That review read more like an 8 or a 9 than a 7, imo. I don't think anything mentioned was negative. I was surprised by the praise in the review, and then surprised again when I saw the score.
Launch games always have a unique place in the market. They usually get more leniency from reviewers as there isn't an established library demonstrating what a game is capable of, and as stated early adopters of hardware are also some of the most prolific consumers of software.
Like any other platform, as more and more games arrive, the harder it will be for any particular game to stand out. We're already seeing that with the Switch.
@impurekind "and you're not stating it like it's an opinion; you're stating it like it's an indisputable fact." I haven't done anything of the sort. I was merely pointing out that you made an assertion and have refused to actually support that assertion, and instead have attempted to shift the burden of proof onto others.
You're trying to use weasel words, but when you say there's pretty much zero doubt something could happen, you're making an assertion that it could happen. Your weasel words don't change the semantic content of the message. Back up your assertion, and if you can't, don't be surprised when you get called out on it, as you have been here.
@impurekind You are the one that made an assertion: that Nintendo could make a hardware replica of the original SNES with perfect accuracy for $70.
Others disputed your assertion, and instead of backing up your assertion with evidence, you have attempted to put the burden of proof on them, asking them to prove that what you said isn't possible. But that's not how evidence works. It's impossible to prove a negative; you made an assertion, and you should provide actual evidence of your own to support that assertion.
I'm sure I'm too far down in the comments for anyone to see this, but...
I think it's smart to not show NX if it's not going to be ready for the holiday. Too long of a delay kills hype. Look at the 3DS. Most info was known in leaks in the months before e3. It debuted at e3 to rave reviews; the glasses-free 3D was the greatest thing since sliced bread. By the time it launched in March 2011, pretty much everyone had forgotten about it. The hype had dissipated.
And there's a pretty compelling case that e3 hasn't been helping Nintendo's message recently, either. Look at the Wii U. Announced at e3 2012, and the general public came away with the impression that Nintendo was releasing a new tablet accessory for the Wii. Sure, a lot of that is on Nintendo's branding, but the confusion resulted because there was little focus on a new console among the cavalcade of info at e3. I think this will come into play with NX too; Nintendo wants to control the message.
Smash Bros. 4 Complete/GOTY Edition Splatoon Complete/GOTY Edition Pikmin Trilogy The Legend of Zelda for Wii U/NX in a Twilight Princess situation
The goal for a new console should be to convince everyone who skipped a Wii U that they should pick up the NX, and look, all the great games on Wii U are now here for NX owners!
Everyone complained that Nintendo's standards for developers were too strict. So they did what everyone wanted to do, and greatly loosened them.
This is the result. Cheap, terrible games flooding the eShop and crowding out the quality. Honestly, I liked it better when every game that was released had a basic floor of quality.
Definition of annexation: "the forcible acquisition of a state's territory by another state." I'm not sure what else you can call it when Russian soldiers seize Crimean parliament.
You can't honestly think they'll keep both old 3DS, old 3DS XL, 2DS, new 3DS, and new 3DS XL on the market all at once, can you? No, the old models are going to be replaced, and if you want them, you should get them now.
It's surprising to me that they're announcing this so early, because I'm not sure who will buy the old version knowing these are on the way. It could definitely hurt their holiday sales.
It's funny, because last generation, the criticisms were all from developers who insisted the Wii Shop and DSi Shop needed to be more open and accessible to small developers.
We can't have it both ways. I would personally love to see only games of some quality make it through, but who is to be the judge?
This is perhaps the sort of story you should be digging into, and if need be, warning your readers that they're likely to lose their money backing what amounts to an obvious scam.
Didn't they add the ability to save custom courses on the Wii VC releases of Excitebike and Wrecking Crew? Seems like they could have done the same here.
@MussakkuLaden FYI, DJ Hero's DLC has been taken down by Activision.
Otherwise, as far as we know, you should still be able to access the Wii Shop Channel and purchase DLC. No guidance has been given otherwise. I know FFCC:MLaaK and MLaaD are not on the list of games whose services are being shutdown.
