Comments 285

Re: Random: Yes, People In The Galar Region Eat Pokémon

Cinaclov

@NoxAeturnus Imported from Kalos. Expect a premium on Slowpoke tails post Brexit.

Also; "When Game Informer originally asked Sword and Shield director Shigeru Ohmori if people in Galar were making sausages out of Pokémon, he replied saying he didn't know what was in them."

Sounds about right. Ponyta meat Lasagna anyone? XD

Re: Poll: How Do You Pronounce These Pokémon-Related Words?

Cinaclov

Ah, Arceus, that 'mon that even Pokémon can't decide on how to pronounce. I first started pronouncing it 'Arr-see-us', then Battle Revolution pronounced it different, so did the movie, then someone explained that 'Ark-ay-us' is probably closest to the actual stuff it's based on. shrug

Re: Early Digital Pokémon Sword And Shield Pre-Orders Also Include A Steelbook, For Some Reason

Cinaclov

I did a double take when I booted up my Switch and saw this, but I'm actually quite excited by it. I'm going to get Sword as a download and Shield as a cart, this is a really cool freebie that eases my slight worry about unequal case space - Sword is to be the main one for me, hence it's a download, but consequently wouldn't have a physical presence in my game collection whilst Shield would, which was concerning on some mild level.

Considering it's free, I would've bought Sword as a dowload anyway and it eases that scenario, I'm fully supportive. Do't ask why, take what you can get

Re: Feature: How Fangamer Changed The World Of Video Game Merchandise Forever

Cinaclov

I remember discovering Fangamer about a decade ago and being absolutely in awe. "You can buy a hand illustrated field guide for Kanto Pokémon! Actual Zelda Small/Boss keys for your keyring! 8bit voxel warp-pipe mugs!"

I just had a look now, it's really cool how they've progressed but there doesn't seem to be much in the way of that kind of stuff anymore, which is a shame.

Re: Feature: Little Town Hero Director On Stepping Out Of Pokémon's Shadow

Cinaclov

This has actually made me a lot more interested in this. I had sort of mentally passed on it but will be paying more attention now; shorter RPGs for busy people are all I need to hear to get my attention these days

Also, "Game Freak have devised a scheme whereby staff can filter out and stretch their legs on other projects before returning to the studio's most famous franchise refreshed and rejuvenated.". I have never heard about this but heartily endorse it, that's fantastic and I hope it continues.

Re: Feature: Best GameCube Games

Cinaclov

There are a lot of games lower down that I was initially annoyed by them being so low, but when you consider just how many truly quality games the GC had it's inevitable that some will get pushed lower than seems fair (though it always pains me how disregarded Sunshine is, and the lack of Pokémon Colosseum is a real oddity imo).

Was pleasantly surprised by the Zelda collectors and Master Quest ranking so high though.

Also, regarding Tales of Symphona; "although the plot might be a little workaday if you're at all familiar with the genre, there's a lot to love here". I'd actually argue it's one of the best storys in the Tales franchise; the way they subtly show the effects of racism in its varying forms, as opposed to battering you over the head with dialogue about it, means that by the time you meet the overall 'villain' you completely understand his motives. It's a really effectively told story, especially compared to some of the more recent games. Xillia for example recycles a lot of Symphonias plot points but the accompanying story is so convuluted and needlessly dense that you very quickly tune out. That's why the HD port was so disappointing; with a little love and attention it could have been the best Tales game, instead it comes across as lazy.

Re: Feature: Pokémon World Championships 2019: Bidding Farewell To The Nintendo 3DS

Cinaclov

@Heavyarms55 "much more enjoyable than VGC which can end in a couple turns. Not to mention VGC's rules make team building so much more limited with obtuse bans on Pokemon that aren't remotely unbalanced while allowing broken OP Pokemon that are just because the former is an event Pokemon and the latter isn't. Remember the XY years? Mega Kanga and Talonflame were basically GODS and on like 90% of teams. Not to mention VGC's asinine ban on any Pokemon that was not obtained in that generation."

