(3DS eShop)

Ikachan (3DS eShop)

Game Review

Ikachan Review

USA USA Version

Posted by Philip J Reed

Squids today...

While most people know Pixel's work from the excellent Cave Story, that's not the only game he's ever made, and exploring his lesser known titles can be a lot of fun in itself. Ikachan is one such title, released as freeware for the PC in 2000. That's four years before Cave Story, and you'll definitely see some overlap in terms of graphics, storyline and even some characters between the two releases.

Ikachan casts you as the titular squid-like creature. When the game begins you wake up in a cavern with no idea of who you are or what you're supposed to be doing — sound familiar? By exploring and speaking with friendly sea creatures you'll come to learn, piece by piece, exactly what's happening here, and what you'll need to do to help.

The narrative style is similar to Cave Story's, as the plot is never exactly spelled out for you. You'll learn tidbits here and there, and get given guidance on what you need to accomplish next, but the player will have to fill in a lot of blanks and assemble the pieces separately in order to gain a complete picture of what's happened here. For those who enjoyed that sort of passive narrative approach in Cave Story, this is a shorter but still rich attempt at the same. For those who were frustrated or confused by it, don't expect much different of Ikachan.

In fact to say anything about the story would be to spoil at least some of it, as the experience itself is incredibly short; we therefore wouldn't want to rob you of any of the possibility for discovery. Front to back the adventure lasted, for us, exactly one hour. That involved a lot of backtracking and level grinding as we had no idea what to expect, and we're sure that foreknowledge could reduce the playtime down to around thirty minutes, without rushing.

This abbreviated runtime is Ikachan's biggest drawback, but it's not its only one. Great concepts and big potential lie almost entirely untapped, as you guide Ikachan around and around a very tiny map, chatting repeatedly with the same NPCs, until the game's one and only boss fight occurs and the game ends. We don't mind short gaming experiences here at Nintendo Life, but we tend to enjoy the ones that offer something memorable. Ikachan comes close, but doesn't quite accomplish that.

Ikachan controls understandably for a squid; he can only propel himself in the way his head is pointing, and he cannot point downward. A press of the A button causes him to swim slightly in that direction, and pressing nothing causes Ikachan to sink down. As you explore the teeny tiny map you'll encounter bizarre structures that award you with upgrades, a la Metroid. However there are only a handful of these, and none of them get the chance to shine before the game so abruptly ends.

You'll need to avoid spikes and aggressive sea creatures until you find the upgrade that allows you to attack them by swimming into them. Once you do you can kill them for experience points, and earning enough experience will give you a higher level, which increases your attack power and health. This lends an RPG-element to the game, but again it doesn't really get the chance to be enjoyed, as we beat the game with a measly level 5 character, and that included a lot of grinding that turned out to be unnecessary.

Graphically it all looks nice, though the 3D effect contributes nothing except placing a nice backdrop further into the distance. It implies a scope and depth to the game world that the game itself doesn't quite support, with its small amount of cramped rooms and corridors. The music is understandably great, but the fact that one single song plays through nearly the entire experience hinders enjoyment a bit.

Conclusion

Ikachan is not a bad game, but there's very little to recommend it apart from its pedigree and connection to Cave Story. There's not much to explore, no real challenge, and no reason whatsoever to come back. It introduces concepts that depart almost immediately, and does not provide optional objectives, and its lone boss fight is criminally easy. It may be worth taking a dip, but don't expect much depth.

More Stories

User Comments (85)

Kholdstare

#1

Kholdstare said:

Hmm... I thought they'd at least expand the story a bit.
Definitely not worth $5, Gunman Clive is longer than this and costs LESS!

Collision_Cat

#3

Collision_Cat said:

A short little PC freeware game now being whored out for money with no expansion or extras to speak of. I hate you Nicalis

theblackdragonAdmin

#4

theblackdragon said:

geez, really? I thought they would've taken the opportunity to really jazz it up... I mean, I'll still be getting this, but i'm sorta wondering if I should just hold off for now and wait for one of it's certain-to-be innumerable remakes featuring bonus content...

akabenjy

#5

akabenjy said:

"There's not much to explore, no real challenge, and no reason whatsoever to come back. It introduces concepts that depart almost immediately, and does not provide optional objectives, and its lone boss fight is criminally easy."