@palatinus This seems to be what obviously happened, and development of the game was interrupted, but then the publisher tried to mitigate their losses by releasing the game as it was still in a middle stage of development, before optimization and bug fixes really began.
Comments 275
Re: Talking Point: What Games Are You Playing This Weekend? - The Triumphant(?) Return
We're all playing the Splatfest, right?
Other than that, trying to finish Breath of the Wild before Odyssey comes out.
Re: Take a Look at Three Musou / Warriors Games Heading to Switch in Japan
Are all three releasing on the same day? That seems counter productive.
Re: Review: Tiny Barbarian DX (Switch)
That review read more like an 8 or a 9 than a 7, imo. I don't think anything mentioned was negative. I was surprised by the praise in the review, and then surprised again when I saw the score.
Re: Developers Discuss the Switch eShop 'Gold Rush'
Launch games always have a unique place in the market. They usually get more leniency from reviewers as there isn't an established library demonstrating what a game is capable of, and as stated early adopters of hardware are also some of the most prolific consumers of software.
Like any other platform, as more and more games arrive, the harder it will be for any particular game to stand out. We're already seeing that with the Switch.
Re: Digital Foundry Does a Deep Dive on the Super NES Classic / SNES Mini Emulation
@impurekind
"and you're not stating it like it's an opinion; you're stating it like it's an indisputable fact."
I haven't done anything of the sort. I was merely pointing out that you made an assertion and have refused to actually support that assertion, and instead have attempted to shift the burden of proof onto others.
You're trying to use weasel words, but when you say there's pretty much zero doubt something could happen, you're making an assertion that it could happen. Your weasel words don't change the semantic content of the message. Back up your assertion, and if you can't, don't be surprised when you get called out on it, as you have been here.
Re: Digital Foundry Does a Deep Dive on the Super NES Classic / SNES Mini Emulation
@impurekind
You are the one that made an assertion: that Nintendo could make a hardware replica of the original SNES with perfect accuracy for $70.
Others disputed your assertion, and instead of backing up your assertion with evidence, you have attempted to put the burden of proof on them, asking them to prove that what you said isn't possible. But that's not how evidence works. It's impossible to prove a negative; you made an assertion, and you should provide actual evidence of your own to support that assertion.
Re: Super Mario Run's Big Update Has Started to Go Live
@rjejr
Purchase isn't limited to one machine on iOS, I wouldn't think it would be on Android either.
Re: Nintendo is "Being Very Selective" on Which Indie Devs Will Be Allowed On Switch eShop
Thank goodness. The race to the bottom we've seen over the past couple of years in the Wii U eShop drowns out the quality content.
Re: Nintendo Confirms Expansion Pass DLC for The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild
DLC is one of the worst aspects of modern gaming. Not quite as bad as microtransactions, but still pretty terrible.
I can't really blame them, though. This is the direction that the industry has been going in, for a decade.
Re: Gallery: Take a Look At These Classic Nintendo Switch Joy-Con Grip Designs
Shut up and take my money.
Re: Matters of Import: The "Perfect" Super Famicom Compendium
If they released a North American equivalent about the SNES, I'd love it.
Re: Nintendo Appears at Apple Conference to Announce Super Mario Run
Pretty surprising. Hopefully not the beginning of the end.
Re: Monster Hunter Generations Launches on 15th July With a Limited Edition New 3DS XL
So it's only pre-installed in Europe?
Re: Reaction: Nintendo Shakes Up E3 With No NX and a Focus on Legend of Zelda
I'm sure I'm too far down in the comments for anyone to see this, but...
I think it's smart to not show NX if it's not going to be ready for the holiday. Too long of a delay kills hype. Look at the 3DS. Most info was known in leaks in the months before e3. It debuted at e3 to rave reviews; the glasses-free 3D was the greatest thing since sliced bread. By the time it launched in March 2011, pretty much everyone had forgotten about it. The hype had dissipated.
