Played it back on the 'cube. Got stuck on a dungeon. Revisted a year or 2 ago on PC. This review pretty much sums out how I felt about it. Now I'm older, the dialogue was a slog, and I've seen far better battle systems that just make this one feel that I had no real control over my main char let alone 'party'.
Good review. Certainly made me feel better that the game never clicked a 2nd time! At least I have Arise...
I don't own the game. I've not played it. I do know however, that the screenshots are absymal and don't do the game justice. The reviewer should have compared the game to games that they'd played, not once they've dabbled with.
Commenters! (Not video):-
Please stop talking about it when you don't understand, and saying "optimisation" like you work on this as an expert. Such engines that most of us utilise in the industry: UE4, Unity, GM, etc. We do not (usually can't) optimise them. This is not the point of them. They are not open, they're locked down tool sets. Sometimes one learns the engine and it gets you the jobs. We make the game — not making equivalent to Havok Physics (even BotW uses this) or writing shader compilation, rendering techniques, shadow volumes/mapping etc. THis is how most games developer are. Not C/C++ experts like previous eras where these legends now make the engines.
Witcher 3 is REDengine. P5R uses in-house engine. No Man's Sky has so much on a technical level that I do not have the effort to say. Doom is using id Tech. Resi and Monster Hunter are own engine. It is no surprise to you, big talented houses with own engines prosper here? Of Course Ark is using UE4
I would prefer less hardware-driven demands and more software. It is something missing. Remember there was bespoke versions of Dead Space, CoD on Wii and DS platforms. Did not fight to get the multi-plat version downgraded, it was a bespoke build. Many good games made just for these platforms.
Switch does not quite have the punch to run first party well for current standards. BotW is very lag game, and drops to mid 20fps many times. However, since 17 you can use this portably with a few hours battery. Trade off is always there. You can play open world action game on Steam Deck 60fps for how long...?
When I was studying, I thought we all wanted powerful consoles, realistic graphics, VR; and to play this on huge TVs systems and sat in home cinemas w/ surround sound. I got that totally wrong. I thought mobile games would dominate and kill off handhelds - also, wrong. Obviously (!), we want small portable screen core video games on low powered hardware.... but still expect latest 3D graphical tech to run!!!
Please hold your punches, some of us have to do this work to pay the mortgage and family. You don't argue with your doctor or mechanic and pretend to be expert. Only with us you do it.
@Debo626 agreed but thing is mate, what else has come out since that's high fantasy, open world? Always being told the market's saturated with that theme alone, I don't see that at all!
It's a shame Skyrim still has any relevancy at all now. It's been so long, we should have gotten way better open world high fantasy titles from the industry.
The term Metroidbrainia has been misunderstood for years. Kate fails to have done her homework on the history of Mystroidvanias nor understands the basics of Brainmospheric (Brmups) game design.
It's a fantastic game. I think 97 is too low. Once they improve performance, I reckon it will be higher based on my personal opinious thus far. I've been completely blown away and wish you all could experience the same enjoyment I am.
I hope all of you can appreciate that a terrific achievement has been made by FROM, for us as gamers, and pray that Elden one day comes to a Nintendo platform.
Wife and I finished it twice, 2nd time on hard. The pets/animal free DLC was cool - would like a big more information on this one to see if it's worth a 3rd playthrough.
NB: played a lot of roguelikes but this one is my fave.
A lot of this music isn't available on Spotify, and it's usually removed if it is. Quite frustrating. Even the linked playlist has some removed tracks already!
Comments 95
Re: Random: Modder Constructs Wii & GameCube Portable With "Reactive RGB"
@solarwolf07 it's 23 seconds.
Re: Review: Tales of Symphonia Remastered - A GameCube Classic That Shows Its Age On Switch
Played it back on the 'cube. Got stuck on a dungeon. Revisted a year or 2 ago on PC. This review pretty much sums out how I felt about it. Now I'm older, the dialogue was a slog, and I've seen far better battle systems that just make this one feel that I had no real control over my main char let alone 'party'.
Good review. Certainly made me feel better that the game never clicked a 2nd time! At least I have Arise...
Re: Video: Digital Foundry Provides A Technical Preview Of Fire Emblem Engage
@Ralizah can you elaborate on questionnable char design?
Re: Review: Dragon Quest Treasures - A Trove Of JRPG Goodness, Perfect For Beginners
DQ11 offered no challenge. To hear this offers less, damn...
Re: Talking Point: As Zelda: Wind Waker Turns 20, Doesn't Toon Link Deserve A Second Chance?
Doesn't matter what we want when Nintendo won't give it.
