company's Mistakes and Shares Thoughts on Nintendo's Hardware Future

CaviarMeths

I still disagree that Nintendo should be offering full games on iOS/Android. That would seriously devalue their handheld line, their bread and butter. But I do agree that smart devices are a powerful marketing tool and should be utilized to their full potential. The suits in Japan are sniffing them and poking at them with sticks, trying to figure them out, and hopefully they eventually do.

They're about 10 years behind in internet years (the Xbox 360 had online down to a science day one back in 2005) and really need to close that gap. I see it as their biggest weakness right now.

Re: The Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask 3D, Monster Hunter 4 Ultimate and New Nintendo 3DS Enjoy Strong Débuts in the UK 

CaviarMeths

Nice to see such an increase over MH3U, but this series is still going to struggle to gain traction in the west. The game is designed from the ground up to be played on handheld with local multiplayer at meet-ups, conventions, after work/school with colleagues/classmates, etc, a style of gaming that westerners haven't really taken a liking to en masse.

Re: Poll: Do Video Game Reviews Need To Have A Score?

CaviarMeths

The problem with a score is that everyone reading it expects that you can directly compare one score to another, even if they're not in the same genre, don't have the same scope, goals, resources, etc. People could generally agree that Super Mario Galaxy, Journey, and The Last of Us are all nearly flawless games, but for some reason, you assign them all a number and people start flipping out.

And in that case, what becomes important is the actual body of the review, to find context for that score. If it comes to that, the score is rather unneeded in the first place, no? It doesn't really matter that SMG is a "perfect" game, what matters is why it's a perfect game, and you won't find the answer to that in a number.

That said, summaries or tag lines are probably needed. Most of the time, I don't want to read through a 500 word review about why a game is terrible and not worth my time. I have stuff to do. I only read full reviews about games that I'm really emotionally invested in.