@johnedwin honestly, I did factor that in while reviewing it. I love this game so much, and I didn't want to be blinded by nostalgia.
But no. In the end, I'm a critic who's played a lot of games. I have given out two 10/10 scores in my career, including this one here, and I stand by both of them. Reviews are subjective, at the end of the day, because humans are not robots, and I hope that I've explained my opinion here. It's up to readers to decide for themselves if they trust me! (and to check against other reviews if they aren't sure!)
@Friendly I mean... there's not much in the way of extra content BUT you can play it big on the TV AND Shu Takumi said they'd consider a sequel if it sold well so I say YES
@ComfyAko the kid is MAGIC. That's how the game handles it! The Harvest Sprites dump a kid with suspiciously similar genes on your doorstep.
@Burning_Spear it was, admittedly, quite hard to set my nostalgia aside for this one, but I hope I did alright. It is quite a dull game, but I honestly liked it more for that, because it made it feel so different to farming games of today!
@Korsica_Is_Best_Girl Please don't be rude. Myself, and many other members of the LGBTQ+ community, use "queer" as a term to refer to ourselves for many reasons, not least of which because it is a helpful catch-all for a number of different things, or an entry point for people who aren't sure where they fit in yet. Reclaiming words is a powerful practice that has existed for a long time. We're certainly not doing it for Cool Points!
@ComfyAko I mean, it's not GREAT queer representation, because being queer in a tiny rural Japanese village would probably not be quite as easy as the game makes it seem! But they haven't really rewritten anything, so it also makes sense that it's not really mentioned or highlighted.
Still, NB character choices in a farming game feels like a good step in the right direction, at last!
As for the child... yeah you HAVE to have one (because that's the story) but it's kinda sweet to see a lil kid with two mums being loved and taken care of in a game like this, even if you yourself wouldn't have had a kid!
@ShinEon I have a guide going up closer to the game's launch that answers a lot of these questions, but I see you've already had some replies! A lot of the weirder design choices are smoothed over, so it's easier (but still not EASY) to make money, especially at the start. Prices have gone up accordingly, though!
@Nintendencies they seem very similar to the OG. That sort of high-pitched BLOORMP from the menus is still there, and the weird sigh that your character does when using the bathroom, too 😊
@CharlieGirl Charlie I have to be honest, I meant this to be my final article but I have a couple more things scheduled that are still good (but less perfectly fitting!) soooo be ready for that 😅 We can say this is my final article though, since it was the last thing I wrote
@rjejr @d0nkeyk0ng_jR @ComfyAko Not to spoil the surprise, but there are a few more articles on the way. I scheduled a bunch of stuff over the last week or two, so it'll be like I'm writing from the graaaaaaaaave
@Toshiro_Baloney I'm not dead, so I'm not gone-gone, but I am no longer an NL staffer 😢 but I'm still hanging around! I might even join the live chat for the Direct later...
@MarioBrickLayer Yeah! It's a really engaging little base-building-ish game, but it runs out of steam really quickly, so unless you like replaying the same thing with not a lot of new content, expect to get about 10h out of it total
@Andee I haven't played much of it, because precision platformers just aren't my thing — even the ones that are about wanting to encourage people to play precision platformers despite being bad at them!
@mr_somewhere I played it on Steam Deck so I think I'm qualified to say that it plays alright with a similar control scheme. It would be easier on PC, though!
This review pretty much nails how I've been feeling! I'm nervous to play the game in case I bump into a game-breaking bug and lose all my progress.
But ohhh my god, the CHARACTER DESIGN ALONE is worth a 10/10. It's all so gorgeous. I met a giant dragon with huge, bulbous eyes, a mouse with gigantic glasses, and Aka himself is so bouncy and wide and I love him so muuuuch!!
But yeah, the bugs and lack of tutorial really bring it down
@ZZalapski I loooooove duck. It's a little bit hard to get hold of where I am, and I would need a dry run to make sure I get it right — it requires very different techniques since it's such a dark and fatty meat!
I would like to do goose some day too, since that's traditional in the UK, but surprisingly, Canada doesn't eat much goose. You'd think they'd be all about the geese!
