@Wexter Fine by me. You know how people are interested to see how GRRM finishes his opus having already seen how the TV series turned out? In the same way, people would be interested to see how GRRM finishes it even with all the fan fiction that would exist under my rules.
If those authors had wanted to finish their stories during the copyright period, IMO 20 years is enough time to ***** or get off the pot. Maybe under my rules they might have.
@Yodalovesu I haven't played this game, but a score of 4 would be consistent, if not generous, given the text of the review.
If it's better than lots of the stuff on the eShop, that tells me there's a lot of dreck on the eShop that deserves a score lower than 4. And I'm quite prepared to accept that.
@Bratwurst35 I know what the rules are, and the rules suck. Given that the rules are made by humans for humans, and the rules are bad for humans, humans should change the rules.
@jsty3105 > I wonder. Are you in favour of comic character creators getting fair money from their creations? Cos it doesn't sound like you do.
Yes I am. But I think you and I would disagree on our definition of "fair".
Copyright should last twenty years or so. That's enough time to make a nice big wodge of money from something popular. After that, it's open slather.
The owners of the Batman franchise don't deserve buckets of money just for owning Batman. They didn't come up with Batman. They didn't finance anyone to come up with Batman. They probably weren't alive when Batman was created. So why do we have to pay them money if we want to sell pictures of Batman? What did they do to earn that?
If they want money from Batman, they can sell pictures of Batman like everyone else, and may the best Batman win.
If they want money for creating a character, then they can damn well earn that money by creating characters! Maybe then we'd have something better to watch than increasingly dull Batman movies.
You missed Griftlands. It's a roguelike double deck builder: one deck for negotiation, one for combat. It has a really cool setting and the stories get more interesting the more you unlock. Highly recommended. GRIFTLANDS.
I'm fine with this. Values change. There are characters in old games who glamourise smoking too, and you can bet they'll be next on the block.
It is a shame that they're not taking this opportunity to update the law to cover real in-game gambling mechanics with real money, which is clearly harmful too.
Copyright law is an ass. It's clear that there is something badly wrong with it, but we're never going to change it. All we can do is just pile on the disrespect and show it up for the stupidity that it is.
It's unacceptable that joy cons should have this flaw and still be so expensive to replace. They're basically consumables. We moan about this ***** when it's Hewlett Packard making their ink carts expensive, but we accept it from Nintendo.
(Glitter beat) Doctor Who, Hey! Doctor Who. Doctor Who, Hey! The TARDIS. Doctor Who, Hey! Doctor Who, Doctor Who, Doc! Doctor Who. Doctor Who, Doc! Doctor Who.
You know what? I don't even care that EA are wasting time porting this crap. I don't want the awful predatory money sinks they might otherwise be shovelling onto Switch. EA can eat a loaf of brown.
@Dezzy It's weird to me that people can think that positive female representation in video games is an issue that we need to take sides over. Does this mean that I need to educate myself? Where can I find a contrary opinion expressed in a reasonable way?
@ATaco Depends what the data is. It might be customer login details which you might be able to use to charge their credit cards for stuff you can sell. It might be secrets that allow you to set up an underground rival DLC store. It could be a game engine that you can populate with other assets and sell as a new game. It could be financial data that could be used to undermine or embarrass the company.
Clearly these guys just want to make a quick buck so they're just selling it.
Comments 364
Re: Hand-Drawn Game Guide Kickstarter Taken Down Following "Legal Trouble"
@Wexter Fine by me. You know how people are interested to see how GRRM finishes his opus having already seen how the TV series turned out? In the same way, people would be interested to see how GRRM finishes it even with all the fan fiction that would exist under my rules.
If those authors had wanted to finish their stories during the copyright period, IMO 20 years is enough time to ***** or get off the pot. Maybe under my rules they might have.
Re: Hand-Drawn Game Guide Kickstarter Taken Down Following "Legal Trouble"
@Mountain_Man A 20 year copyright limit like I'm proposing wouldn't harm any of those situations.
Re: Review: Baldo: The Guardian Owls - Exquisite Ghibli-Esque Art Can't Hide Tortuous Gameplay
@Yodalovesu A broken unplayable mess would deserve a score much less than 4.
Re: Review: Baldo: The Guardian Owls - Exquisite Ghibli-Esque Art Can't Hide Tortuous Gameplay
@Yodalovesu I haven't played this game, but a score of 4 would be consistent, if not generous, given the text of the review.
If it's better than lots of the stuff on the eShop, that tells me there's a lot of dreck on the eShop that deserves a score lower than 4. And I'm quite prepared to accept that.
Re: Hand-Drawn Game Guide Kickstarter Taken Down Following "Legal Trouble"
@Mountain_Man Maybe if the rules weren't so ***** stupid then people would have more respect for them.