And there's a pretty compelling case that e3 hasn't been helping Nintendo's message recently, either. Look at the Wii U. Announced at e3 2012, and the general public came away with the impression that Nintendo was releasing a new tablet accessory for the Wii. Sure, a lot of that is on Nintendo's branding, but the confusion resulted because there was little focus on a new console among the cavalcade of info at e3. I think this will come into play with NX too; Nintendo wants to control the message.
Re: Nintendo Share Value Drops Over 17% in One Week as Global Economic Panic Bites
I feel like Nintendo Life is paying way too much attention to short term fluctuations in stock value and trying to read way too much into it.
Re: Site News: Welcome To The Brand New Nintendo Life!
I can't get the comments to work. Every time I click the comments, I get taken to the home page.
Also, the games list is much less intuitive. The old one was one of the best sources to see eShop games on the web. This one is kind of a mess.
Re: Rumour: Super Smash Bros. Planned as NX Launch Title, Bandai Namco Working on "Several" Games
NX launch titles should include:
Smash Bros. 4 Complete/GOTY Edition
Splatoon Complete/GOTY Edition
Pikmin Trilogy
The Legend of Zelda for Wii U/NX in a Twilight Princess situation
The goal for a new console should be to convince everyone who skipped a Wii U that they should pick up the NX, and look, all the great games on Wii U are now here for NX owners!
Re: Pokémon Red, Blue and Yellow 2DS Bundles Confirmed for Europe, New 3DS Bundle Coming to North America
Doesn't having both versions on one system kind of defeat the point? You can't trade or battle in between them!
Re: Next Metroid Prime Home Console Title "Would Likely Now be on NX"
Nintendo has lost the third parties and I don't think they're going to get them back.
Re: Nintendo Announces Best Buy Locations and Details for Nintendo World Championships 2015 Qualifiers
Wow, this is kind of terrible.
Re: Nintendo Ditches Plans To Create New Hardware For The Chinese Market
Why wouldn't they just release the Wii there? Or even the Wii Mini?
Re: The Legend of Zeldo: Lonk's Awakening is an iOS Flappy Bird Clone, and an Abomination
This article only draws attention to this game and gives the creators of it more support. There's no such thing as bad publicity.
Re: Ubisoft's Unreleased and Finished Wii U Game Has Apparently Been Identified
I was assuming it was that Killer Freaks from Outer Space game. There was a lot of coverage back in 2012 when the Wii U was announced.
Re: Reaction: Nintendo Direct Went Crazy With Reveals, and Was Delightful and Confusing in Equal Measure
I really wanted that standard white New 3DS. I would have loved an ambassador model like Europe got. I guess I'll just grab the Majora XL.
Re: Feature: 12 Days of Nintendo Christmas - Day Ten
Show me your moves!
Re: Review: Tested With Robots! (Wii U eShop)
Everyone complained that Nintendo's standards for developers were too strict. So they did what everyone wanted to do, and greatly loosened them.
This is the result. Cheap, terrible games flooding the eShop and crowding out the quality. Honestly, I liked it better when every game that was released had a basic floor of quality.
Re: Talking Point: The Time Is Right For A Nintendo Phone
It would crash and burn so hard.
If companies like Microsoft, Palm, and Blackberry can't cut it in the modern smartphone market, why would Nintendo be able to?
Re: Masahiro Sakurai Admits That Super Smash Bros. for Wii U May Be His Last in the Series
Every Nintendo console will have Smash on it. It's as inevitable as Mario Kart.
Re: Konami Demands That Hardcore Gaming 101 Presents: Castlevania Book Be Removed From Sale
In this thread: lots of people who don't understand how intellectual property works, but feel compelled to act as experts on the topic.
Re: Moscow Mural Replaces Crimea With Super Mario
Definition of annexation: "the forcible acquisition of a state's territory by another state." I'm not sure what else you can call it when Russian soldiers seize Crimean parliament.
Re: Moscow Mural Replaces Crimea With Super Mario
@ibis_87
It was annexation. Quit rationalizing the Russian invasions of Ukraine.