Re: Random: YouTuber Ludwig Announces His Own Super Smash Bros. Tournament
@Jacket_p how do you think people make money?
Re: SNES-Style Mech-Piloting JRPG 'Chained Echoes' Touches Down On Switch In December
Trailer gives me a headache.
Re: Sega Wants To Know What Mini Console Fans Would Like To See Next
Can't understand how any hardware could run Saturn games.
Re: Best Action Games On Nintendo Switch
Hellblade and action in the same sentence? All I remember is fiddling around aligning objects. Couldn't stand it.
Re: Site News: So, Where's Our Harvestella Review?
"the much-anticipated farming RPG"? Certainly not the reaction I got from it's unveiling.
Re: Review: Aeterna Noctis - An Ambitious Metroidvania That Doesn't Quite Hit The Mark
I don't own the game. I've not played it. I do know however, that the screenshots are absymal and don't do the game justice. The reviewer should have compared the game to games that they'd played, not once they've dabbled with.
Re: Video: New Switch Hardware Won't Stop Bad Ports
Commenters! (Not video):-
Please stop talking about it when you don't understand, and saying "optimisation" like you work on this as an expert. Such engines that most of us utilise in the industry: UE4, Unity, GM, etc. We do not (usually can't) optimise them. This is not the point of them. They are not open, they're locked down tool sets. Sometimes one learns the engine and it gets you the jobs. We make the game — not making equivalent to Havok Physics (even BotW uses this) or writing shader compilation, rendering techniques, shadow volumes/mapping etc. THis is how most games developer are. Not C/C++ experts like previous eras where these legends now make the engines.
Witcher 3 is REDengine. P5R uses in-house engine. No Man's Sky has so much on a technical level that I do not have the effort to say. Doom is using id Tech. Resi and Monster Hunter are own engine. It is no surprise to you, big talented houses with own engines prosper here? Of Course Ark is using UE4
I would prefer less hardware-driven demands and more software. It is something missing. Remember there was bespoke versions of Dead Space, CoD on Wii and DS platforms. Did not fight to get the multi-plat version downgraded, it was a bespoke build. Many good games made just for these platforms.
Switch does not quite have the punch to run first party well for current standards. BotW is very lag game, and drops to mid 20fps many times. However, since 17 you can use this portably with a few hours battery. Trade off is always there. You can play open world action game on Steam Deck 60fps for how long...?
When I was studying, I thought we all wanted powerful consoles, realistic graphics, VR; and to play this on huge TVs systems and sat in home cinemas w/ surround sound. I got that totally wrong. I thought mobile games would dominate and kill off handhelds - also, wrong. Obviously (!), we want small portable screen core video games on low powered hardware.... but still expect latest 3D graphical tech to run!!!
Please hold your punches, some of us have to do this work to pay the mortgage and family. You don't argue with your doctor or mechanic and pretend to be expert. Only with us you do it.
Re: NieR: Automata Anime Will Not Follow The Game's Story, Says Director
Will it not have the same music as well?
Re: Talking Point: Which Zelda Game Should You Play First?
Zelda 2: The Adventure of Link is objectively the best place to start.
Re: Video Game YouTuber Dunkey Launches His Own Indie Publishing Company
Bangers confirmed
Re: Review: Shovel Knight Dig - A Finely Formed Roguelite That Strikes 16-Bit Gold
Another roguelike? Groan.. it is Shovel Knight, but... :/
Re: Wizorb Brings Fantasy-Style Breakout To Switch Next Month
A true classic
Re: Skyrim Anniversary Edition Has Been Rated For Nintendo Switch (Again)
@SpaceboyScreams i love Elden, but it's a taken a ten+ year gap between the games in question
Re: Skyrim Anniversary Edition Has Been Rated For Nintendo Switch (Again)
@Debo626 agreed but thing is mate, what else has come out since that's high fantasy, open world? Always being told the market's saturated with that theme alone, I don't see that at all!
Re: Skyrim Anniversary Edition Has Been Rated For Nintendo Switch (Again)
It's a shame Skyrim still has any relevancy at all now. It's been so long, we should have gotten way better open world high fantasy titles from the industry.
Re: Review: Fire Emblem Warriors: Three Hopes - Musou Magic That Ranks Among The Best
Would be nice if the enemies actually fought back in this game
Re: Apparently We're Getting More Info On The Final Fantasy IX Show This Week
To think back in the day we got FF7, 8, 9, and Tactics on one console...
Re: Poll: Which Dormant Capcom Franchise Would You Like To See Return?
Steel Battalion is just so unique a game, and something I've never seen the likes of since that original Xbox game.
