@DominionGamma Yup this is the downside to a cartridge based medium, GKC are a necessary evil otherwise we would have an N64 situation all over again just look at all the amazing ports Switch 2 already has now
Let's not act like Switch 1 wasn't full of unofficial GKC releases too, at least know it's pretty upfront what it is which is also why I find people calling them a "scam" pretty funny because they're literally telling what you're getting...
Besides most cartridges are outdated by the time they even release so at best on cart games are only saving you storage only.
@Glassneedles Sure this is just gonna be a "surprise" shadow drop from Sonic Central direct, sure they'll announce maybe an SF2 for end of the year or another new game
@StarCollector It appears that some games need to be re-worked completely for a Switch 2 port hence why companies do that back route of Switch 2 upgrade like Skyrim and Stray by making that version discounted on the eshop instead of an upgrade pack
That's why some games have a separate Switch 2 version as opposed to Switch 2 Edition. Remember the Switch 2 Editions are basically DLC so carts for them need to be backwards compatible so if SF is completely re-done port obviously won't work in Switch 1
Now could and should Sega release this on a proper Switch 2 cart, yes but that is another story.
Never played OOT, got the 3DS game but been on my backlog but I got burned on Zelda playing BOTW and TOTK back to back so never got around to it guess I may aswell just wait now!
@Solabound Yes I was a bit confused on this aswell but on the PSN store it's like £12 to "buy" the game which includes a "free" 30 trial period so not a full game price at least. If the Switch pricing is the same it'll just basically be one paying £12 to trial the game for a month.
@Sonicka It's because if they want to sell a game physically it needs an NS2 version & tbf the actual upgrade pack is like half the price of these ones so I think it's fair.
The free upgrade games won't ever get a dedicated S2 physical
@SBandy1 What? This is a news article & NL is reporting news this is news, it's not an opinion article. It's like how their reviews don't mention GKC or Digital only as cons because it's irrelevant to the actual game.
According to Serebii for Switch 2 Editions only physical is counted as digital sales count as Switch 1 sales, bit a weird but I guess it makes sense due to upgrade packs
@Kiz3000 Oh I totally missed your bottom point about the price, I assumed they were the same, yeah disregard everything I wrote then lol you are absolutely right!
@Kiz3000 Well unless the update is the same size as the GKC then it's negligible. Since the Switch 1 cart will be a GKC. Like with No Man's Sky the upgrade on the Switch 1 cart was only marginally less than downloading the Switch 2 version
@Serpenterror Japan does not use USD they use Yen. Converting prices like that is silly. If anything the locked version might still be seen as expensive over there.
@Chlocean I feel like NL needs to abolish scores or at the very least the summary at the bottom, I feel like some people just don't read the actual reviews...
My only concern is I hope this does not discourage companies from making Switch 2 Editions. TV res update and FPS update will still be welcomed for many games.
I ended up going digital cuz feel like this game (along with sports or racing spin offs) warrants that convivence so not surprised that almost half of the 1m are digital sales
Gen 10 coming out in 2027 seems like a brilliant decision not only allows more dev time but also allows the Switch 2 userbase to grow and for Nintendo to release a potential Switch 2 Lite
MNS UK Store also confirms not GKC so I guess this soft confirms any 1st or 2nd party games 10gb or over will be on cart? As Pokopia came it at about 6gb & so far that is only 1st/2nd party game to be GKC
@The_Nintendo_Expat Mostly about budget size of studio etc, Cyberpunk 2077 reportedly had a budget of $400m for example, from the tera leaks Pokémon barely has a fraction of that
Plus the fact Pokémon was handheld for years means it's not triple A
In UK Nintendo charged more for BOTW/TOTK Zelda Switch games then they did Pokémon so even though know Pokémon isn't Triple A
@Znake What are you rabbiting on about. Pokémon has never been a triple AAA game series. Game freak technically more indie with how small their studio is...
This just sums up all this pathetic hate is people rewriting history and making facts up...
@ShadLink U.S/UK/Japan charts have these games top 2 thus further proof that all this "hate" is nothing but empty internet hate. ZA also continues to dominate sales!
Already pre loaded both! Given how rare the genuine cartridges are glad way to play the games whilst preserving the cartridges, although sure in the future I'll be tempted to play them on GBA for the authentic re-experience!
Glad they didn't put these with NSO, not only do we get icons but not tied to a stupid sub and get Home compatibility! (Although I saw that note was apparently removed?)