I don't mean to be negative but how does this receive the same score as The Cave? You go from giving good games like the Denpa Men a 9 (which is a bit generous) to being overly harsh on a game like the Cave (I think a 7.5 would have been more reasonable).

gojiguy

#6

gojiguy said:

am I the only person who actually prefers short, sweet game experience instead of padded-out long ones?

Karakato

#8

Karakato said:

Well, I at least expected a 5 knowing. Was really hoping Nicalis at least added some extra elements (3D effects aside) to this game. $2 would be more reasonable or $3, but it seems that Nicalis is banking on Pixel's fame. They're planning to release Guxt, a shmup by pixel. I just hope they price it reasonably.

Marioman64

#9

Marioman64 said:

it's a nice little gem from Daisuke Amaya, I'll probably get it regardless of the price just to support him and his genious

Kid_A

#11

Kid_A said:

Oh, Phil. How I disagree with this score.
This game is more about the unique atmosphere and children's-book-charm than anything else. It isn't supposed to be challenging. At the very least, I think it's a showcase of Pixel's ability to craft games of a look and feel completely his own.

This is coming from my experience with the game as a free PC download, though. As far as I can remember, it can be beaten in a couple hours. I'll concede it doesn't lend itself to a paid release.

CanisWolfred

#14

CanisWolfred said:

Yeah, I heard this one wasn't that great. Looks like good fun, though, and for $5, I'll get to it someday.

Windy

#16

Windy said:

Is Boycotting the purchase of Ikachan until Europe get's Cave Story You know what would make no sense at all? If Europe got this game before Cave Story

Windy

#19

Windy said:

@TheLilK98 I live in the US and we have it. I'm just Supporting Europe by Boycotting Ikachan until Europe gets Cave Story. I know it's probably a stupid boycott and I will probably be the only one who does it. But Europe should have Cave Story and it's just rediculous they don't. What is it? a Tax thing? I'm sure my Boycott wont effect sales one bit but I will still do it and if Cave story comes out in Europe I will buy this game on that day :)

rayword45

#22

rayword45 said:

Another lazy Nicalis port. #3 best developer alright.

And they said they were gonna jazz it up with new content. What a joke.

BenAV

#23

BenAV said:

It'll probably never even reach the PAL eShop, and if it does, I'll pass. :)

ohhaime

#24

ohhaime said:

If only this was a two dollar game I might bite but five for a shallow experience sounds steep.

C7_

#25

C7_ said:

I was going to pick this up, but since this is just another lazy port by Nicalis I'm going to wait until the inevitably make another 5 versions of it that only add one more thing that people wouldn't even consider new like just swapping out the character sprite and calling it a new campaign.

Thanks for the review, now I know I can just pick up the free PC version and get the same experience.

Knuckles

#26

Knuckles said:

I'm a bit sad the game is rather short, but I'll still get it in the long run. My 1st playthrough of Cave Story, magical. Now its just fun to play.

Birdman

#27

Birdman said:

I'll get this for a rainy day, I guess, but since I felt shorted by VVVVVV and NightSky, it's nowhere near the top of my "games to get" list.

Eien1239

#29

Eien1239 said:

Wait was their any hidden choices like cave story? Gamexplain been lied to it might seem

TheDreamingHawk

#31

TheDreamingHawk said:

@theblackdragon Ikachan probably won't get a real remake, considering that well, THIS is the remake.

I'm still getting this, but I hope there will be some reasons to retry (Time trial, scores ETC)

But seriously, this review score is confusing as it sounds like it should get a 2

JayceJa

#33

JayceJa said:

exactly what i thought of it when i tried it for free on pc, its a short game that is pretty cool, but nothing spectacular, defintely not worth $5

DarkCoolEdge

#34

DarkCoolEdge said:

Way overpriced. They port a short free-on-pc game and charge $5? Are they crazy or what?

And Cave Story hasn't been released in Europe yet, you know what? Screw them, if it finally reaches our shores, I won't buy it.

They are lucky though, I'll probably get VVVVV sooner or later but I'm not sure about it, they don't deserve it.

accc

#35

accc said:

Ouch, sounds like this is more of a proof-of-concept demo than a full game. I guess I'll just be spending my money on Witch's Cat (Rabi Laby Gaiden) and Bloody Vampire this week.