See, those are almost all positives for me. I said about the match time being shorter in VGC; trust me, after 6 hours of concentrating at a tournament you don't want long drawn out games. You speak to some of the TCG players after their 9th round match, where games commonly run up to time and end in draws, they are starting to struggle on the enjoyment side of things. I also prefer the range of strategies and options it presents.

With the Pokédex, I accept that this is largely preference, though you are heavily exagurating; Incineroar currently has the most usage of any Pokémon in VGC, at 78%. Talonflame and Kangaskhan never saw that much usage. Kangaskhan in XY is actually my go to example as to why I prefer a single set of rules per season; under Smogon, Kangaskhan would have been out right banned from the start, there never would have been any development from that. In VGC14, the best players just dealt with it. The result? Kangaskhan was nowhere in the worlds standings. Similar happened in VGC16 with Xerneas.

Regarding Pokémon not being allowed beyond their current gen, if you mostly play on Showdown I can see the frustration; everything is available to everyone, what's the problem. On cartridge though, there have been decades of event/game exclusive Pokémon. Do you remember when Follow me Magmar top cut worlds, almost a decade after it got the move in Pokémon XD? Or the outrage when Ice Punch Tyranitar did well in 2014 but at the time was a Japan exclusive move? There's enough stuff outside of players control as it is, let alone without adding more stuff that most players can't obtain.

There will always be things that can be improved upon, and at the end of the day both of our opinions are just that, but ultimately I think the structure we have is the best for the way our current circuit operates.

Re: Poll: Vote For Your Favourite GameCube Games

Cinaclov

Such a fantastic library, one of my most played retro consoles by far. I had to put a lot of thought into rating this (eg; Animal Crossing just hasn't aged that well, I would have given it a 9 at the time but realistically I think it's now a 7 when compared to all the other games here that have aged fantastically).

It's also tough for some of my favourite titles; Pokémon Box is incredibly useful, to this day in fact (it's far easier to homebrew and PKHex Box through the Wii than it is GBA titles so is the route to GBA competitive Pokémon), it's an incredible tool, but is it actually a good game?

Similarly with Pokémon Channel, I really enjoyed it but is it objectively a good game? Almost certainly not, especially when compared to others on this list.

Re: Feature: Pokémon World Championships 2019: Bidding Farewell To The Nintendo 3DS

Cinaclov

The headline actually touches on one of my biggest concerns going forwards; the 3DS is perfect for competitive play. You have two screens so have the main game play out on top and your commands on the bottom; this not only works with the clamsheel design of the console to hide your commands from your opponent but also means that if you're streamed you just stream the top screen. There's other hardward features as well; infrared is crucial for large tournaments.

The Switch doesn't do any of this. If all the stats are on one screen, how do you stream it without revealing one players entire set of information? Can you imagine trying to use wireless to connect with a 400+ player tournament (I know the right joycon has it, but that's really badly placed and isn't included on the Switch Lite).

I'd be lying if I said I wasn't worried about this. But equally, I'm so excited for the coming season

Re: Poll: How Do You Pronounce These Nintendo-Related Words?

Cinaclov

Yoshi has always confused me slightly, entirely due to Melee (Which I'll come back to). On the character select screen the narrator pronouces it "Yo-shee", which is fair enough. However, when you play as Yoshi and taunt, the dinosaur pronounces their name "Yosh-ee". So I've always pronounced it Yosh-ee as well, as I assume Yoshi know how to say their own name.

But more importantly - Why was Smash Melee on that on the poll? 100% of people either pronounce it "Super, Smash Brothers, MAAAY-LAAAAY!!", with the appropriate pauses and emphasis, or they've never actually played it.

Re: Poll: Have You Ever Had Problems With Nintendo Hardware?