Loool all these comments people don't realise that as soon there is a update your precious game card is essentially a GKC, I could not play a single Switch 1 game card game on my Switch 2 without them requiring some sort of download
@Oldstalk Yeah the comments are very bizarre. If this was a new 3D Mario fair enough but complaining a spin off sports game focuses on multiplayer is bizarre...
Comments 140
Re: "This Is Even Worse" - GTA 6 Code-In-A-Box Reveal Reignites Game-Key Card Debate
Don't know what's worse, no discs or locking stuff behind the "ultimate edition"
Absolutely poor from Rockstar
I suppose the only positive is since there will be retail presence we should be able to at least get usual retail discounts
Re: Dispatch's Free 'HR Violations Pack' DLC Removes Some Censorship On Switch
@solarwolf07 I have a Japanese copy of Cyperpunk and the game is a different build and is censored of nudity yes.
This is just seems like the devs are purely being lazy not wanting to make two builds of the game...
Re: Sonic Frontiers: Definitive Edition Switch 2 Box Art Surfaces Online
@DominionGamma Yup this is the downside to a cartridge based medium, GKC are a necessary evil otherwise we would have an N64 situation all over again just look at all the amazing ports Switch 2 already has now
Let's not act like Switch 1 wasn't full of unofficial GKC releases too, at least know it's pretty upfront what it is which is also why I find people calling them a "scam" pretty funny because they're literally telling what you're getting...
Besides most cartridges are outdated by the time they even release so at best on cart games are only saving you storage only.
Re: Sonic Frontiers: Definitive Edition Switch 2 Box Art Surfaces Online
@Glassneedles Sure this is just gonna be a "surprise" shadow drop from Sonic Central direct, sure they'll announce maybe an SF2 for end of the year or another new game
Re: Sonic Frontiers: Definitive Edition Switch 2 Box Art Surfaces Online
@StarCollector It appears that some games need to be re-worked completely for a Switch 2 port hence why companies do that back route of Switch 2 upgrade like Skyrim and Stray by making that version discounted on the eshop instead of an upgrade pack
That's why some games have a separate Switch 2 version as opposed to Switch 2 Edition. Remember the Switch 2 Editions are basically DLC so carts for them need to be backwards compatible so if SF is completely re-done port obviously won't work in Switch 1
Now could and should Sega release this on a proper Switch 2 cart, yes but that is another story.
Re: Zelda: Ocarina Of Time Description May Suggest A Faithful 1:1 Remake
Never played OOT, got the 3DS game but been on my backlog but I got burned on Zelda playing BOTW and TOTK back to back so never got around to it guess I may aswell just wait now!
Re: Square Enix Releases Final Fantasy XIV Online Switch 2 Gameplay Trailer
@Solabound Yes I was a bit confused on this aswell but on the PSN store it's like £12 to "buy" the game which includes a "free" 30 trial period so not a full game price at least. If the Switch pricing is the same it'll just basically be one paying £12 to trial the game for a month.
Re: Xenoblade Chronicles 2: Torna - The Golden Country Free Switch 2 Upgrade Confirmed
@Sonicka It's because if they want to sell a game physically it needs an NS2 version & tbf the actual upgrade pack is like half the price of these ones so I think it's fair.
The free upgrade games won't ever get a dedicated S2 physical
Re: Surprise! Final Fantasy X | X-2 HD Remaster Is Heading To Switch 2
@SBandy1 What? This is a news article & NL is reporting news this is news, it's not an opinion article. It's like how their reviews don't mention GKC or Digital only as cons because it's irrelevant to the actual game.
Re: Elden Ring: Tarnished Edition Will Finally Rise On Switch 2 This August
@TheExile285 FS aren't publishing ER, does that make a differnce or not?
Re: Nintendo Reconfirms Release Windows For Major Upcoming Switch 2 Games
Nintendo kept a Starfox game under wraps until a month before release.
Let them cook sure they know what they're doing
Year 1 and 3 were always gonna be bigger years in terms of software
Re: Price Controversy Did Nothing To Stifle Pokémon FireRed & LeafGreen On Switch
Feel like it was a missed op to not have a dual release on cart too. Maybe later?
Re: Here's A Look At The Best-Selling Switch And Switch 2 Games So Far
According to Serebii for Switch 2 Editions only physical is counted as digital sales count as Switch 1 sales, bit a weird but I guess it makes sense due to upgrade packs
Re: Bandai Namco Reveals Digimon Story Time Stranger Switch Performance And Resolution
@Kiz3000 Oh I totally missed your bottom point about the price, I assumed they were the same, yeah disregard everything I wrote then lol you are absolutely right!