TotalHenshin

#36

TotalHenshin said:

@gojiguy If this is essentially the same one you can get for free on the internet, then this game doesn't skimp on the padding. I just beat it for the first time in about 40 minutes, and a good portion of that was backtracking. I beat the boss at Level 3, and it still wasn't hard. If the 3DS version is essentially the same, I think many will feel their $5 were misspent. Download the PC version here (nearly PCs should be able to run this): http://www.tinsanity.net/ikachan/

lebad

#37

lebad said:

Where is cave story for europeans? :'( :'( :'(
For Ikachan 2€ would be great...

SilverArrow

#38

SilverArrow said:

@Phillip_J_Reed You've been lost me when you made countless comparisons to Cave Story. You even said it yourself; Cave Story came AFTER this. Comparing Cave Story to Ikachan makes sense; comparing Ikachan to Cave Story does not.

Nintendawg

#39

Nintendawg said:

So, as it turns out, our little squid is anything but titular afterall. This word has been abused, of late.
I enjoyed Cave Story on my DSi and its quality merits the $9.99 spent, but Nicalis is asking way too much for this. Lest they start making fans [really] angry, they should wisen up and start pricing releases like this one more reasonably.
Good review as always, Philip.

Philip_J_ReedStaff

#42

Philip_J_Reed said:

You've been lost me when you made countless comparisons to Cave Story. You even said it yourself; Cave Story came AFTER this. Comparing Cave Story to Ikachan makes sense; comparing Ikachan to Cave Story does not.

It makes sense for the reason that Cave Story is by far the more universal reference point for most gamers, and explaining similarities between the games is meant to give readers a better understanding of how Ikachan works.

IMHO of course.

Moshugan

#45

Moshugan said:

I thought releasing this was stupid to begin with.
It's a great little game still. Everyone should download the freeware PC version!

RevolverLink

#46

RevolverLink said:

That's a shame, I was hoping Nicalis and Pixel might use this as an opportunity to refine the game a bit. Oh well, I'll still probably get it at some point, but just not anytime in the immediate future.

theblackdragonAdmin

#48

theblackdragon said:

@Phil: regarding Cave Story vs. Ikachan, CS may have come second for PC, but it was the first to be repackaged and resold for money, so at this point, it's almost like CS has come first with all the retreading they've done through that game. i'd'a thought they'd'a taken everything they learned from porting and sprucing up CS over the years and applied that to Ikachan now. What a wasted opportunity. :/

rayword45

#52

rayword45 said:

@Chrono_Cross How mediocre you have started is more like it. I don't consider porting to be a feat of any major greatness, even if the games are as amazing as Cave Story.

ilovegaming

#53

ilovegaming said:

@Windy Well, I live in Europe and I appreciate your choice to boycott this game-even if you don't need to- very much. All I want is to play Cave Story on a portable system but it seems I'll never get to do so...And I would most probably buy all the other games Nicalis hasn't yet released in Europe if given the choice.

Ickaser

#54

Ickaser said:

I want to love this, but if it's still so short, I don't think it'd be quite worth my $5. (Gosh darn it. I was so excited...)

Squid

#57

Squid said:

So, let me get this straight; I can purchase this game for $5 or I can get the exact same thing on PC for free? Huh.

rosebud

#58

rosebud said:

Yeah, I'll probably just download the free PC version if there are no extras and it is really short.

Frozenx07

#61

Frozenx07 said:

If this was $2 or $3, I would have bought it. Oh well. I did a Google search for a mac version of Ikachan and can't find one. Does anyone know if one exists?

Azikira

#63

Azikira said:

I've wanted Ikachan since I read it in Nintendo Power. Sad as it is, I will get it either way.

rayword45

#65

rayword45 said:

@Chrono_Cross Well, since you said develop, I'll agree with that since they only developed one crappy iOS game.

But the ports? Those are great games IMO, they're just tarnished by the lazy, glitchy port jobs and immense whoring that Nicalis does. Cave Story in particular I consider a masterpiece of Metroidvania platforming, as linear as it is. VVVVVV is overrated but still fun, and NightSky is for the atmosphere moreso the gameplay I believe.

Had they published La-Mulana I'd definitely agree but they backed out in the most detestable way possible.

tyrone

#66

tyrone said:

Thanks for the review. However, I'm not sure if you're familiar with the origin or too familiar with the original Ikachan. The 3DS and PC version are the same game, yes, but there are a number of improvements on the eShop version. In bullet points I've listed most of the changes below, all of which you HAVEN'T MENTIONED in your review:

  • 16:9 widescreen support (original was 4:3)
  • 3D stereo
  • All-new background art
  • Some new character art
  • Actual title screen and ending sequences
  • Enlarged map with new areas, quest and enemies
  • Revised audio for 3DS

Regarding the length of the game. I've obviously played Ikachan an inordinate amount during development. We've also had a significant number external players go through the game. The average first-time for most players, including really good gamers is about 2-3 hours. If you were able to beat the game in an hour your first time through, that seems very uncharacteristic as the world is fairly large. We priced it at $5 with the assumption that players could get 2-3 hours their first time through the game. That's about $1.50-$2.50 per hour. I, personally, don't mind paying $15 for something like Journey, which is also only a two hour experience.