Re: Pokémon Omega Ruby & Alpha Sapphire to Be Available in an Exclusive Dual Pack
It's nice to know that they've dropped all pretense of two versions of Pokemon being anything other than a cash grab.
Re: Video: Footage Surfaces of Cancelled Wii Star Wars Title
The Rogue Squadron games were some of my favorites on N64 and GCN. I would love to have this game.
Re: Review: Donkey Kong: Original Edition (3DS eShop / NES)
I didn't even know this was released.
Re: Walmart Lists Blue And Red Smash Bros 3DS XL Consoles For September Launch In North America
Hmmmm . . . blue or red . . .
Re: Talking Point: Nintendo Brings Life to the 3DS With New Models
You can't honestly think they'll keep both old 3DS, old 3DS XL, 2DS, new 3DS, and new 3DS XL on the market all at once, can you? No, the old models are going to be replaced, and if you want them, you should get them now.
It's surprising to me that they're announcing this so early, because I'm not sure who will buy the old version knowing these are on the way. It could definitely hurt their holiday sales.
Re: Talking Point: The Wii U eShop is Raising Tough Questions on Quality Control
It's funny, because last generation, the criticisms were all from developers who insisted the Wii Shop and DSi Shop needed to be more open and accessible to small developers.
We can't have it both ways. I would personally love to see only games of some quality make it through, but who is to be the judge?
Re: Areal Passes Kickstarter Goal, Yet More Peculiarities and Questions Remain
NL,
This is perhaps the sort of story you should be digging into, and if need be, warning your readers that they're likely to lose their money backing what amounts to an obvious scam.
Re: Culture Cal Hopes to Celebrate The Holidays With This Majora's Mask Advent Calendar
Licensing concerns won't be an issue? Get real. He can't sell calendars with Nintendo characters without having a licensing agreement in place.
Re: Feature: All Of The Vital Super Smash Bros. Roundtable Details, As Pac-Man Joins The Fight
They have customizable Special attacks, not Smash attacks. Smash attacks are when you smash the stick and press A; special attacks use B.
Re: 2DS Hardware Bundle With New Super Mario Bros. 2 Coming on 4th July
Is that the same color as the red launch color?
Re: Nintendo Reports Financial Losses As Expected, Along With Modest Wii U Sales Targets
Those Wii U projections are bad. Really bad.
Re: Brave, Maleficent, Lilo & Stitch and Guardians Of The Galaxy Spotted In Disney Infinity 2.0 Trailer
Disney Infinity 3.0: Star Wars
Re: Review: Mach Rider (3DS eShop)
Didn't they add the ability to save custom courses on the Wii VC releases of Excitebike and Wrecking Crew? Seems like they could have done the same here.
Re: Super Mario 3D World Double Disc Soundtrack Arrives on Club Nintendo
I seriously doubt this will make it to NA Club Nintendo. If anything, it might be a Platinum prize.
Re: Super Smash Bros. Hitting 3DS This Summer, Wii U Launch To Take Place In The Winter
Seriously, this is a terrible move to help the Wii U. If anything, the Wii U version should come out first.
Re: GameSpy Shutting Down All Online Servers on 31st May, Following Wii and DS Wi-Fi Disconnection
@MussakkuLaden FYI, DJ Hero's DLC has been taken down by Activision.
Otherwise, as far as we know, you should still be able to access the Wii Shop Channel and purchase DLC. No guidance has been given otherwise. I know FFCC:MLaaK and MLaaD are not on the list of games whose services are being shutdown.
Re: Hardware Classics: Sega Saturn
I would love for these to get released on a Virtual Console eventually. I doubt it will ever happen on Wii U, though.
Re: Review: Young Justice: Legacy (3DS eShop)
@palatinus This seems to be what obviously happened, and development of the game was interrupted, but then the publisher tried to mitigate their losses by releasing the game as it was still in a middle stage of development, before optimization and bug fixes really began.
Re: Capcom Cuts Profit Projections By Over 50%, Despite "Strong Sales of Monster Hunter 4"
@Mk_II
Exactly. Mobile games aren't the money machines investors believe them to be.