Re: Bandai Namco Reveals Digimon Story Time Stranger Switch Performance And Resolution
@Kiz3000 Well unless the update is the same size as the GKC then it's negligible. Since the Switch 1 cart will be a GKC. Like with No Man's Sky the upgrade on the Switch 1 cart was only marginally less than downloading the Switch 2 version
Re: Completed Legends: Z-A's Pokédexes? There's A Shiny Prize Waiting For You In Pokémon HOME
Should have done this for base dex and then Hoopa for DLC dex. Needing both for just one feels like a missed opportunity...
Re: Splatoon Raiders Is Alive, And It's Out This Summer On Switch 2
@Lord Japanese page says there will be a package version at 1,000yen more so safe to assume U.S/EU will also have a physical release
Re: Japanese Charts: Combined PS5 Sales Can't Even Beat Switch Lite
@MrGawain PS5 has been a shambles in terms of first party software the fact they have to rely on GTA 6 is frankly embarrassing.
The fact that a football game is the 3rd best selling game on the platform says it all...
Re: Japanese Charts: Combined PS5 Sales Can't Even Beat Switch Lite
@Serpenterror Japan does not use USD they use Yen. Converting prices like that is silly. If anything the locked version might still be seen as expensive over there.
Re: Review: Tomodachi Life: Living The Dream (Switch) - BREAKING NEWS: Mii Life Is Still Bizarre, Hilarious, And A Bit Samey
@Chlocean I feel like NL needs to abolish scores or at the very least the summary at the bottom, I feel like some people just don't read the actual reviews...
Re: Pokémon Champions Bug-Squashing Update Is In The Works, Here's What's Being Targeted
Haven't had much chance to play Champions but I saw Joe from Serebii being very critical so things must have been bad!
Re: Looks Like 'Elden Ring' Will Be A Pricey Game-Key Card Release On Switch 2
$80 for GKC is rough ngl I think SE had their prices right with the FF7 games
Re: Mario Kart World Has Been Updated To Version 1.6.0, Here Are The Full Patch Notes
Wonder how people who paid extra to get MKW physically on launch feel now their game card is severely out dated feel lol
Re: Pokémon Champions Nails Down Switch Release Date, And It's Only Two Weeks Away
Assume this means Home to ZA compatibility will be the same day, right?
Re: PSA: Switch 2 Update Adds Handheld Mode Boost, Here's How To Use It
My only concern is I hope this does not discourage companies from making Switch 2 Editions. TV res update and FPS update will still be welcomed for many games.
Re: Community: Which Switch 1 Games Benefit Most From Switch 2's New Boost Mode?
Why is Hentai House: Lost Rooms so high up lmao?
Re: Japanese Charts: Pokémon Pokopia Gets Off To An Astonishing Start
I ended up going digital cuz feel like this game (along with sports or racing spin offs) warrants that convivence so not surprised that almost half of the 1m are digital sales
Re: Pokémon Pokopia Sales Surpass 2.2 Million Units Globally In First Four Days
Wow 2m for a Switch 2 exclusive? Impressive!
Gen 10 coming out in 2027 seems like a brilliant decision not only allows more dev time but also allows the Switch 2 userbase to grow and for Nintendo to release a potential Switch 2 Lite
Re: Yoshi And The Mysterious Book Estimated File Size And Price Seemingly Revealed
MNS UK Store also confirms not GKC so I guess this soft confirms any 1st or 2nd party games 10gb or over will be on cart? As Pokopia came it at about 6gb & so far that is only 1st/2nd party game to be GKC
Re: UK Charts: Pokémon Pokopia 'Undersupplied' At Retail And Falls Short
Ahh that explains why the place I usually get games from sent an email saying they had a download code for sale for it.
Re: Review: Pokémon FireRed & LeafGreen (Switch) - Red-Hot Nostalgia In A So-So Wrapper
Hoping for RSE next so I can then retire & store my cartridges for good, one of my Ruby ones stopped working so been scared to replay Ruby ever since
Re: Yes, Pokémon FireRed & LeafGreen Are Getting Home Support
@LastFootnote It's obviously intentional, they want you to experience the game intended first. Would make dex completion etc too easy too
That's probably why all tranfers Gen 3 to 4, 4 to 5 were all post game too
Re: Pokémon Winds & Waves Announced For Switch 2, Launching Next Year
Looks so good!!!!
We did wait 2 years for Z-A so fine with this, extra year dev time and allow Switch 2 install base to grow!
Re: Pokémon Presents February 2026: Time, Date, How To Watch
Champions shadow drop hopefully with VGC not that far away it has to release soon right?