Take this all as my own opinion, I can't feel that you might be misrepresenting the game as it sounds like a review of the PC version and not 3DS version. I also can't help put to feel you're putting a rating based on price ($5) and not the game's own merit. Would you have scored it higher if it was .99? I'd say probably, yes.

Philip_J_ReedStaff

#67

Philip_J_Reed said:

Thanks Tyrone. I will of course confirm that the 3DS version was played for review (see our FTC disclosure above), and that the rating was in no way based on price. We appreciate the comment!

andreoni79

#68

andreoni79 said:

what have we done to be considered so stupid? I mean... we (european) nintendo customers?

Aqueous

#69

Aqueous said:

@tyrone - Thank you for saying what you added. Maybe I'll give a download, after the early buyers check for glitches.

ChibiJib

#70

ChibiJib said:

A score of 6 is above average, which is not bad at all! I don't understand why just because a game gets a 6, everyone acts like its a really terrible game and that no one should get it at all! Then when a game gets a 7, ONE point more, people say it's a really great game and everyone should get it! This refers to many games, not just this one...

Azikira

#73

Azikira said:

After beating the PC version, I am sad to say that my playthrough was indeed an hour long. I sadly wish it would have been comparable to Cave Story in length, and the pricetag for a free PC game is a little too steep for the content, but I would love to visit the world of Ikachan if a sequel ever came out.

Undead_terror

#74

Undead_terror said:

Too bad, I was would of bought this game for the game and for some club nintendo coins, but it's not worth it.

russellohh

#75

russellohh said:

@Collision_Cat Worst person ever, trying to make money to live off of. For shame. I mean $5, that's like.... 20 minutes of pay. He's a criminal! OFF WITH HIS HEAD!

GeminiSaint

#76

GeminiSaint said:

Okay, I compared the two versions side by side, and this is what's new in the 3DS version:

  • Revamped title screen.
  • Three save files.
  • Slightly polished foreground graphics (there are edge tiles lining walls now).
  • A neat lighting effect in the background.
  • A handful of new corridors here and there, populated by all-new enemies.
  • Revised GUI (there are hearts and bars now instead of just numbers).
  • Some enemies have been retouched a little (ie: crabs' pincers are a different color now).
  • Slightly expanded story (some dialogue was rewritten to make the plot and backstory a little deeper).
  • Revamped ending/credits sequence complete with all-new art.
    Yeah, it's still a short game, but I think it compensates that with lots of charm. At just $5, I think it's worth it, especially if you enjoyed Cave Story.
rayword45

#78

rayword45 said:

@Chrono_Cross Well, I'll have to disagree with that. I actually liked NightSky the least, but that I felt was a much more artistic game.

Also, over Cave Story, what's a better example of Metroidvania-style platforming in your opinion? Even with the linearity, it's better then, say, Shantae: Risky's Revenge (the other highly revered indie example I can think of) and has far less flaws.

VVVVVV is overrated, I'll be fair about that.

Cats

#80

Cats said:

CUTE CREATION FROM JAPAN... MOVE ZIG!!!
CUTER THAN ALL THE POKEMON.
I MADE MY TIME.

Gregor

#81

Gregor said:

@Collision_Cat they did it with Cave story too. The greedy basterds. Who do they think they are, Capcom? They can't get away with releasing the same game over and over and over again.

Kolzig

#83

Kolzig said:

It's been only eleven months and no European release, typical Nicalis behaviour.

Aqueous

#84

Aqueous said:

43 minutes long. Including my deaths, the credits and time on the title screen.
Glad I waited for a sale. Cute but I'm not sure I'll play it again anytime soon. Fun despite that.
Maybe I'll let friends try it.

TG1

#85

TG1 said:

Bought this when it was on sale recently. Took me about 1 1/2 hours to beat. It's a fun game in spite of its short length, and I really enjoyed it.

Leave A Comment

Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...