Re: Hand-Drawn Game Guide Kickstarter Taken Down Following "Legal Trouble"
@Bratwurst35 I know what the rules are, and the rules suck. Given that the rules are made by humans for humans, and the rules are bad for humans, humans should change the rules.
But they don't and that sucks too.
Re: Hand-Drawn Game Guide Kickstarter Taken Down Following "Legal Trouble"
@jsty3105 > I wonder. Are you in favour of comic character creators getting fair money from their creations? Cos it doesn't sound like you do.
Yes I am. But I think you and I would disagree on our definition of "fair".
Copyright should last twenty years or so. That's enough time to make a nice big wodge of money from something popular. After that, it's open slather.
The owners of the Batman franchise don't deserve buckets of money just for owning Batman. They didn't come up with Batman. They didn't finance anyone to come up with Batman. They probably weren't alive when Batman was created. So why do we have to pay them money if we want to sell pictures of Batman? What did they do to earn that?
If they want money from Batman, they can sell pictures of Batman like everyone else, and may the best Batman win.
If they want money for creating a character, then they can damn well earn that money by creating characters! Maybe then we'd have something better to watch than increasingly dull Batman movies.
O
=+=
/\
Batman.
Re: Hand-Drawn Game Guide Kickstarter Taken Down Following "Legal Trouble"
More ***** caused by terrible IP laws. Under this system, money CAN ONLY be made by huge corporations that own old ideas.
That money was not coming out of Nintendo's pocket. That was new value being created.
IP law in its current form is terrible for almost all humans.
Re: Best Nintendo Switch Card Games, Board Games And Deck Builders
You missed Griftlands. It's a roguelike double deck builder: one deck for negotiation, one for combat. It has a really cool setting and the stories get more interesting the more you unlock. Highly recommended. GRIFTLANDS.
Re: Accessory Review: Inateck Ultimate Nintendo Switch Case
Better to have a hard one. No chance of accidentally pressing buttons or damaging sticks.
Re: New PEGI Gambling Criteria Means Old Pokémon Games Would Now Be Rated 18+
I'm fine with this. Values change. There are characters in old games who glamourise smoking too, and you can bet they'll be next on the block.
It is a shame that they're not taking this opportunity to update the law to cover real in-game gambling mechanics with real money, which is clearly harmful too.
Re: Talking Point: As The Fan-Made 2D Metroid Prime Game Is Shut Down, Where Do You Stand On Nintendo's Takedowns?
Copyright law is an ass. It's clear that there is something badly wrong with it, but we're never going to change it. All we can do is just pile on the disrespect and show it up for the stupidity that it is.
Re: The Amazing American Circus Is A Quirky Deck-Building Title That Arrives Soon
Griftlands is a highly recommended Deck Builder. Surprised not to find a review for it on this site.
Re: Purchase A Digital Copy Of Pokémon Legends: Arceus And Receive 30 Heavy Balls At Launch
Thirty heavy balls to bribe us not to read reviews before buying? I'll admit I'm pretty dumb, but I'm not that gullible.
Re: XEL, A "Vibrant Sci-Fi Zelda-Like", Will Launch On Switch In 2022
RemindME! 6 months
Re: A New Limited-Time Pokémon Sword And Shield Porygon-Z Distribution Event Has Begun
Yoinked it. Ta.
Re: Talking Point: Which Pokémon Legends: Arceus Starter Are You Going To Pick?
Cuteness is the only deciding factor when picking a starter. Rowlet.
Re: Head Of Xbox Shuts Down Idea Of Game Pass Coming To Other Platforms (Again)
Three cheers for platform exclusivity! Hip hip ..! ...
...
.
Anyone?
Re: Pokémon Unite Is Getting A Game Update, Here Are The Full Patch Notes
Still pay-to-win? No thanks then.
Re: Suda51 Hopes To Make No More Heroes Movie Or TV Show A "Reality"
A reality show, you say?
Re: The "Foam Pads" In The Zelda Joy-Con Controllers Aren't New
It's unacceptable that joy cons should have this flaw and still be so expensive to replace. They're basically consumables. We moan about this ***** when it's Hewlett Packard making their ink carts expensive, but we accept it from Nintendo.
Re: Review: Pokemon Unite - Pokémon Divides In Free-To-Start MOBA
> or spend $100
Wait. What? Are you ***** kidding me? How many better games could I have bought to keep forever with that money?
And how the ***** are we still calling such expenditure "microtransactions"??
Re: You Can Now Own The Bike From Pokémon Red, But You're Not Allowed To Ride It
Not allowed? You're not the boss of me.
Re: King's Bounty II Gameplay Trailer Shows Off Key Choices For Progress
It is now that I'm aware of it.
Re: 3DS System Update 11.15.0-47 Is Now Live
@Zeldafan79 > If your 3DS is modded is this going to brick it?
Yes. That's what stability means.