Re: Feature: What The Heck Is A 'MetroidBrainia'? Introducing The Newest Genre On The Block
The term Metroidbrainia has been misunderstood for years. Kate fails to have done her homework on the history of Mystroidvanias nor understands the basics of Brainmospheric (Brmups) game design.
Re: It's Official, FIST: Forged in Shadow Torch Hops Onto Switch Later This Year
Hopping onto Switch later this year - one frame at a time!
Re: Nintendo Issues Joy-Con Safety Warning Ahead Of Switch Sports Release
Do they warn about drift safety as well?
Re: F-Zero X Joins Nintendo Switch Online's Expansion Pack Later This Week
Got my hopes up. Nintendo make themselves hard to like.
Re: Random: Elden Ring And Mario Odyssey Jostle For No. 1 On OpenCritic's 'Best Game' List
It's a fantastic game. I think 97 is too low. Once they improve performance, I reckon it will be higher based on my personal opinious thus far. I've been completely blown away and wish you all could experience the same enjoyment I am.
I hope all of you can appreciate that a terrific achievement has been made by FROM, for us as gamers, and pray that Elden one day comes to a Nintendo platform.
Re: 'Swords & Bones' Looks To Resurrect The Spirit Of Classic 16-Bit Adventures On Switch
Games like these need killer soundtracks. It's what makes a great Castlevania for example.
Re: Best Retro Nintendo Switch Games - Modern Games With Old-School Style
Would not recommend 198X to anyone. Way too short to hand money over for it, sadly.
Re: Feature: 14 Nintendo Switch Ports We'd Still Love To See
Can't see most games people seem to want being able to run on the Switch.
Re: Capcom's Former Switch Exclusive Monster Hunter Rise Is Off To A Great Start On Steam
Expensive upgrade for PC to start all over again.
Re: Metroid Dread: What To Do When You Arrive In Dairon
You aren't heading eastwards. You're heading to the left... Might want to edit that
Re: Record Of Lodoss War: Deedlit In Wonder Labyrinth Is Coming To Switch This Year
Great game -r eally enjoyed it. be warned, it is short.
Re: Nintendo's Switch Exclusive Metroid Dread Is Already Being Emulated On PC
The more people that can play it the better.
Re: Talking Point: What Are You Playing This Weekend? (October 9th)
Re: Poll: Metroid Dread Is Out Today On Switch, Are You Getting It?
@Sam_TSM step your game up
Re: It Seems Masahiro Sakurai Will Be Ending His Famitsu Columns Very Soon
Kid Icarus Uprising 2
Re: Video: Why Didn't Square Enix Port The Kingdom Hearts Collection To Switch?
MVG is a DEV. and knows more about this than most of you, who are just players. You wouldn't question a doctor or a pilot...
Re: Children Of Morta Has 'The Ancient Spirits' DLC On The Way, Free Update Out Now
Wife and I finished it twice, 2nd time on hard. The pets/animal free DLC was cool - would like a big more information on this one to see if it's worth a 3rd playthrough.
NB: played a lot of roguelikes but this one is my fave.
Re: Best Castlevania Games On Nintendo Consoles
@anoyonmus guess they heard me. Hah!
Re: Feature: Banjo And Final Fantasy On The Radio? VGM On Classic FM Was Only The Beginning
A lot of this music isn't available on Spotify, and it's usually removed if it is. Quite frustrating. Even the linked playlist has some removed tracks already!
Re: Astria Ascending Showcases Combat In New Trailer
Looks like a mobile game.
Re: Rumour: Nintendo Will Expand Its Switch Online Service With Game Boy And Game Boy Color Titles
Would not excite me.
Re: Castlevania Netflix Producer Files Lawsuit After Being Excluded From Spin-Off Series
Shame that both the writer and producer are now left out. It's certainly going to be a very different show.
Re: Cave's Shmup Espgaluda II Is Targeting A September Switch Release In Japan
It's getting frustrating to see these games remain Japanese exclusives.
Re: Konami's Castlevania: Grimoire Of Souls Rises From The Dead
THE WIFE IS GOING TO FIND HER IPAD IS MISSING FOR A FEW DAYS.
Re: Grand Theft Auto Remastered Trilogy Reportedly Heading To Switch
Honestly expected more folk to be demanding GTA V on Switch.
Re: Review: G-Darius HD - A True Shmup Legend Reimagined For The High-Def Era
I'd like to see a standalone G-Darius HD in the west.
Re: Limited Run Games Is Publishing SNES And Virtual Boy Retrospective Books
@JJtheTexan meanwhile GRRM is laughing at the notion of "finishing books"