Comments 264

Re: Review: Ys Memoire: The Oath In Felghana (Switch) - An Excellent 'Less Is More' Entry In The Long-Running Series

nilcam

I didyn't understand why this game forces analogue stick usage. The controls are on a 2D plane and the player has to use an extra button to walk so there's literally no reason to use the analogue stick. It's clear that no one understands the usage case for dpad vs analogue stick. I wish more reviewers covered this. It would save me money and frustration.

Re: Anniversary: 8 Years Since Nintendo Unveiled Switch, The World Awaits The Next Reveal

nilcam

I'm not excited about a Switch 2. I really like the Switch but I'm more into retro games these days. I've done a lot of contemplating recently, and have realized that I haven't lived a Zelda game since Minish Cap. I like A Link Between Works, but I wouldn't say I love it. Zelda was my favorite Nintendo series but it clearly hasn't impressed me in a long time. I'm pretty skeptical that I'm buying a new console anytime soon.

Re: Poll: Box Art Brawl: Mega Man Zero 3

nilcam

Both NA and Japan have great covers but I have to give it to North America. The design of that cover is amazing. The movement through the image is beautiful. It's more designed than the others and that speaks to me as a designer.

Re: Reminder: SNK vs. Capcom: SVC Chaos Is Now Available For Switch

nilcam

I bought this instantly. Online is great and there were a lot of players on last night. It's an interesting game for sure and I'm enjoying it. I get the complaint about the price but Fighting games without online play are a waste of money for me. I own a lot of the ACA games but don't play them because there's no online.

Re: Here's A Closer Look At The 'Echoes' In The New Zelda Game For Switch

nilcam

I'm both excited and nervous about this game. This will define whether I'm still a fan of this series or not. I love most of the Zelda games until BotW. There were misses for sure before that game but it marks a completely new direction for the series. If Echoes flops for me, I'm likely some with Nintendo games, sadly.

Re: Talking Point: Could Another Nintendo Series Take Over The 'Traditional' Zelda Template?

nilcam

@Yoshif3 I didn't agree. Aonoma was messing with the formula as far back as Majora's Mask. ALBW want so popular that it would push the team out of the old formula. If it wasa huge success, the formula would have become untouchable. It seems that all of the hidden temples in Wind Waker were a preamble to the approach of the item works games.

I liked that ALBW did away with the sequence to a degree but kept the interesting dungeons and boss battles. BotW and TotK both had terrible boss battles and no real dungeons.

Re: Talking Point: Could Another Nintendo Series Take Over The 'Traditional' Zelda Template?

nilcam

I'm truly sad that A Link Between Worlds isn't the modern formula. It takes the best of classic 2D Zelda and adds in some more modern elements for a truly great experience. If they added in the combat from Minish Cap, they'd have a spectacular formula. Honestly, I'm not sure I'll buy any more Nintendo hardware. They've been my hardware of choice for the durability and their games. I find that I'm not enjoying their games as much as I used to. My main series was Zelda until BotW and TotK. Those games really fail my tastes.

Re: Talking Point: Which Games Were Just The Perfect Length?

nilcam

Persona 5 is the worst for running too long. I skipped as much as possible and still ended up around 90 hours. I beat P3 in less than 60 hours and that was pretty good. Chrono Trigger, as stated, is the gold standard for RPGs. Most classic Zelda games - specifically A Link to the Past, Ocarina of Time, Link's Awakening, and Minish Cap - are good lengths.

Games getting too long are part of the reason I love old school arcade games. Those can be finished in an hour or less and fighting games are satisfying a few minutes per day, pressing to huge amounts of time over a long period. Ultra Street Fighter II is one of my most played Switch games all these years later.

Re: Talking Point: What Is A 'Traditional' Zelda Game, Anyway?

nilcam

Regardless of how Zelda BotW is, I just found it bland. I like when bosses are puzzles; that's why I love Mega Man X and Zelda games. BotW had united boss battles and the game just felt tedious to me. It seems that this is the series new path and not one I'm particularly interested in. Zelda is the series that's kept me in Nintendo platforms so I'm not sure what the future holds in that regard.