Comments 425

Re: Random: In An Alternate Reality, Sega Published Pokémon

Buizel

This is interesting to consider, for two main reasons:

1. Would Pokemon have been as much of a success if published by SEGA?

2. Would the success of Pokemon have saved SEGA's position as a console manufacturer?

I'd say the answer to #1 is undoubtedly "no" --- Nintendo was just in a far better position than SEGA in the late 1990s, and the Gameboy had already absolutely crushed the Game Gear before Pokemon had come around. That said, it's unclear to what extent Pokemon would still have made a splash - there are too many variables to account for (would they have adapted their handheld/console strategy around it? how would they have marketed it outside of Japan? is Pokemon enough to get people to buy a SEGA system in the late 1990s?). It's also worth keeping in mind that SEGA of America was notoriously badly managed at this point so something like Pokemon might not have even made it to the West.

As for #2...it really depends on #1. Assuming that Pokemon was as successful with SEGA as it was with Nintendo...my suspicion is that we would've had the Dreamcast (or equivalent) a bit longer before SEGA ultimately went third party at the end of the 6th gen anyway. Too much damage was already done, and SEGA very much lack the innovation that has kept Nintendo afloat through the competition with Playstation and Xbox. That said, an absence of Xbox may have allowed SEGA to carve in niche in the console market well into the 2000s.

Very interesting to think about. Honestly, I'm happy that Nintendo ended up with the property as it feels very much at home on Nintendo systems.

Re: Introducing Sonic Frontiers, Arriving On Nintendo Switch Holiday 2022

Buizel

Looks like they've dropped Sonic in your average open world game. Nothing about this screams "Sonic" to me.

I'm quite skeptical considering (i) I don't think every game needs to be "open world", and (ii) Sonic Team haven't really made a good Sonic game in 10 years. But I'll try to reserve my judgement until we see some actual gameplay.

Re: Best Pokémon Games Of All Time

Buizel

While I understand the criticism of BDSP, having Platinum in second and BDSP in dead last (when, at their core, they're the same game) is a dead giveaway that maybe this list shouldn't be taken too seriously.

Re: Looks Like Pokémon Brilliant Diamond And Shining Pearl Are The Exact Same ROM

Buizel

@saanaito My thoughts exactly. Animal Crossing of all things managed to implement this with different people having different fruit in their towns. Why not Pokemon?

An alternative idea would be for player choice to have an impact on the region they play through. Maybe seasonal variants of the region which are determined by the player at the start? (e.g. you could choose to play through a winter version of the region while your friend chooses summer)

Re: Looks Like Pokémon Brilliant Diamond And Shining Pearl Are The Exact Same ROM

Buizel

From a programming perspective it sorta makes sense...but from a consumer perspective it's really not a good look, especially to those buying two different versions of the game.

The two version approach should really be done away with at this point. I understand that it promotes trading and sharing of experiences, but there must be better ways to do this within a single product in the modern day.

Re: Review: Super Mario 64 - The Best Launch Game Ever Made

Buizel

I think 10/10 is massively overselling this game for someone playing it the first time in 2021.

Sure, the game was incredibly impactful 25 years ago. But many aspects of it haven't aged particularly well (including, IMO, the controls, which are given as a positive). I think if a mechanically similar game were released today it'd probably score no more than 7/10.

Re: Sakurai Reveals How A Chance Encounter Led To Sora In Smash Bros. Ultimate

Buizel

Yeah I'll second the idea that Sephiroth was probably planned as the final fighter. Ending Smash with another fighting game character would've been underwhelming.

This does make me wonder how many of the third party characters were due to either chance encounters or pre-existing relationships between individuals at these companies. We like to talk about characters that make sense from a consumer perspective, but perhaps small-scale interactions behind the scenes are a lot more influential than most tend to think.

(That said, the sheet variety of Mii costumes shows that Nintendo isn't shy about reaching out to other companies about their IP, and vice versa).

Re: Video: How To Play Rare And Expensive Nintendo Games On A Budget

Buizel

Regarding the mortality of piracy...

Generally with old games I ask myself the question: "is there a way I can purchase this legitimately, in which my money will go to the publishers/developers of the game?"

If the answer is yes, I'll use the best purchase option available to me - usually some form of digital store e.g. virtual console.

If the answer is no...my first option would be the seek out the game in the second hand market. If it's unaffordable...I honestly don't see much of an issue in someone pirating the game, as the publisher/developer won't be getting any money regardless.

In practice this isn't something I resort to. There are too many current games that interest me for me to go back digging through games that I can't easily access. That said, I am a bit of a collector and for some consoles that I absolutely adore or have a sentimental attachment to (e.g. Gamecube) I own a few rare specimens.