Comments 1,327
Re: Review: Ghost Trick: Phantom Detective - A DS All-Timer Returns In Stunning Form
@johnedwin honestly, I did factor that in while reviewing it. I love this game so much, and I didn't want to be blinded by nostalgia.
But no. In the end, I'm a critic who's played a lot of games. I have given out two 10/10 scores in my career, including this one here, and I stand by both of them. Reviews are subjective, at the end of the day, because humans are not robots, and I hope that I've explained my opinion here. It's up to readers to decide for themselves if they trust me! (and to check against other reviews if they aren't sure!)
Re: Review: Ghost Trick: Phantom Detective - A DS All-Timer Returns In Stunning Form
@Friendly I mean... there's not much in the way of extra content BUT you can play it big on the TV AND Shu Takumi said they'd consider a sequel if it sold well so I say YES
Re: Review: Story Of Seasons: A Wonderful Life - Slow, Old-Fashioned Yet Fulfilling Farming
@ComfyAko the kid is MAGIC. That's how the game handles it! The Harvest Sprites dump a kid with suspiciously similar genes on your doorstep.
@Burning_Spear it was, admittedly, quite hard to set my nostalgia aside for this one, but I hope I did alright. It is quite a dull game, but I honestly liked it more for that, because it made it feel so different to farming games of today!
@Korsica_Is_Best_Girl Please don't be rude. Myself, and many other members of the LGBTQ+ community, use "queer" as a term to refer to ourselves for many reasons, not least of which because it is a helpful catch-all for a number of different things, or an entry point for people who aren't sure where they fit in yet. Reclaiming words is a powerful practice that has existed for a long time. We're certainly not doing it for Cool Points!
Re: Review: Story Of Seasons: A Wonderful Life - Slow, Old-Fashioned Yet Fulfilling Farming
@ComfyAko I mean, it's not GREAT queer representation, because being queer in a tiny rural Japanese village would probably not be quite as easy as the game makes it seem! But they haven't really rewritten anything, so it also makes sense that it's not really mentioned or highlighted.
Still, NB character choices in a farming game feels like a good step in the right direction, at last!
As for the child... yeah you HAVE to have one (because that's the story) but it's kinda sweet to see a lil kid with two mums being loved and taken care of in a game like this, even if you yourself wouldn't have had a kid!
Re: Review: Story Of Seasons: A Wonderful Life - Slow, Old-Fashioned Yet Fulfilling Farming
@ShinEon I have a guide going up closer to the game's launch that answers a lot of these questions, but I see you've already had some replies! A lot of the weirder design choices are smoothed over, so it's easier (but still not EASY) to make money, especially at the start. Prices have gone up accordingly, though!
@Nintendencies they seem very similar to the OG. That sort of high-pitched BLOORMP from the menus is still there, and the weird sigh that your character does when using the bathroom, too 😊
Re: Poll: Are You Still Playing Zelda: Tears Of The Kingdom?
@CharlieGirl right back atcha
Re: Poll: Are You Still Playing Zelda: Tears Of The Kingdom?
@CharlieGirl I'm putting some exciting things into the content cannon over here, and I got distracted by the front page!
Re: Poll: Are You Still Playing Zelda: Tears Of The Kingdom?
SOME OF US HAVE OTHER GAMES TO REVIEW, OLLIE
Re: Soapbox: Fortnite On Switch Is Five Years Old, And I Have No Idea What It Is Anymore
@Bizzyb haha, I'm sorry you had to find out this way! I've been gone since February!
Re: Soapbox: Fortnite On Switch Is Five Years Old, And I Have No Idea What It Is Anymore
Hey @JimNorman guess who got really into Fortnite since leaving NL (it's me)
Re: Apollo Justice: Ace Attorney Trilogy Announced For Nintendo Switch
YEAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOI
Re: Soapbox: How Zelda's Bad Economy Made Weapon Degradation Great Again
@Mrkittyhead @Kiwi_Unlimited it's just a one-off, I'm afraid... except I'll be writing more one-offs in future, too!