Hopefully GC NSO games also shadow dropped
And obviously the big on Gen 10 reveal and starters! (Hoping for another fox!)
Re: Pokémon FireRed And LeafGreen Are Already "Best Sellers" On The Switch eShop Charts
@Cyrax77 Exactly this sort of mentality from people is so infuriating and comes across so pretentious
Re: Pokémon FireRed And LeafGreen Are Already "Best Sellers" On The Switch eShop Charts
The cope on this thread is crazy, people condoning piracy is wild.
Glad these are selling well! In the faces of everyone here hahahahaha!!!!!
Re: Pokémon FireRed And LeafGreen Are Already "Best Sellers" On The Switch eShop Charts
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAA NINTENDO LIFE COMMENTATORS IN SHAMBLES LMAO HAVE THAT!!!!! YOU LOVE TO SEE IT!!!!!!!
This proves the internet is nothing but an empty echo chamber!
Re: Poll: Will You Be Getting Pokémon FireRed Or LeafGreen On Switch?
@The_Nintendo_Expat Mostly about budget size of studio etc, Cyberpunk 2077 reportedly had a budget of $400m for example, from the tera leaks Pokémon barely has a fraction of that
Plus the fact Pokémon was handheld for years means it's not triple A
In UK Nintendo charged more for BOTW/TOTK Zelda Switch games then they did Pokémon so even though know Pokémon isn't Triple A
Re: Poll: Will You Be Getting Pokémon FireRed Or LeafGreen On Switch?
@Znake What are you rabbiting on about. Pokémon has never been a triple AAA game series. Game freak technically more indie with how small their studio is...
This just sums up all this pathetic hate is people rewriting history and making facts up...
Re: Poll: Will You Be Getting Pokémon FireRed Or LeafGreen On Switch?
@ShadLink U.S/UK/Japan charts have these games top 2 thus further proof that all this "hate" is nothing but empty internet hate. ZA also continues to dominate sales!
Re: Poll: Will You Be Getting Pokémon FireRed Or LeafGreen On Switch?
Number one and two respectively on the eshop charts not even out yet!
Thus further proving the internet is nothing but an empty negative echo chamber when it comes to Nintendo & Pokémon!
Re: Poll: Will You Be Getting Pokémon FireRed Or LeafGreen On Switch?
Already pre loaded both! Given how rare the genuine cartridges are glad way to play the games whilst preserving the cartridges, although sure in the future I'll be tempted to play them on GBA for the authentic re-experience!
Glad they didn't put these with NSO, not only do we get icons but not tied to a stupid sub and get Home compatibility! (Although I saw that note was apparently removed?)
Re: PSA: Pokémon FireRed And LeafGreen Switch Preloads Are Now Live
@TimeLordBurrito Yeah that's why didn't sell my Switch 1! Being able to trade with yourself for Pokémon games is a godsend
Unfortunately gen 10 would require another Switch 2...
Re: Pokémon FireRed And LeafGreen Officially Revealed For Switch
@Eek132 Welcome to the internet where everything is spun as a negative!
Re: Xenoblade Chronicles X: Definitive Edition Gets Nintendo Switch 2 Upgrade, Out Now
Awesome! Hopefully more SW2 updates are on the way!
Re: UK Charts: Mario Tennis Fever Serves Up A Decent Debut
@ShadLink Fifa/FC usually becomes like half price after a few months that is why, Nintendo games will always stay full price
So it's apples and oranges really.
Re: Poll: What's Your Favourite Gen 2 Pokémon?
Ahhh Gen 2 where most the new Mons were locked to late or post game or even very late post game! Very frustrating games in that sense...
Re: Metal Gear Solid: Master Collection Vol. 2 Switch And Switch 2 Physical Version Download Requirements Revealed
Loool all these comments people don't realise that as soon there is a update your precious game card is essentially a GKC, I could not play a single Switch 1 game card game on my Switch 2 without them requiring some sort of download
Re: Review: Mario Tennis Fever (Switch 2) - Slim For Singles, But An Addictive Core Gives It Online Legs
@Oldstalk Yeah the comments are very bizarre. If this was a new 3D Mario fair enough but complaining a spin off sports game focuses on multiplayer is bizarre...
Re: Oblivion, Skyrim And Fallout Switch 2 Physicals Will All Be Code-In-A-Box, Bethesda Confirms
Tbf Indiana being full cart not GKC is the most welcomed surprise. It's the newer game so makes sense more resources gonna be poured into that
The others I was expecting digital only so this doesn't surprise me