Cinaclov

I recently replaced the D pad in my GBA, just swapped it with one from a cheap GC controller I bought for £1 and it works perfectly. Really pleased with myself for that.

Otherwise, loads of DS/3DS hinges, both my own and other peoples consoles. I know several of my friends had Gamecubes that stopped reading discs around 2 years after purchase but Nintendo didn't charge of us for repairs, which was cool. I've seen others with DS screen issues but never had any myself.

I've also got a pre-owned GBA SP that sometimes the power switch doesn't register for, occasionally you have to switch it back and forth a few times for it to turn on. But considering how battered and scratched it is I'm surprised there aren't more flaws tbh (seriously, how anyone wrecks their console like that one is beyond me, though it's one of the backlit ones and plays fine though so meh).

And that's pretty much it. Nintendo stuff definitely feels pretty sturdy overall.

Re: Poll: Vote For Your Favourite Nintendo DS Games

Cinaclov

Rebought a DSLite recently to transfer Pokémon which has prompted me to dive back into some DS games, it's got a really wide catalogue and a lot of solid titles. As a whole I think 3DS is one of my favourite consoles, largely because it's got an even better catalogue, backed up by the virtual console and DS compatability.

Re: Soapbox: In Praise Of Save States, Rewinds And Walkthroughs

Cinaclov

"Want to tick Tolstoy's War and Peace off the ol' bucket list? There are very few shortcuts for that one, I’m afraid"

But the book is always there, in a fixed form, for you to slowly work your way through.

The problem with videogames, especially older ones, is that you are prevented from progressing until you've 'proven' you're good enough. I could spend 10 minutes a day on War and Peace and eventually I would definitely complete it. But there is no guarentee that I could complete a really challenging retro game in that same timeframe, especially if there is a restricted/non-esistant save system.

That to me is the biggest advantage of playing old games now, with save states and walkthrough guides/videos on tap. It becomes much more plausable to progress through games.

Just being able to continue from the exact moment I left off in a game like Super Metroid is so much more convenient and makes the games much more achievable, let alone that you can create a save right before a tricky platforming section to avoid having to run through the same series of corridors when you fail and fall in order to get back to those platforms again.

Re: Animal Crossing Is Now 18 Years Old

Cinaclov

I remember when we had to petition to get the GC version released here in the UK, especially painful as the Australian version works without any modification on our PAL GC's.

And now it's a flagship series for Nintendo. How times change.

Re: Poll Confirms That Sobble Is The Most Popular Pokémon Sword And Shield Starter

Cinaclov

Grookey is the best one. I don't really like the fire bunny tbh. Sobble seems pretty forgettable.

It's odd, I've always felt like water is my type and for the first 4 gens it was without question (even though Cyndaquil is better than Totodile ). 5th gen I didn't really care for any of them, though Snivy was probably the best, then it's just been the grass types winning each gen since.

Well, there we go. Just a starter Pokemon at the end of the day isn't it.

Re: Sorry North America, You’ll Also Have To Download Final Fantasy X-2 HD Remaster

Cinaclov

FFXHD is possibly the only game that has an arguement against rebuying games on Switch to have them portably. Really love that the PS3/4 versions share saves with the PSVita version through the cloud, and at this point can both be gotten fairly cheaply in sales. I know the Vita sold abysmally outside of Japan and the Switch removes that need completely, but I wish more games had done that.

Re: The Pokémon Let's Go Series Could Progress To Johto If Players Enjoy Lets Go Pikachu And Eevee

Cinaclov

I've been thinking that this seems a reasonable route with regards to remakes. FRLG were remade shortly after RS launched. We've now had remakes for RS at the 10 years mark, and a rerelease of R/B/Y on virtual console. That's not quite the same, and I can't see them doing that for all the games going forward (re-releasing them on VC equivilant). Rather than re-releasing the FRLG remakes, Lets Go makes sense. As much as I loved HGSS it'd make sense for a G/S remake as well.

That felt sort of rambly, but I basically agree.