Re: Soapbox: Zelda: TOTK's Shrines Are Brilliant At Making An Idiot Feel Like A Genius
Okay but what did Queen Victoria like to eat? That was such a tease!
Re: Game Boy And GBA Coming To Switch Online Today
Getting to play Superstar Saga with my stupid new surround sound system is the BEST THING. I love the future
Re: Fantasy Life i: The Girl Who Steals Time Is Coming To Switch Later This Year
famtasy life
Re: Ghost Trick: Phantom Detective Gets Resurrected On Switch This Summer
never heard of it
Re: The Best Endings In Games On Nintendo Switch
@CharlieGirl Charlie I have to be honest, I meant this to be my final article but I have a couple more things scheduled that are still good (but less perfectly fitting!) soooo be ready for that 😅 We can say this is my final article though, since it was the last thing I wrote
Re: The Best Endings In Games On Nintendo Switch
@ComfyAko the Celeste team include some of my close friends, many of whom are gay, bi, and/or trans. The lead designer is trans too 😊
Re: Disney Dreamlight Valley: Festival Of Friendship Update Release Date And Contents
@rjejr @d0nkeyk0ng_jR @ComfyAko Not to spoil the surprise, but there are a few more articles on the way. I scheduled a bunch of stuff over the last week or two, so it'll be like I'm writing from the graaaaaaaaave
Re: Nintendo Direct Confirmed For Today, 8th February 2023
@Toshiro_Baloney I'm not dead, so I'm not gone-gone, but I am no longer an NL staffer 😢 but I'm still hanging around! I might even join the live chat for the Direct later...
Re: Watch: Zion And Kate Talk About Ace Attorney For An Hour
Thank you everyone 😊 I'll miss you all too!! And I'll keep an eye on NL, don't you worry...
Re: Nintendo Direct Confirmed For Tomorrow, 8th February
it's like Nintendo was waiting for me to leave 🥲
Re: Disney Dreamlight Valley: Festival Of Friendship Update Release Date And Contents
@presenttense Check out this guide!
https://www.nintendolife.com/guides/disney-dreamlight-valley-whats-the-difference-between-standard-deluxe-and-ultimate-edition
Re: The Newest Disney Dreamlight Valley Update Will Be Released On February 16th
@ReneeMerrick yeah, so did I. Turns out that was just an announcement for the announcement
Re: Random: The Ace Attorney Court Bot Is Probably Closing Shop Thanks To Twitter's New Rules
@MH4 ah, they largely run themselves these days. But I did a lot of work setting them up
Re: Random: The Ace Attorney Court Bot Is Probably Closing Shop Thanks To Twitter's New Rules
@MH4 I have about ten bots out there, all of which I'm very fond of (and took a lot of work!)
It'll be sad to see them go.
Re: Random: The Ace Attorney Court Bot Is Probably Closing Shop Thanks To Twitter's New Rules
@SpaceyCiel MMM is one of the bright points of my Monday!
Re: Feature: The Real Songs That Inspired Iconic Nintendo Music
@Rinc You might want to check out pages 2 and 3 😉
Re: Ghibli-Inspired 'Mika And The Witch's Mountain' Fully Funded In First 2 Hours On Kickstarter
@Joeynator3000 The developers have cited Ghibli as one of their main influences, and the key art is not a reflection of the game's actual graphics.
Re: Talking Point: Do We Need Another Pokémon Mystery Dungeon On Switch?
@Fuecoco IT'S FINE I'M NOT CRYING YOU'RE CRYING
you are right though 😅
Re: Talking Point: What Are You Playing This Weekend? (January 28th)
@MarioBrickLayer Yeah! It's a really engaging little base-building-ish game, but it runs out of steam really quickly, so unless you like replaying the same thing with not a lot of new content, expect to get about 10h out of it total
Re: Soapbox: Playing Games With Other People Made Me Realise That I'm A Monster
@Purgatorium I asked him this and he said "well you are a weird little gremlin"
Re: Random: Did You Know That Pokémon's HM 'Cut' Could Be Used On Tall Grass?