Re: Poll: Box Art Brawl #88 - F-Zero: GP Legend
Captain Falcon and pals look like a bunch of *****. Europe easily wins this brawl.
Re: Dotemu 'Apologise Unreservedly' As Streets Of Rage 4 DLC Is Unavailable On Switch
Don't worry guys. We're chill.
Re: Doctor Who: The Edge Of Reality Arrives In September Starring Jodie Whittaker And David Tennant
(Glitter beat)
Doctor Who, Hey! Doctor Who.
Doctor Who, Hey! The TARDIS.
Doctor Who, Hey! Doctor Who,
Doctor Who, Doc! Doctor Who.
Doctor Who, Doc! Doctor Who.
Re: Collection Of Mint Condition NES Games Fetches $30,000 For Goodwill
> Your feel-good story of the day
But I wanted crab news
Re: EA Is Bringing Another Legacy Edition Of FIFA To Nintendo Switch
You know what? I don't even care that EA are wasting time porting this crap. I don't want the awful predatory money sinks they might otherwise be shovelling onto Switch. EA can eat a loaf of brown.
Re: Round Up: Here Are The First "Hands-On" Impressions Of The Nintendo Switch OLED
Can't justify a whole new console just for an upgraded screen, even if I do mostly use mine in handheld mode. I'll buy it when it's a proper upgrade.
Re: Talking Point: Nintendo Switch OLED Model Looks Lovely, But May Also Disappoint
Good. I'll keep my old switch and save my money for a new Joycon or two.
Re: After Months Of 'Switch Pro' Rumours, Nintendo Officially Unveils The Nintendo Switch OLED Model
> a new wider kick stand
So no need for hundreds more stability updates?
Re: Nintendo Switch System Update 12.1.0 Is Now Live
I don't want an unstable console!! I NEED TO DOWNLOAD THIS PATCH IMMEDIATELY
Re: Soapbox: Super Metroid Showed Me I Had The Right To Exist
@Dezzy It's weird to me that people can think that positive female representation in video games is an issue that we need to take sides over. Does this mean that I need to educate myself? Where can I find a contrary opinion expressed in a reasonable way?
Re: Back Page: The Ten Best Crabs On The Nintendo Switch
What are the Zelda crab things called?
Re: Netflix No Longer Works On Wii U Or 3DS, So Where's The Switch Version?
I bet there's some stupid boring business mrah reason why Netflix hasn't happened yet on Switch.
Either that or the Switch's OS needs more stability before it can run Netflix.
Re: Back Page: The Ten Best Crabs On The Nintendo Switch
CRAB PEOPLE CRAB PEOPLE
Re: Electronic Arts Hit By Cyber Attack, Hackers Take Source Code And Tools
@Exciter89 Where's the revolution?
Re: Electronic Arts Hit By Cyber Attack, Hackers Take Source Code And Tools
@ATaco Depends what the data is. It might be customer login details which you might be able to use to charge their credit cards for stuff you can sell. It might be secrets that allow you to set up an underground rival DLC store. It could be a game engine that you can populate with other assets and sell as a new game. It could be financial data that could be used to undermine or embarrass the company.
Clearly these guys just want to make a quick buck so they're just selling it.
Re: Nintendo Halts Distribution Of Switch System Update 12.0.3
It's breaking under the strain of SO MUCH STABILITY! Oh God I saw this happen to Theresa May once.
Re: Nintendo Switch System Update 12.0.3 Is Now Live
One shiny internet point to the hacker who can tell us June 2021's new Bad Words.
Re: Random: How Many Crabs Can Unreal Engine 5 Render At Once? The Answer May Surprise You
CRAB PEOPLE CRAB PEOPLE CRAB PEOPLE
Re: EA Insists It Won't Turn Codemasters Into "Another Electronic Arts Studio"
Wow. They really take us for fools don't they?
Re: Where To Pre-Order The Limited Edition Zelda: Skyward Sword Joy-Con
Meh, I don't like blue things.
Re: Netflix Is Reportedly Eager To Expand Into Video Games
Why is there so much hate here?
Is the current state of the gaming industry such a precious gem that we have to defend it against new ideas?
Does it hurt anyone if a company attempts something and maybe it doesn't work out?
Honestly, what's to lose?
Re: Pokémon Trading Card Scalpers Are Causing Some Ugly Scenes Right Now
Humans are the worst.
Re: Random: Fans Are Having A Field Day Reviewing Nintendo Switch's Calculator
I saw a physical edition of this going for £6 at W H Smiths.
Re: Knockout City Goes Live On Switch Next Week With A Ten-Day Free Trial
Wow that looks like an all-out assault on parents' wallets and players' psychologies. I hope games like this become illegal soon.
Re: Zelda-Like Dungeon-Puzzler Elementallis Smashes Kickstarter Goal To Secure Switch Release
Looks like fun. I'll gamble a few quid on that.