Comments 384

Re: A24 Bringing Elden Ring To The Big Screen With Ex-Machina Director

HorseRenoir

He's a good writer and director. I love 28 Days Later, Sunshine, Dredd (apparently he was the real director in that) and Ex Machina. And there was an AMA recently in which he said he was on NG+6 on Elden Ring and playing Shadow of the Erdtree, so dude is actually a fan. So I'm pretty intrigued to see what he does. If this was made 5 years ago, this would've been made with Paul W.S. Anderson, who made those Resident Evil movies. So... have a little faith. We got it good.

Re: Elden Ring On Switch 2 Will Introduce Two Brand New Character Classes

HorseRenoir

It's not very substantial new content, but just having the DLC included makes it a very good deal. It's already a giant, meaty game, and the (excellent) DLC by itself could be a standalone release, it adds 45 more hours or so to the game. Too bad it's a game-key card, but if you haven't played it, I cannot recommend it enough.

Re: Poll: Do You Want Weapon Degradation To Return In Zelda: Tears Of The Kingdom?

HorseRenoir

@Dezzy70 I think so, absolutely, I love gathering resources in BOTW, but they need to nerf the Hearty meals and elixirs. There is almost no point to cooking elaborate meals which require a specific combination of rare ingredients, when you can just throw one Hearty Truffle in the pot and get a Mushroom Skewer that fully heals Link and gives him an extra heart to boot. A good balance, I think, is to only be able to eat them with full heath, but make them increase Link's maximum health for a limited duration, instead of it being a one-hit buff.

Re: Poll: Do You Want Weapon Degradation To Return In Zelda: Tears Of The Kingdom?

HorseRenoir

I think it's necessary to not make the game too easy and to encourage exploration, but tweaks are needed. My biggest problem with it is how you need to pause in the middle of combat to choose a new weapon. Even with the quick menu, it's intrusive. They should swap to another one automatically, or something. I could live with the quick menu not pausing the game, but I can imagine it being a hassle to some.

I think being able to fix them them in shops or with crafting materials is valid, but it needs to be costly, so people don't abuse the powerful weapons too much. As much as I think the durability system is important for balancing the game, it is kind of a bummer to get that Savage Lynel Crusher with +30 power, knowing its days are numbered. It'd be nice to have a way to not lose such a hard-earned weapon, even at a cost.

Re: It's Been Three Years Since We First Embarked On A Super Mario Odyssey

HorseRenoir

One of the things I love most about Odyssey is that it brought back a real sense of imagination that I feel was missing from the series on the Wii U generation. Super Mario 3D Land and World are great games, don't get me wrong, but I think they, for the most part, played it too safe with the gameplay and the worlds. A significant amount of levels in those could fit in the kinda bland confines of a NSMB game. And that even bled into games like Paper Mario Sticker Star and Mario & Luigi Paper Jam.

I love how wild Odyssey gets, and how it takes a lot of the old Mario level themes, and puts a new spin on them. I realize that some of the different art styles of some of the level aren't everyone's cup of tea, but I really like the variety. The Odyssey-inspired tracks in the next Mario Kart are gonna be awesome.

Re: Feature: Every 3D Super Mario Game Ranked

HorseRenoir

I really can't pick a favorite from the top 3. All phenomenal games. I'd still say 64 is my favorite, because it was the one that got me into gaming and no game has ever felt as revolutionary and magical to me, but I think the top three are better games in general.

Re: Paper Mario: The Origami King Almost Had EXP After All

HorseRenoir

@mariomaster96 The first two Paper Mario games did just that. It doesn't take long for enemies to start giving less experience, and that's pretty much the game saying to the player that you don't need to fight as much. Even if a game has a great battle system, it can get stale if it forces you to grind by battling the same enemies over and over, and the first two games did a very good job at making combat fun, essential for progression, and making sure it didn't overstay its welcome.

Re: More Than 200 Old Pokémon Are Being Added To Sword And Shield's National Dex

HorseRenoir

If you needed the expansion pass to have access to these Pokémon at all, it would be shady as hell. But from what I've gathered, you can trade these Pokémon with people who have the pass without you having it yourself, and I assume, you can transfer them from older games with Home. So, that's fine, I think. Still wish all the missing Pokémon were back, but hey, I won't complain about they adding more.

As for the rest... I mean, it would be better to have a decent post-game at launch, but I'd rather have a good paid post game than to not have one at all, like XY. I'm gonna wait to see if the content is worth the price, though.

Re: Nintendo's Smash Bros. Ultimate Countdown Reveals Unpublished Kid Icarus: Uprising AR Card

HorseRenoir

They should really make a remaster of KIU. I got used to how it controls on 3DS, but I understand those who didn't. Maybe releasing it on the Switch, with option for gyro or dual stick controls would finally give it the larger audience it deserves. It has addictive gameplay, a fun story and characters, great music... even the multiplayer is good. It would be a real shame if all that went unappreciated just because it was released on the wrong system.

Re: Feature: A 20th Anniversary Zelda Adventure - Playing Ocarina Of Time For The First Time

HorseRenoir

This is my second least favorite 3D Zelda game, but I still think it deserves the hype. I like all the other 3D Zeldas more than OOT (except for Skyward Sword), but when I really think about it, I can point out a bunch of flaws in those games in a way I can't really do to the same extent with OOT. It's a rock-solid, well-rounded package.

The other games have things that attract me more, but I completely understand when people say OOT is the best. I can only imagine how mind blowing it was at the time. I got into the Zelda series late, Twilight Princess was my first one.