I am not a young Pokémon player — my first game was Pokémon Gold — and I did not know this
Re: Everything Announced In Disney Dreamlight Valley's 2023 Roadmap: Multiplayer, Olaf, And More
@Browny same, she looks like she's melting
Re: Quiz: Do You Know The Meaning Behind These Pokémon Names?
@Munchlax those aren't the names of the animals they're based on though
Re: Talking Point: What Is The Most Frustrated You've Ever Been With A Video Game?
@Andee I haven't played much of it, because precision platformers just aren't my thing — even the ones that are about wanting to encourage people to play precision platformers despite being bad at them!
Re: Random: 'Wii Shop Wednesday' Twitter Account Is Closing Shop
@Coalescence Quinn's pronouns are they/them, and nowhere in the article did it say that they hate their followers.
Re: Feature: 19 Things That Were Added In Stardew Valley Updates (That You Might Not Have Noticed)
@JugOfVoodoo oops, good catch!
Re: Feature: What Is The Difference Between Story Of Seasons And Harvest Moon? A Handy Explainer
@nhSnork I reviewed Hometown Story and Little Dragons Cafe so I'm also one of the few people that played both! They were just so... empty
Re: Feature: What Is The Difference Between Story Of Seasons And Harvest Moon? A Handy Explainer
@tektite_captain wow, really? I didn't come across that in my research but that's even MORE complicated if true!!
Re: A Guide To AGDQ 2023 -- Which Speedruns To Watch, And When
@Hero-of-WiiU Ocarina is on the "must watch" list, SM64 isn't on the schedule at all!
I think it's all virtual this year, no live crowd.
Re: Lucasarts Fans, Take Note: 'The Excavation Of Hob's Barrow' Is Coming To Switch
@Makrus64 I can't speak for all of them, but they often do, yes!
Re: Random: You Should Definitely Propose To Your Partner With This Gigantic Pikachu Ring
Folks, if you're reading a throwaway line about the existence of gay Pokémon fans and running to the comments to tell me that gay gamers in love are too niche of an audience, I promise that it is not that deep.
Also like 80% of Pokémon fans that I know fall under the LGBTQ+ umbrella so let's agree to disagree
Re: Lucasarts Fans, Take Note: 'The Excavation Of Hob's Barrow' Is Coming To Switch
@mr_somewhere I played it on Steam Deck so I think I'm qualified to say that it plays alright with a similar control scheme. It would be easier on PC, though!
Re: Soapbox: One Of My GOTYs Is A Game You Probably Haven't Played (But You Should)
@FantasiaWHT if you have the option, it's more of a mouse and keyboard game since a lot of it is UI!
Re: Level-5 Teases New IP Announcement Coming This Year
@JimNorman U FORGOT FANTASY LIFE THE BEST GAME EVER
Re: Review: Aka – Ponder And Wander In A Cosy Open World That Needs Some TLC
This review pretty much nails how I've been feeling! I'm nervous to play the game in case I bump into a game-breaking bug and lose all my progress.
But ohhh my god, the CHARACTER DESIGN ALONE is worth a 10/10. It's all so gorgeous. I met a giant dragon with huge, bulbous eyes, a mouse with gigantic glasses, and Aka himself is so bouncy and wide and I love him so muuuuch!!
But yeah, the bugs and lack of tutorial really bring it down
Re: Back Page: 8 Video Games That Would Make Perfect Christmas Getaways
@ZZalapski I loooooove duck. It's a little bit hard to get hold of where I am, and I would need a dry run to make sure I get it right — it requires very different techniques since it's such a dark and fatty meat!
I would like to do goose some day too, since that's traditional in the UK, but surprisingly, Canada doesn't eat much goose. You'd think they'd be all about the geese!
Re: Feature: 30 More Things You Might Have Missed In Pokémon Scarlet & Violet
@fromjtov that was a really cool spot, thank you
Re: Feature: 30 More Things You Might Have Missed In Pokémon Scarlet & Violet
@Kirbyo not sure what went wrong there, but it's fixed now! <3