Re: Games Within Games - The Best Video Games In Other Video Games

Buizel

Not Nintendo, but my favourite is Space Harrier in both Shenmue and Yakuza. I'm not old enough to have played this when it came out, but the version within these games' respective arcades is a great distraction from otherwise interesting games.

And as impressive as it was that Iwata squeezed Kanto into Pokemon GSC, and as shocking as it was at the time, I personally wouldn't count it. I recently replayed Gold and outside of the novelty of revisiting a beloved region, everything about it is pretty stripped back and dull IMO.

Re: Talking Point: Everyone Has A Bad Game They Love, So What's Yours?

Buizel

Sonic R and Sonic 06.

Sonic R was the first Sonic game I owned and its just so unique that I can't not love it. I would love to see someone have another go at an on-foot Sonic racer (and bring back tag and the balloon hunt!). Plus it was the first fully 3D Sonic game which was mind blowing at the time.

Sonic 06 is like watching a train wreck. It's also the closest we've had to Sonic Adventure 3 and did have a few neat ideas hidden behind its awful execution.

Re: Talking Point: Should We Be Worried About Screen Burn-In With Switch OLED?

Buizel

Weird to have this come back as an issue, given that it was a problem with CRTs back in the day.

That said, I've never experienced burn-in on any device I've had, whether it's an old crt or a modern oled phone. I think it's easy enough to avoid if you don't leave static images on for hours.

If you're gaming for hours on end on any device (moreso a handheld), chances are you should be more concerned about your health than your OLED.

Re: Where To Pre-Order Nintendo Switch OLED Model

Buizel

@RupeeClock Game charge the £309.99 retail price plus an extra £9.99 for either standard delivery or collection, bringing it to £319.18 =/

I'll look out for pre-orders on the Nintendo UK store or Amazon as they will undoubtedly offer free delivery.

Re: Where To Pre-Order Nintendo Switch OLED Model

Buizel

"Good old GAME" seem to be charging a minimum of £9.99 on top of the retail price (for standard delivery or collection), as well as charging you right away (unsure about this last one).

It's no wonder I've not used this company in years...

Re: Potential Switch Port Round-Up - The Wii U Games That Haven't Come To Switch

Buizel

No Sonic Boom?

At this point, I'm only really waiting for the Zeldas and Xenoblade Chronicles X from the list. Although I do hope for the latter that they make the UI look better in handheld mode than it did on the gamepad - the text was always way too small.

Yoshi's Woolly World would be great as well, especially if we don't see another new Yoshi game on the system. But that game's already received plenty of attention.

The biggest thing I'd like to see from the Wii U however is the virtual console. If they brought all of those games to Switch my Wii U would be nothing more than a HDMI-enabled Wii.

Re: Hideki Kamiya Shares Irritation At Speculation Over Bayonetta 3

Buizel

Have to agree with Kimiya on this one. I think it's clear that Bayonetta is progressing steadily...people are just impatient and entitled. When they want to show something, they'll show it. It's not like we've all individually commissioned the man to make this game and he's not delivering. We'll get it when it's ready.

Re: Nintendo Doesn't Have Anything Else Planned For Zelda's 35th Right Now

Buizel

I believe that we'll be getting these games at some point, but was always skeptical about this year. Certainly didn't expect an announcement before Skyward Sword is out, but Aonuma's wording in the direct (or at least the translation of his wording) seems to imply that they won't come this year at all.

Also - can we stop taking everything "insiders" say at face value? I'm willing to accept that they know more than the average person, but I think they've been wrong enough (or moved the goal posts enough) to make it clear that nothing that they say is a given.

Re: Talking Point: Do You Replay Games?

Buizel

I'd say probably around half the time I spend playing games is replaying old favourites.

There's just something nice about the comfort of playing a game I know I'm going to enjoy, plus also reliving some of the moments that might not be so fresh in my memory.

I almost always have a Pokemon replay somewhere in the background (I must've played through Gen 1 dozens of times, and the generations probably follow the geometric progression in replays thereafter). I've played through the Spyro trilogy to completion maybe three times now, and Mario Galaxy the same. I'm very tempted to give Mario Odyssey a third go. And perhaps the new reigning champions for stealing my life away are Persona 5 Royal and and Fire Emblem Three Houses - the calendar systems in these games (plus the class system and split pathways in the latter) really encourage repeat playthroughs.

Regarding the books: I only read non-fiction (I prefer other forms of entertainment to novels) so will only reread something if I need to refresh my memory!